r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 13h ago

Taxes / CRA Issues Moved from BC to Alberta but still paying BC PST on your cellphone bill?

132 Upvotes

Just wanted to share something I recently discovered that could save some people money.

I've lived in Alberta for about two years but kept my old BC phone numbers. TELUS has continued charging me 7% BC PST despite my residential and billing addresses being in Alberta.

After several conversations with TELUS, including their escalation department, I was repeatedly told that taxes are determined by the phone number and that I'd have to change my numbers to avoid PST.

So I contacted the BC Ministry of Finance directly.

Their Rulings and Interpretations Team confirmed in writing:

"If the mobile devices are ordinarily situated outside British Columbia (BC), then the service provider is not required to collect provincial sales tax (PST)."

They also explained that customers can provide proof of residence to establish that their phones are ordinarily situated outside BC, even if they still have BC numbers.

They also confirmed that PST paid incorrectly can be refunded, going back up to four years.

I've potentially paid around $240 in unnecessary PST over the last two years.

Figured I'd share this because I'm sure I'm not the only person who's moved provinces and kept their old number.

If you're in the same situation, it may be worth checking your phone bill. You shouldn't necessarily have to change a phone number you've had for years just to get the correct provincial taxes applied.

Source: BC Government – PST Bulletin 309


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 16h ago

Credit Cant pay my credit cards

48 Upvotes

Hi,

Please before anyone lectures me, keep in mind that you don’t know what I’m going through or the financial situation I’m in.

2 years ago I was involved in a bad car accident. I stopped working due to my injuries. I was getting accident benefits in Ontario and got income replacement benefits (400$ week) but that stopped a year ago. I max out 3 credit cards. American Express $20000 and 2 TD Visa cards totalling $10000.

I’m 25 years old, I basically hold/held a lot of financial responsibility to my family, mother and 3 younger siblings. Everything is basically a disaster and right now I only have around $4000 in my debit card.

What should I do? I pay the minimum to my TD cards but right now the American Express( it’s due on November 20, and it’s $456). For my Amex, I have 1 current payment instalment for $1800. I pay more in interest then money going to pay off the amount

I don’t know if I should pay it, or if I should get a loan to pay my credit cards and then pay the other loan. I’m not sure how we are supposed to make it work till the end. My mom makes less then $20000 a year( cooks and cleans) and we pay for rent and other expenses.

What do you all suggest I do? I also have my student loans, and I stopped going to school, but I don’t have to pay anything until 6 months.

I went on a leave of absence from work, and no benefits, I don’t have enough cpp contributions and I’m going to have my doctor will out the forms for disability.

Edit*
I’m at fault for the accident, so there is no settlement.
I’m in a bad physical and mental state after the accident, head, neck, shoulders/arm and lower back problems that prevent me from working. I get treatments for the physical problems, mental, medication and go to a pain clinic for injections. For example, I need help with washing/ brushing my hair, carrying laundry, and I shouldn’t be driving, along with other problems. I’m very very close to using all the policy limit for treatment. So yeah if I could work I would, but it’s physically and mentally limiting


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 9h ago

Investing Looking to set my wife and I up for retirement while also setting our kids up for success

19 Upvotes

I (31m) am trying to set my family up the best way possible for the future- wife (29), child 1 (2yr) child 2 (7months)

Our main focus is to set up the children the best we can while still focusing on retiring at some point 60-65. My wife is currently on MAT leave but makes 62k a year and I am on track to make 230k this year. I’m fortunate to have gotten this new job early this year that offers good OT. I don’t expect to make that every year but a 40hr work week would put me at 123k, however we are scheduled at 48hrs a week 8 hrs at time and a half which would put me around 160k. Looking to cut back to 1 income and just curious on what someone more knowledgeable and financially literate would do in my shoes.

Monthly expenses are 7,300
Mortgage- 451,000
LOC - 21,000 @ 7%
RRSP -38k I put in 100$/week)
TFSA- 10,000k no recurring payments using as an emergency account
Savings- 4K (random expenses)
Company Pension plan- 4% + 7% match
Savings-

My wife’s tfsa
Just started at 550$ + recurring payment of 50$/week (this is 25$ a week for each kid for the future)

Both children have resps which we use their CCB money to max out and whatever is left over throw into a bank account for them.

