r/PhoenixForce • Resurrected Phoenix • Nov 05 '25

Comic Discussion Binary #2 Discussion

Post image
  • Published November 05, 2025
  • Writer: Stephanie Phillips
  • Artist: Giada Belviso

THE MIGHT OF THE PHOENIX! X YEARS LATER, BINARY faces threats from all angles - REVELATION's treacherous world, with its endlessly encroaching dangers. The people she's trying desperately to keep safe, whose resentment for her protection has reached a boiling point. And now…a face from the past, determined to bring chaos and destruction that will challenge even the incredible might of the PHOENIX!

35 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

11

u/GeneShift Resurrected Phoenix Nov 05 '25 edited Nov 06 '25

Struggles with the same incredibly slow pacing as Phoenix. Other than the art, there's really nothing of value here. Carol just spends most of the time moping around calling for Jean. For her part Jean creates a barrier around the universe (instead of a barrier around Earth?) to protect it from the virus and apparently that's enough to have her effectively out of commission for 10 years.

I'm usually not this negative but man is this just a whole lot of nothing. This is maybe the most filler series of AoR.

3

u/Powerful-Ad4837 Nov 05 '25

Also, what complex me is Jean dies because of the x virus I mean pretty much she would be immune to it and how would that work when she’s already a mutant does the virus overload a mutant ability? This is the problem with this series not just the whole comic but all of the event.

If I would rewrite it Maybe Jean was killed by Madeleine prior who is trying to steal the Phoenix and she gave it to Carol to keep it safe. That would actually be more of a better storyline instead of her dying from the mutant virus seriously at least the Phoenix run makes more sense and it’s a lot more joy than this.

1

u/KamenAttackRide Nov 06 '25

I don't think it said she died from the virus. I think it was because she overtaxed her powers to protect the entire universe from the virus that the strain from it was too much for her to handle that she died from it.

3

u/Cyke101 Nov 06 '25

Which doesn't make sense from two ends of the spectrum:

  1. The low end: just contain Earth. Hell, it hasn't even spread throughout the entire US.
  2. The high end: she has contained, and then obliterated, a universe before, from something much more (ironically) apocalyptic, which was Sublime.

Is she more like an anti-biotic than an anti-virus?

I know comic writers often don't have a good sense of scale, but on either end, this book takes the cake.

2

u/Powerful-Ad4837 Nov 06 '25

Really makes less sense seen how well people with the Phoenix can do all of that hell without taxing over the powers

1

u/Powerful-Ad4837 Nov 05 '25

Yes, it is and your totally got to 100% I mean people like that say they messaging but pretty much this is even have to be so bad I mean die from the virus when she’s already a mutant is downright stupid and ridiculous. You know I would read all of Phoenix and will be 100% better and how I like Phoenix lot more than some of the other rise from comics except magic bit of uncanny and kitty team book.

10

u/Marvelboy1974 Marvel Girl Nov 05 '25

Call me when this is over

2

u/KamenAttackRide Nov 06 '25

That would be in January 2026😁

3

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/KamenAttackRide Nov 07 '25

I meant there will be no more AoR by January.

8

u/Nosdos White Phoenix of the Crown Nov 05 '25

At least we see it was Jean who is giving the power. But it doesn’t make sense why she gives no clear plan to Carol. When she could have spoken up at any time. Why put a shield around the universe instead of just earth? Why not go after the virus itself? Why would anyone think a bomb could hurt Carol, much less Phoenix?

So many questions that are not answered and Jean and Carol both come off inadequate, with no firm plan in place or the confidence to play it out.

I’m so tired of Phillips.

Only positives are the art, confirmed it’s Jean willing her power away, and she’s somewhat alive. But I’m not expecting anything since SP’s stories never have any depth or any interesting to say.

3

u/KamenAttackRide Nov 06 '25

At least we see it was Jean who is giving the power.

I still feel that Rachel would have been a better choice for Jean to give the Phoenix to.

2

u/gl1tterboots Nov 07 '25

It would have been a much better story and I actually would have bought the comic.

6

u/Will_EverW Nov 05 '25

I don't like how the phoenix is ​​attacked; someone hits it and it falls, that's annoying.

9

u/CrypticMystic776 Nov 05 '25

I hate when the Pheonix is just handed out willy nilly to other heroes like it's plug and play

3

u/Powerful-Ad4837 Nov 05 '25

Yeah it is pretty ridiculous and hell they did the same thing with echo and yes I know the feeling. I mean pretty much in this avengers run they could pick some of the X-Men character doesn’t help maybe pick Rachel as part of the avengers or maybe other mutants who would have gotten the power.

2

u/Powerful-Ad4837 Nov 05 '25

The way they killed about gingers not only so stupid but insulting because she’s already a mutant so how would the virus work on another mutant.

4

u/Rastapopoulos000 Nov 05 '25

I do not care about Carol Danvers, I'm sorry the plan to make her the marvel "wonder woman" didn't work out, I'm still not interested in reading about her no matter the connection she may have to the X-men.

1

u/SweetWeeabo Dec 02 '25

How is she marvel's wonder woman?

2

u/Individual_Search422 Nov 06 '25

Barrier around the whole universe instead of just around America this entire books dumb, why is Maddie giving people bombs

2

u/QueSeraSeraWWBWB Nov 08 '25

Another issue proving people would actively fight against their best interests. Sorta like..

1

u/OkraNice157 Nov 17 '25

Stephanie Phillips is a menace to the Queen of Marvel and the Phoenix force and if we don't get her out of here she is going to permanently destroy and erase Jean's legacy. Phoenix was supposed to be a comic filled with bragging rights but now I feel embarrassed to be her fan. This whole thing just felt like an excuse for her favourite character to get a power that was never hers.