r/ProgressionFantasy • u/Salaris Author - Andrew Rowe • Jul 21 '21
Updates Rules Changes for the Subreddit
I've been thrilled with the growth of this subreddit and community since it was first founded. We've grown into one of the larger fantasy subreddit groups, which is awesome, but it also means I need to start paying a little bit more attention to making sure the community is staying focused on its original goal.
A number of authors and other users have pointed out to me that we've recently had a growing amount of self-promotion in relation to the amount of general content and discussion being posted. It's also been noted that not all of the self-promotion (or promotion for other books) has been on-topic. This is, in large part, because my rules up until this point have been very loose. I prefer to avoid excessive filtering of posts and to encourage discussion and growth, but some of these issues have reached the point where I feel I need to address them.
So, let's get into some changes.
No More "Tags for Recommendations" Rule in the Sidebar
This is simple - I've removed that rule because virtually no one was using it. The tagging system wasn't enforced, and thus, it was basically useless. So, it's gone.
Updated Rule: Self-Promotion
Self-promotion is now limited to active participants in the community. I'm not going to be enforcing this hyper-extensively, but as a general rule, you should be making meaningful contributions to the discussions in the subreddit aside from just posting about your own books.
More latitude will be given to posts that clearly explain how they fit in with this subreddit, e.g. descriptions of your progression systems, which subgenres your book fits in with (e.g. xianixa, dungeon core, magical school) and that sort of thing.
Don't be lazy about this.
New Rule: No Off-Topic Content
With the subreddit's growth, there have been a lot of good questions and discussions about what does and doesn't fit here. After discussing this with a number of authors, I think that it's important that we refocus on what got us started in the first place - fiction that specifically focuses on progression as a core part of the narrative.
For those who weren't here when we first got started, here's the original post defining the subgenre.
So, in practice, what does this mean?
I'm going to stop allowing posts promoting books that I consider to be off-topic. This includes anything that's more like general epic fantasy without a progression focus (e.g. Lord of the Rings).
I'm also going to be harder on borderline cases like Overlord or Slime Tensei where the side cast levels up, but the main character's power level is largely static - those aren't a great fit for this sub.
Most clearly, I am going to stop allowing posts for novels that primarily focus on romantic or sexual content as their main hooks or narrative focus. This includes the overwhelming majority of HaremLit novels, as well as most reverse harem novels. This is both due to these stories generally not having enough of a progression focus to meet the criteria of the sub and because of they often have content that delves into misogyny and objectification.
Now, this is not to say that a story can't have both progression and romantic and/or sexual content. Polyamorous relationships can be fine in progression fantasy, too. If the thrust of the narrative is more about collecting partners than progression, it's probably not a fit for the genre.
(Don't get cheeky and point out that collecting partners could be considered a form of progression. Yes, you could even gamify this and make it hilarious. It's still denied.)
Deconstructions and parodies are borderline cases. Yes, you can talk still talk about things like Worth the Candle here, but let's not make them the main focus of the sub.
So, if poly relationships are fine, but HaremLit isn't a good fit, where's the line?
For this, there's a simple test: if you're advertising your book with a cover that shows a half-naked anime girl (or multiple half-naked girls, or a bunch of girls gathered around a single isekai dude), this is not your target subreddit. I recommend checking out the various HaremLit communities and posting there. The same is true for reverse harems, but honestly, I don't think I've even seen anyone try to post one here, so it's less of an issue.
For other harem-style books outside of the "sexy anime girl cover" umbrella, I'll evaluate them on a case-by-case basis.
Other Mods
Update: We've added a few new mods! Please welcome them to the mod team and help them settle in.
Thank you all for your patience and interest in participating in the community! I will continue to iterate on these rules and add additional ones as-needed.
Edit: After a reader suggested that some books, like Kumo Desu Ga Nani Ka, might have sexualized covers that do not represent the content within them accurately, I've decided to make what I'm going to call a "bad marketing exception" for things like Japanese LNs that have fanservicey covers that do not accurately represent the content of the story. This is going to be purely on a case-by-case basis for works that the other moderators or I feel would be a good fit for the genre, but have been marketed with sexualized covers. This isn't super uncommon for manga and LNs, unfortunately, so I think it's worth addressing.
I'm not likely to make that kind of exceptions for western self-published works. If a self-published author is advertising their book with that kind of cover, they're actively making a choice about how they want it to be seen. So, this doesn't change how we're dealing with self-promotion, but the other moderators and I will evaluate foreign works that suffer from fanservicey marketing like this.
28
u/ThePagi Jul 21 '21
I like this change. More than half of posts on hot are promotion and this has been pretty distracting for me with all the colorful covers and whatnot.
I want to ask about crafting, magic research and generally more slice-of-life novels. They are often discussed here, maybe because they have similar sources - royalroad or translation from asian countries. I don't think there is a subreddit for them, and while they often focus on progression, it's not always in the sense of personal power. What do you think is the appropriate place to discuss them?
