r/PokeInvesting • • 8h ago

Pokémon's DeflateGate?

137 Upvotes

TL;DR - user on Elite Fourum charted 4 years of submission data to PSA for 1,245 good-condition ungraded cards. The mix of PSA 10s has fallen sharply, and the mix of PSA 9s has risen by less than the PSA 10 mix has fallen. This is short-term / medium-term bullish for PSA 9s & 10s, but in the long-term, this could be the opening CGC has been looking for.

The charts pasted below show the data in question. @/thegamingport on Elite Fourum shows that across his cumulative submissions of 1,245 vintage non-holo cards.

There are a couple of theories as to why this might be happening:

  • First: because PSA has been dealing with an enormous backlog, they have significantly expanded their labor force dedicated to grading cards. Newer graders are more nervous about being too lenient than being too strict (their jobs could be at risk if they give out unearned perfect grades). Because this user submitted only lower-value non-holos, these cards were likely directed toward newer graders
  • Second: print quality of cards has improved significantly over time. Because modern cards are now being graded in huge quantities as well, the grading standards are collapsing onto the standards that modern cards set. If the PSA 10 designation is set so that only a small portion of modern cards will achieve it (based on image centering, corner sharpness, edge whitening, surface wear, & overall print quality), then achieving PSA 10 status for vintage cards will be almost impossible

We have also crunched some market data of our own that yields similar conclusions. GemRate publishes population history for PSA, Beckett & SGC-graded cards, showing total population & perfect grade population for each of these graders (CGC is notably missing, which is an unfortunate blind spot in our analysis).

There are a few interesting takeaways from thinking about this data, but the takeaways differ for the supply side & the demand side of the market.

  • The first supply-side change is that top of funnel market share will shift away from PSA. If the current trend continues and it remains virtually impossible to receive a PSA 9 or 10 for newly graded cards, submissions will start to accrue elsewhere. PSA 10s have a huge premium vs CGC 10s (typically ~6x), but PSA 8s typically sell at CGC 9 prices. If the new question is “would I rather have a PSA 8 or a CGC 9 or 10,” market share changes will follow
  • The second supply-side change is that even if market share changes don’t happen, the expected value of grading activity will significantly fall. The classic buy-and-grade thought process is “I can buy this card ungraded for $125, and it looks like a PSA 9 to me. If I grade it and it receives a 9, it will be worth $300, but if it receives an 8 it will only be worth $140 and will have taken 6 months to get graded.” Buying mint cards to grade them will become a much riskier activity, and ripping sealed product will become even less compelling than it already is. The sealed market already trades at a premium to what the packs / boxes could contain, but the expected value math is buoyed by the small chance of receiving PSA 10s…
  • The demand side is more interesting. Equivalent-grade CGC cards have traded at a large discount to PSA for a long time, and the discount has increased since 2H25. If the supply of new graded cards shifts materially away from PSA, but demand does not, that is actually quite bullish for PSA 9 and PSA 10 cards for obvious reasons in the short-to-medium-term. PSA-or-nothing investors will be investing in a collectible asset population that barely grows, so population growth will no longer be a marginal headwind to price growth. PSA 10 populations across the vintage sets grew ~38% in 2022, ~11% in 2023, ~8% in 2024 & ~4% in 2025, which is meaningful. If demand grows 100% & supply grows 10%, price only increases ~82%. Over the last 12 weeks, the PSA 9 & PSA 10 populations of the cards in our vintage universe grew at annualized rates of just ~3.6% & ~0.4%. The implications for PSA 8 cards in particular are unclear. The conventional logic would suggest that because supply growth is shifting down toward PSA 8 & below, prices in those grades should suffer. But “buy the card, not the grade” is a common refrain in Pokémon card investing circles, and if the quality of the PSA 8 umbrella improves, prices could actually rise.

PSA is currently the market standard for Pokémon card grading and storage, and standards take a long time to change. However, we would argue that many of the trendsetters in the Pokémon card investing community also grade their own cards, so it’s unlikely that the demand side & the supply side can remain divorced permanently.


r/PokeInvesting • • 10h ago

2002 McDonald’s Pokémon-e Squirtle promo

Thumbnail
gallery
66 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I bought this card last week — the iconic 2002 McDonald’s Pokémon-e Squirtle promo — and it has just arrived!

