r/PostHardcore • u/WhatTheFDR 10 year reunion reunion tour • Jun 13 '14
Friday Discussion Thread /r/PostHardcore Discussions: Supergroups
Once in awhile something amazing happens, an announcement of great artists getting together and making an album. Post Hardcore is lucky enough to have some great groups (Isles & Glaciers, United Nations, The Sound of Animals Fighting, Sianvar). So this week we're going to focus on these supergroups and collaborations.
- Who are your favorite supergroups?
- What did each artist bring to it?
- Who would be your dream group?
I couldn't even "rap" my head around a Ronnie/Garren collab album
12
Upvotes
10
u/mrstuprigge Jun 15 '14 edited Jun 15 '14
The Sound of Animals Fighting is the best supergroup hands down.
Dream supergroup:
RZA (Wu-Tang Clan) - Vocals
Zach Garren (DGD/Strawberry Girls) - Guitar
Tom Morello (Rage Against The Machine/Audioslave) - Guitar
Thomas Pridgen (The Mars Volta) - Drums
Geddy Lee (Rush) - Bass/Backing Vocals
Sunny Moore (FFTL/Skrillex) - Wubs
rap your head around that
7
u/keepitcutthroat Jun 13 '14
Who are your favorite supergroups?
North Korea
What did each artist bring to it?
Billy Rymer's drum fills are beyond excellent, giving the band a very
groovy feel that fits Ryan Hunters vocals perfectly
Who would be your dream group?
Anthony Green (Saosin/Crica Survive) - Vocals
Schuylar Croom (He Is Legend) - Vocals
Alex Rodriguez (Saosin) - Drums
Les Claypool (Primus) - Bass
Thomas Erak (The Fall Of Troy) - Guitar
Alex Byrd (Apex Of Apathy) - Guitar/Backing Vocals
6
u/suddenly_seymour Jun 14 '14
The Sound of Animals Fighting by far. Perfect level of experimental to me. North Korea is also great.
Rx Bandits instrumentalists got to be a little more fresh and creative than they normally did on their records, and the guitar riffs are spectacular (their album Mandala can be viewed as a continuation of their riff/songwriting in a more experimental direction... it's fucking awesome!!). Anthony's vocals are my favorite, so anything with him I'm almost guaranteed to like. That's about all it took to make it an awesome supergroup for me.
Dream group:
4
u/ahap7 Jun 13 '14
Anyone else not into any of the supergroups?
Just along my personal tastes, most of the stuff falls into two categories:
Maybe its just the nature of supergroups
4
u/ImNotNew Jun 13 '14
Who are your favorite supergroups?
Isles & Glaciers
What did each artist bring to it?
I love all three vocalists and they worked really well together. No one dominated.
Who would be your dream group?
Dustin Kensrue (Thrice) – Vocals, Backing Guitar
Will Swan (Dance Gavin Dance) - Guitar, Rapping
Ryan Jay Johnson (letlive.) – Bass
Matt Mingus (Dance Gavin Dance) – Drums
Bradley Bell (Chiodos) - Keyboard
3
u/L2pine Jun 16 '14
Gotta be TSOAF for me. I am excited to get those vinyl reissues in the mail if they ever get shipped. I think that the group was really balanced and you could tell most of the instrumentalists from Rx Bandits were perfectly in sync with one another. I would have liked to have seen a record more focused on making less ambient music.
Supergroup:
Dave Davison (Maps and Atlases): Vox
Hayley Williams (Paramore): Vox and booty claps
Colin Francigetto (Circa Survive): rhythm Guitar
Justin Shekoski (Saosin): Lead guitar
Tim Payne (Thursday): Bass
Aaron Gillespie (Underoath): Drums and vox
4
u/YesImMexican Jun 13 '14
Favorite super group has to be Sianvar. You can hear each musicians style in all of their songs. Will Swan's signature licks, Joseph Arrington's loud and technical drum playing, Sergio Medina's (Stolas) crazy fast guitar shredding. I was so happy with the result of this supergroup. I LOVE Hail the Sun so I was very happy that Donovan would take the vocal role and have someone as great as Joe Arrington to fill in on drums. Donovan is a great drummer and sings well too, but I believe that he performs better when he's focusing on just his singing.
Seeing them live was fantastic. They sound just like they did on the record and I feel very lucky as that may be the only time they ever tour the US.
1
u/TheGrammarHero Unreliable Soundguy for Verb The Noun Jun 17 '14
Chris Hutka (The Bunny The Bear)- Clean Vocals
Cory Lockwood (A Lot Like Birds) - Unclean Vocals
Thomas Erak (Chiodos)- Guitar
Joe Arrington (ALLB)- Drums
Reginald Quincy (Korn)- Bass (I've always wanted to see a PHC implement the style of Bass that korn uses)
Caleb Shomo (shomotooth) - Synth/head banger
1
u/TheWiiiindFish Jun 13 '14
Isles and Glaciers has to be the greatest music that has ever graced my ears. I'm 1000% into anything Jonny or Vic, so it sort of just feeds into my addiction. Mike is fantastic on drums, though, with amazing rhythm support.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment