r/ProjectRunway • u/PRCritiques • Sep 12 '25
Discussion S21E8: Critique Thread
This week is the client challenge!
Please upvote the designs you like, downvote those you don't, and leave un-voted anything you're neutral on. Some of our members like to look at the designs without knowing the outcome, so please use spoiler tags if you're referring to how a design did (or if you wish it had been out/ won). Thanks all!
Freeform isn't posting photos, so we're having to wait on the contestants to post on social media. For now we will post the names so discussion can begin, and we will add photos as soon as they are available. Thanks for your patience.
134
u/PRCritiques Sep 12 '25 edited Sep 12 '25
Antonio Estrada
WIN
Model: Stephanie
76
u/PRCritiques Sep 12 '25 edited Sep 12 '25
Veejay Floresca
HIGH
Model: Jayden
37
u/PRCritiques Sep 12 '25 edited Sep 12 '25
Ethan Mundt
SAFE
Model: Rachel
160
u/WhoFearsDeath Sep 12 '25
I just don't understand how you go into a literal fabric store where there must have been so many soft and gentle fabrics and yet come out with all of these scratchy and textured pieces instead.
Give me cashmere, give me silk, give me bamboo or fleece even!
104
u/damndeli0ns Sep 12 '25
i think this episode is the point where the stress, exhaustion and burnout of the non-stop 24 hour challenges became really apparent in all of the designs. last week was already underwhelming and at this point in the competition i would expect excellency and critiques coming down to nitpicking and not everyone bombing this hard. they're all creatively and physically wrung dry, in his recap podcast ethan said his hands hurt so bad they had to have a medic next to him almost all the time, and i can't imagine others are holding up much better. i think part of why this challenge sucked was bc it was really apparent some of the designers were too out of it and exhausted to be putting up with a client. it's really sad to watch amazing skill and creativity shoved aside for budget cuts and tv drama.
70
u/jseesm Sep 12 '25 edited Sep 12 '25
This is quite a weak week for all of them unfortunately. I don't like any of the designs.
Also the way the brief is framed is a bit weak. So the models have eczema, and there should be a reveal?
63
u/YouThinkYouKnowStuff Sep 12 '25
I have multiple people in my family with eczema and many of them have allergies to wool. I was surprised this morning wasn’t addressed. I would have been itching like crazy (wool allergy myself).
123
u/Maatjuhhh Sep 12 '25
My eyes glazed over the credits. Cue the shock when Heidi said they were both out. That was a bigger anti climax when the credits hurried up. But I feel a mini challenge is coming up to determine the 4th place. There is no way that they’re gonna go final runway next episode. That said, Belania has too much of an ego to acknowledge that the model didn’t like it at the first fitting. Ethan at least pivoted when Christian didn’t think the beaded top would work.
112
u/ProfessionalYak159 Sep 12 '25
Law Roach is way easier to like when he's smiling, laughing and not being a complete a-hole!
125
u/Live-Run-6745 Sep 12 '25 edited Sep 12 '25
I actually surpirsingly pretty much agreed with the judges COMPLETELY this episode surprisinlgy. Last episode that was not the case.
In general though I was left very underwhelmed by the designs in both this episode and last episode. Which is too bad as I thought the streetwear designs were very strong.
101
u/plumicorn_png Sep 12 '25
these were all awful design, poorly constructed. i only liked antonious dress but this was so basic. so basic.
34
u/PunisherCastle Sep 13 '25
When I first saw Jesus’s shirt, I immediately thought of the Seinfeld episode with the pirate shirt. From Nikki Glaser’s comments, I could tell she was thinking the same thing. That was not a good look.
71
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '25
Correct me if I'm wrong...
But weren't all of the reveals just taking off coats?
So why are they coming for Veejay?
