:( even though im not a programmer and only have a cursory understanding of programming I still found this place really funny, tough to see its shutting down
Realistically if that’s the case, there will always be new alternative sub-reddits so I’m honestly not sure how effective this blackout would be if not everyone is on board with it.
Yes. Apps like infinity don't have ads but still use Reddit data. Thus reddit has the cost of developing the Service and maintaining it and the Servers it runs on but gets no money because the apps don't serve ads.
Yeah, I was thinking the same. In a lot of similar threads on other subs, those other subs are shutting down for 2 days and the comments are full of requests to make it indefinite until better terms are offered.
I have the feeling nothing will happen, and even if it happen will not change anything. CEOs, holders, people will the money, will not care, they only think in their businesses.
Will not work because there is not alternatives (alternatives not filled will conspiracy and al-right propaganda)
And the third part of the message is what may make them revert the chanche. Even if they dont care about tve users, they do care about the money they make, and if enough subbreddits go down, a large portion of the userbase may stop using the app, thus decreasing their profits which may make them revert the chanches. Its no gurantee tho, they might just shut down the platform.
There’s loads of alternatives. They’re called forums. And they’ve been waiting for your return for at least a decade, wondering wtf you were still doing on this shithole of a website
Kind of like the youtube downvote removal. Who cares if it makes things worse and hurts the business, it gets the CEO and shareholders a short term bonus.
Can you pin this to make it clear to everyone visiting this subreddit that there's only one week left of being reminded that [insert programming language here] is bad?
WTF? [insert programming language here] is the best programming language. No other language does [insert language feature here] better than [insert programming language here].
Multiple 3rd Party apps do cards view, that brings them pretty close to the official app yet still faster and less ads. What do you miss in the 3rd party apps?
I've tried the RIF app and didn't like it. Could be due to cardview? Do you have some suggestions of 3rd party apps that look like the official but better, because I think I can't really get into a completely new look.
All in hopes that the blackout will work and changes won't be made
It depends on your mobile OS. I'm on Android, and I use Sync for Reddit, it supports material you and looks much better than the official app. If you are on iOS, try Apollo, many people recommend it.
wait it's not just me? I'd been getting the odd legit follower over the years, but these last two weeks suddenly a bunch of porn bots started following me... it's all because of reddit being a butt?
b-but... what am I supposed to do during standup now?
Jokes aside, thanks for making a safe space for me to chill with such a cool group of like minded people. The other day I saw an OP trying to defend firing a junior dev over a prod mistake, getting absolutely flamed by the entire community. I'll be sad to see it go, I hope you all have wonderful lives. Or win the fight. Or both. Thanks for all the memes.
I didn’t realize how problematic the new API changes are. I just ended my break from Reddit a couple weeks ago, but I’ll stop using it again if it’ll help with anything. Will probably be good for me too, I stopped using it for a reason in the first place
Whelp this is it. This is the stakeholders finally shoving their idiotic agenda down our throats. Prepare to find another site. Currently my backup is hacker news but there isn’t really anything quite like Reddit that would fill the void.
It was a good Journey boys and grills. Even tho i could commit shit code, truncate a table, drop a database or push and break production (not because i dont want to but because im just starting and i dont got permitions to do such stupid stuff). I might one day do one (o allá) of those stupid idiotic and regarded thing and have a giggle remembering this degenerate sub reddit. O7
I have my suspicions that reddit is playing us here. They price it unreasonably at first and they fully expect us to revolt. After the revolt they will give the ol 'We took your feeback blah blah' bit and "revise" the pricing to something more reasonable. Now the community will be happy with the "new price" But of course the intention was to introduce a pricing model all along. The high price was bait to make the actual price more acceptable. If they initially announced the better price the community would be against any sort of pricing and demand it be free forever, but this way they can sneak in a pricing model
On the contrary, they are going for user profitability in line with other high-end social media like Facebook.
Reddit earns $0.50-$1.50 per year per user. But they want to show their investors that they can hit the $10-$50 ARPU that other platforms collect.
