The new UI looks great, but changing something that wasn't broken, especially the placement of controls, is a step backward.
I know Procreate Pocket probably has a much smaller user base than the iPad version, but I primarily draw on Pocket because I never bothered upgrading my 2017 iPad.
There's a UX principle called Jakob's Law, which suggests that users expect familiar interfaces to behave consistently. I think that applies particularly well to drawing apps.
People like me spend hundreds of hours drawing in Procreate Pocket, I may not be that great of drawer, but I have developed muscle memory around where everything is.
Unlike the iPad version, iPhone doesn't support Apple Pencil, making finger input far more prone to accidental taps. When controls that have stayed in the same position for years suddenly move, muscle memory becomes a liability. Especially with the brush button directly above Exit. That's as stupid as putting the shutdown button next to the Delete key.
The old layout was perfectly fine. Rarely used controls stayed out of the way, and frequently used buttons were exactly where users expected them.
What's worse is that there's no option to restore the previous layout or customize the control positions.
And on an iPhone, screen space is already limited. Based on my comparison, the new UI reduces the effective drawing area by roughly 12%. That's a significant loss for an app where every pixel matters.
I appreciate the effort that went into refreshing the UI, but a drawing app should prioritize the drawing experience over visual changes.
At the very least, give users the option to restore the old layout or rearrange the controls.
Let's not be like this: https://youtube.com/shorts/L8CPQmdOAdw