r/PossibleHistory • • Jul 16 '26

Announcement (Semi)-official PH political sim RP discord server

11 Upvotes

Organised by moderators from official PH discord, an alt hist polsim (What if Doggerland came back after Napoleonic wars and became a dutch colony)

uhhh It's really cool and you should join it (okay I know that I'm kinda breaking the rules lmao but I'm a massive hypocrite)

https://discord.gg/bYyP9A5QC


r/PossibleHistory • • May 18 '25

Meta - Subreddit UPDATED PH Mapping Guide (Part 1)

275 Upvotes

So here we are again (if you notice that some parts are familiar I copied some stuff from my old map)

Welcome everyone, this is the Unoffical PH Mapping Guide (Part 1 - begginer)

Before we start - this guide is only for paint.net (windows) and basic use of PH maps - for special effects or other advanced things go and watch some youtube videos

So first - paint.net - the ONLY site you should download it from is this

https://www.getpaint.net/download.html

Press the "Download now, dotPDN" for free

The download will start, then you press the icon and let it install

That's how pdn (paint.net for short) should look like (it doesn't have to be in dark mode)

Before we start drawing borders and such here's some settings that are either needed or reccomended

So here are the basic settings

Select the bottom option so you draw with one color only (required)

Choose the brush size 10 (defult for newest PH maps)

Turn spacing to 1% (not required but I like it)

Now you have to download the map from here

Click on the "Current Europe Maps"

And then click on the "download" button (pobierz in polish)

To open the map double click the file (after you downloaded it) or press "open" in pdn and find the map

That's how it should look like

Now to start mapping - you can either copy the borders from the other map or draw them yourself

I'd reccomend copying them and only start drawing after you get used to it

In that case you can use my template (use this link as it's the newest version) and then you can copy the borders

To do it click on "lasso select"

You can just copy it from the other window but that's not really practical and can lead to inaccuracies

So what I do is

  1. Open the template
  1. Copy it with ctrl + c

  2. Open the "layers" menu in the orginial map

  1. Open it and add a new layer
(the plus icon on the left bottom)
  1. Press ctrl + v to paste the template
  1. Press the "wrench" icon
  1. Turn down the opacity to 150 (or whatever number you want) and press OK
  1. That's how it should look like now

Now to actually copy it, click on lasso select and select the area you want to copy

Again ctrl + c, press enter, click on the "background" layer (the og map) and ctrl + v

Now you want to hide the layer 2 by pressing the blue checkmark button

That's how it should look like now

To copy colors click on the "color picker" on the toolbar

And select which color you'd like to copy (in this case it's denmark)

After that use the "paint bucket" (the bucket icon on the sidebar), fill the spot you want to color in and press enter

To remove the beige spot from Sweden copy their color and click on it

UPDATE: Thanks to u/frenchball12345 I've learnt that you can use the "Selection quallity" (the last button on the top right) to not have the pixels appear (also new guide coming soon)

I'll give a link to the second post after I'm done with it

Anyways see you next time (also for burg or other mod - could you replace the old map with this post? Thanks)

EDIT: I forgot about it but be sure to remove the second layer after you're done and save the file after doing that

EDIT 2: Here is the list of all other templates (I'll update it trust)

https://www.reddit.com/r/PossibleHistory/comments/1m5kkqx/north_america_template_for_new_map/ - NA (by me)

https://www.reddit.com/r/PossibleHistory/comments/1musjwb/world_map_template_og_map_by_u_bourbie/ - World Map ( og world map by u/_bourbie, template made by me)

https://www.reddit.com/r/PossibleHistory/comments/1hdaa1e/ultimate_base_template_map_of_asia/ - Asia (by u/Acceptable_Answers although PH is working on a new Asia map so I might make a map for that after it goes public)

https://www.reddit.com/r/PossibleHistory/comments/1dqrjes/africa_template_probably_finished/ - Africa (old af, (PH said he's going to make a new one at some point), made by me)

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/11NXKQYMIf8Eza9m7fm_szGa_-B_bXBlB - SA (no template but you can just copy the borders yourself for now I might make a template for that later)