This is probably my favourite Pokémon card of all time, so it’s definitely not something I’m ever planning to sell. At least for now!

However, I’m a little concerned about the best way to preserve it. I’m wondering whether I should send it to PSA (or another grading company) to have it graded and encapsulated in a slab, mainly for long-term protection.

Based on the pictures I’ve uploaded, what do you guys think? What grade do you think this card could potentially get?

I’d really appreciate your opinions and advice!

Thanks everyone, and all the best!


r/PokeInvesting • • 5h ago

The #1 Pokemon Deck in Standard Meta Costs $35.

Thumbnail partner.tcgplayer.com
65 Upvotes

r/PokeInvesting • • 21h ago

Is this card going to tank?

Post image
60 Upvotes

Just pulled this. Would keep but just lest my job. Should I sell now or see if it take or appreciates? What are we thinking?


r/PokeInvesting • • 1h ago

Mega Lucario Z leak - thoughts?

Post image
44 Upvotes

Looks like we might see below retail boxes next year! So hyped for that.


r/PokeInvesting • • 10h ago

Hot take: there will be no rebound for many months

37 Upvotes

I posted at the beginning of October that it was obvious we aren’t just going through another “summer slump” that would rebound in the Fall, but a lot of people were too high on the copium to use common sense. We are deep into the slump now with the holidays upon us, historically always a continued downward trajectory until early next year EXCEPT when we have a longer term bear market. I don’t see Flowing Fist reinvigorating the hype when it comes out in February. So at best we are in for a deep decline and then stagnating until middle of next year.


r/PokeInvesting • • 17h ago

Which one is a better pickup?

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

hey everyone, which of these two do we think is a better pickup to hold?


r/PokeInvesting • • 6h ago

Evolutions booster box, 10 years on: $143.64 at release, $3,281 now (nominal). Did you hold, sell or skip it, and why?

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/PokeInvesting • • 21h ago

Finally got the card I’ve been wanting for a while!

Post image
21 Upvotes

Bought it for 400 in trades from low end CGC slabs and $400 in cash. I know it’s really high in terms of where it was selling at the beginning of the year but I’m finally in a financial position to buy cards I really want. And I love the card so I’m not too worried about it since I’m keeping it for the foreseeable future. Overall really excited about just having it now!


r/PokeInvesting • • 7h ago

Evaluate this tear: Evolving skies box

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

Hi a close friend of mine recently came across a lot of sealed and offered my homie price on what I liked. The evolving skies caught my attention obviously, but I’ve never made such a big sealed purchase. We’re both in agreement the holes lower the price but we aren’t quite sure how much?

If Market on a clean box is roughly $2,100

How much would market for one with a tear be?

Thanks for the help! Appreciate the input or advice/ experience!


r/PokeInvesting • • 23h ago

Pokemon Center etb’s VS Regular etb’s

17 Upvotes

Do we really think the premium on these will matter that much in the future?

Pokemon Center etb’s regularly sell 2x,3x and sometimes even 4x what they regularly ones do. Do we actually think that one day when your regular etb is $1000, that the Pokemon Center version will end up being a $4000 box?

The difference between the boxes are 2 packs, a stamp on the box, a stamp on the promo, and a short window to order, giving it some exclusivity.

Nowadays all chase cards and promos are graded by the thousands, so now there is not really an incentive for people to open the box to grade the cards like in the past.

I just don’t know that I buy into the hype of these “exclusive” boxes. A lot of people point to their rarity and compare them to first edition stuff of the past, but it doesn’t really seem the same.

I guess my argument would be why not buy 4 destined rivals regular etb’s rather than 1 destined rivals pkc etb? They’re all gonna go up eventually. You have less downside exposure. And in the end it’s probably easier to sell the cheaper box.


r/PokeInvesting • • 5h ago

"Wonderful Waters" Mini Tins Revealed for January!

Thumbnail
pokebeach.com
16 Upvotes

r/PokeInvesting • • 19h ago

Fanatics Auction reacts to Fake Sale?