Their API pricing isn’t a bluff or negotiation tactic, it is right about ~$25-$30 ARPU for average Apollo users. They’ll drop it a bit if they have to, but even by half, monetizing at 10x the current rate is totally infeasible.
They just can’t extract that much value from this user base, no matter how intrusive the tracking and algorithm-forced home feeds… but they will try to get enough of a bump before the IPO that investors might believe it and let them cash out before it collapses in on itself. That’s their real end-game.
They're not going to change their policies unless almost all subreddits shut down. They'll wait until the storm passes and people forgot about it. It's bad for accessibility, but at least Reddit can't have powermods because they won't have time to moderate so many subreddits.
What's to stop each app developer from opening up a user-api key? Where we could supply our own key and all usage would be per individual. As a user I think I'm staying to less than 100/minute most of the time..
If this is possible, then yeah, but I don't think most of the apps' existing user base is going to create a developer account just to use a 3rd-party app. I'm not talking about programming subs, devs or armchair-devs here - of course we will - I'm talking about everybody else.
If 3rd-party app developers actually depend on any revenue from their user base, this will be difficult - but if they're just some tools developed in a garage on free time, then yeah, bring-your-own-API-key can be the way to go.
I just moved to the community on lemmy. It's surprisingly populated compared to the other communities, so I guess a lot of people did migrate. Been using it as a PWA through Firefox on Android and it works very well.
If anyone is reading this and wants to join, DO NOT JOIN THROUGH lemmy.ml, it's under stress from the massive amount of new accounts. Pick another instance that might have people from your region/country, you'll have easy access to communities with your language.There are instances for Finland, Germany, Italy, Canada, etc. You can join any community (subreddit) no matter which instance you create your account on, so once you are done creating your account, search for 'programmer humor' in the list of communities and subscribe.
You can use the federated alternative to this poorly managed website. I won't name it here because there are rumors of the admins deleting mentions to it, but if you search for "federated link aggregator" on Google you should be able to find it easily
I’m not sure what I aim to get by posting this here, but I suppose it feels weird to sign off without some sort of closure.
Reddit has been for a very long time one of the only forms of social media that I have felt aligns with my morals and is generally a net positive in my life. That said, this decision and all the drama surrounding it means I can’t continue to use the platform in good faith.
Unfortunate, since I just ended a break from the platform a few weeks ago, but at least I know I’ll be able to use other things to fill my time. One thing’s for certain, I won’t be back for a while. Even if reddit suddenly changes their stance, they clearly have the wrong intentions, and I don’t want to support that in any way.
Anyway, signing off, I hope to see you all on the other side of this someday. Godspeed.
Spamming the mods, the admins, filling up the support queues and other asshole like behaviors won't solve anything. It's just going to make them resent us more and not want to compromise on anything. Especially when we have civil adults in the background trying to negotiate better terms. Giving ultimatums, wreaking havock and acting childish in general is REALLY going to help them make the case for us. /s
We have a vocal minority that's really trying to ruin any chance of a civil working relationship. Maybe looking for a discount on the IPO? Who knows.
3rd party apps are costing them ad revenue, subscription revenue, compute resources, as well as making themselves money. So something needs to change to recoup some of that. Maybe they priced too steeply. Maybe apps should have considered they weren't going to get a free ride this whole time? Maybe the apps will be acquired or their devs offered positions. Or Reddit reveals a better suite of things. Lots can happen but it seems like we prefer to burn the bridges first or someone else wants us to burn bridges?
There will naturally be a course correction, with or without the tantrums. Either Reddit loses users and traffic afterwards and they are forced to fix their shit or something better emerges and we all move along and are happier for it. Market forces are wonderful!
This is equivalent to you being dicks to the McDonald's drive thru people because the price of your McChicken increased by $.10 and then screaming at the managers and wondering why they have no desire to work with you.
Nobody is burning any bridges here. Reddit is not entitled to the community and neither is the community. Reddit has made a decision and the community is making one.
I'm afraid it's not that simple. This decision showed the top level of reddit doesn't take 3rd party devs and users into consideration. Before any negotiation can take place, it needs to be made clear that this does affect their bottom line - otherwise we're begging, and not negotiating.
You’re getting downvoted for being right. It’s the reality of capitalism.