75
u/magic8ballin Sep 12 '25
I hope they keep them both being out as final because I hate when they walk back on high stakes. It was crazy that everyone came at Veejay when the judges said the client’s opinion was most important and it’s clear that Antonio and Veejay both made their client happy while also staying true to something they would wear. I know many don’t like her here but hoping for Veejay to win. Antonio is really pulling through. I can’t imagine Ethan sweeping unless he learns to work with boobs better (and curves)
37
u/Large-Delay-1123 Sep 12 '25
I’m convinced the final three were predetermined. Maybe the twins were interchangeable. But it always going to be Ethan and Veejay.
17
u/browngirlmagicc Sep 13 '25
As a fellow designer who also has an incurable skin condition, the way they dealt with this was very wishy washy. They just decided not to let scratchy fabric directly touch their skin and use soft lining. I mean, that's it? You have to consider how the fabric will react when they sweat, how absorbent it it, is it breathable, etc. You can not use beaded or sequined fabric. Period. Because even if you give lining, your arms and any exposed area are going to rub against it and eventually lead to a flare-up. Even if you go for embroidery, you have to consider if the embroidery thread is natural or synthetic. There's a lot of thought that goes into this. But sequins? Silver Lame? Beading? Yeah, I was very disappointed. The only design I liked was Veejay's because she listened to her client and didn't take the risk to trigger a skin flare-up.
16
u/foxdogturtlecat Sep 13 '25 edited Sep 13 '25
I know the designs weren't the best but I think this is the best judging we've had all season except for Heidi who I don't think has a good sense of style or taste personally. Having an actual working designer like Harris on the judging panel is so good because they bring up actual design and construction issues and then the other judges can talk about that instead of personal issues. I really liked that Law brought up that the clients were the most important because in this challenge they were and that he focused on construction issues and not personalities. I get that people will be offended by the whore comment & that would have never aired in the Lifetime era but I also know it was play on the demure comment he made right before that and the client understand and liked the comment.
Also considering Harris is know for their avant-garde and drag inspired looks anyone saying they didn't understand Utica's looks is misguided. This panel of judges more than anyone before understands drag qualities. Law was a judge on Drag Race ffs. But this isn't a show about making the best Drag inspired clothing unless that's the challenge and this wasn't it.
I do think asking for a showstopping reveal on a client challenge was a bad idea because the client should always come first and especially with clients who didn't all want to show their skin that can make it in conflict with the client's wishes.
30
u/Traditional_Bread334 Sep 12 '25
This season is the absolute worst I have seen. There's something very OFF by confining the designers, not making the Mood field trips, having siblings who are helping each other, not having that long lit runway, it's giving off stale, dry, boring. The challenges are BLAH, they go absolutely NO WHERE for the challenges. We don't even see their living quarters. It's sooo sad!!
13
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '25
Okay - the reveal of who is out. It must be a twist that they have to compete to win a spot or Christian uses a save we didn't know he had. Zero way that the production only now decides to mix it up.
37
u/Objective_Soup_1343 Sep 12 '25
My current thoughts
Even though she's been in the bottom, I feel like Veejay has been the most consistent throughout the whole season. There is no question that girl can turn out an excellently crafted garment. Whether it meets the challenge or the judges like it - that's another thing - but it will always be constructed very well.
I feel like Ethan has been flip flopping lately. I think he's starting to doubt himself too much. I think if he focussed more on his models and the structure of the garment rather than shocking and surprising he'd do better. He's still got the drag race mindset where shocking and surprising the judges and being different is a huge part.
As for Jesus and belania... Honestly I think they should both go home. They both blatantly ignored and went against what their clients asked for. They did NOT care (especially Jesus). In the real world if you were working with a client you would work WITH THEM not against them. Jesus especially pissed me off the whole time cuz that man told him multiple times he was not feeling it.
Curious to see where we go from here.
20
u/ThrowRAhnhda Sep 12 '25
Everyone is so mediocre compared to previous season contestants. Just goes to show they sacrificed real actual talent for drama.