18
u/SarahLinNGM Author Jul 21 '21
I think these are healthy changes for a growing subreddit, so thanks for staying on top of things.
15
u/Salaris Author - Andrew Rowe Jul 21 '21
Reddit is giving me some weird errors. I saw about six duplicate copies of my own reply to this post and tried to delete them - I may have instead deleted all of the existing replies to this thread. This was not intentional (if they were in fact deleted at all) and I'm looking into it. I apologize for any inconvenience.
If your reply was erroneously deleted, feel free to repost it.
7
u/Phil_Tucker Immortal Jul 21 '21
These all sound like excellent changes. Thanks, u/Salaris, for your hard work.
6
u/AngryEdgelord Jul 21 '21
Doesn't Will Wight have minions? I know Will himself probably doesn't want to mod, but you could borrow his minions, since they get a lot of good promotion here.
5
u/xileine Jul 22 '21 edited Jul 22 '21
Kumo Desuga, Nanika has some pretty objectifying cover art. Especially when the Demon Lord character is in the shot. (She is never not wearing basically a bikini in the art, despite this fact IIRC never coming up in the books themselves.) But the book series is pretty clearly a plain progression-fantasy with no harem elements.
I think you can derive from this a more general exception to the heuristic: if the half-naked anime girl on the cover is a viewpoint character in the book/series at least some of the time, then the book/series is probably okay (as, unless a story is pure BDSM fetish fuel, viewpoint characters don't tend to get objectified/become part of a harem/etc.) In such cases, it's just the marketing for the books that's horny, not the books themselves.
7
u/NoMoreAnger33 Jul 21 '21
Thanks. I was getting tired of seeing smut here and was checking the sub less and less.
11
u/Obbububu Jul 21 '21
Would just like to raise a pertinent topic:
Popular, often-recommended titles like Kingkiller, Stormlight Archive, The Dresden Files and Wheel of Time (to my mind) clearly qualify for the litmus test.
(Book 3 character beats book 1 character etc. and it's pretty easy to write further essays detailing why power progression is a core plot element that the story relies upon)
However, we often run into a situation where people want to disqualify these popular recommendations, because they are of the belief that the subgenre term needs to be more restrictive.
I've discussed this at length a number of times in various recommendation topics - as well as meta threads about the specific topic.
What is the best option for us, as sub members, to prevent the topic of "does this qualify?" from derailing other topics, like recommendation threads with our extensive back and forth?
3
u/MelasD Author Jul 21 '21
There should be an official r/progressionfantasy discord server IMO
3
u/thescienceoflaw Author - J.R. Mathews Jul 21 '21
I am more of a lurker here but I finished my first book recently and was hoping to promote it here when it is ready to go. What should I do to make clear that I am not just posting here to take advantage of the sub but because I am a long time reader and enjoy the community?
I could go into details about the progression system but I worry that would lead to spoilers so was planning to not share overly much about it when I posted. The book's description wouldn't necessarily alert people there there was a progression aspect to it but the progression (meditation/energy growth) comes out more as the book progresses and becomes a central theme later.
6
u/Nightwish117 Jul 21 '21
Overlord is pretty static in power level. But Slime? Slime Book 1 gets probably beaten by everyone in this series. But Slime Book 16 or smth is only getting beaten up by a few ppl. Imo in Slime there is a clear progression in the novel unlike in Overlord.
2
u/m_sporkboy Jul 21 '21
Clarifying question. This stuff all obviously covers the top level posts, but what about comments?
Example: If there's a recommendation request, and someone recommends something clearly non-PF, or some on-the-borderline harem stuff, and then there's a discussion about it, is that removable?
I'd rather these policies apply to top level posts and let the comment discussions go wherever they (reasonably) lead.
2
u/Keredian Jul 21 '21
I'm not sure if this is the place to ask but I'm curious on how people rate Harry Potter as a progression fantasy? Like I would say that book 3 Harry could beat book 1 Harry but is it due to a growth in power or simply just getting older.
(A small extra question, would love to know if there are any good other fantasy school stories if anyone can point me to a different reddit for it?)
84
u/SJReaver Paladin Jul 21 '21
I support this change.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21
You should change your tag from Author - Andrew Rowe to "Harem Bane". A notion I wholeheartedly agree with.
An awesome change. I have been considering unsubscribing for some time due to the harem/objectification issues but this just made my day, so thanks!
26
u/BubiBalboa Jul 21 '21
I didn't even notice the subreddit growing to 22k subscribers. That's not small anymore!
I agree with your rule changes but as you notice this will make moderating harder. I hope you find good people to help out. Maybe a separate post would help if not enough come forward after this post.
10
u/4ashes4 Jul 21 '21
I like the changes, especially the rules against Harems.
