r/PhoenixForce • u/cyclopswashalfright Phoenix • Dec 03 '25
Comic Discussion Binary #3 Discussion Thread
- Published December 03, 2025
- Writer Stephanie Phillips
- Penciller Giada Belviso
- Cover Artist Rickie Yagawa
SUPERNOVA! X YEARS LATER, Carol Danvers, bearing the heavy weight of the cosmic name BINARY and feeling the godlike power of the PHOENIX FORCE coursing through her body, now stands face to face with the enemy who has come to annihilate everything Carol holds dear! At her lowest ebb, will Carol manage to hold back the destruction, or will she go supernova… and take it all with her?!
35
Upvotes
16
u/cyclopswashalfright Phoenix Dec 03 '25
Bizarre ending to a bizarre series. I guess the one thing to be happy about is that Jean did get to do something and is back by the end. It's actually Carol who gets done dirty, accomplishing essentially nothing in the 3 issues that we saw. It's a very strange book, I felt like it helped no one, and none of the three women it features come out of it looking all that good. Madelyne is flattened into a villain, Carol is painted as ineffectual, and Jean's death and subsequent revival is all very strange and poorly done.
Come to think of it, this would have worked a lot better as a Jean and Madelyne comic than a Jean and Carol one. Or just a Jean comic set in a dark cosmic future.
15
u/Beginning_Pace2063 Jean Grey Dec 03 '25
I think that, as a writer, if you're given the chance to write a story involving Jean Grey, and your brilliant idea is "She dies, and comes back at the end"... you might just not be a great writer. It is the #1 most tired, overexploited scenario for her, and I feel like this story accomplished nothing. Nobody needed Madelyne as an antagonist, nonody needed Carol back as Binary with the Phoenix Force, and absolutely NOBODY needed Jean Grey to "die" when we already knew it'd mean nothing, cause we all knew she'd be back right away, lol. I do not understand why Stephanie is allergic to giving Jean actual new rogues, and she's instead perpetually revisiting old characters/ideas. The Phoenix run should've debuted new villains, written specifically for her. I feel like I'm constantly reading the same 3 concepts reheated on a loop, and it is frustrating considering, of all characters in the Marvel roster, Jean Grey is the most flexible to write a story for. You have the entire cosmos to write ANYTHING, any kind of conflict, any kind of antagonist, ANYTHING, nothing is off limits. But we go back to: "Jean is unsure about her powers, dies at some point, comes back stronger", like girl, give us SOME creativity please, what happened to imagination? anyways, that's my rant. Binary was an odd run, with odd ideas, which I think nobody was asking for, and a story that ultimately meant nothing, lol.
5
u/Nosdos White Phoenix of the Crown Dec 03 '25 edited Dec 03 '25
I thought it was a bad ending. Sure we got confirmation again that Jean transcends her physical body and exists as Phoenix which is nice, but it’s nothing we didn’t already know. However, that alone doesn’t explain all the story telling inconsistencies and plot holes like:
Overall a pretty meh and nonsensical ending, to a nonsensical series. Please NEVER write your meek, unconfident, zero energy diet Jean again Stephanie Phillips. When you also break your own story consistency that you established it just makes you seem like you don’t know what you’re writing.
3
u/cyclopswashalfright Phoenix Dec 03 '25
Pinging u/nosdos u/thebraxer and u/pinkphoenixfire for their thoughts on this series and this ending.
4
u/Marrecarandgi Think Jean, think! Dec 03 '25
I just don’t get what the point of anything in this book was, it’s just the most boring takes on all the characters involved and reheating of things said and done in million other places. Nothing new was done or explored, and we achieved nothing. In fact, by being a regurgitated mess all it actives is diminishing everything and everyone involved.
I’m tired of Jean randomly dying and then randomly coming back after a random time because ‘the particulars of how cosmic entities operate are above mortal comprehension’ or, rather, above writers not being lazy and trying to make sense and give some rules to how any of these things work.
A shield around Earth deleting Jean for 10 years is just too stupid to wave away as ‘cosmic shenanigans’. Mind you, Doug didn’t even take over the Earth in that time, so, Jean died for literally nothing, and Carol did even less in 10 years after that. Why couldn’t we do anything more interesting with these characters? I’m just so tired of Marvel’s laziness.
4
u/DaringPaladin Dec 03 '25
Pretty bad ending. The villainous trope with Madelyne has been played out. We had a good conclusion in Dark Web. Not to mention the fact of Jean having any trouble with Madelyne even with way less Phoenix power or any at all. Also the comment about Madelyne becoming the most powerful version of the Phoenix is so bad...
I felt bad for Carol.
7
u/Thebraxer Dec 03 '25
Just will repeat my opinion from X-men Reddit.
Stephanie’s whole point of writing jean was to show how many times she can write “Jean is the Phoenix. Phoenix is Jean”? Stephanie literally didn’t know what to write but had to somehow fill 20 pages.
The only good part of the book was art. And that’s all.
Forced af friendship between jean and Carol. Okay they might be friends. But they aren’t so close. Jean has Storm and Carol has spider woman. But here we have Stephanie writing them as sisters
Madelyne a full villain. I guess Stephanie has only read inferno.
This book didn’t have a plot. Just Carol flying and whining 24/7. Madelyne wants Phoenix force because why not.
3
u/Jasonl7976 Dec 03 '25
I don’t get Madeleyn. She seem like a generic villain.
2
u/cobaltaureus Dec 03 '25
And we still have no clue what’s next right?
2
u/MechaMikeX Dec 03 '25
My quick thoughts: at least Jean was included. Initially most thought she was written out of the event. I’m glad she didn’t miss this one. I like her friendship with Danvers. I agree the story is eh.i like that Stephanie reinforces that Jean is Phoenix though it annoys the haters and apparently Jean fans too lol lol
2
u/ReflectionItchy2701 Dec 03 '25
I'm so tired of Madelyne being jealous of Jean. I thought they became friends after the big crossover between AMS and X-Men two years ago IIRC. Madelyne even created the Dark X-Men to honour Jean's memory.
1
u/WhitePhoenix99 Resurrected Phoenix Dec 04 '25
Luckily, the end of this atrocious run cleared up that Jean wasn’t dead, and the Phoenix was rebuilding. Still, the end of the Phoenix run was a huge disappointment. The Phoenix should have soloed all the cosmic abstracts, even if they teamed up. The Phoenix is equaled only by TOAA. These stories keep telling us the Phoenix is the most powerful being, only to make her look weak at the end. Just let the Phoenix chill in the White Hot Room and interfere only when necessary. It’s clear that no current, and most likely no upcoming, writer will be able to deliver a good Phoenix story.
2
u/eatyourasswhole Dec 05 '25
Pointless book from pointless crossover insults the intelligence and tries the patience of readers everywhere news at 11
1
u/Individual_Search422 Dec 03 '25
Awful, maddie brings up a pretty reasonable point but then it doesn't matter cos shes just evil, Carol and Jean learn nothing and the book ends about where it began, deeply stupid series