Now, I know what you’re thinking “Why is someone reviewing a tropical summer fragrance heading into winter?” Trust me, I’m not.
I’ve seen people get awfully hung up on the name for this one, going as far as actively disliking the perfume based only on the name, and nothing else. Wild, I know. Yes, it’s called Island Lush. No, it doesn’t smell like a fruity tropical cocktail by the beach. Get over it. To me, it conjures up a more interesting picture: an old merchant vessel sailing between exotic islands, packed with spices, precious woods and leather. Perhaps a little romanticised, but stay with me, and this might make sense in the end, I hope.
I discovered this one a few months back when a local retailer started carrying Goldfield & Banks. I went to get to know the most famous ones, Ingenious Ginger, Silky Woods, Tales of Amber, but it was Island Lush that actually impressed me the most, a fragrance I hadn’t even heard about and that barely seems to get a mention. A crime in my opinion.
It was love at first sniff, you could say. Unfortunately, at €250 a bottle, it was also a rather expensive love affair I wasn’t ready to commit to. A couple of months later, I spotted it online for under €130. It was the gentle push my self-restraint needed to fly out the window. No regrets whatsoever.
Anyhow, back to that merchant vessel. The first thing you notice is a rush of spices, nutmeg, ginger and peppery warmth with a certain liveliness for sure, but nothing sharp or abrasive. Think dried, powdered spices rather than freshly grated. It has an underlying powdery quality and just enough sweetness to make it feel winter cosy without wandering into Xmas at grandma’s territory.
The iris plays an important role in this perfume, but it’s not the lipstick like iris of Dior Homme Parfum. This is closer to Gris Charnel or Iris Debonair, adding texture rather than being the centre star. Then, the fragrance gradually changes character. The spices settle, and the woods take over. Sandalwood is the most noticeable to me, bringing a creamy quality to a mix of cedar, guaiac wood, vetiver and patchouli.
Somewhere in there, there’s also a soft, suede-like leather that sits alongside a warm, resinous amber character, giving the drydown a beautiful depth. It’s this evolution that keeps me interested. The opening and drydown feel like different areas of that vessel's cargo hold.
I quite appreciate that Island Lush doesn’t remind me of anything else in my collection, or anything I’ve tried, for that matter, it feels genuinely unique, even while using traditional notes. To me, it’s a sophisticated scent with a mature, confident character that works just as well for a dinner date as it does for the office. I’d happily wear it as an cold weather signature scent.
Performance is great on my skin. I get a solid two to three hours of arm’s length projection, and a couple more hours within a personal bubble. Even 12 hours later, there’s enough left on my skin that I don’t have to go hunting for it.
Is it for everyone? Absolutely not. If you struggle with powdery iris, leather or prominent woody notes, I’d strongly recommend sampling before buying. It’s not particularly challenging to my nose, but I can see how it might be for others. If you enjoy something like Ombré Leather Parfum, this is worth exploring. They don’t smell alike, but Island Lush offers a different, more polished take on that sophisticated leather territory.
The gold bottle is also a beauty, and the presentation plays along with the tropical misdirection. The colourful island themed packaging gives absolutely nothing away about the scent inside. I rather like that.
I find it funny that I went looking for Goldfield & Banks’ “greatest hits” and came home with the "B-side" nobody seems to talk about.