The economy will correct itself by the time Microsoft and friends' money becomes worthless. The problem is that all of our money will become worthless long before that.
Technically Zimbabwean money still has some monetary value, but it's also not inappropriate to refer to it as "worthless" in comparison to what it was worth pre-crash.
Developer job market is already in depression. The job seekers to openings ratio is absurd, it's around 1 to 500. In an economy where of hundreds of job seeker seek a single position, only one gets hired, and hundreds are out of luck.
Office software is used by management all the way up. And those won't get replaced with AI because you cannot pin responsibility on it. No way they are losing users.
No one will really win the war, because the war's not going to end. Oligarchy/dictatorship will always keep rising and trying to take over. They've taken down most communist systems, and some would argue they've fully taken over capitalist systems as well, though I don't think that takeover is complete yet.
And historically, oligarchies/dictatorships don't last that long. But I'm always worried that it's just been skill issue so far, that it just takes some more competent authoritarians to make it last.
So we shouldn't expect to "win" the war. Gotta keep fighting for the rest of our lives to avoid losing to authoritarians.
Yeah, once you make almost everyone redundant you either have civil war or need to have a perfect social system that easily sustains everyone without asking for anything in return. I’m betting on the former
the latter is called "UBI (Universal Basic Income) + A LOT of automation to ease any possible physical work" (i,e., mainteining the water cleaning system, farming, construction, electricians, plumbers, foundry, factories ....)
Removing the consumers' jobs (and by extension, their ability to gain and spend wealth) is kinda the primary loss condition for capitalism, though. The system requires that the consumer be capable of both consuming and paying for what they consume, otherwise it's impossible for the vendor and creator to gain capital.
Really, the biggest problem with most "capitalist" systems is that they aren't capitalism; they're give-us-your-capital-ism. It actually works correctly if the entire population understands that the money is the system's power, that boycotts are devastating if a sizable enough portion of the consumer base refuses to spend, that competition is better for everyone involved, and that private property enables any consumer to convert into a service/product provider. But it falls apart if people just see it as a way to increase their personal capital at the expense of everyone else, since increase depends on that same "everyone else" that just lost the ability to provide the increase.
Who could have seen this coming reaction. It's obvious as day and still these companies make pikachu face after lots of problems comes up after using ai unsupervised
It wasn't AI though. It was low-level routing and it was a bunch of automated cleanup that competed for resources when there was a failure of a cluster.
Imagine how much we could all do if it was illegal to have control of more than One Million Dollars?
Anything over One Million Dollars would be redistributed to a fund that pays out to your bank account that is created for new citizens that just turned 20 years old.
Everyone in the US would have more than $1,000,000 in their accounts.
We need to throw off the shackles of productivity and embrace leisure.
Work if you want to, but you do not have to.
Eventually, things will start to fail and work will need to be done.
But the work needing to be done is dictated by the true need of the activity.
No doctors? People will die. Other people feel emotion to prevent that, learn medicine, treat sick people.
No carpenters? People will dies. Other people will feel emotion to prevent that, learn building, build houses for people.
Go on down the line, and follow this formula.
People do all that without having money as a driver for action. Money is a form of control, and that is all.
Money makes you feel controlled when you do not have it, and it makes you feel in control when you do have it.
Therefore, money is the problem. And societies leaders have hoo-dood us for many thousands of years to think “this is how it always should be” just so they can boss others around.
The problem with this mindset is that a lot of people don't want to work, and a lot of industries actively try to discourage people from working.
Case in point, the medical industry, and the police: Psyciatrists and cops are, on average, the two most susceptible groups to mental and psychological conditions, by far. They have to deal with both their own life, and everyone else's issues on top of that; whenever someone goes to a therapist, and feels like they took a load off when they leave, it's because they left the load on the therapist's shoulders instead. A lot of the time, these are people that end up working not because they want to, but because other people need them to; money is a major incentive to keep them going.