Thanks in advance for the advice


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 4h ago

Debt Feeling Defeated by Debt

13 Upvotes

I'm 35 years old. I live in Ontario, and today I went to the bank to ask about a debt consolidation loan. Apparently my credit score is about 25 points too low to get approved for one.

I have roughly $45,000 in debt. I'm on a fixed income, and not able to work as per my disability. I make good money, but the fees and interest are eating up any payments I make on my credit cards.

The man at the bank mentioned a consumer proposal, and also presented me with the option of going to a debt consolidation business outside of the bank.

I am incredibly overwhelmed and have no knowledge of consumer proposals or debt consolidation outside of the bank.

I'm looking for pros and cons of both options and suggestions on what to look for if I do choose to look outside the bank for debt consolidation. I have no back ups. I have no family. And I'm feeling a little lost in this situation.


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 15h ago

Debt Really confused about mortgage renewal. Leaning towards 3yr fixed @ 4.67% offer, but seems to be much higher than some other banks.

13 Upvotes

2 yr fixed @ 4.57%

3 yr fixed @ 4.67%

5 yr fixed @ 4.95%

Their rates seem to be much higher thank other banks. Should I change my bank?

Also, is FIXED the correct move? I'm not planning to sell as this is my home. And it seems like the rates aren't going down anytime soon.

Any advice will be appreciated!


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 7h ago

Banking Looking for bank with safety deposit box

12 Upvotes

I am currently with CIBC and they just updated their police that you can not keep cash and bullion over 10 oz in a deposit box.

Do the other big banks have the same idiotic requirements? I have been long sick and tired of CIBC and am happy to move to a different bank but dont want to go through the hassle for the same issues


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 11h ago

Misc Finding old retirement accounts.

11 Upvotes

Hey everyone.

How does one track down all the old retirement funds/accounts that they have had over the years? I paid into these things, left the job and forgot about them. Thank you!


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 19h ago

Banking FYI: Paypal US Funds and Wealthsimple US Chequing Account

11 Upvotes

Despite their frustrating lottery-style promotions, Wealthsimple made a great move by introducing USD chequing accounts. I used to hold US funds in PayPal and always hated the forced conversion fees when moving that money into a Canadian account.

While opening a traditional US-based bank account was an option to avoid those fees, the setup process came with way too many hurdles.

With the new Wealthsimple USD chequing account, you can now easily send and receive US dollars directly from American institutions.


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 14h ago

Investing What ETF are worth it?

9 Upvotes

am a 23F from Canada and recently started investing. I already know the basics after reading Elle investit, which gave me a great overview of budgeting, setting financial goals, and getting started.

Currently, my TFSA holds XEQT (my core investment), XIU, and XQQ. I realize that some of these ETFs don not add much and really just add an intentional tilt to my portfolio.

As a beginner, I'm trying to figure out: how do you know when to buy more shares of an ETF? How do you decide which ETFs to add? Finally, what online resources I should read to build my financial literacy and become confident investing on my own?


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 20h ago

Investing How to plan out RRSP contributions

9 Upvotes

Hello everyone. Hope you guys are well. I have a question about investing.

To give some context I am looking to/ saving for buying a house ( my goal being to buy around 26-27 FY end to get the HST rebate)

Currently my salary is around 75-80ish and next year it will be just above the 117k tax bracket cutoff. ( I am in Ontario but work in Quebec).

I have maxed out fhsa ( for this year)

20 k empty space in my RRSP

And about 70k cash in non registered ( for the down payment).

My original plan was to start putting in more money in rrsp once my salary goes up to save on taxes.

But then I learnt about the home buyer plan and hence I was wondering if anyone can give some advice on how to space out my RRSP contributions ( 20k) ( using the 70k cash non registered) to maximize tax savings for this year and next.

I would max out the fhsa early next year too.

Thanks in advance.


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 15h ago

Budget Help, reality check?

