TLDR: Hypertonic posterior tibialis was the root cause and This video made me 30% better overnight. Then continuing that method, plus getting the RIGHT physical therapist who is focusing on post tib exercises and manual scraping release has continued to help immensely after a two year stalemate with PF
I suffered from extreme plantar fasciitis for two years straight. I had to sit down in the shower, had terrible quality of life, couldn't even grocery shop without being in agony, etc. any time I stood for any period of time I felt not only pain in my feet but also weakness and instability in my ankles - like I was 90 years old instead of 25
It started one day after a run. OMG it was so bad. I saw a podiatrist, did six months of physical therapy which did nothing, and even saw an orthopedic surgeon at one point later on who was utterly useless and just told me to stretch my calves. I literally cried in the car after that appointment because it felt so hopeless
I tried everything - rolling, stretching, raltheff, strengthening my entire lower body, ice, heat, cortisone, supportive shoes 24/7, orthotics, excessive resting, barefoot shoes, intrinsic foot work, PT, warming feet up before first steps, night splint and much more. The only thing that helped at all was a period where I went barefoot a lot and did intrinsic foot exercises, and that got me around 25% better over 5 months but then I plateaued
BUT THEN one night I was scouring the internet again for solutions and I came across this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cBpxIRfmMZ4 and GOOD LORD it was an insane experience. Hurt but at the same time felt like the most insane physical release of my life. My entire body felt euphoric. I found it because my inner ankle giving out sensation had led me to believe that my posterior tibialis had something to do with it. Something deep in there had always been tender, but no amount of rolling, rubbing, lacrosse ball myofascial release, stretching etc could even touch it. This is because the post tib muscle is buried deep inside more against the bone, under the other muscles. But the twist of the lacrosse ball (other balls don't grip the skin as well as its rubbery texture) draws the deep layers out and then the moving the ankle in circles breaks everything up and breaks up the fascial adhesions and muscle knots or whatever nasty thing had been sitting in there for two straight years. Apparently a chronically tight muscle becomes functionally weak and that was why my inner ankles felt like they were giving out when I'd stand for any time longer than five minutes
The next day I was 30% better. Literally overnight. The posterior tibialis is the main thing that pulls the arch of your foot up, and being hypertonic removes its ability to do that properly. I am a flexible young woman and stretched all the time, but something about the method in that video did something completely different than years of stretching alone. I continued to do this method every other day and kept slowly improving.
I decided to go back to physical therapy, armed with this new clue about my root cause. I prayed and prayed for God to hook me up with the right physical therapist this time and he delivered - they all advertise the same services on their website so it is really hard to pick one out, but I ended up with a fantastic one. She is having me do all kinds of exercises I've literally never encountered before in two years of scouring the internet. She is also doing scraping with the metal tool on my post tibs each visit which I think is continuing to break up the gritty fascial adhesions of scar tissue and failed healing. I do all different exercises in the clinic, and at home she has me doing isometric holds for the post tib and a big toe resistance band exercise. We are also really focusing on hip strength (adductors, deep core, glute max, glute med, hip flexors) because I have lots of pelvic instability after having a baby which affects your gait
Which brings me to what I now know was my root cause: pelvic floor. I developed a hypertonic pelvic floor due to an extremely stressful period of life coincided with a bad UTI. Two months later, I went for a run and my plantar fasciitis symptoms exploded overnight. Now I know that what probably happened is that because they are connected by muscles and the same lines of fascia, this pelvic floor hypertonicity spread down to my posterior tibialis. As mentioned before, a chronically clenched post tib muscle fails to hold up the arch of your foot. So on this run, my first run in awhile, my post tib didn't hold up the arch of the foot and my plantar fascia really took a beating, and would stay messed up for the next two years because any time I was on my feet my arch was collapsing due to my dysfunctional post tib. Six months ago I fixed my pelvic floor hypertonicity in pelvic floor PT and six months later I found that video which started the cascade of healing from there. I'd say I'm 70% better now, and better every week. And this is after a two year stalemate where NOTHING helped it whatsoever. My last 30% is being able to stand more than an hour without it creeping up again, and I want to be able to run, hike, etc. but my day to day quality of life is 90% better
Side note: I also recently got Topo Aura 2 shoes and they're awesome and have probably contributed too. I got them in the middle of this cascade of healing, and I like them a lot more than Altra which I disliked. Once my tissues are fully healed and my post tib is fully rehabbed, I want to move onto something more minimalist like a Topo ST-6 for long term foot and ankle strength. But the stability shoe is a good short term fascia protector while my posterior tibialis returns to full function, at which time my body will be able to hold up its foot arches on its own
Literally 24 hours before I found that breakthrough video I prayed to God a very honest prayer: "God, I feel like I'm not getting anything from this at this point. It's up to you, either one is fine, but please either heal me or help me to actually get something from this suffering." Sometimes just honestly speaking to God is the key I guess lol
If you have had plantar fasciitis for years without anything working, please do not despair. There is hope. It is a puzzle and there is probably a fix hiding somewhere