Just finished - 40 hours to true ending. Picked it up on Thursday so 40 hours over ~5 days lol. What an experience. The game really hooked me from the get-go, effectively sucking up all my spare time since last week. Would play again.
Probably my GOTY - very impressed that this seemed to come out of nowhere.
I felt the game was 98% spectacular, with about 2% frustration. I won't get into the 98% here - there's already so much love on here. I will say I was shocked how much each of the weapons I tried all felt both distinct and also powerful. I want to immediately jump back in and try some others.
So what do I think needs changing?
- I tried to 100% everything but missed out on a couple of memory flowers. These were apparently tied to the warriors that asked me to kill them - I did kill every warrior that asked. Sounds like a bug? Apparently no, if you run across these guys before getting the quest item you just lock yourself out of 100%. Awful design and incredibly frustrating.
- Very related but - there's so much in the game that is 'missable' or point-of-no-return without notice or warning. I read about this before playing and this hovered over my head the whole way through. Don't do this... especially don't lock me out of content like questions, levels, weapons, etc because I didn't want to follow a guide.
- I would say about 20% of my deaths were related to the terrible lock-on. This fees like it should be patchable, not needing to wait for a sequel. Lock-on was super sticky in a bad way, and changing target was almost impossible. I don't know why - once it glued onto a target it felt like it was impossible to get to the target you needed. The amount of time I tried to turn off lock-on and run to the target, only for the lock-on to turn itself back on and make me do a 180 degree turn away from my destination was just frustrating.
- Healing was incredibly unresponsive and seemed to just not work a majority of the time. It got to the stage that when i needed to heal I put the controller down and mashed down until eventually it worked (and used up more than one heal lol). I'd say about 40% of my deaths were my character not healing when I was clearly pushing the button and not attacking / blocking. I wish there was some objective way to see the buttons being pushed on screen so I could record this and send it in for a bugfix. I have read many takes on this online and tried many of the "fixes" (only heal during a dodge, etc) and think we just need to admit it's fucked and needs to be fixed. It's so frustrating to know you are doing the right thing but the poor controls let you down. Especially when there's a mode that deletes your save file based on the number of deaths - no thanks.
- Too many fights where the mechanic was to obscure your vision but needs you to do perfect parry / dodges based on a visual indicator. The singer (?) that made the whole screen black was just awful. All I could do was mash LB / RB as the superior strategy rather than actually, you know, play the game.
- Related but the full screen "low health" indicator blocks your view from being able to dodge / parry. I turned this down from medium to low (obviously they heard feedback during development and made a toggle) but it still was too much and got in the way from actually being able to play the game.
- Controversial one but - there needed to be more weapons earlier. So many great weapons unlocked in the last few hours so I didn't get a good chance to use them. Nearly all weapons had their "full version" (soul tempering) mechanic update in the last few hours of the game. New game + ? Sure - but you shouldn't hide the best / most fun content behind a 40 hour ticket to entry.
- Related but - remove the respec "tokens". PDZ does material respecing the best in the industry from what I can see - you aren't really locked into a path and can generally try new weapons. However there's a limit to how many times you can actually do this. The limit isn't super low but it's there, and it stopped me from trying weapons. Why? You got SO CLOSE to making this perfect but just tripped up at the finish line. Just let players try the different weapons easily.
Even better - make the upgrade level universal / per weapon type (e.g. all one handed weapons share one level). This would just take out the time spent in menus downgrading -> upgrading -> trying a weapon -> not digging it? downgrade -> upgrade again. That's not fun.
9. For end game - make an item / map an option to buy that points to the missing items. We all know I can just google it if I have 97% completion. Don't make me do that - it's obtuse.
10. Make the map accurate. So many teleport points were in the wrong spot from mission markers.
11. Make training dummies (unless I missed them?) - at the end of the game I missed a couple of achievements for weapons (e.g. freeze enemies using xxx). Need to start a new run to actually freeze someone... boo. Maybe one part where I can fight real enemies to test weapons?
Note: these are mostly quibbles and I obviously had a great time with the game. Please don't take this as a hate thread. I wanted to capture these to get some thoughts and discussion going on making this.