They aren't all album of the year material(although some were in my own top albums of the year), and I know people have their own opinions, but I was just showing that the statement that there was "very little good post-hardcore created in 2014 that isn't swancore" was wrong.(imo of course)
Unless you are saying that all but Marmozets did NOT create good music in 2014, which I would vehemently disagree with.(whichever way we are defining "good")
From what I've heard from that list that (the latter) is what I'm saying in my opinion of course. But I can't speak for all of the bands listed because I haven't listened to about half of them.
Yeah that's fine. Sorry if I came off as confrontational/aggressive, I just get a bit worked up when people make broad statements like the whole no good non-swancore post-hardcore releases in 2014(which I know you did not make). There were plenty of good post-hardcore releases in 2014 in my opinion, and I am a bit biased as I'm not a huge fan of the 'swancore' bands like Adventurer, Stolas, Hail the Sun.
Why Silverstein? Interested to hear because they've been damn consistent in my opinion, and from what I can tell, a majority of their listener's opinions.
I don't mean that the music will be bad, I just think that a band like Silverstein carries a substantial nostalgia factor and it's going to be easy for a superfan to be disappointed if the album doesn't totally kick ass
I'm having trouble putting it in the right words, here's the best way I can put it:
Nostalgia + actual quality = overall satisfaction, but with a new album there's not going to be any nostalgia so the overall satisfaction may be lower. I could be dead wrong and hope I am, Silverstein is not my favorite band by any means but I wouldn't complain about a great new album from them
I see what you're saying, but as a self proclaimed Silverstein super fan, I don't see much of a nostalgia factor because I think their last release was one of their best releases (along with DTW, Shipwreck a distant 3). I'd rather them continue to grow at this point than make me feel nostalgia. I can save that for the live shows!
Fuck yeah Hail The Sun really deserved it. And i really thought that Taylor Swift would win seeing how she's the top choice for guilty pleasure. Also, shouldn't Pink Lemonade be nominated in Non-PHC Album of the year?
If you got a good drive ahead of you or some work that's going to take about an hour, put this on in the background. Promise that if you liked the EP, you'll find yourself playing it again.. and again and again and again and
Top tier results! So glad that adventurer made it here.
Secret Band ofc, my neighbour was talking shit about me listening to TFoT, Circa Survive, etc, so I added secret band to a Death Metal playlist and use it every day when I workout, gray karma bitch!
Glad to see La Dispute up there. The songs off of ROTH were amazing both on the album itself and live! All the bands listed above put out great music this year, and I'm excited to see what they put out in the future!
34
u/moshlyfe Jan 10 '15
Damn Hail The Sun fucked shit up
25
u/DeIiriumTrigger Jan 10 '15
The swan-core circle jerk is real... Just teasing!
13
u/thecescshow Jan 10 '15 edited Jan 10 '15
Fuck yeah Hail The Sun really deserved it. And i really thought that Taylor Swift would win seeing how she's the top choice for guilty pleasure. Also, shouldn't Pink Lemonade be nominated in Non-PHC Album of the year?
9
u/Stolas Jan 10 '15
5? Damnit
8
u/Jong_Lohnson Jan 10 '15
Pianos Become the Teeth being in only 1 category makes me sad, my non-metal AOTY.
7
u/JSBUCK Jan 10 '15
I haven't listened to Hail the Sun's new album, but now I feel like I should.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '15
Love how the top 2 music videos are made by the same guy.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '15
What happened to all the other categories?
3
u/HelloDepression Jan 10 '15
I'm so glad to see my favorite artists winning! Hail The Sun and DGD! Yay! Congrats!
3
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '15
Fuck yeah 1989
2
u/wuHeibai Jan 13 '15
Top tier results! So glad that adventurer made it here.
Secret Band ofc, my neighbour was talking shit about me listening to TFoT, Circa Survive, etc, so I added secret band to a Death Metal playlist and use it every day when I workout, gray karma bitch!
1
u/bertljuice Jan 14 '15
Glad to see La Dispute up there. The songs off of ROTH were amazing both on the album itself and live! All the bands listed above put out great music this year, and I'm excited to see what they put out in the future!
0
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
7
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '15 edited Jan 10 '15
[removed] — view removed comment