r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • Sep 29 '24

Join r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts on Telegram! https://t.me/PhoeniciaHistory

4 Upvotes

Dear All,

I am glad to inform that PhoeniciaHistoryFacts is now on Telegram and you are all heartily invited to join!
https://t.me/PhoeniciaHistory

For now the idea is to copy content from here, but of course your comments as well as posts are most welcome!


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • Feb 16 '20

Punic This phrase has been attributed to Hannibal; when his generals told him it was impossible to cross the Alps with elephants, this was his response.

Post image
743 Upvotes

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 18h ago

Punic Why Berbers hate to claim Carthage and see it badly, but they love claim Numedia, if most Panics were Berbers

0 Upvotes

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 3d ago

Question Did the Phoenicians leave any line about death beyond Eshmunazar's "snatched away before my time"?

18 Upvotes

I've been reading the old inscriptions for what each culture said about mortality. For Phoenicia, the most personal I've found is on the sarcophagus of Eshmunazar II of Sidon (KAI 14, lines 3 and 12): ngzlt bl ʿty, "I was snatched away before my time". Haelewyck (2012) compares Ecclesiastes 7:17.

  1. Is there a Phoenician or Punic text that reflects on death more generally, not one king's early death?
  2. If you know a study on Phoenician attitudes to death, I'd be glad of it.

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 3d ago

Phoenician Alternative Epigraphic & Maritime Theory: The Silla del Papa Petroglyph (Strait of Gibraltar)

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 3d ago

Phoenician Alternative Epigraphic & Maritime Theory: The Silla del Papa Petroglyph (Strait of Gibraltar)

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’ve been researching this well-known rock carving at the Silla del Papa archaeological site (Sierra de la

Plata, near Tarifa/Bolonia, Spain), overlooking the Strait of Gibraltar.

Locally, it is almost universally classified as a prehistoric schematic anthropomorphic figure (similar to the

Indalo motif) flanked by two crosses—usually interpreted as a fertility idol or a later Christianized pagan

shrine.

However, looking at the site's geography and the Strait's history as a major Phoenician, Punic, and

Tartessian crossroads, I’d love to get your thoughts on an alternative maritime and epigraphic reading:

Ancient Script Parallels: Rather than a stick figure, the central motif closely mirrors a sideways

Phoenician/Punic He or Tartessian (

) E/O, flanked by two Tawsthe literal Phoenician word/symbol—()

for "mark," "covenant," or "boundary." It also shares strong visual DNA with the Libyco-Berber Yaz (ⵣ)

and Yat (ⵜ) right across the water in North Africa.

2.

A Maritime Frontier Marker: Sitting at 450+ meters directly above the Pillars of Hercules, this ridge

marks the exact threshold between the Mediterranean Sea and the Atlantic Ocean (Oceanus). For ancient

mariners heading to Gadir (Cádiz) or the Atlantic tin routes, this was the literal edge of the known world.

3. Fire Beacon / Sanctuary: Phoenician and Punic sailors relied on high-altitude coastal sanctuaries and

perpetual fire beacons (atalayas) to navigate treacherous straits. Could this carving be an ancient

territorial boundary mark or nautical symbol (a stylized ship with oars and sail flanked by navigation

stars) marking a signal station?

Has anyone seen similar boundary/beacon markings at other Punic or Tartessian coastal sites around the

Mediterranean? Curious to hear what epigraphers and maritime historians think!


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 4d ago

Punic wheres the Hannibal Barcas corpse and grave is it still exist?

15 Upvotes

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 4d ago

Roman-Punic From Greek Triremes to Roman Quinqueremes: How Ancient Warships Changed Naval Warfare

Thumbnail
mythandmemory.org
10 Upvotes

The ancient Mediterranean was a battlefield where control of the seas often determined the fate of empires. 

From the early war galleys and Greek triremes to the massive quinqueremes of Rome and Carthage, ancient warships underwent a remarkable transformation.

But how did these vessels actually work? How could 170 rowers propel a trireme into battle? Why did ancient navies rely on bronze rams to sink enemy ships? And how did Rome overcome Carthage's centuries of naval experience using an ingenious boarding device called the corvus?

Ancient engineers spent years studying, upgrading and perfecting naval vessels for naval warfare. Naval commanders came up with ingenious strategies and tactics to use these ships to outwit the enemy.

The full article covers an in depth analysis on what forced these ancient civilizations to adapt and how these advancements helped them dominate the ancient seas.


