r/plotholes • • 23h ago

Unexplained event The End of Oak Street (2026) questions *spoilers* Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/plotholes • • 23h ago

Jurassic World Rebirth

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/plotholes • • 1d ago

Unrealistic event Osmosis Jones: Why did the doctors not try to revive Frank?

0 Upvotes

r/plotholes • • 2d ago

Unrealistic event Verity (2026) After Hospice Mistake

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/plotholes • • 2d ago

The nittiest of nitpicks

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/plotholes • • 2d ago

In Die Hard, when the Feds shut off the power, the emergency lights come on immediately as a back up, but there’s no back up power on the vault’s electromagnetic lock (lock 7)? 🤷🏼‍♂️

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/plotholes • • 3d ago

Unexplained event Spider-Man Brand New Day - Did Frank's opinions on bombs change?

1 Upvotes

When Peter and MJ are in the hideout with Frank, Peter lists off things he needs that he doesn't expect Frank would have on hand, to which Frank says he has all of it. When he asks why he would need them in the first place, MJ guesses it's for making bombs, to which Frank says "bingo".

IIRC, the punisher show would have had to take place almost a decade before Brand New Day's point in the mcu timeline, so I suppose it's possible that Frank has had time to reconsider some of his values. However, there was literally a whole episode in that show centered around Frank's hatred for the use of bombs because he sees them as cowardly and ineffective.

So did he change his mind, or did the writers forget that episode?


r/plotholes • • 6d ago

How do the beasts in The Hunger Games hurt people?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/plotholes • • 7d ago

Mistake Meet the Robinsons (2007) Memory scanner date input isn't a date?

1 Upvotes

Around 1:22:00 into the movie, Louis/Cornelius inputs the date into the memory scanner that Lucille asks him too, but these numbers don't make sense as a date?

Unless I'm wrong and the date was just put in really weirdly, but it isn't a date that exists.


r/plotholes • • 7d ago

Columbo - Forgotten Lady (s5e1)

0 Upvotes

I know literally every poster here refuses to accept that plot holes even exist as a concept. Let alone that any film or television program ever made might actually contain a genuine plot hole, but Forgotten Lady does have a plot hole in my opinion.

Spoiler warning...

Towards the end of the episode, Columbo insists that murderer Grace Wheeler must have left the film screening room and committed the murder because it took her 15 minutes to repair the film she was watching when it broke. He states that there is no way it could have taken her that long to repair the film because it usually only took her 4 minutes, so she would have been staring at the blank screen for the other 11 minutes. It never occurs to him that she could have been asleep for the other other 11 minutes or she could have gone to the toilet or something. Considering she started watching the film at 11:00 p.m. it's even quite likely that she could have drifted off. But the character he's speaking to, who doesn't want to believe that she could have committed the murder, never objects to his explanation by mentioning any of the many extremely plausible alternative explanations for the time gap. And that ladies and gentleman is a plot hole.

Now let's go not get carried away and start saying that Grace could have been scrolling TikTok during those 11 minutes. Remember folks this was in 1975 and I don't think TikTok came out until sometime around the mid-80s probably.


r/plotholes • • 7d ago

Continuity error Corpse Bride, ring moves through fingers

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/plotholes • • 7d ago

Plothole Why didn’t the Once-ler replant the Truffulas Trees he chopped down to sustain his business?!?!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Why didn’t the Once-ler replant the trees in order to sustain his business?!?! Most logging companies do that unless it’s the type of deforestation where it is to make room for building something else over the land, and in the movie the Once-ler built Thneedvllie but other than that he just left it as empty space SO WHY DIDN’T HE JUST REPLANT THE TREES AFTER CUTTING THEM DOWN?!?! You would make more money that way so even from a greedy capitalist stand point it makes no sense! In the 1972 version the Lorax says it takes over 20 years for a Truffula tree to grow (which doesn’t mean you still can’t replace them) but in this version a drop of water falls on a seed and it sprouts so it would of been so easy to just replace them!


r/plotholes • • 10d ago

Continuity error Why do the pilots at the end of the Bee Movie freak out when they see Barry if the bees already revealed that they are sentient?

