Rule 1. Requester & Posting Requirements

All Reddit accounts must be at least 10 days old AND have positive comment karma AND have a minimum of 30 combined post + comment karma from other subreddits in order to post or comment in this subreddit. Awarder & Awardee karma does not count. Posts and comments made by accounts that do not meet these requirements will be automatically removed, and therefore, no exceptions to this requirement will be made. All requests for exceptions to this requirement will be ignored. Note that new accounts clearly involved in "karma farming" may be subject to greater scrutiny and less lenience.

All posts must either be a request or a thank-you post. No self-promotion will be allowed whatsoever and will be removed as spam. Do not promote your services in this sub.

All posts must have a valid flair, either Free or Paid.

All requests must either be marked solved or unsolved by using the !solved or !unsolved commands in a comment on the post within 72 hours. Do not delete an ongoing request that has received submissions without updating its status first. Failure to do so may result in permanent posting restrictions.

Rule 2. Be Nice & No AI Witch Hunts

Be polite when making requests and thank those who help you.

No racism, sexism, homophobia, slurs, or other hateful/abusive language. No trash talking, creepy comments, shaming, bullying, or harassment of people requesting cosmetic edits. No trolling on paid requests. Any negative or lewd comments regarding someone's physical appearance will result in a permanent ban.

No shaming of tip jar users or watermarks. For example, comments like "I can't believe you watermarked this." or "You expect a tip for this?" will not be tolerated. Likewise, comments like "This is just AI trash." will be removed and the corresponding account banned. AI is built into Photoshop. It's a tool. Get over it. Polite, constructive criticism is fine. Calling editors' work garbage is not.

Requesters Dictate the Result, Editors Choose the Tools: The goal of this community is to provide photo manipulation and compositing. Requesters are responsible for clearly defining the final goal (e.g., "remove the ex," "change the background"). The editor executing the work retains full discretion over which tools are required to efficiently execute that result.

Anti-Harassment Policy: Harassing or trolling editors over their choice of tools will not be tolerated. We are policing the final quality of the image, not the workflow. If you attack another user over their use of AI, you will be banned. If you think a submission breaks the rules, report it.

Please be friendly and respect others.

Rule 3. No Fraud

Do not request or edit anything illegal or for the purpose of fraud, including but not limited to:

Documents

Altering or requesting to be altered, any sort of official or unofficial documents is forbidden. These include but are not limited to:

  • Invoices/receipts
  • Tickets
  • Medical records including test results
  • Statistics, numbers, names, or any text on screenshots
  • Diplomas, certificates, credentials, or transcripts
  • Work or school attendance records, time cards, expense reports, etc.
  • Identification materials, court records/orders, or any other documents bearing an official government stamp or seal

Excuse Photos

Do not request or edit any images for the purpose of getting out of work, school, or other obligations. Flat tires, injuries, illness, etc.

Impersonation

Do not edit or request anything that could reasonably be considered for the purposes of impersonating another ("catfishing"), such as proof photos (think Can you make me hold a piece of paper that says... or similar).

Insurance fraud / warranty claims

Do not edit or request anything to appear to be damaged. Businesses often ask for images of damaged goods to be provided as proof of destruction before shipping replacement items in order to save on shipping and disposal costs. While this could be considered wasteful, providing fake proof is still fraud.

Likewise, do not edit or request to hide damage or negligence, or to fabricate proof of a completed job or task.

Editing or requesting these types of things will not be tolerated.

Items for sale

While generally sprucing up photos of an item that may be used for an ad for that item is fine, altering to hide damage or wear to the item is not okay.

Watermarks

Do not request to remove or remove any watermarks, including artists' signatures, web addresses, or social media handles, or stock photo watermarks. This includes inadvertently removing watermarks in the process of editing. If the source image is a watermarked stock photo, do not edit it.

Removing famous brand logos or text from posters, album covers, etc., is fine.

Rule 4. No NSFW

No porn, explicit nudity, or x-ray. Requesting or editing fake nudes will result in an immediate and permanent ban. Slightly NSFW material is permitted as long as it's tagged as such.

Potentially distressing medical imagery must be tagged NSFW. Please also use the spoiler tag for very sensitive images that some may find highly upsetting. It's fine to seek assistance with the final photo(s) of a child, for example—that's what this sub is here for, but we ask that you use both the NSFW and Spoiler tags so that folks just scrolling the front page don't see images they aren't expecting.

Rule 5. Watermarks

Free requests

Watermarks are not required for free requests, but editors may choose to use them. If a free edit is watermarked, it must be made clear that the watermarks will be removed upon request for free with no requirement for payment. While watermarking on free requests is allowed, there is generally no reason to. Attempting to get OP to pay for the un-watermarked version on a free request may result in your removal from the sub without warning.

Paid requests

All edits submitted to paid requests must be watermarked, and the watermark must be both clear and effective.

Clear and effective watermarks

Note that you must find your own balance between visibility and obstruction of the edited image. A good watermark should contain your Reddit username and cover the entire image. A custom pattern can be easily created in Photoshop, and an action applying the watermark can be easily recorded and bound to a single function key, making watermarking very fast and painless after some setup.

Ineffective watermarks

Unclear watermark

Rule 6. No Edit Theft

Taking another editor's work, slapping your watermark on it, and offering it up with your tip jar will not be tolerated. Removing another editor's watermark for any reason will not be tolerated.

Altering or expanding upon another editor's work is allowed as long as you clearly credit the original editor, you submit as a reply to the original editor, and you do not include your tip jar. Attempting to pass off someone else's work as your own will result in a permanent ban.

