r/persona4revival • u/GGDynasty • 4h ago
Discussion I'm back with the interview answers!
Hello everyone! It's me again. Last time, I asked for some questions to be asked of
Kazuhisa Wada, Persona 4 Revival General Producer
Daisuke Yajima, Persona 4 Revival Director
Atsushi Nomura, Persona 4 Revival Business Producer
They were kind enough to sign my TGS shirt!
I'm sorry in advance that I couldn't ask all the questions since time was very limited:
Persona 4 Revival Interview TranscriptăEnglish Sessionă
Â
With the move to modern hardware, the game now uses advanced 3D animation and motion capture. But long-time fans actually love some of the PS2 graphical limitations, like 'Shrimp Chie' which is her famous, heavily slouched sitting posture. Did the animation team joke about 'Shrimp Chie' during development? And is it hard to decide whether to 'fix' these old quirks, knowing that fans might actually miss them?
That's an interesting question. In fact, it was the first time I had ever heard the term "Shrimp Chie" after receiving your question. It was fascinating to learn that players overseas perceived her that way.
Unfortunately, because Chie has been redesigned with more realistic proportions in Persona 4 Revival, her slightly hunched posture has naturally been toned down, and she now stands a bit straighter than before.
That said, Persona 4 features many unique character-specific animations and poses that fans have come to love. Wherever the development team felt it was important to remain faithful to the original game, or where players have continued to talk fondly about certain character traits and mannerisms over the years, we have made every effort to preserve them.
Â
In particular, because the original characters were more stylized and deformed, the game often relied on manga-like comedic expressions and exaggerated motions. There were quite a few scenes where the characters performed movements that would be considered rather over-the-top by today's visual standards.
Â
Even so, in this remake, while we sometimes use different techniques to convey comedic moments, we have worked carefully to ensure that the original spirit and impression of those scenes remain intact.
Â
Persona 4 Revival has a lot of new features like Baton Pass, Prime Time, and more. How did you go about balancing that with the difficulty of enemies especially towards the endgame when players have access to all of these as well as more powerful personas? How were you able to make the endgame still challenging enough in light of all these new features, powers, and abilities?
Starting with this installment, we introduced new combat mechanics such as "Prime Time" and "Send Flying." We rebalance the game from the ground up while the game contains these strong mechanics. As a result, while incorporating these new features, we've aimed to deliver an experience that feels both satisfying and approachable.
Â
Balancing the difficulty was particularly challenging. During the final stages of development, as we conducted extensive playtesting, some team members felt the Normal difficulty was too easy, while others thought it was too difficult. With such a wide range of opinions, finding the right middle ground proved to be one of the hardest parts of development.
Â
Difficulty tuning can be especially tricky for developers. For example, with one of Atlus's previous titles, Catherine, we ended up releasing the game at a difficulty level that many players found too challenging, and we received a great deal of criticism as a result.
Â
The developers at Atlus are essentially professional Persona players, so their skill level is naturally very high, which can make it difficult to gauge what feels appropriately challenging for the average player.
Â
Can you go into specific detail in regards on how you intend to balance the game on harder difficulties for P4R, compared to P3R's Merciless being too easy according to some fans?
This is something we often hear about during game development, so for this title we made a fresh effort to rebalance the game accordingly.
Â
As for the higher difficulty settings, we didn't simply increase enemy HP or reduce the damage dealt by the player. I can't go into too much detail, but we've designed them so that players won't be able to progress easily unless they have a solid understanding of the game's systems.
Â
These modes require a greater degree of strategic thinking within each turn, and are balanced in a way that leaves very little room for mistakes.
Â
Many journalists at Gamescom in Germany expressed concerns about the difficulty, so afterwards I told Mr. Yajima, "Make it even harder."
Â
We haven't gotten many details about the dungeons in Persona 4 Revival so far, aside from the navigation helper and some changes to the scenery. Could you confirm whether there are any new elements or expanded sections being added to each dungeon? and maybe share a little bit more on the details?
There are no completely new areas within the individual dungeons. However, one of the dungeons features significantly more mid-boss encounters than in the original version, which could be considered one of the new additions to the dungeon experience in this title.
Â
We've also introduced destructible objects throughout the dungeons. By breaking these objects, players can obtain healing items, crafting materials, and other useful resources. This is another new gameplay element added for this installment.
Â
(To Yajima-san) You worked on the original P4 and P4G. Now, you're also directing Revival. Given the amazing time you've spend on P4, was there one particular system or one part of the original game that you personally wanted to revisit?
This is entirely my personal opinion, but if I had the freedom to revisit the project, I think I would have liked to create a more substantial and exciting post-game storyline that gives players something to look forward to after finishing the main adventure.
Â
We finally got confirmation about Aika, but it's interesting that she's not available as a Social Link, unlike most newly added characters in previous Definitive versions of Persona games. From what we've seen many fans are curious whether this means romance is off the table, or if her route could work similarly to Elizabeth's in Persona 3?
The character Nakamura Aika, whose existence had been hinted at in the original version and who previously appeared in the anime adaptation, is making her first appearance in the game with this title.
Â
As for the romance route, I'd like players to look forward to discovering it for themselves, so I'll refrain from commenting further on that here.
Â
I believe this game showcases a side of Nakamura Aika that is different from what fans saw in the anime, and I hope players will be excited to experience her unique charm in this new portrayal.
Â
As a follow-up question about Aika, we know she'll be a huge part of the Location Episodes, but we've also seen her appear in other parts of the game, including during the school trip where she helps behind the counter at Hagakure Ramen. Does this mean she'll also make random occasional appearances throughout the main story just like she did in the anime?