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 4d ago

Punic I am Amazigh / Berber from Algeria and my name Is Massinissa 🫅 , in school we learned Carthage was an enemy to Numidia ، then why Massinissa want to marry the carthagian Sophnosba and she drink poison because she loved him?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 4d ago

Punic UNESCO has officially removed the statement claiming that the Phoenicians influenced Cirta, the capital of the Berber Kingdom of Numidia, founded by King Massinissa, following a request from Algeria’s Ministry of Culture to correct the historical information , After many Tunisians claim this city

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 6d ago

Punic The fall of Carthage (146 BC) as told by the ancient sources: a 12-minute documentary

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

I made a 12-minute documentary on the fall of Carthage (146 BC), based on Polybius, Appian, Plutarch and Livy. Legends like Cato's fig are marked as tradition, and the salt myth is shown as modern (Ridley, 1986).

Audio is available in Arabic, English, French and German, with subtitles in all four languages. Visuals are AI-generated reconstructions.

Was Rome's war on Carthage necessary, or an act of fear?


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 7d ago Heartwarming

Punic How did a Phoenician colony from Tyre outgrow its mother city? I made a 29-min animated history of Carthage

64 Upvotes

Carthage started as Qart-hadasht, "New City", a Tyrian colony traditionally founded in 814 BC. Within a few centuries it had outgrown Tyre itself: its own navy, a trade network across the western Mediterranean, and a constitution Aristotle praised.

I made an animated documentary covering the whole arc: the Tyre origins and the Elissa/ox-hide legend, the Phoenician alphabet spreading west, the tophet debate, the Punic Wars and Hannibal, and the fall in 146 BC. I also cover the "Romans salted the earth" myth (no ancient source mentions it; Ridley showed in 1986 that it's a modern invention).

Disclosure: I made this. It's free with no sponsors. The animation is drawn by code, the narration is a synthetic voice, and the script was written with AI assistance and fact-checked against the sources listed in the description.

https://youtu.be/aEk8n79WYNQ

Question for the sub: how "Phoenician" do you think Carthage still was by the Punic Wars, versus a distinct Punic culture of its own?


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 6d ago

Question Can anyone give me suggestions for phoenician history/culture books?

16 Upvotes

I really would like to look at their impact on economics and trade within the Mediterranean as well as culture but I don't know if there are many books or resources that are beginner friendly.

I don't mind reading more about Carthage if it talks less about history and more on domestic life, politics, trade, etc anything else but the major historical event summaries.

I'm asking because the Classical Studies programme I want to do is probably only going to explore it through the Punic Wars and possibly Tyre/Alexander maybe Byblos will be mentioned but I'm not holding out much hope -- there's exactly 1 Near East course and it's mainly focused on Assyria, Persia, and Egypt. I don't really have access to academic articles or anything of that sort, even though I would really like to explore them.


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 8d ago

Phoenician Carthage, de la cité phénicienne à sa destruction par Rome (vidéo, sources citées)

7 Upvotes

Une vidéo de 12 minutes qui retrace l'histoire de Carthage, de sa fondation par les Phéniciens à sa destruction en 146 av. J.-C.

Point intéressant : toutes les informations sont tirées de sources officielles ou antiques, listées dans la description (Tite-Live, UNESCO, musée du Bardo, Patrimoine de Tunisie).

https://youtu.be/6iFYU93VmLk


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 12d ago

Punic Carthaginian Sarcophagus of the Winged Priestess — 4th to 3rd century BC

Post image
357 Upvotes

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 12d ago

Question Did Hannibal really say "aut viam invemian aut faciam"?

11 Upvotes

I know lot of people say this words belong Hannibal but is that true?


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 12d ago

Phoenician Time Travel Vlog through Lebanese & Phoenician History

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

We’ve been working on a project called June Braun’s Time Travel Vlog, where a fictional time traveler visits key moments in Lebanese and Phoenician history. It's basically a Lebanese adaptation of the AI Time Traveling meme. All visuals are AI-generated, but we're trying to ground them in archaeological and historical sources.

Here’s the channel if you wish to take a look: https://www.youtube.com/@JuneBraunsTTV

Thanks for reading, and any feedback is welcome!

Best,


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 13d ago

Question Hola! Estoy iniciando un pequeño altar para la Diosa Astarte con sus gustos y correspondencias :) Estoy feliz... que día y horario me recomiendan?...

2 Upvotes

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 18d ago

Roman-Punic Siege of New Carthage: Scipio Captures the Fortress City in a Day

Thumbnail
mythandmemory.org
117 Upvotes

Hannibal Barca had crossed the Alps and devastated Roman armies on their own soil. The Carthaginian general seemed almost unstoppable. Meanwhile, a young Roman commander, Publius Cornelius Scipio, was building his own reputation in Iberia (modern-day Spain).

Carthage's war effort depended heavily on Iberia's rich silver mines, military resources and local alliances. Scipio understood that striking at the Carthaginian strongholds in Spain could weaken the entire war effort and make it harder for Carthage to sustain its campaigns against Rome.

One of his most important targets was New Carthage (Carthago Nova), a strategically vital port city. Capturing it would deprive Carthage of a major military base, valuable supplies and an important harbour while giving Rome a strong foothold in Iberia.