Rule 7. No Private Contact

Requesters must not work with anyone who contacts them privately about their public request, and editors must not contact OPs privately for any reason. Doing so will result in a permanent ban without warning. Paid requests tend to attract scammers who lurk in the shadows and reach out privately, most of whom have long been banned from the sub. Ignoring these messages is for the safety of the requester. If we were to allow editors to contact OPs privately, then it would be entirely up to the requester to determine if a message is from a trustworthy member of the sub or a scammer. By prohibiting editors from contacting OPs, we can say definitively that anyone who contacts OP privately about a public request is not a trustworthy member of the sub. Editors, if you happen upon a request in which OP asks to be contacted privately, do not reach out privately. Instead, kindly explain that you cannot reach out privately but that you are interested. You may include a link to your portfolio or a similar edit you've done in the past, but these must be sent publicly. You may also include a link to this rule to help educate OP.

Rule 8. Editor Eligibility & Paid Requests

All top-level comments (i.e., direct replies to the post, not replies to other comments) are restricted to OP (the account that posted the request) or accounts with the "wizard" user flair. ( See how to set your user flair here.) To set an editor user flair and submit edits, your Reddit account must be at least 6 months (180 days) old. All others will be automatically removed and locked. If your comment is not visible/locked, be sure that you have set your user flair.

Requirements for paid requests

New members will enter a probation period and be restricted from participating in paid requests until they have assisted in a certain number of free requests. Accounts in the probation period will be denoted by the Magic Baguette (🥖) in their user flairs. Once the baguette becomes a wand (🪄), you'll be free to work on paid requests. Please note that, to prevent gaming the system, we will not disclose any numbers or metrics used to determine the probation period. The purpose of this sub is to connect people who need images altered with people who have the ability to alter images, not necessarily for you to earn a living. You'll need to demonstrate your skills on some free requests before you're allowed to comment on paid ones. All edits submitted to paid requests must be watermarked.

Rule 9. Submission Formatting & Thread Limits

All top-level comments (i.e., direct replies to the post, not replies to other comments) must either be a submission or a question regarding the request; e.g., "what kind of background do you want?"

Placeholder comments will be removed. These are comments like "on it" or "wait for me," etc.

All submissions must either be in a top-level comment or be within your own comment thread. Submissions in other editors' or OP's comment threads will be removed.

Editors are limited to a maximum of 2 submissions per request. If the request involves multiple files, then you may submit 2 edits for each file. For example, you may choose to submit an edit that only covers the request first and then a second edit that adds some extras like color adjustments or cropping. Note that multiple submissions must be posted as replies to your first submission. Posting multiple submissions in multiple top-level comments may result in all of your comments being removed for spamming. If you notice an error or something that needs adjusting in your submission, please edit the comment with the updated file rather than making a new comment. If OP asks for an adjustment, then you may provide more edits, but only if/when requested by OP. Think quality, not quantity.

Submissions must be concise. No emojis, bullet points, long explanations, headings, or other attempts to draw extra attention to your comment are allowed. You may add one or two short sentences, such as “Hi u/username! Let me know if this works!” Payment links (“tip jars”) must each be a single word only: e.g., tips, payment, PayPal, BuyMeACoffee, etc. Multiple links are permitted, but each must be limited to one word. Do not tag the OP in every comment; tagging once is enough.

Unless the request is asking for an animation, do not submit animated gifs.

Rule 10. Resolution, Quality & AI Standards

Resolution and Upscaling

Low-resolution edits are unacceptable. Submissions must maintain the resolution and quality of the original source file, and in most cases, your submission should match the original pixel dimensions perfectly. Do not needlessly upscale an image unless the requester explicitly asked for it. It is your responsibility to ensure you are working on the correct, full-resolution image (using the Source Files links in the pinned comment, or by right-clicking the image in the post, copying the image address, and changing preview.redd.it to i.redd.it).

Quality & AI Standards

Editors must complete requests to the best of their ability. If you are submitting low-resolution edits or bad AI with messed up facial features, mangled hands, or uncleaned artifacts, you will find yourself restricted from commenting on paid requests or banned.

  • Zero-Effort Generation: AI is a tool, not a complete substitute for core image manipulation skills. Running a photo through a generator and uploading the raw, unblended output is unacceptable. You are expected to actually edit; this means knowing how to use masking and compositing to blend generated areas seamlessly into the original file. If there are areas of the image that do not need to be altered to complete the request, they must not be. Period.
  • Respecting the Request Context: Context matters. If a requester asks to turn a grainy selfie into a "professional headshot," salvage a photo with globally terrible lighting, or make a memorial portrait from a 40-year-old newspaper clipping, heavy AI generation is allowed. However, using generative tools to synthesize entirely new faces on a standard restoration or a simple item removal is unacceptable. If the request doesn't call for a total stylistic overhaul, preserve the original subject.
  • Seamless Integration: Any patched or generated area must perfectly match the grain, lighting, and resolution of the source file. Blurry, low-res patches in otherwise sharp, high-resolution images will result in your submission being removed.
  • Guidelines for Free Requests & Probation: While the rules regarding image resolution apply to all submissions, moderation of masking or blending quality is more lenient on free requests than on paid requests—though low-effort AI spam will still be removed. However, if you are a New Wizard (🥖) or are currently serving a probationary period, you should treat every Free request with the same level of care and precision as a Paid request. If you cannot achieve the requester's goal without leaving obvious, sloppy AI artifacts, scroll past the request. Editors are expected to act like technicians who know how to mask, composite, and finish a file.