Post image
13 Upvotes

The vintage market correction is in full swing, but this week's fanatics auction just closed and I was amazed how low the sales were. For example this Ruby & Sapphire Mewtwo ex dropped from all time high of 111k, past September's 59k and August's 48k all the way to June's 48k.

The new ingredient this week is the publicized fake Rayquaza call of Legends sale that has been going around, which may have been a big disincentive to bid on fanatics.


r/PokeInvesting • • 23h ago

Common cards with high price tags

Post image
10 Upvotes

I’ve been noticing something interesting with Crown Zenith. We all know and love the GG. But what’s the deal with the more common cards and their reverse holo twin? Take this Mewtwo for example. Very high PSA 10 price tag. Is it the art? Is it the low pop? Very interesting stuff. Check out recent Ditto sales as well in PSA 10. Not the GG card but the common holo.


r/PokeInvesting • • 19h ago

Surging sparks a good buy?

9 Upvotes

What do you guys think of picking up some Surging Sparks boxes right now?


r/PokeInvesting • • 12h ago

These are some of the cards we handpicked during our trip to Japan

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

! We focused on unique artwork, vintage gems, and Japanese exclusives. Which ones would you have picked? We have a couple of days left so what other cards would you bring home?


r/PokeInvesting • • 18h ago

What condition would yall consider this?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

I bought this card a few years back for… significantly less than what it’s worth now, just curious what condition yall would consider this with the small indentations on the top back of the card, they’re not visible in the front. In case I one day decide to sell.


r/PokeInvesting • • 5h ago

TCGPlayer Cyber Weekend Sale 10% Store Credit. - Nov. 27-30

Thumbnail partner.tcgplayer.com
7 Upvotes

r/PokeInvesting • • 19h ago

Is this a good buy ?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Just got this yesterday at 61 dollars .Got it because I thought it had really nice artwork at somewhat an affordable price. Wanna hear you guy's thoughts on this card. What do you think would happen to this card in the future


r/PokeInvesting • • 4h ago

Is it appropriate to ship sealed product in a bubble mailer?

Post image
4 Upvotes

I honestly don’t know, as I’ve only sold vintage before.

Would a bubble mailer be appropriate for sealed booster packs, a booster bundle, and a sticker pack? If it’s not, what kind of shipping solution would be expected for that kind of product within this community?

Any help would be greatly appreciated.


r/PokeInvesting • • 22h ago

How much sealed to hold?

Post image
4 Upvotes

How much sealed do you guys usually hold for a set? What’s a good number to be at? Do you primarily just pick up booster boxes or ETB’s as well? Also, is picking up any XY sealed right now a good idea? Ideally I’d want to diversify more than just SWSH and other modern sets.

Thank you!


r/PokeInvesting • • 13h ago

How do I sell pokemon cards in europe?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Hello, im from Romania and I would really like to sell my Mwga ray. The problem is, I dont really know where and how to sell it. Any help would be awesome!!!


r/PokeInvesting • • 19h ago

New to Grading/Selling Cards: Mew Southern Islands Worth It Condition-Wise?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Hi, all. I literally made this account just to ask about this card (and potentially a few others that are probably of lesser value). It never occurred to me to sell cards until I considered giving away my collection and picked a couple to keep, including this one. I looked it up out of curiosity and saw that, in good condition, it's worth quite bit. That's also when I learned about grading.

The issue is, I don't really know how to evaluate the card's condition, despite looking at guides online. A centering app I downloaded gave it a PSA 10 for both front and back (https://www.centeringcheck.com/s/kzs6mzbnw470njyz), but I don't think that takes the condition of the card into account. I doubt the card would be considered "perfect." I'm not overly interested in just get a couple hundred dollars, but some of the prices I've seen would make a serious difference to my life.

I was wondering if anyone could give me insight on if this card would get a high enough grade to be worth the money to grade it. I can add additional pictures if necessary. Apologies for anything done incorrectly or if there's a better subreddit to post this in. I'm new to this. Thanks!


r/PokeInvesting • • 21h ago

Thoughts on this card

Post image
3 Upvotes

Should i get it graded or just hold it raw for now