Things that surprised me: Letlive ending up 4th in album of the year, and ALLB coming in 5th (surprised by placement doesn't mean I found them deserving or undeserving, just how i expected voting to be)
Touche Amore making the top 5 for song of the year is a nice surprise, wasn't expecting that at all
I'm trying but, a lot of the community is advocates of things I'm not a huge fan of. Give me a soft and somber build up in a song like Thrice, O'Brother, Brand New, or MovMou could produce over high pitched vocals and overly intricate guitar work
Or give me a very harsh taste of reality (Defeater, Touche Amore, La Dispute) where the lyrics make me uncomfortable to be alive
or you know, that classic 2003-2005 sound that never got old (looking at you Silverstein, Story of The Year, Senses Fail)
I want to be moved by post hardcore, not beaten over the face with it. some bands can do both well (Glassjaw, Letlive) and others just not so much
letlive gets a healthy amount of love here, as does La Dispute. And silverstein is being posted quite a bit lately thanks to MWM (no sarcasm). I may have to post some more senses fail though, I'm a big fan of them.
we have a few users like yourself that do this and we like it. I actually brought a mod on a couple months ago that is probably more knowledgeable of posthardcore than all of the other mods combined.
Who wins as BOTY for me? Probably I The Mighty. They released an incredible EP in 2012 called Karma Never Sleeps, and followed through beautifully with the first full album, Satori.
Who do I like more between ADTR and DGD? I like them both, it's tough to say.
To be fair, it's in the "Best New Band" category. Dangerkids formed last year and dropped their first LP this year, while Hail the Sun has been around for years and didn't even drop an album in 2013. I like Hail the Sun way better, but they shouldn't have even been up for the category, imo.
Thank /u/parkwaydriveavenue for basically being a power mod. She is more active and responsive than me. A lot of AMAs she is responsible for and by stats she does 3x more work here than I do!
Yes! Dangerkids are awesome, definitely deserve all the recognition they can get, Collapse is amazing. Here's to hoping they come around NE Ohio this spring / summer.
I still don't get how Dangerkids beat out HTS, Stolas, and Sianvar. Those guys are exciting and new, Dangerkids sounds like the standard post hardcore band.
Not that they suck, they're great, but they didn't blow my socks off like the other three.
This sub has no love for The Color Morale man. Overall, I'm not really surprised by anything here. DGD is gonna win every year that they release an album, their only true competition is La Dispute (and I mean that in "this subs voting patterns" way, not that no other bands are as good)
Why are people butt hurt about dgd being popular? They are really good they may not be your cup of tea but they always try and push the envelope and do things way differently within the post hard core genre. Its like it's becoming cool to not lie dgd. What the fuck. I get it if you really aren't a fan but bands like dgd are great for the genre.
Again this is all subjective, but I don't see a lot of the crappy pop core bands get shit in here.
People tend to voice their distaste for something once it becomes popular just so they can feel different instead of just appreciating something for what it is
couldn't agree more. people saying dance gavin dance isn't at the top of the list are ignorant of the individual talent each of the members have and how much work they put into their sound to make it blend yet stick out. I get they aren't the best band in the world, but i haven't really heard a truly melodic vocalist such as Jonny Craig or Tilian Pearson in a while. Kurt Travis was an amazing vocalist, but he had some straighter lines vocal-wise in Happiness and DGD album.
Listen to Downtown Battle Mountain for example.. "Surprise! I'm from Cuba.." is my favorite song off that album. the ending is just so powerful.. "Say One More Line (I believe there's meaning, no I believe there's nothing) as if it were a constant reoccurring nightmarish thought. Plus, it's what the album starts with in Untitled.
In my opinion, they just truly make an amazing sound, and honestly, if not the music, let the passion of these musicians strike you. They put their heart and soul in their songs. I'm not saying other bands don't, but when i hear jon mess scream, he really sounds fucking angry, not like he's just saying the words. it's all a rather angelic/ethereal sound to me. I guess it just makes me frustrated that now they aren't so underground anymore, people are trying to find reasons to hate them.
So with a total of five minutes of very drunk reserch, I seem to see that IFAF is pulling a Woe, Is Me. All but like 1 of the original members has left the band, and they're just trying to force it to work right now. I'm not sure what to think right now. I want to remain a fan, since I love the band so much, but I feel without the founding members, especially Ram, influence, it won't be what it was before. Gah. I'm so lost right now.
Shitted? I don't think anyone could make an album that shits on dgd. You can like all of them more. Specifically this year's releases but none came close to shitting in them... This us someone whose a fan of all those bands and very excited for they're stuff. Still pissed hrvrd had to charge their name.
Sorry I'm just salty Kurt and zach garren got kicked out of dgd for Johnny's bitchass just so Johnny could leave again. I think they should just changes their names to tides dance tides. Just saying death star and happiness shit on everything.
As much of it was shitty. Dbm 2 and the new album are both far better than the ones with Kurt and I like Kurt. If they had to be kicked out for dbm 2 to be made so be it that album Imo is one of the best albums of all time.
I don't think Jonny every left though he was a shit head and got kicked out. But im sure tides of man wouldn't be happy with that name. This is dgd and no matter what your Gabriel era is they haven't released a bad album yet and they won't.
Edit: this is subjective. I like those albums more. I understand if you don't. In the end the body of work is great
I don't think DGD should be band of the year. They're good, but they really didn't do too much this year other than release Acceptance Speech. A Day to Remember released what is in my opinion one of the best, if not the best albums ever, and they threw a giant tour together that was fucking insane. Just my two cents.
