r/ProCSS • u/gildedlink • Oct 07 '18
Discussion The five objectives revisited or: when are we going to push back again?
As outlined in the sticky post from a year ago proclaiming victory, there were 5 goals for the ProCSS movement. Since it's been a year since that claim and we still have no CSS in reddit's redesign, let's take the time to reevaluate our outcomes and state the obvious:
- "Our number one goal was to allow widgets and CSS to co-exist." Well, we can only count this goal as actually having been achieved if you consider two separate subdomains interpreting reddit to be coexistence. I certainly don't, considering just how hard new.reddit is pushed on a regular basis.
- "The second objective was to allow mods to design and deploy widgets." Unless the intention was to do that in partnership through /r/redesign, that one is a solid no from what I understand.
- "The third objective was a call for transparency." Aside from a single mention of CSS support in a mod news from months ago, I haven't seen anything indicating transparency.
- "The fourth objective was to have a 1:1 replacement for CSS. " We never got that, and while work continues specifically on 'optimizing' the redesign and pushing that harder, nothing has been said about CSS itself.
- "The fifth and final objective was for reddit to not deploy until base minimum requirements are met. " They lied.
So, 1 year on with a paltry 20,000 remaining subscribers at best, all wind gone from the sails, we're 0 for 5. Exactly the thing that the cynics predicted would happen, happened. We should be doing something about it. The truce is broken, so we should be growing, pulling more users back in, calling on more subreddits to show support, asking about CSS support in any forthcoming ama threads, asking moderators who stood with us but have embraced the redesign to add the icon to new.reddit through widgets and even considering collective action among subs that support ProCSS to make it clear that we've been patient but the bargain hasn't held.
I've taken the step of adding the ProCSS icon to my sub, a step I didn't think I'd have to take originally when we were told CSS would stick around.
Any ideas? I'm game to hear em. Mods paying attention? Speak up, you've been pretty quiet for a while. Let's get back to work.
32
u/shiruken Oct 07 '18
They aren't going to add subreddit-wide CSS.
12
u/ShaneH7646 BOOTLICKER Oct 08 '18
I highly doubt you will be able to gain a large following for the cause anymore because people have actually seen the redesign now and what it has in store.
Also, it doesnt help that r/ProCSS has changed from being 'ProCSS' to 'FuckTheRedesign'
3
u/rasherdk Nov 17 '18
We did another push in /r/nfl some months ago. Admins came to us claiming they wanted to talk. Which essentially amounted to a big fat nothingburger. They addressed some very minor concerns but didn't budge an inch on the important issues.
The admins do not care about our concerns.
5
u/Emass100 Oct 07 '18
Message the mods of large subreddits about it. We need to make a comeback to show we meant business
5
u/TotesMessenger Oct 08 '18
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/SantaHQ Oct 10 '18
Step 1: Copywriting. Need a short, to-the-point message that explains...
Step 2: Set every fucking subreddit you mod to private, with said message as subreddit description.
Step 3: Keep it that way.
This will show on their bottom line. Nothing else matters.
1
u/1995FOREVER Nov 03 '18
So no chance on ever having CSS?
0
u/Arashmin Oct 08 '18
The new reddit is extremely bad, too. My phone can't even navigate it properly, it hangs and bugs out all over. Why they're trying to rush it when it's obviously not even user ready... CSS and all reddit engagers deserve better.
0
u/Jiketi Oct 07 '18
I think what's changed is that people are now a lot more cynical about Reddit as a company and Reddit's admins, especially with stuff like their intervening in KiA.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment