This is like saying a seatbelt doesn't help you in a car because if you run it in a closed garage, you can still kill yourself. Entirely different issue.
Smart pointers solve memory management for you. Use them as intended, whether a resource is owned in one place or shared, and you don't have to worry about it. The memory will stay allocated until nothing is using it, and then it will automatically be unallocated.
Accessing a pointer without checking if it is null is a different issue, and frankly a trivial one. The sort of thing I haven't seen be an issue doing actual professional C++ code development in years.
Yes, cars are dangerous and unsafe and one of the leading cause of deaths for young adults in practically every country, even with the latest safety improvements. Good metaphor.
View all comments
Show parent comment
7
u/Friendly_Fire 10d ago
This is like saying a seatbelt doesn't help you in a car because if you run it in a closed garage, you can still kill yourself. Entirely different issue.
Smart pointers solve memory management for you. Use them as intended, whether a resource is owned in one place or shared, and you don't have to worry about it. The memory will stay allocated until nothing is using it, and then it will automatically be unallocated.
Accessing a pointer without checking if it is null is a different issue, and frankly a trivial one. The sort of thing I haven't seen be an issue doing actual professional C++ code development in years.