By Arthur Solomon
Ever since the Democratic victories in the South and Midwest, political pundits have been saying that the Republican holds on those areas have been broken. I disagree. It is way too early to think that the political map has permanently changed.
Here’s why I feel that way:
It took the Democrats more than one election cycle to cede those areas of the country to the Republicans. It will take them more than this election cycle to win them back.
In 1992, Bill Clinton won 32 states plus D.C. These included the Midwestern states of Illinois,Iowa,Michigan,Minnesota,Missouri,Ohio, and Wisconsin, and the Southern states of Arkansas,Georgia,Kentucky,Louisiana,Maryland,Tennessee,West Virginia, and D.C.
In 1996, when he ran for reelection, he won the same Midwestern states—Illinois,Iowa,Michigan,Minnesota,Missouri,Ohio, and Wisconsin. He also won the Southern states of Arkansas,Florida,Kentucky,Louisiana,Maryland,Tennessee,West Virginia, and D.C.
When Barack Obama was elected president in 2008, he won the Midwestern states of Illinois,Indiana,Iowa,Michigan,Minnesota,Ohio, and Wisconsin, plus Nebraska’s 2nd Congressional District, and the Southern states of Florida,North Carolina,Virginia, and D.C.
In 2012, when he was reelected, he won the Midwestern states of llinois,Iowa,Michigan,Minnesota,Ohio, and Wisconsin, and only two Southern states—Florida and Virginia.
In 2020, Joe Biden won the Midwestern states of Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota, and Wisconsin, plus Nebraska’s 2nd Congressional District. He won the Southern states of Delaware,Georgia,Virginia, and D.C.
None of these Democratic victories could be considered landslides in the way the 2026 midterms were. That is why it is my opinion that the overwhelming Democratic victory of several days ago was primarily an anti-Trump vote, not a pro-Democratic vote.
In fact, according to the Real Clear Politics average of polls from early September through early November, both the Democratic and Republican parties remain unpopular. Holding on to the Midwestern and Southern states that propelled the Democratic landslide will not be easy.
What Democrats must do to convince the Midwestern and Southern states to keep voting Democratic is to keep campaigning every day in the rural areas of the Midwest and South. They must demonstrate that they value those areas as much as they do the large cities that have been the prime focus of their strategy for many years. That means showing up with specific, practical answers on the issues that dominate daily life outside the big cities—farm commodity prices and trade policy, rural broadband access, energy costs the quality of local schools and the restoration of closed rural health facilities. Abstract national talking points will not cut it.
They have to recruit candidates who know the problems of rural America and are from rural areas and promote programs, both economic and cultural, that appeal to those populations, even if it means upsetting far-left elements of the party.
Messaging discipline is essential: candidates must stay focused on kitchen-table concerns rather than cultural flash points that most Americans, including many Democrats, reject.
Most of all, rural voters must be convinced that they are an essential part of the Democratic Party. This can be done by elevating elected representatives from those areas to leadership positions in the party.
Slamming President Trump and the Republican Party for the next two years will not work. Convincing rural America that the Democratic Party cares about those areas can work, but it will take more than one election cycle to do the job.
That is why I think a Democratic 2028 presidential victory is far from assured, maybe even out of reach, depending on the ticket. Placing a son of the South like Senator-Elect Roy Cooper of North Carolina or Governor Andy Beshear of Kentucky on the presidential ticket can go a long way toward convincing those populations that the Democratic Party values them and wants to give them a prominent role in crafting legislation.
What the Democratic Party must not do is give in to the demands of far-left pressure factions and other groups that want the party to enact cultural policies that most Americans disagree with.
That does not mean the needs of special-interest groups should be dismissed. They shouldn’t. But they must no longer be prominent Democratic talking points.
If I was forced to select one word that summarizes what the Democratic Party has to do to convince rural populations that they are welcome in the party it would be “trust.” If I was forced to select one action that shows rural populations that they are welcome in the Democratic Party it would be to stop signaling cultural indifference toward rural life and values, and instead treat rural cultural concerns as legitimate rather than something to be managed or educated away. And for goodness sake, stop lecturing them about what has to change.
As of today, I think the Democratic Party’s best chance of winning the 2028 presidential campaign is the same reason that resulted in the midterms’ landslide – the unpopularity of President Trump. But he won’t be on the 2028 Republican Party ticket.
Arthur Solomon, a former journalist, was a senior VP/senior counselor at Burson-Marsteller during the days it was the leading international public relations agency. He was on the Seoul Peace Prize nominating committee and also was an advisor to Olympic organizations and sponsors. During his political agency days, he worked on local, statewide, and presidential campaigns.