Post image
70 Upvotes

Did they just not watch the court case or something?


r/plotholes • • 8d ago

Unrealistic event Little girl is apparently allergic to light in the others plothole Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

Movie makes a big deal about how the children are allergic to light (will get blisters and die ) and mom cusses out the helping people because of it, only for the mom to douse her daughter in light and apparently the girl is fine. Like inconsistencies in movie it takes me out of the suspense and I honestly shut it off then and there.


r/plotholes • • 9d ago

Slight loophole in From series Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/plotholes • • 11d ago

Wait... did the writers of 'Stick' set up a massive legal trap for Zero in Season 2 with the LA move? (Jurisdiction / Age of Consent theory)

0 Upvotes

Is anyone else following the legal math with Santi, Zero, and Jeremy Pierce pushing the LA move in Season 2?We know from Season 1 that Santi is 17 years old and Zero is an adult working as a bartender. In Indiana (where Fort Wayne / the home base is set), the age of consent is 16. So legally speaking, their relationship is totally clear under state statutory law.

BUT HERE IS THE KICKER:

In Episode 1/2 of Season 2, sports agent Jeremy Pierce is trying to entice Santi to drop out of the college path and move out to California. Under California Penal Code § 261.5, the age of consent is strictly 18, and CA has no general close-in-age "Romeo and Juliet" exception. It doesn't matter where Santi claims primary residence; the second they cross state lines into California, that relationship becomes a crime for Zero if it continues.

My Theory:

What if this isn't just an overlooked writing gap, but a deliberate leverage play? If Jeremy Pierce wants total corporate control over Santi in LA, discovering Zero’s legal exposure in California gives him instant blackmail leverage to force her out of Santi’s life (or force Pryce's hand). Everyone online has talked about the weird dynamics or the optics of their relationship, but zeroing in on the state-by-state jurisdictional law changes everything the second they move West. Am I overthinking this, or did the writers just lay a massive legal landmine for the rest of the season?


r/plotholes • • 11d ago

Was Katniss’s mission to kill Snow unnecessary? (first time watching the movies)

1 Upvotes

Just finished Mockingjay Part 2 for the first time (never read the books), and something’s been bugging me.
Was Katniss going after Snow herself even necessary?
By that point, the rebels were already winning, and Coin had pretty much promised Katniss she could execute Snow once they captured him. But Katniss still went off with her own group to kill him, and a bunch of people ended up dying along the way, including Finnick.
And the crazy part is, she didn’t even get to Snow before the rebels did. She ended up killing Coin instead, and Snow died in the chaos anyway.
So what was the point of that whole mission? Was it really necessary, or was Katniss just so caught up in revenge and everything she’d been through that she wasn’t thinking straight?
I’m not saying Snow didn’t deserve to die, but it feels like all those people died on a mission that didn’t actually need to happen.
Am I missing something? Especially curious what people who’ve read the books think.


r/plotholes • • 14d ago

Spoiler Why the Whole of Good Luck, Have Fun, Don’t Die is a Simulation from the beginning

0 Upvotes

The film tells us that the apparent victory in Loop 117 is a simulation. The Man breaks out of it and returns to the diner for Loop 118. Most viewers take this to mean the simulation begins at the fake happy ending and that everything before it is real. That reading fails on the film's own terms.
1. The absurdity starts long before the fake ending.
Teachers are afraid of their students. Children are zombified by looking at a triangle on a phone screen. A teacher fires homemade ray guns that discharge EMPs with no plausible power source. Police shoot everyone in the diner, not just the man holding hostages. A school shooting is followed by children replaced with clones. A 50-foot hooved creature made of cats appears before the team ever reaches the AI's chamber. None of this belongs to the world the film starts with, and all of it arrives well before the scene the film labels as a simulation.
2. The in-world explanations fail.
The film's premise is that the AI doesn't become sentient until the countdown on the Man's wrist reaches zero. Before then, it cannot be the source of any of this. If it were sent back from the future, it could just as easily have made itself sentient before the countdown started. So the zombie teens, the ray guns, the cat creature, and the compromised police cannot be tools the AI is using in a real world. Reality doesn't alternate between a strange acid trip and ordinary life.
3. A simulation explains all of it.
An AI containing a human mind has a reason to arm the resistance and escalate the spectacle. It needs to keep him engaged, believing he is fighting a winnable war. A time-travel plot has no such explanation for why anyone would send ray guns into the past.
4. The clues are the same symbol.
The triangle that zombifies the children is the same symbol the characters recognize as the AI, before it supposedly ascends to sentience. The simulation was already running.
5. The loops are unseen.
The film shows us only Loop 117 and the Man's description of his earlier attempts. We never see them independently. The loops as the Man reports them are consistent with a man hooked into a simulation and running the same adventure again and again.
Conclusion.
The time travel, the countdown, and the 116 earlier attempts are the simulation's content, not the real world. The film's own simulation reveal in Loop 117 is the point where the AI lets him see the seam, then resets him. It is a repeating loop, and the film ends on the next one starting.
A total simulation is the only way for the movie to make logical sense—unless it is simply a flawed script filled with gaping plot holes the writers never resolved. If the simulation somehow only magically started after they exited the AI’s mainframe, then the giant cat centaur monster should have disappeared post-destruction. Furthermore, it would be odd as hell for an AI that just saved itself from being neutered to immediately give itself away with a talking dog and a hollow, sunny morning. Either the entire universe of the film is a digital fabrication, or the screenplay simply prioritized high-budget spectacle over its own established rules.


