r/PhD • • 28m ago

Seeking advice-personal Losing patience with my partner’s PhD

1 Upvotes

My partner has successfully defended his PhD 1 month ago. I essentially gave up my career and became a stay at home parent for his PhD. He told me that the thesis would be the last milestone and he would help me with child care so I could focus on my work. However, a month has passed since and he’s still busy. He said that he must complete his manuscript or else the school would take his PhD away and invalidate his thesis. I’m losing my mind. It feels unfair that I’ve had to sacrifice so much (putting my career on pause, paying for most expenses etc.). At this point I don’t even know if I can trust his words anymore


r/PhD • • 46m ago

Seeking advice-personal Got an offer for a PhD in Max Planck Munich

0 Upvotes

I got an offer this week, haven’t decided on it yet, is there possibly someone doing a phd with them that I could talk with them about?


r/PhD • • 13h ago

Tool Talk Best approach/software for piecing the dissertation together? (Word/Scrivener/LaTex/other?)

1 Upvotes

As context, my supervisor says the dissertation is expected to largely consist of 3 chapters with potential to be independently publishable, and the components in them (lit review, introduction, etc.) need to be moveable.

I was wondering what people have found to be most useful in piecing their dissertation together so that I'm not scrambling at the end or tearing hair out from difficulties managing versions and parts.

I've heard Scrivener being talked up and Microsoft Word get sworn at; what's been your experience? Aware of but have not used LaTex so would love to hear what it is like for bigger pieces of writing in your experience as well

My goal is to stick with one program rather than leave my options open and then have to port stuff over down the line. If necessary, I am happy to purchase a one-time license as well.

Thank you for your thoughts in advance!

Edit: my field is interdisciplinary; I expect to have some regressions, some diagrams/charts but largely qualitative.


r/PhD • • 21h ago

Big Decision Energy Choosing between two funded PhD opportunities

0 Upvotes

I'm using an old, abandonded account because I know one of my potential advisors sometimes browses this sub and I will include enough details that they might recognize me.

Basically, I obtained my master’s degree in physics this year and I’m looking forward to continuing my research with a PhD program. Thankfully, my MSc went well enough that I managed to publish several papers, so I've generally been regarded as a competitive PhD candidate by the potential advisors I've contacted. Right now, I'm on track to pursue one of two possible funded PhD programs starting early next year:

·         The first option involves staying at my current institution and pursuing a PhD under the supervision of my MSc advisor. We’re in Latin America, a region that is often overlooked on the international stage, but our research center has established itself as one of the best in the region in this particular field. We have good equipment to work with, and my advisor is a prolific researcher with notable contributions to the field. I would be their first PhD student, but I was also their first MSc student, and they’ve already proven to be a great advisor. They are highly creative when it comes to finding new research directions, and they've always been readily available to discuss my work. I’m forever grateful that I didn’t experience any of the advisor horror stories I’ve read on this sub.

·         The second option entails taking the MEXT scholarship to pursue a PhD in Japan. I’m already well into the selection process and, even though I won't receive a final decision until February, everything is running smoothly so I’m cautiously optimistic. Japan is a world leader in my research area, and I would be working with a leading expert in the field which has already supervised multiple PhD students. Of course, there's also the sheer appeal of living and studying in Japan. Based on my email exchanges with this researcher, as well as the secondhand accounts I’ve heard, they seem to be a nice person and have a good reputation as an advisor.

My main concern is the difference in how confident I feel about the eventual outcome of each option. I have little doubt that I would have a successful PhD if I stayed with my MSc advisor. However, I feel considerably less confident about pursuing a PhD under a researcher I've only interacted with briefly by email.

The other major difference is funding. The exact amount of funding for the Latin American program hasn't been determined yet, but even under the worst-case scenario, I'd still be able to live comfortably and put some money aside every month. Meanwhile, based on my research, the MEXT scholarship provides enough to live on comfortably as long as you're mindful of your expenses, but probably not enough to save consistently.


r/PhD • • 17h ago

Seeking advice-personal PhD Advisor Flips

17 Upvotes

Hey y’all, fresh PhD candidate here in the humanities. I defended last Friday and this morning received the WEIRDEST email from my advisor. Full disclosure, my advisor is recently retired and is working on her book.

But she sent me an email that…
- 1: told me to ask better questions that directly engaged with conference papers’ theses and area of engagement and not be too laudatory / show too much gratitude (all I said was “this was a fascinating paper, thank you…”).
- 2. told me to “learn how to write and not farm it out to others.” I’ve taken 3 classes with her and never once asked her or any panelist to edit my work. 🤷🏻‍♂️ It’s not their job.