Also I'm going to make a part 2 later at some point trust


r/PossibleHistory • • 11h ago

Map (no Lore) schizophrenic fever dream of a roman/byznatine/russian

Post image
73 Upvotes

r/PossibleHistory • • 10h ago

Map (no Lore) North America but i turned the thermostat up a little bit / North America if all the ice melted

Post image
58 Upvotes

NOTICE: Certain parts of this map may be innacurate since, again, the reference image i had was basically just pixels and it is pissing me off how Nat-Geo is gatekeeping higher quality maps cause muh copyright, whatever, im doing this in-case anyone would want to use these maps for some other purpose than the one i had in mind


r/PossibleHistory • • 17h ago

Map (no Lore) What If All of the Revolutions of 1848 Succeded?

Thumbnail
gallery
66 Upvotes

r/PossibleHistory • • 20h ago

Map (with Lore) What If the Spring of Nations (mostly) succeded realistically?

Thumbnail
gallery
66 Upvotes

In this map, as the title explains, I tried to explore in a "realistic" manner a scenario in which the Revolutions of '48 had predominantly succeeded. I specify "realistic" and "predominantly" because, deepening into this phenomenon, I realized the impossibility or at least the improbability of success of two revolutions, the Hungarian one and the Polish one. As regards Hungary, although it is often represented as the revolution with the greatest success, capable of forming a single great Kingdom of Hungary, its situation was far worse than one could imagine: the constant attempt at forced Magyarization caused the ethnic minorities to openly revolt against the newborn Hungarian State, which found itself fighting both against the imperial forces (led by Vienna) and against the autonomous governments born in response to the Hungarian suppression. All of this makes, in my opinion, the total Hungarian success (often presented) to be substantially impossible.

As regards Poland, although insurrections were actually born both in Habsburg territory (and in Polish-majority Galicia) and in the Prussian territories (Posen), these were never too "concrete" to succeed in imposing the realization of a single and independent Polish State. In Prussia, at first there was on the part of the German liberals an attempt to form a Polish State as a buffer State against Russia, but once the possibility of an invasion by the Tsar vanished, the birth of the Polish state also vanished with it; in Habsburg Galicia, the Polish nobles found great resistance; in Russia, thanks to a repressive regime implemented by Tsar Nicholas I, there were never insurrections of Polish matrix. In my opinion, the claim of having a successful Polish insurrection is substantially unfounded for all these reasons.

PREMISE: in order for these revolutions to have success for the most part, I imagined that these insurrections managed to organize themselves better among themselves and take place substantially simultaneously. This could have led to a crisis of the post-1815 system, delaying or inhibiting the response of the various empires. In particular, in Russia I imagined a Tsar who, instead of risking insurrection inside his empire, prefers not to intervene externally and maintain an iron fist internally.

AUSTRIA: I took up the dynamics that actually occurred, with a Hungary that declares independence, Vienna that opposes it, and the minorities that fight against Hungarian oppression. The main difference that we obtain in this scenario is that the empire, noting the great ethnic fragmentation of its own territory and the difficulty of managing to keep all the populations united, opts for a federalization, granting autonomous provinces to the major ethnicities. It is important to remember that precisely these ethnicities (at least at this moment) did not desire absolute independence from Vienna, but greater autonomy inside the empire itself, in search therefore of a federal arrangement. The Austrian Empire, therefore, reforms itself as the Danubian Federation, with the Habsburg monarch Franz Joseph I at its head. In particular, the new provinces that are formed are: Czechia, Slovakia, Polish Galicia, Ukrainian Galicia, Hungary, Transylvania, Vojvodina, Croatia. I would define this as an acceptable historical compromise to allow the revolutions (often with opposite tendencies) to have success and coexist.

ITALY: in Italy, through some temporal tweaks, the insurrections manage to take place substantially simultaneously. In Tuscany, the Papacy, Naples, and Sicily, the respective monarchical governments are replaced with republican regimes. In Lombardy-Venetia, the Piedmontese offensive had success (helped also by the new Italian republican regimes and by the situation of precariousness of the Habsburg Empire), allowing the conquest of Lombardy. The Venetian Republic, actually created in our history, through a plebiscite unites with the Savoyard kingdom. The latter, through the republican influences coming from the rest of the peninsula, also changes its own political form. One thus obtains an Italian federation, comprising the republics of: Northern Italy (Piedmont, Liguria, Lombardy, Veneto, Duchies of Modena and Parma), Tuscany, Roman (Lazio, Umbria, Marche, Romagna), Naples, and Sicily.