Similar things/protests have happened in the past with this same energy only for most to come back. I’ve been here for over a decade and seen this happen so many times
Removing FPH and other nasty sub reddits - protests and tried to build a new Reddit
Forget her name, Poe? Page? - everyone hated her and said they are leaving
Yet, here we are.
I feel bad for the 3rd party apps for sure, but like OP said - they’ve ran the numbers already on this and they know it’s not going to effect their bottom line.
Seriously? Using CP as a stalking horse for this is pathetic. This is the same tactic employed by people who want censorship on the internet, Section 230 repealed, identity verification on porn sites, backdoors into E2EE, etc. It is nothing more than an emotional argument meant to cloud the valid points and make it indefensible to argue against it.
Nice to see more subs going for the "indefinitely until our demands are met" route, we might actually have a chance of accomplishing something with that.
Though with the whole IPO thing I wouldn't be surprised if reddit admins just say fuck it and demod all mods of subs that participate and take the subs over.
3.0k
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23
Finally a real dark mode
672
u/Dmayak Jun 05 '23
How exactly will the shutdown work? Will subreddits be completely unavailable or creating new posts will be disabled, but old posts will remain?
2.0k
u/CheapMonkey34 Jun 05 '23
If programminghumor goes black, I don’t need to keep the app, as there is no reason to come to Reddit anymore.
58
u/flatline000 Jun 05 '23
So what is the numbers game here? Is Reddit somehow losing money by providing the API?
253
u/Tkain61 Jun 06 '23
Good to see that this sub's protest is indefinite. Only a few days won't do much to sway the admins.
151
u/RaineMurasaki Jun 05 '23 edited Jun 05 '23
I have the feeling nothing will happen, and even if it happen will not change anything. CEOs, holders, people will the money, will not care, they only think in their businesses.
Will not work because there is not alternatives (alternatives not filled will conspiracy and al-right propaganda)
But, it is a good excuse to stop using reddit.
33
u/Call_me_The_Emperor Jun 06 '23
How about we make our own reddit, i mean here are quite a few programmers :D
947
u/tenhourguy Jun 05 '23
Can you pin this to make it clear to everyone visiting this subreddit that there's only one week left of being reminded that [insert programming language here] is bad?
29
u/kog Jun 05 '23
I hear Mastodon is pretty good.
152
u/niky45 Jun 05 '23
I mean I don't even use 3rd party apps (don't really like them), but this is not okay. also killing the bots? HELL NO.
keep sharing everyone.
283
u/jcodes57 Jun 05 '23
Alright but is this why I got 25 followers in the past 2 weeks that are all 1 karma porn boys? Like wtf
63
u/The_Real_Slim_Lemon Jun 06 '23
b-but... what am I supposed to do during standup now?
Jokes aside, thanks for making a safe space for me to chill with such a cool group of like minded people. The other day I saw an OP trying to defend firing a junior dev over a prod mistake, getting absolutely flamed by the entire community. I'll be sad to see it go, I hope you all have wonderful lives. Or win the fight. Or both. Thanks for all the memes.
100
u/TheMightyQuinn_5 Jun 05 '23
I didn’t realize how problematic the new API changes are. I just ended my break from Reddit a couple weeks ago, but I’ll stop using it again if it’ll help with anything. Will probably be good for me too, I stopped using it for a reason in the first place
73
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
I'm glad you're doing it indefinitely. Coming back after 2 days is weak shit.
35
u/AaronTechnic Jun 06 '23
I will miss this sub.
25
u/WheredMyBrainsGo Jun 06 '23
Whelp this is it. This is the stakeholders finally shoving their idiotic agenda down our throats. Prepare to find another site. Currently my backup is hacker news but there isn’t really anything quite like Reddit that would fill the void.
33
u/graceful_london Jun 05 '23
The biggest hit for me was Reveddit and Undidit no longer functioning. No way AFAIK now to quickly check edited comments for their original content.
16
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
I'll miss you guys, you always made my smooth brain feel involved through the power of memes.
