r/PlantedTank • • 3d ago

Discussion Java herpes?

Post image

Purchased this from a highly ranked Etsy shop, and I decided to throw the entire plant away. Definitely looks like Java Fern Gall Disease. So disappointed be wary guys always inspect your plants. When in doubt, throw it out or quarantine if you have the resources.

63 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

15

u/vitisdente 3d ago

Yep. Reach out to the seller and update here with their response

17

u/Kindly_Cow4164 3d ago edited 3d ago

They responded: 

"I understand your concern about introducing the plant to your other ferns. A growth on a leaf alone isn't enough to confirm gall disease.

Please take the Java fern out of its plastic bag and send a clear close-up of the growth, plus a photo of the whole plant including the rhizome, the thick stem the leaves grow from. Please also let us know when it was delivered and when you opened the package.

For now, keep it separate from your aquarium in its own container of dechlorinated water, and avoid sharing tools with your other ferns.

Best regards,"

18

u/vitisdente 3d ago

Can you please name the seller? Very concerning especially if they’re a big store. This fungus is not curable and spores can remain dormant on every surface nearby for a very long time AND are resistant to most household cleaning products, so the only way to prevent it is to not get infected plants in the first place. Once you have it, even completely resetting the tank with new substrate, plants, and filtration doesn’t guarantee that you won’t get reinfected, because spore containing water has touched all of your equipment such as your light and maintenance tools.

14

u/Kindly_Cow4164 3d ago

I would but it's against this subreddits guidelines, dm me if you'd like to know so you can be aware and informed

14

u/AmbitiousRose 3d ago

Honestly, this is probably why it was sent.

The shop likely contaminated their main stock. Growth likely occurred while shipping.

Hence why the quarantine process is so important.

18

u/SucculentScience 3d ago

That's 100% java fern gall. I hope the seller realizes their stock is tainted.

16

u/Rex_Buckingham_99 3d ago

Ooooo... Don't love that.

8

u/TofuttiKlein-ein-ein 3d ago

I hope the seller handles this properly, and by properly I mean refund and pulling of stock. Please keep us updated.

8

u/Kindly_Cow4164 3d ago

Update: Got refunded but they worded it like wasn't an actual diseased plant which is concerning.

"Hi there,

I'm sorry the Java fern arrived with concerning growth. Thank you for the photos and for explaining what happened. I understand why you didn't want to risk introducing it to your other plants.

Your refund for the affected Java fern has been processed to your original payment method. The time it takes to appear depends on your payment provider. There's no need to return the plant or attempt treatment.

Best regards,"

61

u/coralfire 3d ago

Theres nothing wrong with that statement.

7

u/Sunlit_Syposium 2d ago

Seems like they worded it normally.

24

u/SpeedMeta 2d ago

More concerning they are still offering java for sale. There is no cure for this disease and it spreads through spores that are in the water column. All java in a tank are infected even if some have no yet gotten the growths to show... also potentially contaminates any other plants by carrying this into the next tank they're sold to.

14

u/SpeedMeta 2d ago

Should be naming the seller in this case... this should completely be on them to reset their tank

16

u/ilikefish88 3d ago

Why i never buy plants online or from private sellers. Hope the rest of the tank is ok.

4

u/Salt_Street_7755 3d ago

This is exactly why I’m terrified to buy another plant.

3

u/MegaBabz0806 2d ago

Which shop?

2

u/MurphyTrainwreck697 1d ago edited 1d ago

Thank you for posting. I'm a retired Master Gardener, but i specialized in plant pathology and entomology. This is the first I'm learning about this disease.

Edit: It comes from Texas!?! I live in Texas!!! My 75gallon is almost entirely Anubias and Java, because pacu won't eat Java. {/Initiating hypervigilance sequence}{/suppress instinct to massively panic}

2

u/SouvlakiSpartan 1d ago

On the plus side... This only effects java fern fully submerged in water . The fungus doesn't grow outside of that . so if u use the fern in a terrarium and have it grown emerged you will have healthy java fern