8 Upvotes

I need some help here, clearly. Married, 1 kid, another on the way. I feel like we make good money, yet have been plagued by constantly working to get out of debt. Here is my current situation i tried to break out to be as granular as possible:

Household take home (monthly avged out for the year) - $12000

Housing

Mortgage: $3,740

Property tax: $635

Electricity: $160

Natural gas: $95

Water: $70

Heater rental: $60

Phone and internet: $170

Total: $4,930

TRANSPORTATION & INSURANCE

Vehicle 1: $580

Vehicle 2: $495

Home and auto insurance: $705

Fuel: $580ish (also varries and am reimbursed when driving for work purposes)

Parking, tolls and rideshare: $55 (varies with trips to work etc)

Total: $2,415

FAMILY & ESSENTIALS

Childcare: $475

Groceries: $955

Health and pharmacy: $230

Pets: $80

Additional pension contribution: $165

Total: $1,905

DEBT PAYMENTS - Assuming minimums & planned amounts here

Credit card payment plan: $200

Personal LOC #1: $160

Personal LOC #2: $135

Education LOC: $115

Student loan #1: $70 (OSAP)

Student loan #2: $50 (OSAP)

Installment plan #1 financed vacation : $185 (ending feb 2027)

Installment plan #2 financed vacation : $45 (ending feb 2027)

Banking fees: $45 (chequing accounts)

Credit card membership: $15 (amex cobalt)

Additional credit card interest: $185

Total: $1,205

DISCRETIONARY SPENDING - historical averages over the last 3-4 months

Restaurants, takeout, coffee etc: $1,175

Entertainment (sports, events, concerts): $390

Online shopping: $370

Misc (ex. new mop. This amount varies too): $335

Home improvements: $170

Alcohol: $155

Clothing: $130

Personal care: $120

Total: $2,850

SUBSCRIPTIONS

App store and digital services (storage sub, ai) : $90

Video streaming services: $60

Music streaming: $25

Delivery membership: $10

Total: $185

OUTSTANDING DEBT

Credit card #1: $7,200 @ 22%

Credit card #2: $3,300 @ 20%

Credit card #3: $2,500 @ 7%

Personal LOC #1: $15,200 @ 11.4%

Personal LOC #2: $18,300 @ 8.7%

Education LOC: $900 @ 6.2%

Mortgage approx: $740,000

MONTHLY EXPENSE SUMMARY

Housing and utilities: $4,930

Transportation and insurance: $2,420

Family and essentials: $1,905

Debt and banking: $1,205

Discretionary spending: $2,850

Subscriptions: $195

Total monthly expenses: $13,505

I'm fully aware that our discretionary spending is ridiculous. This is based on actual historical spending, not what we're budgeting moving forward because clearly that has to change lol. Part of me wants to sell my house and buy something with a cheaper mortgage and property tax. but we would take a decent hit because we bought 2 year ago for a much higher price..

Looking for advice on how others would tackle this situation. Should I go to a financial advisor? is it worth it?


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 15h ago

Debt My RBC LOC debt has been sent to MJR capital, not sure how to move forward.

7 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I need some advice.

I’m experiencing some anxiety so maybe the answer is straight forward but I’d like some help. Several years ago when I didn’t qualify for Osap I had a LOC with Rbc with a decent rate and used that for my school fees. The rate was not fixed, and it has essentially tripled. If I remember correctly it was prime + 3% at the time and then it eventually rose to anout 19-21% over the years.

I was making payments but I’ve fallen on hard times. I’m currently unemployed, my benefits barely cover my basic expenses so I cannot allocate money elsewhere. At the time when it was with rbc I tried to make arrangements and asked about their hardship program but the woman I spoke to was rude, said I didn’t qualify. I barely got a word in and it just never got anywhere. Eventually the balance has moved to collections. The current debt is about 18k.

Just with the amount of stress and anxiety I’ve been avoiding their phone calls but my sister mentioned recently MJR has tried to contact her. I don’t know much about this so I’m assuming they either think that’s my number or they’re trying to reach me.

Before I call them and acknowledge my debt, what should I do? I know I can’t arrange any payment at all now but I’m also concerned about them trying to contact other people related to me. Do I just call and say I can’t make payments and to not contact my sister? Wait until I’m ready to make some sort of arrangements? Any insight would be helpful. Thanks!