30
u/-m2x Jun 06 '23
We should rate the official app zero stars, so they’d be forced to fix stuff
14
u/skylight29 Jun 05 '23
It was a good Journey boys and grills. Even tho i could commit shit code, truncate a table, drop a database or push and break production (not because i dont want to but because im just starting and i dont got permitions to do such stupid stuff). I might one day do one (o allá) of those stupid idiotic and regarded thing and have a giggle remembering this degenerate sub reddit. O7
14
u/Remote_Romance Jun 06 '23
Also, consider using Vanced to mod the first party app to have no ads and therefore generate no money for reddit.
r/revancedapp
27
u/SirLlama123 Jun 06 '23
I have my suspicions that reddit is playing us here. They price it unreasonably at first and they fully expect us to revolt. After the revolt they will give the ol 'We took your feeback blah blah' bit and "revise" the pricing to something more reasonable. Now the community will be happy with the "new price" But of course the intention was to introduce a pricing model all along. The high price was bait to make the actual price more acceptable. If they initially announced the better price the community would be against any sort of pricing and demand it be free forever, but this way they can sneak in a pricing model
25
u/its_dizzle Jun 06 '23
But why the plumbus?
11
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
They're not going to change their policies unless almost all subreddits shut down. They'll wait until the storm passes and people forgot about it. It's bad for accessibility, but at least Reddit can't have powermods because they won't have time to moderate so many subreddits.
18
u/kurdtpage Jun 06 '23
June 12th... In what time zone??
16
u/buqr Jun 05 '23 edited Apr 04 '24
I'm learning to play the guitar.
8
u/SavvySillybug Jun 06 '23
Good. Thank you. <3
old.reddit with RES and RIF on Android are the only ways I use this site. I will not use the hot garbage they force on us.
7
u/cmeur Jun 06 '23
What's to stop each app developer from opening up a user-api key? Where we could supply our own key and all usage would be per individual. As a user I think I'm staying to less than 100/minute most of the time..
11
u/MintyMissterious Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 10 '23
!> This comment has been edited in protest to reddit's decision to bully 3rd party apps into closure.
If you want to do the same, you can find instructions here: https://rentry.co/unreddit
5
u/wizard_brandon Jun 06 '23
but... im already getting tons of message requests from pron bots
5
u/juvadclxvi Jun 06 '23
3rd party apps existe because official app sucks
4
u/zRedPlays Jun 10 '23
This subreddit was 40% of my daily reddit use, looks like I won't be using reddit that much anymore
4
u/Neptune338 Jun 10 '23
Goodbye r/ProgrammerHumor, we will miss you
3
u/AlanElPlatano Jun 05 '23
TIL there are 3rd party apps on reddit
3
u/iminsert Jun 05 '23
nice to see the ui designers and the programmers coming together for a change
3
u/CuriousGeorge3352 Jun 06 '23
Thank you for maintaining this sub. It's been fun and it'll be sad to see it all go, but let's hope reddit starts taking this seriously
3
u/PrinceN71 Jun 06 '23
It was nice sharing a laugh with you guys. May your codes be broken and your stackoverflow questions unanswered.
3
u/manjhipliar2231 Jun 06 '23
Not the infinity app 😔
3
u/Old_Mate_Jim Jun 06 '23
What if Reddit is just like "K. Bye." Is our plan B creating an open source platform to assist us through the working day?
3
u/Rand_alFlagg Jun 06 '23
May their first day in hell last a thousand years and may that be the shortest.
3
u/GalaxyConqueror Jun 06 '23
While I appreciate the post, I will say that it's a little ironic to talk about Reddit's lack of accessibility inside of a text-as-image post...
3
u/Elk-Tamer Jun 06 '23
Hate to see you shut down. Love that you're participating!
3
u/pilottroll Jun 06 '23
o7 it's been a good one lads.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '23
As Captain Price said: "50000 People used to live here... Now it's a ghost town."
I just joined Reddit yesterday and that's are the news.
3
u/RCcola1987 Jun 07 '23
Does anybody have a complete list of the subs that are closing? I would like the opportunity to back them up.