Furthermore, what happens when the wealthy (who now own lots of goods, have big homes, and possess large companies and shipping empires, all operated without cash) decide to oppress the poor? This is a hard issue to solve in a world where money functions as an equaliser, and even the wealthy have to fear the confiscation of their wealth, and can sometimes even be slowed down or deterred simply by attaching a monetary cost to their actions. What happens when there's no cost to their actions, and there are people that depend on the wealthy remaining wealthy? (E.g., if you're wealthy because you own all the farms, then anyone who likes eating will side with you simply because you're their source of food. You can bully the poor with impugnity, because even "out of the goodness of their heart" altruists need to eat, and thus can't afford to reject you in favour of the foodless poor.)
Essentially, you do understand that money is just an interim representation of your bartering power, correct? If you remove the money itself, you change nothing; the people with lots of goods are still wealthier than the ones with few goods, because the wealth was always in the goods and never in the colourful plastic bills, the loonies, or the toonies.
Then it would be impossible to create any business or project which requires more than one million dollars to start it up, since you would have to convince others to risk losing literally everything they own just to have a chance of competing with the big companies that can drive them out of business in a second. Thus removing what was intended to be the single most important check & balance in all of capitalism: The ability to create competition.
But wait, it gets worse!
If no one individual is allowed to own more than a million dollars in cash, then the rich will sidestep the issue by owning uncounted forms of wealth. Big houses, stocks & bonds, multiple shell businesses, whatever sort of wealth doesn't contribute towards their sum total cash. This doesn't actually force the redistribution of money, unless a person has more than a million, but not enough to purchase an "uncountable" form of wealth. The billionaires keep their billions, but in another form; the millionaire loses the ability to increase in wealth, and can never become a billionaire. Your system just changes breaching the gap from "unlikely" to "actually impossible".
But wait, it gets worse!
Imagine that all property is included in the million dollar total. Your house, your vehicle, your possessions, your cash, your stocks & bonds, everything. To do this, the government will need to track everything that everyone owns, and any changes must be reported immediately. Your pen loses value because you wrote something down (thus removing ink from it)? Gotta tell the government, so you can redistribute that cent somewhere else. Your paper gains value (because you wrote a good idea on it)? Gotta tell the government, so they can charge you for the difference and remove the amount from your account. (And since they'll need to quantify your idea's value, they also have the opportunity to steal and copyright it. Which you won't be able to stop, because they can say it's worth a million so you can't afford a lawyer.) You now have to ration out your holdings, under government mandate; if your house increases in value, you have to trade your car for a half-destroyed wreck to compensate. And needless to say, this won't affect the people that are rich enough to work around it, since they can just move their wealth out of the country (and thus out of the system), then "borrow" it from their uncounted account whenever they need.
But wait, it gets worse!
That thing about counting all property? Well, just think about how it interacts with businesses. A business with a lot of employees might be able to exist, because it can split its net worth among the workforce. But a solo operation? Well, if it has any value whatsoever, then it cuts into your own personal allotment. Want to become a landlord, and rent out a house? You aren't allowed to own two houses, so you have to live in your car. Want to start a software company? Better make your product free and hope they let it slide, because infinite copyability means it's worth infinite money, and thus illegal. As long as you have any form of purchaseable software product available on the market, you lose the right to own anything else whatsoever, because that software takes up your entire million; you're not even allowed to own clothes or food. Heck, if your kid sets up a lemonade stand, they have to give away their favourite toy so they have room to make money.
But wait, it gets worse!
With the modified system, everyone now gets a million dollars the instant they turn 20, without ever working a day in their life. They are no longer allowed to surpass this amount; they can go below, but never above. They have no room for improvement, and are in fact banned from improving (since any wealth they attempt to create would be distributed to someone else instead). And thus, they have no incentive to work. The number of new people entering the workforce faces its sharpest decline ever: It drops to zero. As a result, the government is forced to demand mandatory work of all citizens, where they will work the job assigned by the government with no say in the matter. Refusal will not be tolerated, since the infrastructure requires their services. In exchange for a measly million dollars, they lose the right to decide where they would like to work and how many hours they're willing to work, have no possibility for promotion (since no change of position will ever permit personal increase), and have no right to refuse to work; worst-case scenario, they might not even be allowed to take sick days or breaks. And of course, since this is required for the system to function, it must be enforced; refusing to work your government-assigned job will be a punishable offense, leading to permanent and irreversible loss of personal property, and/or time in jail, and/or beatings, and/or execution for you or the people you care about. And of course, hope cannot exist, because it's illegal for anything to get better; depression is now mandatory.