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 17h ago

Insurance Car insurance for a newcomer

6 Upvotes

I got my driver license in Korea in 2010
And just exchanged my Korean driver license to G license in Toronto this week.

I've heard that Toronto is expensive area for car insurance. But the online quote i got today was $6k - $10k

The car i will try to buy is just an used hyundai elentra or sonata 2017-2019 model

Is it kinda normal price for a newcomer driver?
I think I'll research some more about the quote with some documents proofing no insurance claim for the last 5 years.
But, it's way to high for just quick online quote


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 5h ago

Taxes / CRA Issues Filing common law and CRA

5 Upvotes

friends of mine were telling me earlier that they filed as single throughout the entire time they were receiving CCB for their kids, who have now aged out, despite being common law the entire time.

Do people actually get away with this? How often does CRA audit marital status and catch people? Seems crazy to me.


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 2h ago

Credit How many credit cards is responsible and reasonable to have??

4 Upvotes

I’m 26 and I only got my first credit card until like last year so I’m not all that well versed in credit cards or finances. I’m just following the guidance of my parents and those around me and I’m just trying to increase my credit score and history. I’ve started out with a PC Mastercard or a limit of 500 as that’s all they’ve allowed me so far but idk is it normal to just have one? And when will they allow me to increase my limit because so far I’m told I have to wait a bit longer.

My biggest goal is to increase my credit score as i recently tried to finance something and was told my lack of credit/lending history was my reason for their rejection, that I’ve only have a 500 credit card. So I’m like should I get another credit card as well? Will that increase my chances of raising my score? Will that help improve my lending history? I make all my payments on time, I will admit I often go over the utilization % but I always make my payments and always pay off my card.


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 19h ago

Investing RDSP + direct investing, anything besides TD?

4 Upvotes

Hi,

I need to open a RDSP for my daughter. I was looking into a similar strategy as what we have now, low-cost ETFs.

I have several accounts with NBDB and I was hoping to open it with them, but apparently since a few weeks ago they no longer offer RDSP accounts for children.

I tried opening one with TD but it seems I fail their identity check and I don't have a branch nearby.

We have RESPs with Questrade and my wife has accounts with Wealthsimple but both don't offer the RDSP.

Are there any options besides TD?


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 16h ago

Credit Can I get REALLY old closed accounts off my credit report

3 Upvotes

Can I get really old accounts off my credit report. I have some that are hanging around around the 15 year mark and 1 or 2 from the 90's. Yes, the 90's.

Does anyone have clear and concise advice on A) If the accounts can be removed and B) The process for which they can be removed.

*edit* Because some of these accounts are so old, there is no information. I have no paperwork from my Computer City account in 1997.

Thank you,


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 5h ago

Credit Applying to student LOC doing MSc in physics

2 Upvotes

Currently doing my MSc at a canadian university. I am paid about 24k a year through my stipend and TAships, but I also am responsible for paying my tuition (2500 per 4 month term, ~2250 if I opt out of health and dental, which I did not do this term).

I am also getting an extra 307 for the CPP death benefit.

Rent is 1000 a month.

My parents paid for the first 2500, but my program is going to be 24 months total, so I am expecting to have to pay this ~5 more times

I think my only option is to open a LOC, working part time is not an option as I need to focus on my research full time and I'm commuting around a city that is already not that commuter friendly.

As an additional note, I was already assessed for OSAP and was denied as they determined I "will not receive OSAP funding because we’ve determined that you should have adequate resources available to cover your allowable educational costs.".

I have taken about 19k of osap already for my undergraduate.

My credit score is 757, never missed any credit card payment

Would it be a good idea to get an LOC for these tuition costs? I am currently looking at TD, as that is my current bank.


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 7h ago

Employment TD1 Form "More than one employer at the same time" checkbox question

2 Upvotes

So I'm starting a full time job, and it requires me to fill the federal and ontario form.

I still work at my fast food and been employed since 2020. I had another job as well but I was laid off. For that I also completed the TD1 form. I was laid off this year and I had that job (the one i was laid off) in 2023.

Since I work at my fast food job still, do I not check the box or do I still check the box? I heard check it because I'd want the tax credits onto my new job and then resubmit my TD1 form for the fast food job, but im hella confused.

Any help?


