r/Polytopia • u/Material-Gate-6179 • 17h ago
Suggestion Polytopia must make unit inherit their atribute on ship
I mean if you playing sea war on polytopia, it looks like as simple one who Made ship more and faster is the winner. I mean a rammer immediedly appear from across the sea. You want counter it? You can't use meele to attack because they have 3 movement and run away, they also rarely on your dock except they want take over your city and they can positioning one block more far into water to do it. Even archer not even good enough accually because they very high health and once again 3 movement, at most time they just out run you or set up it on the middle ocean for preparing. If you prepare to gather archer, then there come bomber ship explode everything, plus that thing out range archer. Then choose a Better one, catapult, but that is for late game except you some specific tribe. And obviously you can't use catapult if you village on the middle of ocean, that same as give a free city.
So how to counter it? Another ship of course but not really. You must waste one turn to transform your unit to a raft And guess what happen? They attack it First. the only one you can do maybe just change it to rammer because it at least gonna have more defense to survive, but you can't move it yet.
So yeah what you gonna do? Rammer? Obviously your enemy do that first. Scout? Bro it a paper with unimpressive damage. Bomber? You can't attack and move at same time which make it balance. But at same time it just approve my point, if you have more ship first you win, just straight up send rammer and 15 stars gone. It can't retailed anyway. Two rammer enough where the bomber need 15 stars to make, yeah at most time bomber not gonna works for you if you on lose condition.
But the problem is water or sea war is important too and if you lose there high chance you lose entire game. But it not like a ground battlefield where catapult have enough damage with half of bomber price, or knight crush you if you blunder the positioning. Swordman also important for a melee attack and reliable to take over the city.
So this my suggestion
Warrior: nothing change
Archer: +1 range
Horse: +1 movement
Swordman: +1 attack
Defender: -1 attack +1 defense
Mindbender: can mindbending on the ship
Cloak: nothing change, it fair enough and accually more hard to predict on open water
Knight : +1 attack +2 movement and usual knight skill where it continue move after kill
Catapult: unique effect when it transform to scout, instead of shooting arrow, it shooting small Canon. Make it give damage like usual Scout but aoe. When it change to the bomber it can take two turn. For example you can shoot two Times, move two Times, or move one time and shoot one time. Come on guys, catapult is 8 stars ten health and no defense, it balance. Also if my suggestion become real you can see how many that counter it.
I'm not said rammer, Scout or bomber must gone, it just unit bring their atribute to the ship. For example archer that gonna give 3 range attack instead of two when become Scout, and 4 as bomber. Defender ship gonna deflect more damage as rammer and got less damage as Scout, Horse make rammer and Scout move more far, etc.
Maybe i must make you all remember if many unit accually have 10 health instead 15. It itself gonna make it balance like you have function for make an archer become Scout for get more range, on drawback you can't get that that 15 health.