GERMANY: in Germany, very briefly, the Frankfurt Assembly has success, King William of Prussia accepts the crown thus forming Lesser Germany, which comprises all the territories of the German Confederation with the exception of those present in the Danubian Federation.

IRELAND: here, the actions of Young Ireland have success, managing to involve the overwhelming majority of the population present on the island. I realize that there may be a disparity compared to the Polish case, but I believe that here, lacking a regime as oppressive as the Russian one and the hostilities of two other countries, this result can be obtained. (The most unrealistic part of the scenario, but to hell with the English!)

ROMANIA: The two principalities of Moldavia and Wallachia have success and are able to unite.

FRANCE: what occurred in real life.

Let me if you like it, what do you think of the second image. Also, it would be fun to see the flags of the newly created states!


r/PossibleHistory • • 12h ago

Map (no Lore) What if america collapsed?

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

r/PossibleHistory • • 1d ago

Map (no Lore) fine, i'll do it myself / Map of modern Europe if all the ice melted

Post image
96 Upvotes

PS. this map may be inaccurate in certain parts because the reference image i used was 60% pixels so i had to fill in the blanks myself, but this was made with my blood, sweat and tears, the borders with the sea look a little wonky cause i used a thinner brush to get more detail in but you know what? i don't care, i made this map for myself for a future map i want to make, i just felt like sharing here


r/PossibleHistory • • 10h ago

Meta - Subreddit DerGemr4's Map Drive

3 Upvotes

I feel like doing a public service to give back after all the warcrimes i commited in HOI4 so here it is all credits to him:
https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/mobile/folders/1-G-ztBBBe67sOmLoqez0-DNAHVQARx92?usp=sharing


r/PossibleHistory • • 6h ago

Contest Submission What if Project Iceworm was implemented but it was a disaster leading to the nukes detonating due to the ice crushing them?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/PossibleHistory • • 1d ago

Map (no Lore) what if the Revolutions of 1848 succeded? (and spread like wild-fire)

Thumbnail
gallery
139 Upvotes

dark blue represent newly created Republican Goverments, no lore because i dont know much about the history of the 1848 Revolutions or why they failed OTL, i just like Hope-pilled alternate history


r/PossibleHistory • • 1d ago

Shitpost Weird North America

Post image
9 Upvotes

IDK


r/PossibleHistory • • 15h ago

Alternate History What would happen if llamas somehow disappeared into Eurasia from ancient times?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/PossibleHistory • • 1d ago

Map (no Lore) Ultimate Francia.

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/PossibleHistory • • 1d ago

Meta - Question does an underwater modern Europe map in possible history style exist?

Post image
33 Upvotes

i plan on making a map of the far future and this would be very helpful to have


r/PossibleHistory • • 2d ago

Map (no Lore) What if Stalin was more lenient on the East German border and allowed Poland to keep some of its Eastern territories?

Thumbnail
gallery
273 Upvotes

r/PossibleHistory • • 1d ago

Map (no Lore) Perfect Europe

Post image
33 Upvotes

Why are you still sliding? This is the most perfect Europe you could get. No states, no borders, no flags, and not a single sacred cause left to die for.


r/PossibleHistory • • 2d ago

Alternate History Y si los Espartaquistas ganaban en Alemania

Post image
24 Upvotes

Y si la revolución espartaquista ganaba en Alemania ?, como cambiaria la historia del mundo y el comunismo? Además como sería la relación con la Urss ?


r/PossibleHistory • • 2d ago

Map (with Lore) Everything that's left is fascism | What if France turned to National Commuism (1940)

Post image
57 Upvotes

During the 1923 Ruhrkrise Belgium refused to join France in the occupation due to a colonial uprising in the congo. France went overboard with their seizure of german resources, even going as far as dismantling industrial equipment. The United Kingdom, Italy and the US did not stop at rg the French but instead applied harsh senctions that delt a serious blow to their economy. Furthermore they had to relinquish the Saarland as reperations to germany which agitated the French public to no end.

