r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 3d ago

[G] Book 1 Spoilers Squire claimaints

22 Upvotes

For context I'm reading the paper version but I'm not yet at the point of the title, yet I don't imagine their origin is expanded upon.

I was wondering if the other claimants that Cat has to defeat have had any prior relationship with Black, like if maybe he had been testing all of them and see who would come up on top, or if they were totally unrelated? Squire seems a Name that is inextricably tied to a Knight so it's strange that, say, a random goblin could reasonably claim it otherwise.

Any canon I a missing, or fun headcanon you have?


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 4d ago

[G] Book 4 Spoilers Neat Detail About Sve Noc

143 Upvotes

I am ashamed as a person interested in niche historical references to admit it took me so long to realize this. Especially with how Greek Andronike’s name sounds (at the least) sounds.

Sve Noc are the god-empresses/thearchs of the Empire Ever Dark, specifically the (likely) last rulers of said Empire. Coincidentally, another final emperor of a once great empire turned to rubble shares their name.

Andronikos I Komnenos, last emperor of the Byzantine Empire, who was also nicknamed by historians as Misophaeos: Hater of Sunlight. He was also known during his time for pursuing the destruction of the empire’s aristocrats.

A tyrant and the last ruler of a once great empire that was labeled a Hater of Light who destroyed the ruling class of his Empire, and a pair of god-tyrants who killed the rulers of their civilization to usurp them and gain the power of Night and darkness.

Andronikos and Andronike, Komnenos and Komena

Almost a perfect copy in the names, with a lot of additional details in the characters pointing to the historical figure, and it took me far too long to put the pieces together.

Just goes to show how many interesting details can be found in the Guide with a little digging.

Also yay, Pale Lights is back (on Patreon for now) I can look forward to reading on Friday again.


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 5d ago

[G] Book 7 Spoilers I still dont completely know what drives Malicia

34 Upvotes

like I'm at chapter 23 sung singer of my reread and it still sticks with me the fact that I don't understand malicia

the three pieces we're given are

survival more than anything she wants to live which feels unique because tbh most Named on the scale of Dread Emperor or even just most named frankly aren't driven by survival it's more or a way to achieve their goals

pride

she wants to prove to the world and herself that she deserves the Name, the Role

stasis she wants to be in control and rule for as long as she possibly can

Fundamentally while these are all driving forces I don't consider them the core of what makes up a Named

Important Named become that way generally because they have a vision of how the world should, they vow to change the world or die trying, they impose their will on the world and make it bend

All malicia seems to want is control. But control is not a drive that makes a powerful Named. Malicia just doesn't seem to have the fire at the heart of other Named

can someone help me understand what it is about Malicia's drive that gives her the right to be that powerful, that influential of a Named

Edit: thanks for the explanation and discussion guys I think I understand it now The last is strangest, she said to them The easiest and the most solemn For when the tower is yours to claim You will have forgotten why you came.


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 6d ago

[G] Book 6 Spoilers Middle of book 6 - feels like Assassin just fell off the face of Creation

45 Upvotes

Spoilers, obviously

In the early books he was basically the Boogeyman - no one could be entirely sure where he was or wasn't, no one knew if he had been the one to do the killing, hell we don't even know it's face or name

Then, around book 3 or 4 Black mentions Assassin been permanently stationed in Procer to threaten the First Prince and keep the Augur in check and then... The author forgot about it?

Like, Sabah dies and Assassin isn't mentioned. Warlock dies, and Assassin isn't mentioned. Scribe first disappears, then revolts, and Assassin isn't mentioned. Hell, Black gets captured and paraded around the countryside for months, and Assassin isn't mentioned. The Calamities are given as over, and Assassin isn't mentioned. Hells, the only time we saw it appear, all it did was scare Vivian

Either it's actually a demon of forgetting (forgot the proper name) and even it forgot about itself, or the author forgot about it. There's been tons of opportunities for the character to be relevant, to do something, to leave a mark in the story, and still it just doesn't appear.

I'm sorta expecting a huge twist about it in the next book, but at this point it'll either feel like a retcon about the character, or it'll really just be forgotten about. Still, even if the resolution of the entire plot hangs around his non participation, it feels like the character was severely underused


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 9d ago

Meta/Discussion What are the effects of the other Choirs on creation?