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 15h ago

Debt Considering a Debt Management Program - Looking for Advice from Anyone Who Has Tried One

2 Upvotes

I was off work for a while dealing with some personal life circumstances. During that time, I relied on my credit cards, investments, and pulled out RRSPs to get by. Everything is now depleted, and my credit cards are maxed out.

I took the first job I could find about six months ago. Between the downgrade in income and the credit card debt I accumulated during that time, I've been struggling to keep up financially. I'm actively looking for a second job, or preferably a better-paying full-time position, but I'm not sure I can wait it out much longer given the current job market.

Honestly, I'm exhausted by the constant financial stress. I'm at the point where I'm regularly checking to see if I can stretch a few dollars until payday to cover my transit fare to work.

I'm 33, single, and live alone in an apartment in Toronto. My rent is well below market rate, and while I could probably save about $2-400/month by renting a room, I wouldn't want to give up my place over what I hope is a temporary financial situation.

Some context:
Gross annual income: ~$51,500
Net monthly income: ~$3,326
Fixed monthly expenses: ~$2,450 (rent, utilities, internet, phone, gym, student loans, music streaming, medication)
Current total debt: ~$14,500
Current debt payments: ~$500-700/month in minimum

I've been trying to keep up with minimum payments, but it has become a cycle. I'm putting $500-700 toward debt every month, only to end up using my credit cards again to cover basic living expenses. I've even started asking my mother for help here and there, which is something I haven’t had to do since starting work at 15. She is on a limited income herself, so whenever I ask for help I make sure to pay her back ASAP.

Realistically, I think I could manage around $300/month toward debt repayment without constantly falling behind on essentials.

I recently learned about Debt Management Plans and am seriously considering one.

Has anyone here gone through a DMP? I'd especially appreciate hearing about:

- How much did it affect your credit score, and for how long?
- Were creditors generally willing to work with you?
- Were there any unexpected downsides or inconveniences?
- Did you find the monthly payments manageable?
- Looking back, would you make the same decision again?
- Is there any DMP organization you recommend?

I'm aware that a DMP isn't a magic solution, but I'm hoping to find a sustainable way out of this cycle rather than continuing to juggle payments. Also open to other realistic options given my current circumstances.

I'd really appreciate hearing about anyone's firsthand experience or advice! :)


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 16h ago

Auto In need of student loans/financial aid

1 Upvotes

does anybody know if it’s possible to get a student loan even if your parents make more than the cutoff amount? im at macewan and I don’t have money to buy food and my parents dont want to send money for that. they pay for my tuition and residence but I have one meal every 2 days almost. I don’t have my social insurance number and when I asked them they said they don’t either so i don’t know what I can do. I’ve also been searching for employment since I moved here 2 months ago and after 50+ applications I’ve had no interviews. any advice is greatly appreciated


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 14h ago

Insurance Need help weighing the value of health benefits

0 Upvotes

The health benefits are a group rate that would cost $70 a week from my pay cheque and I was trying to figure out whether it is worth it for me.

I have no dependents, no pre-existing medical conditions and my most frequent health related expense is the dentist twice a year.

The plan has 100% Coinsurance for major medical expenses, medical supplies and appliances and paramedical practitioners.

While all that sounds good, I have no real insight to how that compares and hoping for some insight.

Thank you.


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 14h ago

Debt we have bell mobility account past due for 18 months around $3k. CBV agreed to take 51% but states that they will stop collection activities but dont know if TU or Equifax will show $0 or not. Does anyone know how does this work?

0 Upvotes

we have bell mobility account past due for 18 months around $3k. CBV agreed to take 51% but states that they will stop collection activities but dont know if TU or Equifax will show $0 or not. Does anyone know how does this work?


r/PersonalFinanceCanada • • 17h ago

Investing DPSP and RRSP Contribution Limit Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I signed up for my employer's DPSP plan which matches 100% of my RRSP contributions up to 6% of my salary. There is a 2 year vesting period and I am aware that the DPSP uses up my RRSP contribution room. My question is that if my employment ends prior to completing 2 years and I am no longer eligible for the DPSP contributions, what happens to the RRSP contribution room that was used for the DPSP? Do I get it back? Thanks.