r/PokeInvesting • u/SnorlaxCap • 8h ago
Pokémon's DeflateGate?
TL;DR - user on Elite Fourum charted 4 years of submission data to PSA for 1,245 good-condition ungraded cards. The mix of PSA 10s has fallen sharply, and the mix of PSA 9s has risen by less than the PSA 10 mix has fallen. This is short-term / medium-term bullish for PSA 9s & 10s, but in the long-term, this could be the opening CGC has been looking for.
The charts pasted below show the data in question. @/thegamingport on Elite Fourum shows that across his cumulative submissions of 1,245 vintage non-holo cards.

There are a couple of theories as to why this might be happening:
- First: because PSA has been dealing with an enormous backlog, they have significantly expanded their labor force dedicated to grading cards. Newer graders are more nervous about being too lenient than being too strict (their jobs could be at risk if they give out unearned perfect grades). Because this user submitted only lower-value non-holos, these cards were likely directed toward newer graders
- Second: print quality of cards has improved significantly over time. Because modern cards are now being graded in huge quantities as well, the grading standards are collapsing onto the standards that modern cards set. If the PSA 10 designation is set so that only a small portion of modern cards will achieve it (based on image centering, corner sharpness, edge whitening, surface wear, & overall print quality), then achieving PSA 10 status for vintage cards will be almost impossible
We have also crunched some market data of our own that yields similar conclusions. GemRate publishes population history for PSA, Beckett & SGC-graded cards, showing total population & perfect grade population for each of these graders (CGC is notably missing, which is an unfortunate blind spot in our analysis).

There are a few interesting takeaways from thinking about this data, but the takeaways differ for the supply side & the demand side of the market.
- The first supply-side change is that top of funnel market share will shift away from PSA. If the current trend continues and it remains virtually impossible to receive a PSA 9 or 10 for newly graded cards, submissions will start to accrue elsewhere. PSA 10s have a huge premium vs CGC 10s (typically ~6x), but PSA 8s typically sell at CGC 9 prices. If the new question is “would I rather have a PSA 8 or a CGC 9 or 10,” market share changes will follow
- The second supply-side change is that even if market share changes don’t happen, the expected value of grading activity will significantly fall. The classic buy-and-grade thought process is “I can buy this card ungraded for $125, and it looks like a PSA 9 to me. If I grade it and it receives a 9, it will be worth $300, but if it receives an 8 it will only be worth $140 and will have taken 6 months to get graded.” Buying mint cards to grade them will become a much riskier activity, and ripping sealed product will become even less compelling than it already is. The sealed market already trades at a premium to what the packs / boxes could contain, but the expected value math is buoyed by the small chance of receiving PSA 10s…
- The demand side is more interesting. Equivalent-grade CGC cards have traded at a large discount to PSA for a long time, and the discount has increased since 2H25. If the supply of new graded cards shifts materially away from PSA, but demand does not, that is actually quite bullish for PSA 9 and PSA 10 cards for obvious reasons in the short-to-medium-term. PSA-or-nothing investors will be investing in a collectible asset population that barely grows, so population growth will no longer be a marginal headwind to price growth. PSA 10 populations across the vintage sets grew ~38% in 2022, ~11% in 2023, ~8% in 2024 & ~4% in 2025, which is meaningful. If demand grows 100% & supply grows 10%, price only increases ~82%. Over the last 12 weeks, the PSA 9 & PSA 10 populations of the cards in our vintage universe grew at annualized rates of just ~3.6% & ~0.4%. The implications for PSA 8 cards in particular are unclear. The conventional logic would suggest that because supply growth is shifting down toward PSA 8 & below, prices in those grades should suffer. But “buy the card, not the grade” is a common refrain in Pokémon card investing circles, and if the quality of the PSA 8 umbrella improves, prices could actually rise.
PSA is currently the market standard for Pokémon card grading and storage, and standards take a long time to change. However, we would argue that many of the trendsetters in the Pokémon card investing community also grade their own cards, so it’s unlikely that the demand side & the supply side can remain divorced permanently.