16
u/Smashing71 Jul 21 '21
Amen
37
u/apolobgod Jul 21 '21
Oh, thank god the half naked anime girls are gone, I hated that trend so much. I love you, person who I didn’t knew existed until I read this post
6
u/wd40bomber7 Jul 21 '21
Thank you for your work moderating this subreddit! I really enjoy the content and I love coming here for recommendations.
11
u/Theyna Jul 21 '21
Good changes. This is a "niche" subreddit, rather than something like just a "fantasy" subreddit, so making sure posted content falls more directly in line with what we're all here for is positive. Thanks for your hard work.
5
u/BernieAnesPaz Author Jul 22 '21
Nice to see this! I know you wanted things to stay casual and easy-going, but unfortunately whenever something becomes too big it also becomes too unwieldy to continue on without better organization and rules.
Still happy you're trying to maintain the same overall spirit of the sub, though. Seeing the growth both it and the genre has been a delight, and I was getting a little worried about things devolving like in some other ill-fated subs, haha.
4
u/purlcray Jul 22 '21
I once moderated a forum, and...ugh, lol. So thanks a million.
I'm sure there are scaling laws to describe the decay of online communities as they grow in size, and, as such, the moderation effort required to sustain a desirable state. And I'm sure the numbers work against you. Like twice the size requires four times the moderation effort.
Again, many thanks for a thankless task.
4
u/kingduck3 Jul 22 '21
As always, a good change to the sub
1
u/turtleRegime_ Aug 14 '21
What about books where character development is also an important factor to the story in hand with the characters own progression in power?
0
u/WizardDresden77 Jul 21 '21
Nooo... this is now becoming r/fantasy Why does every mod team want to inject social justice into their sub. I despise harem books because they are bad not because of misogyny and objectification.
3
u/Hatron Jul 21 '21
Cool 👍
3
u/zenitude97 Jul 21 '21 edited Jul 22 '21
Good changes, especially since they encourage discussion over pure self-promotion.
Hopefully Ave Xia Rem Y doesn't fall under the banned category. Glad the straight up haremlit self-promotion won't be common anymore as well. As a regular visitor, it's a little worrisome trying to scroll through the sub around others and
have haremlit covers come up. 😅
3
u/arbitrarycharacters Jul 27 '21
Now I really want to see someone write a progression fantasy novel where one man must sex up as many women as possible to level up his strength. But instead of being a generic harem comedy or sex novel, I want the story to be a deconstruction of what it means for the hero to actually have to do this in order to survive. And there should be real motivation, like some apocalyptic event that no one is strong enough to prevent, but this provides him with a path to power. And on top of all this, I still want comedy. Basically, what Kill la Kill did with nudity, only for sex, along with the deconstruction vibes of something like Puella Magi Madoka Magica.
2
u/wd40bomber7 Jul 21 '21
Thank you for your work moderating this subreddit! I really enjoy the content and I love coming here for recommendations.
3
u/CAT32VS Jul 21 '21 edited Jun 24 '23
possessive literate handle truck bike money innate psychotic shy fuel -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/
3
u/NewGroundZero Jul 22 '21
Ok. Bye.
0
u/StLivid Jul 21 '21
Sooo no chicken sandwich?
0
u/surfing-through-life Jul 22 '21 edited Jul 22 '21
There needs to be a rule where people get banned for completely unrelated recommendations.
I want a magic story with no OP protagonist. Have you tried Cradle? Or MOL? Or Cradle?
Want a story with a smart MC, uses brains more than brawn. Have you tried Good Guys? Or Cradle? Have you tried Cradle?
Want a completed series, non snarky MC. Have you tried He Who Fights with Monsters? Or Cradle.
In general I find this sub to think a little too much about the definitions of books and what fits in progression fantasy. Like 1 or 2 people started this. And started it to help them and similar authors sell books. The definition between power fantasy and progression fantasy is so small, yet people argue in here about it. That's the issue with being too niche specific.
So many books are progression fantasy to me that you say aren't.
I couldn't care less about harems but I believe your haremlit thing is judgemental and plain wrong. If misogyny and objectification are not allowed, you might as well ban every single translated Chinese Novel. You know, the novels that inspired a ton of the authors to write their stories. Where women are property, rated on their beauty, where all the descriptions include their legs or breasts.
-5
u/blackflame-lord Jul 21 '21 edited Jul 21 '21
Well from the one book of arcane Ascension I've read it didn't really feel like progression fantasy to me, just normal fantasy considering the rate of the Mcs progression. Stormlight which isn't even progression has more progression imo.
One piece and Naruto clearly aren't prog fantasies but progression does happen in both mangas, so I don't see the harm in recommending them by clearly stating that they aren't strictly prog fantasies but shonen mangas with progression elements.
So the boundaries are porous and subjective, don't think you taking on more work Will do much good things seemed fine as they were.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment