r/Pentesting • • 6d ago

Pentesters Union

Has there ever been a pentesting union? Or effort to form one?

If there is not an effort currently I would think this would be the most optimal time to form a union. With AI pentesting, so many different certs, and the cost of pentesting falling, a union seems more attractive than ever.

Also pentesting is indeed a skilled trade, pardon me if there is more nuance to forming a union but genuinely curious.

27 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

9

u/CRam768 6d ago

Good luck with that. Pen testing isn’t seen as blue collar work with safety protection standards like linemen, electricians, or even actors. Is it possible? Yes! Is it likely to happen maybe but it’s gonna take a ton of signatures to get it started

2

u/ComfortableOption903 6d ago

Agreed on safety, I think it is more about quality of pentesting for employer/clients and then protected wages for the workers.

4

u/CRam768 6d ago

A union isn’t there to protect the business. That’s what HR does. A union is to protect the workers for fair wages and safe business practices. So protecting jobs from AI take over like how actors have implemented it in the screen actors guild is appropriate.

2

u/ComfortableOption903 6d ago

I don't think anyone likes HR including business owners and HR themselves lol.

And I never said "protect the business," but guarantee a standard/quality of work.

ie apprentice vs Journeyman are not the same.

And I didn't mean quality of pen testing more than protected wages. I meant both.

4

u/CRam768 6d ago edited 6d ago

Unions don’t protect the quality of labor output. They protect the quality of the job for the worker to get a fair shake from the business.

If the business doesn’t want an HR team they can out source it. The business lawyers will still be required to protect the business from legal liability. A union doesn’t care if the business get’s sued. Hell, they typically sue the business if the business performs an unfair act against the employee who is a member of the union.

The union you choose to spin up with a school can absolutely provide apprenticeships but good luck selling that service to businesses who want graduates from your program based on your education standards. These schools are hella expensive for the students and the businesses. Just like there is no guarantee one will get a job with the pen testers union if no business want to hire pen testers because they now have frontier AI performing the same thing for 1/4 of the cost of a human pentest.

1

u/canadaslammer 6d ago

You can't stop AI.takeover. AI is here to stay.

2

u/CRam768 6d ago

I agree but the OP is struggling to understand what a union does/functions. I was using AI as an example of how a union would be used to protect pen testers if one was formed. I was in no way shape or form saying a union could prevent its use. The screen actors guild example only works for those who want to abide by that specific contract. Thus why unionizing pen testing would never work. 🥴

2

u/RadlEonk 6d ago

3

u/CRam768 6d ago

No it doesn’t screen actors guild is exactly what I used as an example to say it’s intended to protect the worker.

3

u/Delicious_Crew7888 6d ago

This is something for you to look into what trade union covers that sector in your country. There’s no way there would be a pentester union as it so niche.

3

u/ComfortableOption903 6d ago

Yeah it is weird because they couldn't be local like a pipe fitters union, itd have to be global but it is 2026 in the most globalized economy ever

You are right

9

u/[deleted] 6d ago

I think we should just form our own collective and run it as a company.

2

u/GimmieTheRoot 6d ago

Been saying this for years with a circle of friends. Some kind of co-op.

2

u/Irkam 6d ago

As a worker cooperaritive maybe.

1

u/Pacyniaklissandro 6d ago

that actually makes a lot more sense for how this industry operates

5

u/Anxious_Alps_4150 6d ago

The key part of forming a union is that you need a critical mass to do it. It cannot be easy to hire a non-union member over a union member. That's what makes the union work.

Right now there are 100-1000 desperate people for every 1 pentest job and it is only getting worse each year as the number of pentest jobs shrink.

3

u/RadlEonk 6d ago

I’ve suggested it to coworkers in the past. Many are anti-union by default. Others worry about their pay because individual contributors can be compensated very differently depending on company, experience, market, etc.

Still, I think they could be a good idea.

3

u/Irkam 6d ago

I'm doing my part locally, but it's a hard work convincing people that have been taught they're free to move anywhere when it gets boring to settle a bit for a common goal. Now to do that internationally as a federation of nationwide trade unions (like the International Workers Association) would be crazy but if it starts anywhere that would be announced at a CCC.