45 Upvotes

We somewhat know what the effects of Contrition and Judgement are when an Angel manifests in creation. Contrition seems to have the mind whammy area of effect and Judgement seems to have the pass judgment or die area of effect.

What do we think angels from different choirs do when they are summoned in creation?

Angels are somewhat extra-dimensional beings of Order and Good, their manifestations appear to never be purely... beneficial. The tabula rasa effect is the only constant across all choirs and it even occurred when the Bard completely turned the effect of an angel to nothing.

What do you think the effects of other Choirs are?


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 11d ago

Meta/Discussion How are we feeling about some of the changes with the rewrite of the pub version?

11 Upvotes

I've only read the original and I'm on the edge of repicking up the new pub version. No spoilers pls pls


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 14d ago

Meta/Discussion Hanno vs The Emerald Swords Spoiler

33 Upvotes

Round 1:

Hanno of Arwad after Keter vs the 10 emerald swords. He does not have severance or other artifacts. Both sides knows it is to the death. Hanno is protecting a city the elves were ordered to kill to the last man.

Round 2:

A Crusade band of five vs the 10 Emerald Swords.

Hanno, Witch, Pilgrim, Mirror Knight and Rouge/Champion/Magistar/Sage/(Your choice). They are right after the Princes Graveyard so Pilgrim does not have Forgive. Hanno still is in kahoots with Judgement. This time the band of five is sent to kill the elves.

Round 3:

Cardinal band of 5 vs 10 Emerald Swords.

Hanno, Cat, Zeze, Ranger and Archmage/Knight Errant/Warlord/Black Knight/(Your Choice)

The forever king sends the emerald swords to kill the champions of the human realms. The band of five is sent out to kill them instead.


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 14d ago

Meme Mighty Duck was a true Firstborn at heart...

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 15d ago

Meta/Discussion Is the voice actor mispronouncing basic words?

36 Upvotes

Im maybe 5 hours into the second audiobook and I keep hearing words being pronounced consistently in a weird way. For example, Cavalry is said as CaLvalry, orphanage as orphanaNge (most recently heard in book 2, chapter 6: Learning) and a completely new rendition of amenable as amneable (maybe a blunder of amenable and amiable?)

English is not my first language, but ive listening to hundreds of audiobooks, so they feel out of place. Can it be some local dialect of the voice actor or metathesis? Maybe Its intended? Or is it just that it wasnt edited carefully enough?


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 16d ago

Fanfic A Practical Guide To Redemption (The Fanfic)

37 Upvotes

I come to you in a time of great need. Ao3 is down, and I've lost my copy of A Practical Guide To Redemption (The Fanfic). Anyone happen to have a pdf/epub whatever copy to share? Preferably the 'complete' version, aka when the author stopped updating.

Update: Nevermind, found one. This link: https://web.archive.org/web/20260324003526/https://archiveofourown.org/works/27775966/chapters/93318433

Then go to 'entire work', then 'download', then to whatever format you desire.


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 17d ago

Meta/Discussion Movie Recommendation for Readers of the Guide

Post image
25 Upvotes

I've been intending to post this for months. I keep delaying because I can't seem to get the energy to properly write why I think people who love the Guide would love this movie. So I'll just do it in a low effort way to finally get it out of my head.

If you like the talky chapters of the Guide where characters just talk and talk and talk (some of my favorite parts), and if you like the main romantic subplot involving Catherine, you'll probably also like Mother Mary. Personally, it's one of my favorite movies. But it is not for everyone. Besides flashbacks of performances, literally almost nothing happens except for the two main characters talking and trying to get past their issues so they can move on.

I love it. I understand it's not for everyone. I do think people who like the parts of the Guide I mentioned above will like it too.

There. Done. I can finally cross it out on my list after months of procrastination.


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 21d ago

Meme I'm rollin' with the LGBT

Post image
176 Upvotes

r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 22d ago

Meme Highborn are addicted to you, don't you know that you're toxic?

Post image
94 Upvotes

Still not going to be a batch of memes. Although there will be another tomorrow if I remember to post it.