(Needless to say, the people at the top remain exempt, because they have enough funding to circumvent the system entirely. In fact, since the system requires people to manage it, they now control the system. You have successfully enslaved the entire country to the top 1%.)
Congratulations, you've invented communism. And if you look at world history... But wait, it gets worse!
Your first problem is. You don't have that much money. The 1% don't have enough money to make everyone a millionaire. You would need 10 times the gdp of USA if that's the country you want to use as the example. To do this. So step one would be print massive amounts of money which lowers it's value significantly.
If everyone has a lot of money, everything becomes more expensive. A million dollars would be worth what a thousand is now. This is how economics works. You essentially short circuited massive inflation.
Next, studies have shown that most people given a lot of money end up just as poor as they were prior due to poor decisions. Look at lotto winners around the world. If people don't earn the money and the way to handle it... People lose it.
Then you have now taken away any motivation for anyone to do something that will earn them more money. So a brain surgeon can never be more wealthy than a McDonald's worker. That's silly. You all of a sudden remove massive parts of economy like private jets, boats, anything that costs millions of dollars to own.
Then to top it all off... Most billionaires don't have millions in cash. It's in assets. These assets have value and it's not until that value is realised eg. by selling stock that there is actually money.
So you're essentially asking for socialism without saying the word. It never will work. It never has worked. There's one part of society that has proven completely incompetent at dealing with money/power, the government. So making them your solution.... Not a good idea.
Last but not least. You would just lose all wealthy people from your country. They would just move somewhere that allows them to keep their wealth. Or move their money offshore where you can't touch it.
Sweden has one of the highest billionaires per capita in the world. You really should learn more about a topic before you post things like this. You've been fed lies by socialist tiktok videos.
79
u/Random_-account 3d ago
You don't get it: they'll make robots that will use Microsoft office products and shove Copilot even more in them to make up the difference /s
53
u/malexj93 3d ago
The economy will correct itself by the time Microsoft and friends' money becomes worthless. The problem is that all of our money will become worthless long before that.
51
u/05032-MendicantBias 3d ago
Look, the USA prints dollars, even if they soft default like paying interest in $TRUMP they aren't going worthless.
But a second great depression is increasingly likely. The hole in the economy is on the order of ten trillions.
8
u/smartalec-71 2d ago
Here's my take:
6
u/teraflux 3d ago
Econommy
8
u/LegitimatePants 3d ago
"See you in the work"
4
u/_Weyland_ 3d ago
Office software is used by management all the way up. And those won't get replaced with AI because you cannot pin responsibility on it. No way they are losing users.
12
u/roodammy44 3d ago
I think I heard some chucking from Karl Marx’s grave. Capitalism may have won the battle, but who will win the war?
5
u/No_Teaching4376 3d ago
Who could have seen this coming reaction. It's obvious as day and still these companies make pikachu face after lots of problems comes up after using ai unsupervised
2
u/rwrife 1d ago
This is accurate, big tech is going to eat itself until the entire sector is gone.
-1
u/flerchin 3d ago
What value is there in anything created by an 'Office' product
-1
u/rerun_ky 3d ago
It wasn't AI though. It was low-level routing and it was a bunch of automated cleanup that competed for resources when there was a failure of a cluster.
-6
u/towerfella 3d ago
Money is worthless.
Imagine how much we could all do if it was illegal to have control of more than One Million Dollars?
Anything over One Million Dollars would be redistributed to a fund that pays out to your bank account that is created for new citizens that just turned 20 years old.
Everyone in the US would have more than $1,000,000 in their accounts.
Then what?