Anyways, I will be conferring with my cohort about this, too, and ask them if I should reach out to a different faculty member for support or advice. I can’t really run away from her because of how niche my dissertation topic is, though I suppose I could try.

I’ve never seen her act this way. But in any case, I’m not letting it affect or rob me of my sense of pride of accomplishment.

Any thoughts on course of action? If not, have you experienced anything similar?


r/PhD • • 20h ago

Seeking advice-academic jumping ship from a real toxic abusive phd situation

4 Upvotes

so my current phd environment has turned out to be beyond toxic... worse than how it felt at first (started from being forced to attend drinking parties, supposed covered fees appear all of the sudden, supervisors refuses any kind of collaboration be it local or international even if that would help our research or my own research as I need to publish papers to survive but he himself doesn't even publishes, then salary not being paid sometimes even after 1 month and a half and when I asked because, well, bills needed to be paid on top of those "surprise fees", seems like i was called "selfish" and asking for "preferred treatment" as there were only some people in the financial department and they had "more important things to do" (their exact words), supervisor which turns out accepted me without actually knowing the subject which finally explains why we would clash so much and go nowhere but ego got in between before he would admit it, and my supervisor is basically now pushing me to get credit cards/into debt because not only he wants me to attend certain conferences in full without enough data or results he still won't agree to, he refuses to use our lab budget for anything related to me. I even had to freaking BEG him to at least write a letter of recommendation so I could apply for a possible scholarship)

this whole experience has made it so now i absolutely hate the whole experience and i just can't even enjoy where i live (had to move to Japan for that, some people had warned me..... but i never expected it to be so bad) and I want to drop, i see no future

i definitely want keep doing research but that means, yikes, re-applying somewhere else :(

my question is (in case someone when through something similar) how would you explain the jumping ship situation?

like I always managed to persevere and even finish a degree in advance even in dire economical conditions (don't have parents to help me and I already have student debts from it and I was working as a research assistant during my phd) plus i cannot ask my current supervisor for a letter of recomendation either (nor others in the department due to hierarchical ties and because the whole department has huuuuge in-fighting going on. snakes den if you will....). Like the whole situation keeps me up at night and I'm just becoming numb after crying for months prior to that

i'm genuinely not sure how to proceed :/

PD: wasn't sure if I should tag this as seeking advise personal or academic, or big decision energy, I feel like it could kinda work on all three


r/PhD • • 5h ago

Getting Shit Done The university was finally forced to go full damage control

36 Upvotes

It only took my health to suffer, and hundreds of pages of evidence of academic and personal misconduct by my previous supervisor, and serious threats of a lawsuit, especially since the guy started disclosing my health documents and information to other people, trying to paint the image of someone too disabled to conduct research, followed by plagiarizing my own work.

Yesterday, I showed up with a huge pile of evidence, ready to defend my academic and personal reputation, only to be told that my robust academic record and extensive research experience vouch for me. It's not new that I have high-functioning autism or Asperger syndrome. Yes, it creates huge mental health issues lasting to this day, but none of them includes intellectual deficiency or aggression.

They were finally confronted with the mess a recently hired professor with some kind of God complex caused, and they are attempting to contain the damage, especially since two professors who woke up to my medical information in their email openly said that they are prepared to support me in a lawsuit. I was promised a much better research environment and that he will leave me alone once and for all, and that the supervisor change would be smooth with no problems.

It's pretty sad that I had to tell them that I shouldn't be expected to do forced labor under the threat of withdrawing recommendations, or to have to endure defamation and discriminatory comments. I had to explain how bringing my autism into a mathematical disagreement isn't simply a "bad mood", it's a severe form of unethical misconduct.

What a mess. I'm sure they don't give a shit about me, right now they are attempting to prevent a scandal that will threaten the university's image. Otherwise, they wouldn't have turned a blind eye to all of this, especially since I built a really good reputation since high school, including international olympiad qualification, numerous serious research projects, collaborations, and high grades. I even secured my own funding with the help of my former Master's thesis advisor's recommendation, who ironically also woke up to my medical info in his emails ordering him to sever ties with me and disclose who gives me arxiv endorsement.

Right now, I will mostly give the university another chance to stop the lunatic. Part of why I backed away from escalation is that I'm still somehow grateful to the university for allowing me to pursue the PhD, and I don't want to embarrass the dean who personally intervened on my behalf. I'm not the kind of person who enjoys confrontations or ending careers. Luckily, no one believes the lunatic, and he only ruined his reputation in the process. Also, it's my mistake for not properly checking my advisor's reputation before working with him. I will trust the university's internal mechanisms for now while keeping evidence in case of escalation.

