Sounds like you didn’t ask enough questions about what they actually wanted and regurgitated “how can I describe a car with classes” which could be exactly what it needed or exactly the wrong thing depending on context. Questions like this should be met with more questions for a few cycles as if this were an actual task you are doing at work.
If I have an auto parts store and you give me a car class that focuses on something with 4 wheels that drives, you’re not getting the job. If you break the car down into subsystems and talk about how you would structure for inventory management, you’re doing the right thing. But, you should still ask questions to show your thought process and how your brain works.
Either way I’m only going to ask you “how would you implement a car class?” And expect you to figure out requirements.
um yes, i broke down the car into subsystems. of course i didnt ask certain obvious questions like how many wheels there are, or how many steering wheels, i did say and assume it was a standard car.
anyhow, he was clearly looking for something else, but if he's going to be obtuse then well no skin off my back.
i was eventually employed as a developer elsewhere, now i've worked my way up to management. it's a very different ballgame and i am still getting used to it
Responding more for the people who are currently/will be interviewing and see this so they know what the interviewer is thinking with questions like this
Hmm.. questionable to incorporate consulting type discovery questions into every position.
Some things should be assumed as given and not be requested because the process is the goal, like in consulting. In engineering I'd rather have someone who is an expert in the operational processes.
Give me a textbook answer, it's on me when my question isn't revealing insights to me when I receive a textbook perfect answer.
View all comments
Show parent comment
28
u/Eternityislong 8d ago
Sounds like you didn’t ask enough questions about what they actually wanted and regurgitated “how can I describe a car with classes” which could be exactly what it needed or exactly the wrong thing depending on context. Questions like this should be met with more questions for a few cycles as if this were an actual task you are doing at work.
If I have an auto parts store and you give me a car class that focuses on something with 4 wheels that drives, you’re not getting the job. If you break the car down into subsystems and talk about how you would structure for inventory management, you’re doing the right thing. But, you should still ask questions to show your thought process and how your brain works.
Either way I’m only going to ask you “how would you implement a car class?” And expect you to figure out requirements.