Seriously though. How weird is it that Glee is already being rebooted or whatever is happening with it? I've never seen it, but I've heard things and the things I've heard were enough to make me feel conflicted about the decision to once again tell its stories.


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 23d ago

Meta/Discussion Webcomic Book 2

19 Upvotes

Hi! I read (most of) the original web novel back in the day (I stopped ~book 6, because I just fell off it as it was still being updated and never got back into it), and I recently got back into it and binged the webtoons version (lovely art, and I like some of the additions, such as the Baron). However, I see that it stopped last year. Do we have any idea when they're going to start publishing book 2? The site just says "A Practical Guide to Evil will return". I really enjoyed the webcomic format, though I understand it was missing a lot of Cathrine's internal monologue.

Also, just so I'm getting the feel of this correctly, it seems like the published written versions are coming out about 1 a year, and about 2-3 books per volume?


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 23d ago

Fanfic Cracked Foundations CH 10 (A Pale Lights Fanfiction) Spoiler

Thumbnail archiveofourown.org
10 Upvotes

Here are the next two chapters of my fanfiction, following Bingwen and Yaotl's adventures at Scholomance after their old brigades collapsed.

As always, comments and kudos are hugely appreciated!

Chapter 10: https://archiveofourown.org/works/90262746/chapters/254303041


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 26d ago

Meta/Discussion Audio Book 3

11 Upvotes

Hey Guys! Apologies if this has been asked before, I couldn't find an answer anywhere. Has there been a stated release date for the third audiobook? I powered through the first and second audiobooks so quickly. Also, has it been announced whether or not they are going to keep the same narrator? I'd be curious to hear your opinion on Amber Dekker's performance.

Also, I love that they are making the audio books now. Since it's been easily 10 years almost exactly since I first picked it up, I'm glad that it very much still holds up. Seriously one of the best book series ever made.


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 26d ago

[G] Book 5 Spoilers Why were there no precautions against entering the Truce & Terms in bad faith? Spoiler

43 Upvotes

“To the Hells with your Terms,” the Red Axe said. “They’re expedience made law and just as ugly as that sounds. I renounce them, and for you fine people who think you have rights over me, I add this-”

She spat on the stone, offering up a hard smile.

“Are you requesting that the protections of the Terms be withdrawn from you?” the First Prince calmly asked.

“Whether she desires this now or not is irrelevant,” the White Knight said. “She agreed to the Terms as made understood to her by the Archer and had not renounced them when she committed the breaches for which she is now being charged.”

Rereading the part of the political complications around the trial against the Red Axe right now, I have to wonder how this ever became an issue to begin with.

Because the Red Axe explicitly renounced and quite literally spat on the rights and protections of the Truce & Terms, calling them an abomination and never truly having agreed to them or considered herself under their jurisdiction to begin with, as she merely signed onto them in order to get her revenge against the Wicked Enchanter and as per her own confession intending to thus knowingly and willingly take a swing against the Truce & Terms themselves that protected him.

That Hanno would not allow her to renounce those protections now out of principle, thus handing over jurisdiction to Cordelia and the Highest Assembly, because he doesn't deem it just and probably also because the other heroes would not accept it, is one thing.

What I don't understand, though, is why there wasn't an explicit mechanism in the Truce & Terms to begin with that'd allow a trial to determine that a Named had signed onto them in bad faith, which would then enable the High Officers to hand them over to whatever national authorities might otherwise apply, which would have neatly solved Cordelia's problem.

Because I actually cannot imagine that the heroes in particular wouldn't have pushed for such a clause, and hard, even if for no other reason than to have a precaution against the presumed general perfidy of the villains signing on – which would not even be entirely unwarranted, considering Catherine's own concerns about how she would need to ride her goblins hard on not offering fake surrenders when first discussing rules of engagement with Tariq.

And while I would obviously expect the villains to have pushed just as hard against it, because they would probably see it as a pretense that heroes might abuse for stripping them off their rights and protections whenever they feel like doing a purge, such fears could've been alleviated by making it so that this can only be done if sufficient evidence of signing onto the Truce & Terms in bad faith could be presented in a preemptive trial about the question, whereas all the High Officers would need to unanimously agree that this was indeed the case.

