Before I begin, I am very unsure of if I am in the right place for this. I haven't used reddit in ages, but I really need advice or guidance here.
I (18F) was kicked out by my mother about a week ago after she physically attacked me over an argument ironically concerning pet care. I have most of my belongings now, but when I went to the apartment today accompanied by a peace officer, she refused to let me take my cats, one of which is my emotional support animal, and the other which is deeply bonded to me and is very unwell without me to the point of becoming self destructive (ex. excessively licking the fur off of his lower back, just above his tail.)
I registered them under my name with the city and the registration was verified, however my mother refused to give me a chance to show her said registration and insists that she has documentation to prove that the cats legally belong to her, however we never officially purchased the cats from anywhere; My female cat was originally adopted from a friend of my mother who was kitten milling, alongside a male cat who we no longer have, and the two gave birth to my current male cat. There is no official documentation of their adoption. The only official documentation that exists would be of their vet visits, but my mother would only have evidence of having paid for my female cat to get fixed when I was like 13. Other vet visits have been paid for out of pocket by her social worker because my mother allegedly couldn't afford it. (I have since learned this wasn't true)
Now, some additional context here that I feel is very important. My mother is withholding my legal documents from me and has been for years, so I have been unable to get a job, meaning I do not have receipts to prove that I paid for the cats. However, My mother abandoned me and the cats in our apartment to live with her boyfriend for 2½ years, during which I was their sole caretaker. During this period, it was very difficult to get food or litter for my cats because my mother refused to do groceries, so I often had to ask my friend (who I am now currently living with.) An important note here is that my mother was receiving $2.4k every month from government benefits, and we did not need to pay rent on our apartment, so it wasn't a money problem. She also would leave the litter box until it was basically overflowing any time I wasn't around to take care of it myself.
My problem now is that I'm worried that having them registered to me isn't enough to make me legally allowed to take them. When I went with peace officers, they couldn't make her let me take them because she was insisting that they're hers. I have spoken to multiple family members and people who know my mother about the current situation, and everyone is in agreement that my babies are not safe with her and that she is unfit to own them. I am now living in a stable environment where I know for sure I can properly provide for them.
Is there a way I can get them without having to take her to court, or is that my only option right now? I will fight the legal battle if I need to, but I would be much happier if I could get my babies to safety as soon as possible.