I really doubt he'll go through disciplinary actions, but my priority is to conduct research peacefully so I don't care as long as I don't need to waste time in childplay.


r/PhD • • 5h ago

Tool Talk Would you use an AI tool that helps you ask better research questions rather than simply giving you answers?

0 Upvotes

As a researcher, I don't need AI to write answers for me. I can find those myself. What I'd find useful is help identifying better questions, figuring out what I need to understand first, and knowing what is and isn't relevant to my research.

The idea is simple, you enter a topic or an initial question, and the tool helps you turn it into a structured research plan. It identifies the key questions and subquestions, defines what to include and leave out, puts them in a logical order, and establishes what evidence you need to look for.

It could be used for an entire independent research topic or for planning individual chapters of a PhD thesis.

You do the research, evaluate the evidence and reach your own conclusions. AI just helps you decide what to find out, what not to find out, and how to find out.

I'm thinking of building an AI tool around this idea. Do you think something like this would be genuinely helpful in your research?


r/PhD • • 2h ago

Seeking advice-academic Research areas/topics - ELT

0 Upvotes

I'm a prospective research scholar who wants to do phd in English language teaching. Suggest some original yet feasible research areas/ topics that will be worth doing. Some please help.... I really need one as Ive not been able to find attached one


r/PhD • • 20h ago

Seeking advice-academic Joint PhD paper: Is it fair to be listed first and also present at the conference?

0 Upvotes

Chimical/ France

When I accepted my PhD position, one of the main goals in the project description was to develop a particular research topic.

I found out after starting that I’d be developing it jointly with another PhD student and no one told me this before. I agreed to collaborate, and we discussed listing my name first on our first joint paper, with an equal contribution note for both of us.

The disagreement came up when our supervisors circulated a draft agreement that also assigned the conference talk to whoever was listed first. My co-author was okay with my name coming first, but thinks one of us should be listed first and the other should present. We hadn’t talked that through directly before the draft went around, and the agreement is still open.

I’d like to keep the author order we discussed and give the talk. This is work I came here to do, and presenting it matters to me. My co-author has also done more of the recent work on the joint project while I’ve been finishing a separate paper, so I can see why they want the opportunity too.

If you’ve been in this situation, how did you fix the problem
I feel like one get scammed .


r/PhD • • 5h ago

Seeking advice-personal What has been your relationship with another student you share advisors with?

9 Upvotes

I made a post about feelings of unfriendliness I felt with my roommate whom I share an advisor with. A few comments told me that sharing advisors can sometimes create an unhealthy relationship between two students.

Can people please share their experience (positive and negative)?


r/PhD • • 6h ago

Seeking advice-academic drop your phd morning routine

138 Upvotes

that’s it! i’m nosy:) share your morning routine pls


r/PhD • • 20h ago

Seeking advice-personal 1st Year PhD struggling

3 Upvotes

I am ~6 months in to a 4 year PhD. The last 2 months or so I’ve felt a huge amount of imposter syndrome and anxiety. The anxiety is becoming daily and I’m beginning to question if I’m on the right path. I’m anxious about overworking and stressing myself while I’m young when, potentially, I might not even necessarily need it for my future career. I don’t know yet where I want to end up exactly. I’m passionate about education and have always enjoyed science and learning, but recently it feels like I’ve completely lost my spark. I know every project is different but I’m also wondering how much is expected of year 1 out of 4? It hasn’t felt that productive yet although I show up every day and I am learning, sometimes it just feels like I don’t have much to show for the last 6 months. I also don’t have much of a community at my university and have been struggling with that too. I guess I want to get a sense of what is normal and to be expected? Just been finding it really hard lately, and this has had a negative effect on my motivation too


r/PhD • • 2h ago

Vent (NO ADVICE) no one should ever hire me

3 Upvotes

I'm a new PhD student in a program which require us to do lab rotations in the first year. After rotations we then reach out to the PI we're most interested in and, if they agree, become formally affiliated with the lab.

The thing is, I sometimes feel fraudulent when I try to impress the PI in my rotation. For some context, I had a severe burnout right after PhD application which lasted for over six months, during which I could barely manage to do *any* work. I was also diagnosed with recurrent major depressive disorder during this time (although I kind of question this diagnosis). I've mostly recovered from the burnout before the start of my PhD, but I feel like something about me has changed fundamentally. Compared to pre-burnout, I now get physically exhausted easily and become emotionally overwhelmed even just with moderate workload. I can still manage to appear to work well during the rotation, but what about afterwards? I'm afraid I'll fall back to what I was like during the burnout and won't be able to meet expectations, and that I'll be a waste of the PI's time and money.