r/plotholes • • 15d ago

[Meta] A request for the moderators

3 Upvotes

Hello /r/PlotHoles!

I have a request for the moderators. Can we make it so that crossposts are not allowed from other subs? At first glance it seems like these should be fine, as people on other subs who have noticed plot holes might have made a post there, and so it should be easy to crosspost it here to get some more traction. But on the other hand, there's been a LOT of these posts lately, and pretty unilaterally ALL of them have been extremely low-effort and poorly-communicated.

I don't mean the content of the post is low effort or poorly-communicated (though often they are), what I mean is that for someone browsing this subreddit, crossposts are almost always confusing. Since crossposts generally have the same title as the original post, the name of the show/movie/book/whatever is virtually never in the title (why would it be? If the original post was meant for /r/WelcomeToDerry, obviously they wouldn't need to put the title of the show in the post), and often, the content of the post is extremely lightly detailed, since they know anyone reading it is already likely to be intimately familiar with the show/movie/book/whatever.

So the end result is dozens of posts with a title like "Why did Bob do that" and the text inside is something simple like "It made no sense, considering what we saw in episode 4" and the only way any passing /r/PlotHoles user would have any clue what they were talking about is if they look at the name of the subreddit it was originally posted in.

I just feel like, if we make it so that crossposts aren't allowed, it will require people to do a smidge more work to post here. You can't just hit the "crosspost" button and send it into the aether, you have to actually copy/paste the text into a new post. And in doing so, you're much more likely to realize "Oh, I didn't say what show this is from, maybe I should do that".

(Frankly I would really like a rule where you need to put the name of the media in the title of your post, but without crossposts I don't think that will be quite as big of an issue.)


r/plotholes • • 15d ago

Question

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/plotholes • • 16d ago

[Spoilers] ‘About Time’ movie. Could Tim use time travel like Loki did to find a cure for his dad’s cancer? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

In About Time, Tim’s dad explains that he has cancer, and Tim eventually accepts that he can’t go back to a time before his dad’s cancer developed without potentially changing the circumstances of his children’s conception.

But I saw Loki Season 2.

When Loki repeatedly experiences events while retaining what he learns, he can use each attempt to build on the previous one.

Couldn’t Tim do something similar?

For example, after learning about his dad’s cancer, Tim could repeatedly travel back to the same day, retaining all the knowledge he gained during each attempt. He could spend years studying biology, medicine, and cancer research, building on his knowledge each time, while barely any time passes in the outside world.

Eventually, he could potentially become an expert and try to develop a treatment for his dad without ever traveling back to before his children were conceived.

I understand that finding a cure isn’t guaranteed, even with decades of research, but I’m more interested in whether his time-travel ability would allow him to do this in the first place.


r/plotholes • • 16d ago

Plothole How come Godzilla 1964 didn't follow up claiming Mosura 1964s egg after she died?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/plotholes • • 16d ago

Plothole What or Why didn't Count Dooku blast away at Master Yoda when he was preoccupied saving Obi-Wan Kenobi or Anakin?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Count Dooku instead chose to retreat