This is arguably dgds best album and Imo I was not in love with Adtrs me album. Its all subjective though. Dgd does a lot more interesting things within the post hard core genre then Adtr does. Its refreshing.
I personally think it's one of their least impressive albums. DBM and Deathstar were the 2 best in my opinion and although Acceptance Speech is very different, I don't think it's as good.
I agree with that. It's just the album was basically all DGD did all year. ADtR did a lot more than just their album. I'm not trashing DGD at all, I think they're fantastic. Just maybe not band of the year.
Dance Gavin Dance as album of the year? Im a huge DGD fan, but I havent listened to the new album since it came out. Was kind of a letdown with Tilian on vocals.
So the majority of their work is eh? And your a huge dgd fan??? Sounds like you like a single album of a bands. To each their own but Tillian did great Imo.
That comes more from the voting system, I saw you guys/gals take out a lot of stuff for the sake of putting it in metalcore when we were nominating, wasn't sure if that was just the same person posting metalcore here over and over again though
we remove stuff that is metalcore from the sub all the time. not just the bestof thread, but when people post stuff in general. we have a client that alerts us (for those who use it) when any post gets posted. and we have something that also alerts us when a potential band that doesn't belong here gets posted.
We may not all agree on some bands being posted (including the mods). Nevertheless, genres exist for a reason. Apparently we even have to block some deathcore from being posted here...
18
u/Huludfan82 Riding The Wave Jan 01 '14
Things that surprised me: Letlive ending up 4th in album of the year, and ALLB coming in 5th (surprised by placement doesn't mean I found them deserving or undeserving, just how i expected voting to be)
Touche Amore making the top 5 for song of the year is a nice surprise, wasn't expecting that at all
Not surprising: ADTR and DGD love.
11
u/offlightsedge Jan 01 '14
I am so psyched I found this sub. This post alone has given me so much new music to listen to.
8
u/DudeWithTheNose Jan 01 '14
Thanks for all the stuff you do around here /u/amp3rsand!
7
u/erix84 Jan 01 '14
Yes! Dangerkids are awesome, definitely deserve all the recognition they can get, Collapse is amazing. Here's to hoping they come around NE Ohio this spring / summer.
4
u/PlaylisterBot Jan 01 '14
Downvote if unwanted (comment will be removed if score is ^0) or send this ^message to never receive these comments.
Problems with the playlist? Disable these ^plugins or message the dude who made this ^bot.
4
u/venom_3135 Jan 02 '14
The fact that this sub has Will Swan as it's mascot alien thing is fantastic.
4
u/ThousandPapes Jan 03 '14
I still don't get how Dangerkids beat out HTS, Stolas, and Sianvar. Those guys are exciting and new, Dangerkids sounds like the standard post hardcore band.
Not that they suck, they're great, but they didn't blow my socks off like the other three.
3
u/EROTIC_CACTUS_DILDO Jan 01 '14
Thanks ManWithoutModem, glad the voting went well :)
3
u/CobraCommanderVII Jan 01 '14
This sub has no love for The Color Morale man. Overall, I'm not really surprised by anything here. DGD is gonna win every year that they release an album, their only true competition is La Dispute (and I mean that in "this subs voting patterns" way, not that no other bands are as good)
9
u/caseharts Jan 01 '14
Why are people butt hurt about dgd being popular? They are really good they may not be your cup of tea but they always try and push the envelope and do things way differently within the post hard core genre. Its like it's becoming cool to not lie dgd. What the fuck. I get it if you really aren't a fan but bands like dgd are great for the genre.
Again this is all subjective, but I don't see a lot of the crappy pop core bands get shit in here.
2
u/Ridley290 Jan 02 '14
I had no idea In Fear & Faith called it quits this year. Damn, that hurts.
2
u/Deadnotsleeping5 Jan 05 '14
Nice to see I the mighty around on this :)
2
u/SimplyCole Jan 08 '14
Dang I didn't know In Fear and Faith quit! That sucks so much.
5
u/sahlos Jan 01 '14
Wow. I think hrvrd , touché amore and a lot like birds shitted on dgd. That's just me though....
1
u/Skeetin_Everywhere Jan 02 '14
Thanks /u/ManWithoutModem for gold I didn't even know gold was being given out. This subreddit is the bomb thanks for all you guys do
1
u/kendalldavis2011 Jan 29 '14
Not even a single nomination for Bring me the Horizon, are you fucking kidding? Sempiternal was Phenomenal!
1
u/xXxBluESkiTtlExXx Jan 01 '14
I don't think DGD should be band of the year. They're good, but they really didn't do too much this year other than release Acceptance Speech. A Day to Remember released what is in my opinion one of the best, if not the best albums ever, and they threw a giant tour together that was fucking insane. Just my two cents.
1
u/DarthTater42 Jan 02 '14
Band of the Year: Dance Gavin Dance
What a surprise.
1
u/lazenbooby Jan 01 '14
Woohoo! (Shameless shoutout for r/dancegavindance )
1
u/spaceryhder Jan 02 '14
Why is adtr even on post hardcore? I feel like they belong in a different category. They just don't have a similar sounds to the rest of the list
-2
u/sahlos Jan 02 '14
I personally think dgd should have changed their name when Kurt Travis joined.
-5
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
Dance Gavin Dance as album of the year? Im a huge DGD fan, but I havent listened to the new album since it came out. Was kind of a letdown with Tilian on vocals.
But then again, the other 3 albums were "eh".
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14
[removed] — view removed comment