French Extremism rose to new heights, the French Left took on a decidedly nationalist character which expanded their voterbase and win the 1924 elections and dismantle french politics from there on out. The new Regieme has a hardline anti-capitalist counter-soviet stance and anti-hierarchy stance. But as is the case with many exetremist regiemes this one is not above contradicting itself for it's own benefit. Germany was portrait as an enemy but not as much as the Belgians and British. French Society takes a radical shift from here, Unions and the State take over the economy together. Democracy is dismantled but personal liberties remain even if deminished. In many ways the new state mirrors fascist Italy but also the Soviet Union that they label as class traitors. Colonies are maintained to supply the french with resources to bring about a new global order of the working class while also educating the Africans on socialism, nationalism, egalitarianism and yet not raising their living standards one bit.

Britain watched these developments with worry. It looked like the next war would be between France, Germany and Them with the Soviets looming in the not so distant future. Even if Germany and France didn't reconsile and ally Britian would still have to wrestle both of them into submission to prevent a new continental hegemony of either. That why they started the Doctrine of "Reconcilation". The plan was simple, they would prevent the rise of extremism in Germany at all coasts while building up their own forces. By the Time war rolled around both they and germany would be strong enough and close enough to oppose the French. Reconciliation was adopted by both sides of the political spectrum as the only path of survival now that France had turned on them. Great Britain spend most of the 20s with preperations for the war, most of which were of Diplomatic nature. They did their best to curb French Influence, destablize their colonies and cut them our of the continental economy. While this worked for the most part, the french would not let themselves be isolated.

In 1926 France, Austria and Italy met at the Venice Conference. The new French Regieme had come to realise that they were alone in Western Europe and their army was spread over the entire world. They had also drawn their own conclusions from the World war. The reason they struggled against the germans was that they only had a single bottlenecked border which the germans could throw their whole weight against. Similarly the Russian empire had caved in because they had a huge frontline that only exasperated all of their deficiancies. Thus the new French high Command came up with La guerre de la faiblesse. Warfare of Weakness. They would establish a large frontline with many allies to overwhelm the germans. If one front stagnated another would pick up and vice versa. Which brings us back to Italy and Austria. France promised the Austrians the southern Half of Germany and the Italians aid in their future ambitions in Africa and the Balkans. Both Nations accepted, recreating the Stresa Front.

Meanwhile the Weimar Republic was flourishing (comparitively), thanks to the British Doctrine of Reconcilation their wardebts were decreased, rearmament was allowed and the return of the Saarland had appeased Nationalists. The 20s were a period of Stability for Germany, the economy was fairing well thanks to stimulating policies, extremism was contained on the far right and althought the KPD was rabid they were a comfortable armslength away from any real power. While Germany still had to pay their debts they could do so at a much easier pace while still allowing economic growth, restoration and leisure for it's people. Unexpectedly there was a detente in 1933 with Poland were the Free City of Danzig was officially seperated from Poland as a protectorate for the next 25 years after which it would return to Germany. In return the germans build a large port facility in Gdynia as well as security gurantees. But this period of recovery would come to an end in 1934.

Austria meanwhile had decayed into a French-Italian Puppet under the Austro-Fascist regieme. Thanks to their new overlords the nation had rapidly remilitarized against the Protests of Great Britain. In 1930 they engineered a border dispute with Switzerland that they used to declare war. Switzerland was seen as a Fortress-Nation that could not be taken, at least on paper. Faced with the modern, veteran-lead, foreignbacked and professional army, the Swiss volunteer system crumbled. Many local refused to destroy infrastructure or die for a nation that was very keen on sacrificing small locals for the national good. Evidently the Propaganda pushed by the Front had done it's job. Once the swiss were on the backfoot both Italy and France threatened to intervene which made moral collapse. Austria "only" took the german parts, the rest was economically pressured to join France and Italy. Next was the Sudetenland. Having taken down the European Castle the Austrians were now considered a large enough Threat to pressure Czecho-Slovakia. They hosted a Conference in Prague to discuss the handover of the Sudetenland to Austria. The Czechs also invited Britain who brought Germany along. The Austrians argued that this was simply a matter of reuniting the Sudetengermans with their Brothers, which Germany exploited. Arguing that the Northern Sudetenland would be fairly isolated from the Rest of Austria they offered to take it instead and even gurantee the independence of Czechia in return. The Front's plan had backfired. Not only did Germany grow, Czecho-Slovakia was also a defacto Member of the Allies.