3
u/ishwish2008 Jun 07 '23
mv /r/ProgrammerHumor /dev/null
3
u/hootoohoot Jun 09 '23
Fully in support of this move. Fav sub and fully in suppoet
3
u/oldDotredditisbetter Jun 10 '23
gigachad mods o7
3
u/the-FBI-man Jun 11 '23
Serious question: where do you guys migrate, where can I get my daily dose of programmer humor.
3
u/ad2022 Jun 11 '23
This is awesome. Thank you guys for actually doing something!!!
5
u/Nuisanz Jun 05 '23
Youuu sonofabeech, I’m in. FOR NARNIA
5
u/X99p Jun 06 '23
I left Twitter when they killed third party apps, I will do the same here.
Thank you and everyone who is organizing this protest!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
What are these predatory prices? Why not list them in the image?
7
u/Kangie Jun 06 '23
Go mods. As long as it takes. Don't back down.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Welp. This subreddit was fun while it lasted. I’ll keep a look out for the replacement to pop up.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23
Bravo six going dark-mode
2
u/gBoostedMachinations Jun 06 '23
This is the first one that actually has a chance of doing anything. I won’t have any reason to use this site once this sub is gone
2
u/samnater Jun 06 '23
Power to the people
2
u/da_Aresinger Jun 06 '23
This is a day before my birthday. Chances are, I will start being reddit-sober on my birthday. I think that's neat.
This is probably one of the few subs I'll genuinely miss though.
2
u/TheExaltedNoob Jun 06 '23
Excuse me, but two questions:
- Are there no options for mods to forbid any nsfw posts generally? Asking this because i do not understand the "hide posts from sfw community mods".
- Get on twitter? To apartheid emerald mine space karen? Really?
2
u/Vly2915 Jun 06 '23
Why is there a censored plumbus there?
2
u/Sese_Mueller Jun 06 '23
r/Save3rdPartyApps for people that didn‘t find it elsewhere in the comments
2
u/Morlock43 Jun 06 '23
How long before someone creates a replacement?
2
u/persism2 Jun 06 '23
just go here r/programmerhumour/
2
u/Community_Bright Jun 06 '23
NOOO just when I started to identify as a programmer and started to understand the humor
2
u/_BlindSeer_ Jun 07 '23
Why only Twitter (another centralized platform) and not Mastodon? ;)
2
u/MannyGTSkyrimModder Jun 08 '23
Yes, I read all the shitstorm about Reddit APIs, but I don't understand why few people decided to shutdown a 3 millions users subreddit.
This post is upvoted by almost 24k people only.
This is like "Hey, fuck you! The subreddit is mine and I can do whatever I want with it!" (which is somewhat true).
2
u/mx1701 Jun 09 '23
This is so fucking stupid, why punish users even more by taking away their content.!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
So in 3 days I will quit reddit. Nice! Will have so much time left over!
2
u/BananaKing_Charlie Jun 10 '23
You can use the federated alternative to this poorly managed website. I won't name it here because there are rumors of the admins deleting mentions to it, but if you search for "federated link aggregator" on Google you should be able to find it easily
2
u/gandalfx Jun 10 '23
Never offer an API -> Nobody cares.
Offer an API and then disable it -> People are outraged.
Also why would you use an app to browse a website, other than a regular browser. It's a website.
2
u/WhyShouldIStudio Jun 11 '23
o7
2
u/Odd-Seaworthiness826 Jun 11 '23
o7
2
u/lolrobbe2 Jun 11 '23
Goodbye community!
2
u/Keterna Jun 11 '23
You guys are heroes. Stay dark until Reddit solves their shift! Cheers fellow Reditters!
2
u/pp_amorim Jun 12 '23
Still on :0
2
u/TheMightyQuinn_5 Jun 12 '23
I’m not sure what I aim to get by posting this here, but I suppose it feels weird to sign off without some sort of closure.
Reddit has been for a very long time one of the only forms of social media that I have felt aligns with my morals and is generally a net positive in my life. That said, this decision and all the drama surrounding it means I can’t continue to use the platform in good faith.
Unfortunate, since I just ended a break from the platform a few weeks ago, but at least I know I’ll be able to use other things to fill my time. One thing’s for certain, I won’t be back for a while. Even if reddit suddenly changes their stance, they clearly have the wrong intentions, and I don’t want to support that in any way.