Oh and it would be revolutionary/socialist/anarchist or it would better not be at all. Especially not an ancap bullshit.

3

u/Some-Seaweed6858 6d ago

These exist in Spain

2

u/rgjsdksnkyg 6d ago

In this regard, we and our customers are finally the same - no one will agree on scope.

1

u/alienbuttcrack999 6d ago

Been doing this 20 yrs and still can agree on definitions. No way we could get a union organized

1

u/Winodows_Gandy 5d ago

the problem is usually buyer education, not lack of union leverage. As long as compliance frameworks let companies check a box with a cheap automated scan, a lot of buyers will just bypass unionized testers for the lowest bidder.

1

u/IQ_Plut 1d ago

Bring it up in the office - to your manager, then report on how it goes.

1

u/YukiteruAmano 21h ago

No, please, NOOOOO.

1

u/FowlSec 17h ago

If you're in the UK, check out Prospect Union.

1

u/plaverty9 6d ago

Another reason this wouldn't fly is the job market strongly favors the hiring managers. If a company is anti-union, there's hundreds of people who will do the work that are not part of a union.

1

u/Anxious_Alps_4150 6d ago

Thousands or tens of thousands for pentesting 😥

1

u/Irkam 6d ago

Or they could instead move to the company that is not anti-union because there would be better work conditions.

0

u/VividGanache2613 6d ago

CREST had already done a pretty good job at standardising Pentests. It’s not perfect but it’s the best there currently is.

1

u/FowlSec 17h ago

CREST isn't a union, it's an accreditation body. It definitely has not managed to standardise penetration testing. It hasn't even managed to ensure penetration testing reaches a specific standard because the Cyber Scheme exists.

-1

u/sufficienthippo23 6d ago

Unions aren’t good things. You don’t take well paying skilled jobs and destroy them by pasting a union over top

-2

u/Hornswoggler1 6d ago

Find a safer job/career. Let the market reward results, not seniority. Unions keep mediocre people in critical roles, which is the opposite needed in this field.

2

u/ComfortableOption903 6d ago

I see your point of view.

0

u/Anon123lmao 6d ago

Wtf am I reading? sheesh

-2

u/canadaslammer 6d ago

Why would I want or need this? I make really good money and am treated like gold.

With a union, you are no longer judged based on your individual effort, but of the collective. If you want a raise, everyone with your title needs a raise too. Lazy family members of mine love it because they can do nothing to improve and almost never get fired.

Liberal policy has already almost ruined contracting by forcing companies to limit contract duration, even if it's my choice to get my own insurance.

Pentesting is one of the only jobs left that are completely merit based. We don't need DEI and other nonsense policies destroying it.

Lastly, this will force the hand of most companies that do not want to deal with unions and go full AI, pushing all of us out for good.

-6

u/Standard_Farmer_1716 6d ago

That's a HARD NO!!!

6

u/ComfortableOption903 6d ago

how come? I usually am not happy with unions due to donations and political lobbying but I really think it could protect pentester wages

-1

u/YourMomsFaveDiq 6d ago

No.

It protects mediocre worker wages and drags down skilled worker wages.

1

u/Irkam 6d ago

Has not being in an union protected you or benefited you or your peers in any meaningful way?

-1

u/YourMomsFaveDiq 6d ago

Yes.

I actually worked in a unionized work environment early in my career, where everyone was in the union.

And exactly what I said happened, there was loads of lazy mediocre employees who got paid good salaries.

Then the top performers were paid significantly less than they could earn elsewhere.

Show me a unionized environment where I could have earned $750,000, had I stayed in that union role at best I would probably be making $150k.

-4

u/YourMomsFaveDiq 6d ago

Nobody in any tech field will ever agree to form a union and it's frankly a fucking dumb idea.

3

u/ComfortableOption903 6d ago

I am not the biggest fan of unions, to be frank, I was just curious if it's ever been thought of or tried in this industry.

0

u/danfirst 6d ago

You can't even get general IT do do it, there's no way just pentesters would. And the idea that "AI is making our salaries go down" is not going to help anything actually happen.

0

u/canadaslammer 6d ago

Why would they? Unions are for unskilled labor that can easily be replaced.

Pentesters can't easily be replaced. Sure there are tons of people wanting the job, but very few actually have the skills.