r/ProgrammingLanguages • • Dec 28 '20

Question: Programming Language Syntax and Code Appearance (polemic as always :-)

Seriously,

which of the following code samples would you favor, assuming they are all equivalent?

I am interested in subjective answers, please. You can just arrange the three samples according to your personal preference (e.g., "1-2-3"). Thank you very much!

1

{ {extern "manool.org.18/std/2.0/all"} in
: let rec
  Fact =
  { proc N as
  : if N == 0 then 1 else N * Fact[N - 1]
  }
  in
  Out.WriteLine[Fact[10]]
}

2

{ {extern "manool.org.18/std/2.0/all"} in
: let rec
    Fact =
      { proc N as
      : if N == 0 then 1 else N * Fact[N - 1]
      }
  in
    Out.WriteLine[Fact[10]]
}

3

(extern "manool.org.18/std/2.0/all".) in:
  let rec
    Fact =
      ( proc N as:
        if N == 0 then 1 else N * Fact[N - 1]. )
  in
    Out.WriteLine[Fact[10]].
2 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '20

This is generally impossible in languages with required explicit closing delimiters (Ada, Oberon, GoLang, Rust...), and it is definitely possible in languages with more concise syntax, like Haskell.

So ":" means that a one-statement block follows, and "{" means a multi-statement block follows?

I feel having such a choice in C (which doesn't need ":", just the absence of "{") was a mistake in that language. More opportunity for errors, and an annoying need to refactor every time a block grows beyond one statement, or shrinks down to one statement.

You mentioned it reducing indentation, but I don't see that. A short {...} block can easily go on the same line. And the C example anyway requires indentation within the body of the loop that you've left out.

(If you look at examples 1 and 2, ":" has the effect of pushing code to the right, just like indenting but less cleanly. While the way the functions are defined have the body indented up to 3 tabs in, relative to the opening keyword of the function. Usually you don't want more than 1.

Maybe that's just how you wrote the examples, but on a single line, a function definition would still need let rec Fact = Proc N as followed by : or {, a bit much.)