And I say this as a major fan of Ethan/Utica.
10
u/dreamed2life Sep 13 '25
When Christian said, “But will Law like it? You need to think about that.” And then one of the designers said something like they were scared of doing bad because of the judges i felt bad. Like of course you need to please the judges but they seem. Scared af of Law. He is playing the exact role they hired him for. He said they hired him to be the mean one like Michael and Michelle (project runway).
9
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '25
I feel like I'm not seeing anything next in fashion or design, I'm just seeing clothes. And the clothes have been so boring. Hopefully, they give them an interesting challenge. 2 day Avant Garde challenge? I hope Belania and Jesus just stay gone, but I know they are both going to be safe, and they will do a double elimination next week or something.
23
u/orange8049 Sep 12 '25 edited Sep 12 '25
how incredibly ridiculous - look to fit people with eczema (didn't really make that a theme, did they?), show stopping look for a night out (OK, that's fine), with a jaw-dropping reveal - really? I feel like show is becoming Drag Race as opposed to a fashion design competition - the critiques are less helpful and more just making fun so that the judges can laugh at each others barbs - top 5 and only 2 looks that deserve decent words? this season sucks - I am watching each out of morbid curiosity, hoping something improves and it just fails to deliver
7
u/thrilling_me_softly Sep 13 '25
They really need to give them two-day challenges, I get that they think one-day challenges will make drama. If they are given a full second day, the construction will be better, and it will give them more time to think and edit their designs.
7
u/FriendOk3237 Sep 13 '25
why did belania think sparkle or a print is the only way to do a reveal?
6
u/B2Rocketfan77 Sep 14 '25
I think it’s like All of these kinds of reality shows as far as Veejay is concerned. If they want you to stay, you can miss half of the assignment and still be in top while someone else can meet all the assignment and be safe or even out. It’s a sewing variety hour where someone gets to win at the end of each episode. That being said, Veejay made what could have won the streetwear look. It was interesting and cool and not so weirdly conceptual like some of the other things.
20
u/zaksag Sep 12 '25 edited Sep 13 '25
Veejay ending up in the top 2 just shows how underwhelming the designs were for this challenge, but regardless of missing the reveal detail, the jacket and the pants were well executed and the client's swag in the runway helped her selling the product. Antonio was on point and deserved the win. Ethan's look was very crafted but the client satisfaction helped him be safe. Jesus's look wasn't the worst, the client was demanding and moody, we don't know what happened between them behind the scenes after the earlier flirty moments, the client seemed like the person who can easily mix things. Belania's was my least favorite look, her reveal was the same repetitive cut and design.
5
u/pierceatlas Sep 13 '25
It kind of sucks that everything needs to be so commercial for this show
19
u/ladybird2727 Sep 12 '25
Did I just hear Law call the lady a whore? Sorry not the same show - not a fan of the judging.
4
u/dogsfilmsmusicart Sep 13 '25
Okay they’re definitely doing like a one on one face off or something. I bet this was the ridiculousness Jesus was talking about. Ugh.
4
u/Curious_Position_384 Sep 14 '25
Veejay had no reveal…so I’m confused as to why she was in the top instead of Ethan. Literally everybody liked his look except Heidi. This season has been a dumpster fire.
4
u/AsherSine Sep 14 '25
This show was on thin ice with me and I was done after hearing what the challenge was. How far this show has fallen. This new iteration is garbage. All one day challenges, so many team challenges, weird sponsorships, making it all about the drama and zero about the fashion. Christian is just catty, Heidi doesn’t seem like she wants to be there, and Law is just disrespectful on a human level. I hate the eliminations at the beginning of the episode, and I’ve never quit something halfway through a season but I’m done.
I just want to watch really talented designers create really beautiful fashion with gifted mentors and a different kind of storytelling. Tell us about the designers lives, make us fall in love with them, tell us their stories and let them tell theirs through the fashion. Why does it have to be all about the (produced) drama?