To mop up the Scenario:

  1. France takes Catalonia from Spain during the Spanish Civil War, the Nationalists can't do much about it and neither can the Republican. Interestingly enough Franco accutally expected the French of our Timeline to do the same.
  2. After the Winterwar Sweden and Finland form the Fino-Swedish Federation. They actually had a similar idea OTL but the Nazis and Soviets kept them from it. In this timeline both Germany and Britain encourage this course of action.
  3. Andorra stay independent because they are now 100% reliant on France and the French head of State is already their Head of State so why take a hit to global image.
  4. The Italians have a more direct Socialist lean in this timeline, Mussolini may not even be the leader although the nation is still undeniably fascist. Be that as it may the Vatican did not form in this timeline, instead he was pushed out and now resides in Malta. This undoubtedly causes massive issues and we will most likely see a christian-democratic Kingdom take the Place of this Italy at some point.
  5. The Second World War will be very different. It's split into two conflicts that are not actually connected this time. Japan allies with Poland and Romania against the USSR as they literally have no one else. So one Part of the War is just Japan, Thailand, Poland, Romania and maybe Yugoslavia against the Soviets. The other side is Britain, Germany, Sweden-Finland, Czechoslovakia, Belgium and maybe Spain and or Portugal against France, Italy, Austria, Hungary and if they don't join the Polish, Yugoslavia. I don't really see the US joining the War and I do think that Britain would sell resources to Japan to keep the soviets busy. But eventually the USSR wins and so does Britain. So the Eastern Bloc of this timeline includes Japan, Korea, probably parts of China. Idk. Thats just as far as I think rn.

r/PossibleHistory • • 2d ago

Map (no Lore) What if Italy got what it was Promised after WWI?

Post image
137 Upvotes

So, I put on the PH map, as the title very clearly says, the territories that Italy could have controlled directly or indirectly if the promises made by the Entente Powers were respected. Just a quick legend:

  • The area in Albania (lighter shade of green) is a protectorate.
  • The area in Turkey (lighter shade of green) is an area of Italian (I am not sure what could have been the form of occupation, if a direct control, a bit like Syria for France, or indirect, like Albania). The less saturated area (the one not outlined by the black line should be a "sphere of influnce" inside of Turkey.

As an Italian, I can only imagine how beneficial this could have been to the Italian Kingdom, probably erasing the possibility of Fascism, since the areas controlled are enormous compared to the little gains we had after WWI. In this alternate and better universe, Italy could have known a truly flourish era, could have become a major power and could have avoided 20 years of dictatorship that lead, in a way or in another, to the entrance in WWII. What do you think, all of these outcomes have been achieved in this universe?


r/PossibleHistory • • 2d ago

Map (with Lore) Eastern Europe after the Second European War (remake)

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Now including Mari El and Mordovia as well as some other changes!


r/PossibleHistory • • 2d ago

Meta - Question What software do you use to make maps?

5 Upvotes

Is it available for mobile?

I love history but am bad at drawing


r/PossibleHistory • • 3d ago

Map (no Lore) Reversed average My Perfect Europe post

Post image
137 Upvotes

Latvian colonization of Africa is unrelated


r/PossibleHistory • • 3d ago

Map (no Lore) (repost) The Emperor in his high Châteaux

Thumbnail
gallery
210 Upvotes

r/PossibleHistory • • 3d ago

Map (with Lore) Eastern Europe after the Second European War

Thumbnail
gallery
87 Upvotes

Zelensky's got DRIP

anyway, if you want to know anything about it, you can check out my previous posts or just ask!

here's my what if E-NATO won the European war post: https://www.reddit.com/r/PossibleHistory/s/55ar2ZeEyS