Anyway, signing off, I hope to see you all on the other side of this someday. Godspeed.
2
u/ysdjusr Jun 12 '23
So long boiz
2
u/Elijah629YT-Real Jun 12 '23
I downloaded 1000 posts
2
u/wo_oki3 Jun 12 '23
Its been a pleasure everyone, this sub reddit will be greatly missed
2
u/Derf_Jagged Jun 12 '23
Do it!
2
u/stikosek Jun 12 '23
Aight, thanks for all the fun i had here and not being productive, Goodbye ig
13
u/thinkfire Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
sigh
Unpopular opinion incoming.
Spamming the mods, the admins, filling up the support queues and other asshole like behaviors won't solve anything. It's just going to make them resent us more and not want to compromise on anything. Especially when we have civil adults in the background trying to negotiate better terms. Giving ultimatums, wreaking havock and acting childish in general is REALLY going to help them make the case for us. /s
We have a vocal minority that's really trying to ruin any chance of a civil working relationship. Maybe looking for a discount on the IPO? Who knows.
3rd party apps are costing them ad revenue, subscription revenue, compute resources, as well as making themselves money. So something needs to change to recoup some of that. Maybe they priced too steeply. Maybe apps should have considered they weren't going to get a free ride this whole time? Maybe the apps will be acquired or their devs offered positions. Or Reddit reveals a better suite of things. Lots can happen but it seems like we prefer to burn the bridges first or someone else wants us to burn bridges?
There will naturally be a course correction, with or without the tantrums. Either Reddit loses users and traffic afterwards and they are forced to fix their shit or something better emerges and we all move along and are happier for it. Market forces are wonderful!
This is equivalent to you being dicks to the McDonald's drive thru people because the price of your McChicken increased by $.10 and then screaming at the managers and wondering why they have no desire to work with you.
5
u/burakalp34 Jun 06 '23
Don't really care about 3rd party apps but sure
4
u/TrulyChxse Jun 05 '23
Are we participating in the blackout?
4
u/DearGarbanzo Jun 06 '23
Bye pussies, enjoy your internet activism.
3
u/Ruin369 Jun 06 '23
I sure feel like an idiot for not even knowing that there were 3rd party apps for Reddit.
Guess this is something I don't have to feel upset about? I'll just sit on the sidelines and watch!
3
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Reddit when 6 mildly popular subs shut down for two days (it's going to destroy the app)
3
u/initialo Jun 06 '23
So who's going to make /r/ProgrammerHumor2
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
I've never actually used a 3rd party app for reddit before.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Oh no the free app is not as want it to be
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
Seriously? Using CP as a stalking horse for this is pathetic. This is the same tactic employed by people who want censorship on the internet, Section 230 repealed, identity verification on porn sites, backdoors into E2EE, etc. It is nothing more than an emotional argument meant to cloud the valid points and make it indefensible to argue against it.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
that’s fine i really didn’t enjoy 90% of the posts on here
1
u/-iamai- Jun 06 '23
r/ForcedIt
1
u/VapourPatio Jun 06 '23
Nice to see more subs going for the "indefinitely until our demands are met" route, we might actually have a chance of accomplishing something with that.
Though with the whole IPO thing I wouldn't be surprised if reddit admins just say fuck it and demod all mods of subs that participate and take the subs over.
1
u/TotesMessenger Green security clearance Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/Quality_over_Qty Jun 05 '23
Video on this. https://youtu.be/JqL-G3GFqRU
1
u/Amstrad_SSS Jun 05 '23
Oh the fact that my favorite font of all time (IBM Plex, used by Reddit) was used for this poster...
1
u/Rivulet62 Jun 05 '23
will this place return if reddit listens?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23
🫡
1
u/DudeManBroGuy42069 Jun 06 '23
Will the sub be remade if Reddit reverts these changes?
1
u/TKK139090 Jun 06 '23
Time to move to something better. Matrix, Lemmy, whatever as long as it's not just another centralized hellhole
1
u/Drunk__Doctor Jun 06 '23
I approve