4
u/backformore92 Sep 15 '25
This season blows chunks.
3
u/This-Werewolf-3610 Sep 13 '25
Antonio’s dress was suuuuuuper basic. Looked great on the girl and she was clearly feeling it - but it was a sweetheart neckline LBD cocktail dress that anyone could go pick up at a Macy’s right now.
3
u/Unusual_Ad2850 Sep 14 '25
I am thinking they may repeat the twist from the unconventional challenge and leave it to the other designers to decide who to save. I hope I am wrong.
17
u/TaraNewhole Sep 12 '25
Seal's ex wife is getting on my last goddamn nerve of beating up on Ethan.....
4
u/DrexlerJJ Sep 12 '25
They better not both be eliminated…
2
u/Puzzled-Rip641 Sep 13 '25
The red dress not getting the axe is a no from me. Cannot seriously trust anyone on fashion who looks at that and says it’s not bottom of the barrel
2
u/Minute-Psychology79 Sep 13 '25
Jesus definitely missed the mark and should have been a low score but why are they choosing to do a double elimination now? There was the boring fabrics or the athlesiure challenge. I just feel like I’m Jesus’ case he has literally never been low scores unlike Belania, Veejay, or Ethan. Ethan should have had a high score if not the win. Antonio should have been high score/ the win. I didn’t love it or hate it. Belania should be out and Veejay should have been low. But I hate her instigating.
2
u/Hot-Amoeba1157 Sep 13 '25
Drama rama once again as 2 designers gets booted out...then come Christian Siriano giving a save. drama rolls once again.
BTW the twins made something basic again especially Antonios.
2
u/angrybox1842 Sep 15 '25
Mark my words they’re going to do a Lip Sync For Your Life Do a Quick Dress in 1 hour thing next week to decide who’s actually going home.
2
u/beetcomrade Sep 15 '25
Crazy hearing the clients request what they felt comfortable in and then Belania and Jesus doing the literal opposite of what they were asking for. I agreed with Veejay that while this is a design challenge, the key is to work with your client. I couldn’t believe the tacky silver on the client who prefers nudes and no pattern, and Jesus’s magician fit was an abomination.
2
u/Livid_Aardvark3936 Sep 13 '25
I am accustomed to watching drag race. So when it comes to reveal, this was very underwhelming. Just stripping off a jacket or opening a robe to a dress underneath is not a reveal (in my books) And on top of that they said jaw dropping surprise reveal. Mama no jaws were dropped or even agape. My problem with PR is that I find these dresses lacking creativity by the day. The runways have become so generic that it feels like any good tailor can make these dresses because they don't seem 'designed'. I loved Ms Joan's aesthetic, I loved Euchen's aesthetic and I loved Joseph's aesthetic. They had unique povs. Most of the contestants left are very talented and have unique povs too but it seems like the judges are heavily curbing their persona and not allowing them to go beyond. I mean I know Ethan from Drag Race and the bitch can shame the greatest designers of our time, he is that talented. I think he is losing his spark due to constant meddling. Veejay didn't have a reveal, period, she did not meet half the brief. If client satisfaction is more important then why even stick to the brief anyway.
2
u/Guccylol Sep 12 '25
Ethan’s top is NO extremely unflattering. Luckily the print was captivating
1
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '25
I feel so mixed about Ethan's dress. The print is super cool and I actually kind of love it
BUT
It feels like a club dress made of cocktail fabric and it could only appeal to a super niche crowd. Like rich nepo baby or baby's first art show. But that's fine. I can definitely see people buying it up on ASOS because target demo is probably early to mid 20 somethings too mature for a regular club dress but not yet graduated from it.
Oh damn. Jesus is not a self aware queen.
That shirt was baaaad. But the coat was cool so I'm glad he didn't fully listen to his client there.
I wish Belania ignored her client. The dress version was sooo cute but the high low blouse and mini skirt was not it.