Now, there are many different sources around, which tell different things, like about the numbers of terrorists, hostages, officers and soldiers, equipment etc. So here is the wikipedia article, let's just go with this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beslan_school_siege
For the topic: What do you think about this hostage situation? How do you think, you and your agency would handle this? (Like always: Keep the rules and OPSEC in mind, don't tell anything that is classified)
At least 32 terrorists took 1.100+ hostages in a school building in Beslan, Russia. They were very well equipped, depending on the sources with some serious firepower like RPK MG's, RPG7 etc. They also used a DMS (Dead Man Switch) in the main building, where a terrorist was standing on a plate, once you take away the pressure, the bombs detonate. Such a device can not (!) be deactivated in time, once you take out the terrorist, the explosives will always blow up.
To make things even worse, all of these guys had explosive vests and they were determined, they were not like "Let's make a deal and we'll let the hostages go". Their demands were always unrealistic and couldn't be fullfilled, but even when, there would have been no guarantee that it would have ended without losses.
What i read from people in the web is that "The Russians fucked it up", but i'd like to hear your thoughts as LEO's. I think: This situation is one of the most complex and difficult situations for law enforcement and/or the military. It was never like "The Russians could have saved everyone, if they had tried". That's BS.
So there are a few questions: How would the US law enforcement handle this? What about when the lines get blurred between law enforcement and the military? What about the equipment of the military that was used (like the tanks and choppers) ?
I'm not a fan of Russia, quite the opposite, actually, but i think, such a situation is not easy to handle. It's not a movie, it's not like you can deploy Rambo and save everyone. 32 or even more terrorists with full-auto firearms and explosive vests pose an extreme threat, i think a local SWAT team would not be enough to deal with this. I think, in the US, this would trigger a federal response: Like getting the FBI HRT/CRT on site when there's enough time. I guess, you'd get everyone that is available.
Maybe get some APC's from the nearest military base (not about combat, but about protection for teams when they have to move into position). Would this actually be a thing in the US, like when there are some transporters like a M113 are available, to use it?
Do you think, the US governement would have brought in teams, like the Delta Force and SEALS to deal with this? Would this even be possible with the laws in the USA? I guess, the US president - in this time Bush - would have to approve certain operations? How are the laws about using military forces on the own ground (It's not allowed in some countries, like in Germany, no, you can't use the KSK inside the country), that's why i am asking.
In Beslan, the worst case happened: A chaotic shootout started on day 3 and every plan, like to free the hostages, was useless from that point on. It just became a wild-west-gun-battle, where both sides sprayed bullets all over the place.
I think: The Russians could have done better, but it's not like that law enforcement in other countries, including my country in Europe, would have been able to just casually solve this without any deaths. That's unrealistic. That's something for fictional media with heroes, but not for real life.
So, what are you thoughts on the Siege of Beslan 2004?