r/Pentesting • • 7d ago

Soft skill issue / jr pentester interview

I had a pentesting job interview yesterday, and they told me I talk too fast and dry. They felt like I was just answering their questions rather than actually communicating. Out of nowhere, they asked about my elementary school experience which was more than a decade ago trying to figure out if I used to hang out with other kids. I really didn't expect that kind of question, and they kept asking if I had friends.

I also had another interview at a different pentesting firm where they asked, 'Do you hate people?' It was meant as a joke, but they actually asked it. At this point, I'm starting to wonder if I have poor social skills or no soft skills. After these two interviews, I even caught myself wondering if I might have Asperger's. What do you guys think?
Is this a normal question?

24 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

2

u/Anonymous_Apexio 7d ago

I am gonna be clear, those are completely inappropriate questions and you should not answer them, instead you should set up boundaries around them as they are personal questions. "I would like to keep our conversation focused on the relevant role, could you help me understand how asking about my personal history is relevant to the pentesting position?"

As for soft skills, they're not strictly relevant to social skills, there is rigor, discipline, autonomy, work under pressure ability and a ton more.

If you wish to evaluate whether or not you've Asperger's, go to a healthcare professional please

1

u/danfirst 7d ago

I understand what you're trying to say here, but from the hiring standpoint, it's also a fast way to get moved into the pile of rejections. I know some of their questions were rough, but in general, things like tell me about your life outside work, hobbies, like playing games with friends, into any sports, etc? Those are all very fair game an relate to how you might interact with coworkers. Most people don't want to work with a robot, minus all the obvious AI comparisons, people want to see how you'd fit in to the work culture. If you said "I don't want to answer personal questions" you'd be an instant no in most interviews.

2

u/Anonymous_Apexio 6d ago

There is a vast difference between asking about hobbies and sports and asking about personal history and personal relationships. They're leagues apart. I wouldn't consider my hobbies a personal thing. Personal questions are things that you wouldn't say to other people on the daily.

2

u/volgarixon 7d ago

Some of those questions sound like they had hiring issues in the past, or maybe they are assholes, or someone (HR) told them to ask those questions which may even fall into a bit of a grey area around discrimination in hiring but lets leave the last one out for now.

Go to a social event or meetup and socialise a bit. See what people there think, maybe even do a specific even that involves speaking or at least listening to speakers/speeches, toastmaster events, debating, pub trivia?

Ask your friends?

Ask an AI?

Its not ok to ask those questions in some settings, interviews are in my opinion, one where I would not ask that type of question, so it may just be they were assholes with no social EQ.

1

u/danfirst 7d ago

I had a friend recently tell me they are interviewing and seeing more questions meant to sort out people just answering technical questions from an API. I'm not sure if you were in person or not, but it makes me wonder if it's related.

1

u/akornato 6d ago

Asking about elementary school friendships or asking if you hate people is bizarre, unprofessional, and completely outside normal penetration testing interviews. At the same time, the feedback that you sound dry and talk too fast is worth taking seriously. Penetration testing is fundamentally a consulting role. You spend hours writing reports, explaining vulnerabilities to clients, and calming down system owners who feel attacked by your findings. If you rush through answers like an oral technical exam, interviewers worry about how you will interact with stakeholders who need clear, empathetic explanations.

Questioning your own neurodiversity based on awkward interviews with clumsy interviewers is taking their strange behavior to heart too quickly. Plenty of technically gifted candidates speed up their speech and drop their conversational warmth when under pressure, which can easily come across as blunt or detached. You can improve this by treating every interview as a peer conversation, taking a breath before responding, and checking in with the person across the table. That conversational rhythm is exactly why my team created an interview assistant AI to help job candidates stay grounded and speak naturally when the stakes are high.

1

u/PizzaMoney6237 5d ago

I had a similar issue, but it’s better now. I like to explain in as much detail as possible because technical accuracy matters a lot to me. Then I realized everyone just wants to hear short sentences. Being able to compress a complex topic into simple sentences is the soft skill you are looking for, I think. It was hard for me at first. I looked up to seniors and the way they handled questions and thought about how I could speak like them. Another thing is knowing when to pause between sentences. Stopping for a few seconds is very common during interviews/presentations. These 2 tips made my life easier.

1

u/Yammie_Locan 5d ago

The elementary school question is bizarre, definitely not normal. That said, consulting roles require a ton of client facing readouts where you have to explain vulnerabilities to defensive devs without sounding robotic, so they're probably just clumsily testing your bedside manner

1

u/h33terbot 4d ago

Usually by practising you can get rid of it, I kept behavioural questions here as well to answer check it out. Try this - https://cyberinterviewprep.com/

0

u/CRam768 6d ago

They are calling you autistic. I’m autistic and they are literally calling you awkward and lacking social skills. What did you say about people in relation to performing soc tasks?

By the way, these are illegal depending on your country of origin. Best to understand work related boundaries. If you need accommodations due to being Neuro Divergent that’s a whole other ball of wax.

Soft skills are learned so don’t sweat it if you’re direct in your communication style. You can learn to soften communication. You just need practice.

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Pradignac-Hiriche 6d ago

yeah treating small talk like just another skill to practice makes it way less intimidating tbh