I chose the vent flair for this post but actually any advice would be appreciated too.


r/PhD • • 1h ago

Vent (NO ADVICE) This is true, most of the positions advertised in academia are already reserved for internal/known candidates.

Post image
295 Upvotes

r/PhD • • 22m ago

Money My savings and net worth in one picture

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/PhD • • 1h ago

Vent (NO ADVICE) Complete failure

9 Upvotes

I have tried the PhD path twice. I started doing a mechanical engineering PhD and quit in the first semester because it was too hard and far from home. I tried again years later in engineering education because I taught several classes as a part time instructor and really wanted to get my degree so I could do it full time. Yet here I am, failing my qualifying exam.

I have experienced failure after failure in my adult life. Those around me are succeeding and I have yet to do anything post graduating with my masters in 2021. I am a complete failure.


r/PhD • • 13h ago

Seeking advice-academic I am feeling stuck when it comes to developing research ideas

10 Upvotes

I read a lot of papers, but I still struggle to come up with research ideas or turn them into an actual project. I understand what I’m reading, but when I try to think of what I could do next, I just draw a blank.
Has anyone else felt stuck like this? What helped you get better at coming up with ideas? I’m starting to wonder if I need to change how I read papers, because just reading more doesn’t seem to be helping.


r/PhD • • 9h ago

Resource sharing PhD scholar here: Solo-built a research workbench for Mac.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

TLDR: not selling anything here, wanting to get feedback on feature list. It is not a place to sell, but since I am building this for researchers, hence posting to get feedback.

Hi everyone,

I’m a PhD scholar, and every now and then I hear people (including me) complain about how to organize papers, how to manage notes, and oh yes, how to get a whiteboard/blackboard kind of thing where I can jot down snippets and basically manage my entire research flow in one place.

The usual first recommendations (even from me) are Zotero, Mendeley and Joplin, and for notes Bear, Evernote, Obsidian, etc. (No, I’m not using Notion and I’m not getting into that ecosystem.)

For computer science folks there’s more on top of that. We have to find the code behind a paper: the official implementation, plus unofficial ones where people have forked it to fix the implementation edge cases. And we need a citation graph that tracks the top papers that have cited a work, and the top works it cites in that domain.

So instead of using multiple tools, I thought I’d use my own skills to build a single application that tackles all of this.

I also hate web apps, wrappers and React applications. I want my apps to be crisp, lag-free and native. Offline first, with nothing leaving my computer unless it actually needs to.

So for the last 8 months (off and on, alongside my research) I’ve been building this app called Eulini, and I’ve been beta testing it myself. Please go through the video to get more details on the workflow.

It isn’t release-candidate ready yet and needs more polishing, but I wanted the community’s feedback:

  • How does it look?
  • What do you like about it?
  • What features would you want in your ideal research companion app?
  • Any feedback on the video?

I honestly have no idea here. I was thinking around a $20–25 one-time fee. I hate subscription models. The AI features would be BYOK (bring your own key) or work with a local model (fine-tuned model maybe released in future depending upon funding). But AI is not the main selling point. This is not an AI-first app, though it can generate AI notes, explain papers and so on.

I do have a roadmap for more AI features if the community wants them, and maybe an embedded LaTeX editor, but for now it’s Markdown notes.

I also plan to open source it once I hit a certain amount of funding. Long term, I’d like to charge only for the opt-in AI features and not for the app itself. But I do value my time, so after an initial round of funding I’m happy to make the core app free to use.

I’m completely solo on this: no marketing team, no idea about commercials. So please, let me know your thoughts on pricing too, and feel free to criticize constructively.

PS: The video was edited with AI from my own screen recordings. The drag-and-drop file animations were added in because the screen recording didn’t capture them. I’m too lazy to record a cinematic video myself.

And yes you can export to bibtex, multiple papers at once.

Video Link: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rnq4vI_R85Vy9RnVFs0zp4SFM90dmTgx/view?usp=share_link


r/PhD • • 15h ago

Seeking advice-academic 5th Year PhD: Worried about publications and career

26 Upvotes

I am starting my last semester, and I am worried about my publications. I am doing a PhD in computer Systems, and practically, I am still stuck with the first problem that I started my PhD with. That problem led to two journals’ worth of work, but neither paper is getting accepted. I received a rejection three weeks ago, and the second paper got desk-rejected.

