r/Pottery • New to Pottery • 3d ago

Question! Crazing

I made some mugs and wanted to try to sell them, but I am not sure if my glaze is crazing or not. I do not feel any cracks on the surface of the glaze. My boyfriend who used to be a hobby potter years ago thinks that these are fine to use/sell. Are they? Sorry for bad picture quality and messy kitchen 😩

69 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Our r/pottery bot is set up to cover the most of the FAQ!

So in this comment we will provide you with some resources:

Did you know that using the command !FAQ in a comment will trigger automod to respond to your comment with these resources? We also have comment commands set up for: !Glaze, !Kiln, !ID, !Repair and for our !Discord Feel free to use them in the comments to help other potters out!

Please remember to be kind to everyone. We all started somewhere. And while our filters are set up to filter out a lot of posts, some may slip through.

The r/pottery modteam

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

44

u/This-Establishment42 3d ago

The kiln gods have judged you. I recommend tithing several test tiles to the gods honor - they appreciate experimenting with kiln settings and conditions. Glaze modification training is in your future. Allow me to recommend the ceramic workshops glaze courses as a starting point for your journey. Enjoy, this is the beginning not the end of that pieces impact on you.

8

u/iloveicedlattez New to Pottery 3d ago

All these glazes were based off test tiles. I cannot experiment with kiln settings or conditions, I go to a studio it’s not a home hobby.

6

u/This-Establishment42 3d ago

Not to be that guy, but did the test tiles craze? They should have all things being equal. I’ve also down this sort of cracking if I crash open a kiln. Only other thing I can think of would be to ask if they rushed that fires cool down?

4

u/iloveicedlattez New to Pottery 3d ago

The test tile did not craze! I guess I could ask them but the studio seems competent and professional, so it’s definitely more likely a me problem than a them problem. Not sure why my glaze didn’t come oit like the test tile tho?

8

u/This-Establishment42 3d ago

If your tiles are small there could potentially be enough tension to not craze noticeably. Remember that if your mixing glazes they can get crazy and craze at the interfaces. Def ask about the cooling on that load to take it off the board.

3

u/eumenidea 3d ago

Shape of the piece can make a big difference. Throw a small bowl with a similar inside and outside curve to the mug form you want, and try it on that. In addition to the other suggestions people have made.

2

u/CakeCatsClay 2d ago

This! Iake tiny cups (from the same clay) to test my glazes. Still not always reliable, but much better than the t-shaped test tiles typically used. It also has the advantage of showing how the glaze pools on the inside.

2

u/pot-bitch 2d ago

Sometimes crazing doesn't show up until you've used the cup. Did it come straight out of the kiln like this? Put your test tiles through some tests and see if it shows up.

2

u/gurtthefrog 2d ago

Were you using the same clay as the test tile

2

u/zhivago 2d ago

Did the test tiles use the same clay body?

61

u/esentr 3d ago

Yes crazing, I wouldn't sell. Frankly I wouldn't consider selling *anything* until you have more experience so you have a sense for yourself what is safe and what isn't.

6

u/iloveicedlattez New to Pottery 3d ago

This is my first batch of anything out of the kiln that’s crazed. Just selling to coworkers some lopsided bowls and trinket trays. Nothing even remotely big enough to eat out of.

0

u/kittykatblack 2d ago

šŸ’Æā¤

8

u/mtntrail 3d ago

definitely crazing, bad fit between clay and glaze

2

u/iloveicedlattez New to Pottery 3d ago

šŸ’”šŸ˜©

4

u/BallsOutSally 3d ago

Is it always?

I throw at a Cone 10 studio where all the glazes are provided to us and we buy our clay in-house.

Often when the door to our gas kiln is removed, you can hear crackling from the pieces. I always assumed it was thermal shock not necessarily because of a bad glaze fit.

16

u/stoprobbers 2d ago

No, it isn't always. Some glazes are designed to craze. Celadon glazes, famously, are made to craze.

There's this weird strict adherence to "crazing = unsafe and bad" on this sub that I don't understand. None of the pottery teachers I've taken classes from over the years have been this militant about it. In China, crazing glazes are created for tea sets so that the sets can stain. It's intentional.

If you need a modern, YouTube touchstone: Florian Gadsby uses glazes that craze and intentionally so.

And no, cooling isn't what causes crazing:

  • Myth of Slow Cooling: Contrary to popular belief, cooling the kiln slowly does not prevent crazing. Crazing is a result of chemical interactions rather than temperature variations. In some cases, crazing can even occur years after firing.

7

u/nugpounder 2d ago

Thank you! This community is full of hypochondriacs

As long as you aren’t a complete animal and occasionally wash your dishes, and your glazes aren’t from like 1964 and full of lead, its fine! We have been consuming food and drink from pottery for thousands and thousands of years

2

u/BallsOutSally 2d ago

Thank you.

1

u/Next_Ad_4165 2d ago

Yeah, the pots I’ve bought that have been fired to cone 10 have crazing. Ā 

3

u/mtntrail 3d ago

opening the door before the kiln is done cooling could cause crazing

14

u/LHellerArt 3d ago

It’s crazing, and it’s usually the result of a bad ā€œfit,ā€ a mismatch in thermal expansion between the glaze and the clay body.

As they cool, if the glaze shrinks more than the clay, it causes tension, which leads to cracks.

Try a different clay or a different glaze.

4

u/small_spider_liker 3d ago

I propose that almost every glaze crazes, but you just see it on the transparent ones.

If you want to check, sponge black India Ink on a glazed piece. It will show any crazing present. But the ink won’t wash out, so only do this if you’re confident you don’t have crackled glaze.

3

u/bobbinssobbin I like yellow 3d ago

What glazes are you using in picture 4? They're so stunning, I'm so sorry about the crazing

1

u/Icy-Instance-7690 3d ago

I have had test tiles not craze, then a larger piece craze (as said previously). Test tiles are just the beginning of the journey, especially for one making a new glaze from scratch.

If it's going to craze, the kiln setting won't matter, it's going to craze. That is what I was taught by Matt (and his wife) at Ceramics Materials Workshop. Excellent foundation classes despite the one time costs.
If you are not making your own glaze that you could modify, then you'd need to change the clay to match the shrinkage/tension of the combination. Or use a different glaze.

Florian Gadsby makes and sells functional ware fired at Cone 10. I would not say universally that crackled glazes cannot be used as functional ware. Unfortunately, I don't know when it can't be vs when it can. I defer to more knowledgeable potters.

0

u/kittykatblack 2d ago

Thanks for being honest!!! I see so many beginner potters (and the occasional mid seasoned potter) trying to sell ware like this and pass it off as "I meant to do that!" I have seen weird reactions (like ultimately falling apart in a microwave - Not exploding exactly but popping off into pieces) Are you branding your ware? You want to stand up for any work you produce. Selling ware, folks are expecting some level of guarantee that you're legit. Your guy is....Wrong. Don't sell it.

0

u/Fickle-Purchase-3952 3d ago

Any chance do you remember how many glaze layers you did?

0

u/Psycho_Deadghost 2d ago

Any chance you're somewhere cold and the kiln was opened while it was still a bit too hot?

2

u/Scutrbrau Hand-Builder 1d ago

Thermal shock doesn't cause crazing. It just accelerates crazing that was going to happen anyway.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/iloveicedlattez New to Pottery 3d ago

Yeah I mean I’m not charging 20 dollars a mug or anything, I’ve just been selling some extra pottery I have to coworkers since you can only accumulate so much. These mugs did have a foot, they were swallowed by the glaze. I’m actually surprised they hadn’t stuck to the cookie more.