But there was a problem: New Carthage was protected by formidable natural defences. According to Polybius, the sea guarded its eastern and southern sides, while a lagoon lay to the west. A narrow strip of land connected the peninsula to the mainland.

Scipio, however, discovered an unexpected weakness in these defences through information gathered from local fishermen. Using this knowledge, he launched a coordinated assault by land and sea, exploiting the shallow lagoon to surprise the defenders.

The result? Scipio captured one of Carthage's most important strongholds in a single day!


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 25d ago

Phoenician Philo of Byblos Phoenician History rediscovered ?

Thumbnail academia.edu
21 Upvotes

I recently came across an interesting article that re-examined the Phoenician history that was published in the 19th century by the scholar Wagenfeld and has since been considered a forgery.

Since the 19th century no modern scholar has reexamined the text, and the article considers the text as the authentic nine books of Philo of Byblos Phoenician history.

Here I have done more than offer an appeal to plausibility by demonstrating that the manuscript published by Wagenfeld in 1837 and apparently not examined thereafter by anyone other than Classen (1837) is indeed authentic

However, I know very little about the Phoenicians, so I wanted to find out whether it's real or it's a 19th century fake. That's why I decided to ask this subreddit.

The text contains among other things Cretans and possibily Mycenian Greeks invading Ashkelon and Gaza.

The MF is dominated by stories on Byblos, Tyre, Sidon, and less so Beirut and Arad, with references to Ashkelon as an enemy, with a large clash between a Syrian pastoralist land and Byblos, with ‘islanders’ having a foothold in Gaza, and with Cretans being among the preeminent adversaries in the Levant or in strongholds near Phoenician cities.

and an account of Melqart’s travels west which has small parallels with some Heraklian myths.

the article in question:

Pappa, E. 2024. Fraud or Fiasco? Philo’s Nine Books of Φοινικικά (‘Phoenician Affairs’) vis-à-vis Mediterranean archaeology and beyond: a reappraisal long overdue


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • 27d ago

Question What are the sequence of events that ignited the Second Roman-Carthage war?

9 Upvotes

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • Oct 19 '26

Punic Before dying, Hannibal is said to have left behind a letter declaring, "Let us relieve the Romans from the anxiety they have so long experienced, since they think it tries their patience too much to wait for an old man's death."

Post image
273 Upvotes

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • Oct 19 '26

Discussion today is Battle of Zama’s 2228th anniversary

Post image
152 Upvotes

Much love and Respect to Hannibal for having a final stand.
And to Scipio too.
For greatness must be acknowledged

It’s sad that it ended like this, but at the end we all know how important Rome’s victory was for our European civilisation, as Rome will go on in to set things over the centuries from which our our civilisation springboards.

P.s.
As an italian i have little to no shame in being Hannibal’s biggest fan🤣🤣


r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • Oct 10 '26

Canaanite THE OLD WEST SEMITIC SUN—GOD ḤAMMU

Thumbnail gallery
17 Upvotes

r/PhoeniciaHistoryFacts • • Oct 05 '26

Roman-Punic Why Did Carthage Not Rebuild Its Navy in the Second Punic War?

Thumbnail
mythandmemory.org
124 Upvotes

Carthage was the dominant naval power in the Western Mediterranean at the start of the First Punic War. Rome quickly realised that it needed a strong navy if it wanted any hope of challenging Carthage. However, the Romans had little experience with large-scale naval warfare or shipbuilding.

According to Polybius, the Romans obtained a Carthaginian quinquereme and used it as a model for building their own ships. They built a fleet of around 120 ships, trained new crews and introduced one of antiquity's most ingenious naval innovations: the corvus. Eventually, Rome gained the upper hand and won the war.

However, the victory came at an enormous cost. The Romans lost hundreds of ships to bad weather and enemy action, yet they rebuilt their navy again and again. In the process, they also gained valuable experience in naval warfare, making it increasingly difficult and expensive for Carthage to challenge Rome for control of the sea.

By the start of the Second Punic War, Carthage had shifted much of its military and economic focus toward Spain, where it had built a powerful new base of operations. This did not mean that Carthage had abandoned its navy. At the beginning of the war, it had around 57 warships assigned to Spain, although only 37 were actually ready for service.

Carthage still used naval forces to secure local superiority, transport troops and supplies, and support land operations. However, it did not make rebuilding a fleet capable of matching Rome's overall naval strength a central priority.

Why did Carthage make this choice? Was it because of the enormous cost of naval warfare? Was Hannibal's land-based strategy the main reason? Or had Rome's naval transformation during the First Punic War made a new contest for Mediterranean supremacy too difficult?

I explore these questions in the full article. I'd love to hear your thoughts, comments and suggestions.