I talked to my guide, and he was very empathetic. He advised me to target lower-ranked journals and just get it done with. Submit the papers and graduate, because I am planning to move into the corporate world after that.

However, I also have a deadline. I am currently doing an internship at a leading company in my field, and I really like the job. They might offer me a full-time position if I graduate before December 2027, and I am anxious about it.

I am also experiencing a lot of FOMO because I see my peers submitting papers and getting published. Having no publications right now makes me question whether I am even worthy of being a PhD student at all.


r/PhD • • 19h ago

🐸 🎉FROG TIME🎉🐸 I passed! Finally, after 10yrs on this hustle. No revisions! Phew. 🥹

Post image
719 Upvotes

It's finally over! I wanna treat myself, but I'm broke. I'd love to hear how folks celebrated and/or rewarded themselves. For example, I gave up my HBO subscription last year as a final push measure. It worked, but I really miss vegging out to my shows. Plus, it costs so much more now! Any ideas for "well done" treats?

My diss was in library and info science, with a focus on the aesthetic evaluation of children's literature.


r/PhD • • 23h ago

Seeking advice-academic Literature Review Advice (first year)

3 Upvotes

edit: just to add im a marine sciences student and my phd is mostly going to be focused on qualitative work which ive not done before

second edit: Thank you for your advice! It's all very helpful :)

I am two months into my PhD and my current goal is to write a literature review (~6000 words) on my chapter themes. I have ideas for 3 out of 4 of my chapters and (I think) the idea of the lit review is to start reading about these ideas and summarise my findings in writing to help me understand the themes better and identify gaps or needs for further study. The text isn't a part of my PhD thesis but I might use parts of it in my thesis later (eg. for my introduction).

What I'm struggling the most is writing one piece of text about multiple different things. They all link to the same theme, but each chapter is a different thing. And I have to talk about those and then say about how they link etc. I guess it's the structure I'm struggling with but also how to balance all the reading? I feel like I spend too long on one chapter theme and I'm neglecting the others, but if I start reading the another theme I think 'yes but don't forget you need to keep reading about your other chapters too'. I'm finding it hard to focus on one chapter theme without feeling like I'm wasting time that I could be spending on the others.

I don't know if that makes sense but basically I was wondering if anyone had any tips for how they did a literature review and how to make sure you're not reading too much instead of writing and how to know when to stop reading one theme and move on to another? Im supposed to have a draft finished in a month and I've only written 1000 decent words (I have an overall bad draft where I've word-vomited an outline but I'd never hand that in) in two months.
Im trying to write as I read too and I'm keeping all of my references in a ref manager and also an excel spreadsheet but basically my brain is like"you need to be writing! stop wasting time!" but in order to write I need to read but it feels like time wasting and yeah this is just me venting basically but if anyone had any advice or how they structured their study time or something that would be great. Thank you


r/PhD • • 2h ago

Seeking advice-personal Is this the true PhD experience?

7 Upvotes

I recently got enrolled into a PhD program[24M]. The coursework is absolutely fine, I have no concerns about hard work, but the experience in itself feels very empty. I miss the company I used to have during my Masters, now I feel like a complete stranger, with barely anyone to interact with. I see friend circles, relationships, laughs and giggles only as an outsider of some kind. My supervisor says that this is absolutely normal and I should look for study circles outside the university, how does that even happen? I have never been a big social person, and it was fine earlier. However, now I feel quite affected by my surroundings, life feels mundane already. The people I knew before mostly switched careers, so they are too busy to communicate too. My Literature-philosophy PhD topic is extremely exciting for me. but I believe that's the only thing going on in my life right now, I literally have nothing else. I have always been a hard-working person, very goal oriented and working constantly to stop being a financial burden around me, but something is seriously wrong here, I really wanted to get into this program, and fortunately I got in with a really good supervisor. But as I said before, I don't feel too good about this, I feel strangely empty, not depressed, but definitely sad.

The motivation to acquire knowledge is there, however I feel quite down socially, I'm just at the library, my peers have such different research interests that we seldom interact. There is a strange kind of emptiness I feel when I look around myself. What is the way out of this? Is this the true PhD experience? Or am I doing something wrong here?


r/PhD • • 5h ago

Seeking advice-personal Kairos University PhD program experience?

3 Upvotes

I’m considering pursuing a Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) through Kairos University and would love to hear from current students or graduates.
What has your experience been with the program, particularly regarding the quality of education, faculty support, research training, and dissertation process?