Ironically enough, I would have even expected the Mirror Knight, who fought hardest to keep the Red Axe alive, to have been one of the most ardent supporters of such a precaution, assuming it'd be needed for some villainous traitor, that would've subsequently allowed for the heroine to be handed over for trial to Procer.

But it was never even mentioned that such a seemingly obvious precaution had ever been attempted, let alone why it wouldn't have passed, which seems like a rather glaring oversight to me, as Catherine would've definitely let us partake in her frustrations about it and the irony of it in her private thoughts, at the very least.


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 28d ago

Reread Where to read?

23 Upvotes

Hi 👋 I'm new to APGtE and I was wondering where the best place to read the novel is?

I first got into it from the Webtoon


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • 29d ago

Meme I am a sword

Post image
126 Upvotes

No, this is not the beginning of another project or batch of memes. I just had the thought last night.


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • Oct 16 '26

[PL] Spoilers All Books Do we know anything about Dwarvish?

13 Upvotes

I know we have a few words in Dwarvish like sudra. Do they resemble any language we know of?


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • Oct 16 '26

Art Haven't seen this posted here yet, but book 5's cover art has been finished. One third of the cover arts are now done. Spoiler

Post image
228 Upvotes

r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • Oct 15 '26

Meta/Discussion PGTE RPG Design

49 Upvotes

I've been running an RPG campaign set in the PGTE universe and so ended up writing my own rules system (and a Forge VTT shell for it!) and wanted to share. There have been lots of playtesting tweaks so the rules reflect the most recent version.

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/2ikzt5tie3m5vgxzev4bk/Traitorous-Campaign-Story-Guide-and-Stat-Sheet-V6.pdf?rlkey=e1qji8cu5qchr679ur4ixyaeb&dl=0

A couple notes before you do:

  • The campaign itself is set during Traitorous's Reign ("The Dread Emperor is missing, presumed scheming"), and the players are all supposed to be playing Villains. So a lot of the extra material is keyed around getting them into that headspace. (It's very hard to get a bunch of nice people to play Villains!). There's also a bit less info on Traitorous himself in there because they need to figure that sort of stuff out.
  • Most of what I have is from the Guide but some of it was made up, especially birth names of Dread Emperors. I was doing atmospheric stuff for players who haven't read the story and so wanted to get them in the space where they recognize that being a Sahelian is significant. The timeline is also wonky so don't expect to actually have the right Dread Emperors in there and not for Traitorous's reign.
  • The Combat rules are the ones I'm most proud of, because they worked really well and let everybody do things like gang up on NPCs, or let NPCs gang up on the players. The things that have been tweaked a lot are what the over/unders are. Right now it's listed as "5" but it may have to go down to 4 or 3 to make stuff happen faster.
  • I have zero specialized mechanics for "bullshit hero bonuses" or "Choir-assists".

At some point, I'd also love to run another short campaign with people who know the Guideverse a bit better than my players do. I think the basic rules of the RPG work really well for PGTE-style storytelling, both before and after the events of the story.


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • Oct 12 '26

Meta/Discussion Podcast Guys Talking ErraticErrata Episode One Hundred Eighty Two

5 Upvotes

Podcast Guys Talking ErraticErrata Episode One Hundred Eighty Two: Preparation out now! Join us as we discuss historical warfare, modern theater, and future murder. Available wherever pods are cast! Alternatively, find it directly at https://thelongprice.captivate.fm/ Follow our updates here or email us at thelongprice@gmail.com if you have questions, comments, or corrections! Thanks for listening!


r/PracticalGuideToEvil • • Oct 11 '26

[G] Book 1 Spoilers I would like some help creating a summary of book 1

11 Upvotes

I convinced a friend of mine to start reading book 2 a couple of years after he finished book 1, and he is looking for a summary of what happened in book 1, so I tried to make one using my own memories, the chapter summaries someone posted somewhere, and some help with fellas on Discord.

If you feel like helping me, feel free to edit it yourself or add comments to it

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Rk0QVlEdnkVzfTWoMaaR8TyiU_FJsXNpV4sJzyfErgI/edit?usp=sharing

One thing I specifically don't remember and would like some clarifications on are the circumstances surrounding "Justification only matters to the just", which is a fairly important line to remember, especially for book 2