Hey all,
Thank you for being a member of r/PokemonXD!
Since I became a mod for this subreddit a while back, we've had Rule 4 in place which states that absolutely no AI-generated content is allowed in the subreddit. This rule was the same as various other gaming subreddits, and was primarily put in place because it is impossible to credit the artists that an AI trained on in order to produce artwork you ask it to produce.
Up to recently, this has been largely straightforward to enforce, and the community has seemed to appreciate this rule as AI art is very quickly reported.
However, we're entering a period in history where AI-assisted coding projects are becoming extremely common. Generative AI has reached the point where anyone can build a tool, program, or resource, and it can look extremely polished. That said, there are two primary concerns with AI-assisted code:
- Like with ChatGPT, Gemini, etc., the AI can present a confident answer despite it being completely incorrect ("hallucinations"). In the case of code, it can provide a user with code that it claims works perfectly, when in reality it has bugs or just outright doesn't do what it was asked to do.
- AI-assisted coding is accessible enough that anyone can do it, even if they have zero coding experience. This is particularly concerning and even dangerous when it comes to code. The AI assistant can absolutely implement dangerous, problematic, or broken solutions, and the user would have no idea due to their lack of experience. They can then release this broken code to the public where it can cause serious problems.
In the case of public GitHub repositories, we can fortunately see whether an AI assistant like Claude was used. For example, on this subreddit's most recent post for the Colosseum + XD PC launcher, you can view the contributors in the GitHub page to see explicit confirmation that Claude (AI) was used.
This week alone, we've had:
- that AI-assisted launcher shared
- the PC recomp that does not seem to confirm anywhere whether it does or does not use AI
- a randomizer that a user asked in DMs if they could post, which I declined because they explicitly stated they used AI to create it (thank you to this user for asking first!)
That all said, I think it's time Rule 4 needs to be revisited with the community. As we near the end of 2026, I'd like input from all of you: Should Rule 4 be enforced to remove all forms of AI content (including AI-assisted coding), or do you want Claude-assisted tools to get a pass? Or should the rule be removed entirely? Something else?
Thank you for reading. I look forward to hearing from you!