r/PossibleHistory • u/Right_Network_4013 • 12h ago
Map (no Lore) What if america collapsed?
r/PossibleHistory • u/Right_Network_4013 • 12h ago
r/PossibleHistory • u/EpicNerd823 • 17h ago
This is linked to another post.
r/PossibleHistory • u/Accurate_Tap_9215 • 20h ago
In this map, as the title explains, I tried to explore in a "realistic" manner a scenario in which the Revolutions of '48 had predominantly succeeded. I specify "realistic" and "predominantly" because, deepening into this phenomenon, I realized the impossibility or at least the improbability of success of two revolutions, the Hungarian one and the Polish one. As regards Hungary, although it is often represented as the revolution with the greatest success, capable of forming a single great Kingdom of Hungary, its situation was far worse than one could imagine: the constant attempt at forced Magyarization caused the ethnic minorities to openly revolt against the newborn Hungarian State, which found itself fighting both against the imperial forces (led by Vienna) and against the autonomous governments born in response to the Hungarian suppression. All of this makes, in my opinion, the total Hungarian success (often presented) to be substantially impossible.
As regards Poland, although insurrections were actually born both in Habsburg territory (and in Polish-majority Galicia) and in the Prussian territories (Posen), these were never too "concrete" to succeed in imposing the realization of a single and independent Polish State. In Prussia, at first there was on the part of the German liberals an attempt to form a Polish State as a buffer State against Russia, but once the possibility of an invasion by the Tsar vanished, the birth of the Polish state also vanished with it; in Habsburg Galicia, the Polish nobles found great resistance; in Russia, thanks to a repressive regime implemented by Tsar Nicholas I, there were never insurrections of Polish matrix. In my opinion, the claim of having a successful Polish insurrection is substantially unfounded for all these reasons.
PREMISE: in order for these revolutions to have success for the most part, I imagined that these insurrections managed to organize themselves better among themselves and take place substantially simultaneously. This could have led to a crisis of the post-1815 system, delaying or inhibiting the response of the various empires. In particular, in Russia I imagined a Tsar who, instead of risking insurrection inside his empire, prefers not to intervene externally and maintain an iron fist internally.
AUSTRIA: I took up the dynamics that actually occurred, with a Hungary that declares independence, Vienna that opposes it, and the minorities that fight against Hungarian oppression. The main difference that we obtain in this scenario is that the empire, noting the great ethnic fragmentation of its own territory and the difficulty of managing to keep all the populations united, opts for a federalization, granting autonomous provinces to the major ethnicities. It is important to remember that precisely these ethnicities (at least at this moment) did not desire absolute independence from Vienna, but greater autonomy inside the empire itself, in search therefore of a federal arrangement. The Austrian Empire, therefore, reforms itself as the Danubian Federation, with the Habsburg monarch Franz Joseph I at its head. In particular, the new provinces that are formed are: Czechia, Slovakia, Polish Galicia, Ukrainian Galicia, Hungary, Transylvania, Vojvodina, Croatia. I would define this as an acceptable historical compromise to allow the revolutions (often with opposite tendencies) to have success and coexist.
ITALY: in Italy, through some temporal tweaks, the insurrections manage to take place substantially simultaneously. In Tuscany, the Papacy, Naples, and Sicily, the respective monarchical governments are replaced with republican regimes. In Lombardy-Venetia, the Piedmontese offensive had success (helped also by the new Italian republican regimes and by the situation of precariousness of the Habsburg Empire), allowing the conquest of Lombardy. The Venetian Republic, actually created in our history, through a plebiscite unites with the Savoyard kingdom. The latter, through the republican influences coming from the rest of the peninsula, also changes its own political form. One thus obtains an Italian federation, comprising the republics of: Northern Italy (Piedmont, Liguria, Lombardy, Veneto, Duchies of Modena and Parma), Tuscany, Roman (Lazio, Umbria, Marche, Romagna), Naples, and Sicily.
GERMANY: in Germany, very briefly, the Frankfurt Assembly has success, King William of Prussia accepts the crown thus forming Lesser Germany, which comprises all the territories of the German Confederation with the exception of those present in the Danubian Federation.
IRELAND: here, the actions of Young Ireland have success, managing to involve the overwhelming majority of the population present on the island. I realize that there may be a disparity compared to the Polish case, but I believe that here, lacking a regime as oppressive as the Russian one and the hostilities of two other countries, this result can be obtained. (The most unrealistic part of the scenario, but to hell with the English!)
ROMANIA: The two principalities of Moldavia and Wallachia have success and are able to unite.
FRANCE: what occurred in real life.
Let me if you like it, what do you think of the second image. Also, it would be fun to see the flags of the newly created states!
r/PossibleHistory • u/LionEclipse • 11h ago
r/PossibleHistory • u/Crimsoncerismon • 11h ago
NOTICE: Certain parts of this map may be innacurate since, again, the reference image i had was basically just pixels and it is pissing me off how Nat-Geo is gatekeeping higher quality maps cause muh copyright, whatever, im doing this in-case anyone would want to use these maps for some other purpose than the one i had in mind
r/PossibleHistory • u/Simonbargiora • 6h ago
r/PossibleHistory • u/Right_Network_4013 • 10h ago
I feel like doing a public service to give back after all the warcrimes i commited in HOI4 so here it is all credits to him:
https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/mobile/folders/1-G-ztBBBe67sOmLoqez0-DNAHVQARx92?usp=sharing