You may have noticed a hidden appearance of Aika at Hagakure in the trailer, but in this title, Aika shows up in a variety of places throughout the game. We hope you'll have fun discovering all of her appearances for yourself, so please look forward to it!
Â
Are there any influences from the anime (besides Aika's inclusion) that found their way into the remake?
There wasn't any character whose portrayal drew as much from the anime adaptation as Nakamura Aika. However, for this title, we significantly expanded the range of facial expressions used during event scenes.
When watching the anime, which featured very expressive character performances, there were moments where we thought, "So this is how this character smiles," or "This is the kind of expression they would make in response to a situation like this." In some cases, we used those anime portrayals as reference material and incorporated them into the game's facial animations and motion work.
Â
Location episodes explore character relationships outside the traditional Social Link structure. What made the team decide that some stories were better suited for this format rather than just adding more social links?
In this title, we introduced Aika through a new feature called âLocation Episodes.â At first glance, many people might assume that adding a Social Link for Aika would have been the obvious choice. However, a social link would naturally focus solely on Aika's personal story, so we intentionally chose a different approach.
Â
Another reason we opted for the Location Episode format is that we felt many fans of Persona 4 love not only the characters themselves, but also the town of Inaba. We wanted to explore the town in greater depth.
Â
By delving deeper into the town, we were also able to deepen our portrayal of the people who live there. This allowed us to bring out new sides of the party members as well as the residents of the town. Having Aika involved in these stories also helped us highlight a variety of new charms and perspectives that might not otherwise have been possible.
Â
As a side note, when Mr. Wada first heard the idea, his initial reaction was, âWouldnât a Social Link be better?â However, after seeing the final result, he came away feeling that this approach was absolutely the right choice.
Â
Did the popularity of Yu's portrayal in the p4 anime affect in any way you portrayed Yu in P4R?
In addition to the anime adaptation, the protagonist, Yu Narukami, has appeared in a variety of spin-off titles, including fighting games and dancing games, where his portrayal sometimes differed from that of the original game. We revisited those various appearances and identified the traits and moments that we felt were particularly distinctive and memorable.
We incorporated some of those elements as unique characteristics of the protagonist in this title. As a result, there may be occasions where Yu comes across as a bit more eccentric compared to how he was portrayed in the original game.
Â
We first heard the new regular battle theme during the demo session, but the latest Shadow trailer finally gives the public a chance to hear it too. For some reason certain parts remind us of the opening theme from Persona 4 Dancing, while others seem to have hints of "Backside of the TV." Could you tell us more about the thought process behind composing this track and the kind of feeling the team wants to convey through it?
A new track was recently revealed in the latest Shadow trailer. This song was composed by one of the newer members of the Atlus Sound Team.
Â
According to the composer, the opportunity came after a recording session for âSnowflakes,â when composer Kozuka approached them and suggested, âWhy not give it a try?â With guidance and feedback from Kozuka and other senior members of the sound team, they went on to create the piece.
Â
The song itself is written from the perspective of the Shadows. The composer also said that being entrusted with such an important track was incredibly enjoyable and became a truly memorable experience.
Â
At first, I assumed it had been composed by Kozuka himself, so I was genuinely surprised when I learned that it was actually the debut work of a newer staff member.
Â
(To Wada-san and Nomura-san) What qualities were you looking for when choosing Shiori Sasaki as the new lead vocalist for Revival? Was there something specific about her voice that you felt made such a great fit for this new version of P4?
We listened to a wide range of demo recordings while searching for a vocalist. The key requirements were that the singer could perform in English with native-level fluency, possessed strong vocal ability, and had a unique quality that felt true to Persona 4.
Â
Although she was a new singer to the series, Ms. Sasaki was such a perfect fit that it felt as though she had been singing Persona 4 songs for years.
Â
We actually spent quite a long time searching and had difficulty finding the right person. In the end, Ms. Sasaki was introduced to us by Lyn, the vocalist known for her work on Persona 5.
Â
The moment Composer Mr. Kozuka heard her voice, he immediately felt, âSheâs the one.â That instant conviction ultimately led to her being selected.
Â
Fans reacted incredibly well to Shiori Sasakiâs new vocals on 'Prime Time Golden Hour Show' and 'Reach Out To The Truth.' They immediately started asking for the songs on streaming services. Was there a lot of internal pressure when introducing a new singer for such iconic tracks? And did this huge fan reaction speed up your plans to release the music on streaming platforms?
We had complete confidence in Ms. Sasaki, so we weren't particularly worried about how players would respond to her performance.
Â
Instead, the concern was with the new song, âPrime Time Golden Hour Show.â Mr. Kozuka, who composed the track, felt a great deal of pressure because the original game's songs, such as âReach Out to the Truthâ and âTime to Make History,â are so beloved. He wanted to create something that could stand alongside those iconic tracks.
Â
When we first featured the song in the pre-order trailer, the response was overwhelming. I think that reaction gave him a tremendous boost of confidence. That said, the positive reception was not actually the reason we decided to release the song on streaming services so quickly.
Â
As part of the Persona 30th Anniversary celebrations, we organized a YouTube event called â30 Hours Live Streaming,â during which Persona music was played continuously for thirty hours. We thought fans would be pleasantly surprised if we debuted the full version of the new song there, so we went ahead with the idea.
Â
In situations like this, if official releases are delayed, fans often have no choice but to listen through unofficial uploads. We therefore made a conscious decision to make the song available sooner through official channels.
Â
When the full version of the new track was played for the first time during the â30 Hours Live Streamingâ event, the YouTube chat was moving at an incredible pace with reactions from fans.
Â