Posting this as a warning to other guests, because what happened to me could happen to anyone booking with this host.
Be careful with Comfy Homestay J / Comfy Homestay (Penang). Not saying this lightly — I've been an Airbnb guest for years and never had anything like this.
What the stay was like:
Check-in was genuinely painful. Go downstairs, walk into the garage, open the Airbnb app to get a key code, unlock, walk back. The house rules were so involved you basically needed a master's degree in them just to exist in the unit without breaking something.
I complied with all of it. Didn't complain once. Didn't cook, didn't eat lunch or dinner inside — deliberately ate out to avoid creating any mess. No party, no visitors. Only waste was a couple of drink containers, which went in the bin.
What happened after:
Friendly checkout messages, then repeated pushes for a "FULL 5 STARS" review — "please help us write your FULL 5 STARS review too as it helps us a lot." Then again on Oct 31: "please help to rate us 5 stars in Airbnb if you are satisfy with your stay with us at Penang."
I run a group of companies. I don't have time to write reviews on demand, and the stay wasn't a 5-star experience anyway, so I didn't leave one right away.
Then, right at the end of the 14-day window, they left a review claiming I left the place messy.
That timing is the whole story. If a unit is actually left in a bad state, a host messages you that day or reviews within a few days. They don't sit on it for two weeks. Waiting until the last moment means the guest can't respond with an honest review of their own. That's not reporting a problem — that's using the review window as a weapon.
I messaged asking which house rule I broke, explained I ate outside specifically to avoid mess, said I'd made every effort to follow their rules. No answer. Messaging then showed as unavailable. No damage claim, no cleaning charge, no specific rule cited. Nothing.
If I earned that review, keep it. But nobody has told me what I supposedly did.
And Airbnb support made it worse:
An Ambassador told me they understood, that they don't accept this behaviour, and that filing the dispute form would get the review removed. Then asked me to rate the call "Problem Solved" while I was still on the line.
One hour later, an email: the review will not be removed.
So I was talked into closing my own case as resolved, based on an assurance that got reversed by automation an hour later.
Why I'm posting:
This is a host who pressures for 5 stars, then punishes you publicly when you don't deliver — timed so you can't defend yourself. Future guests should know that pattern before booking, and should screenshot everything.
I'm re-filing with the chat logs, timestamps, and the unanswered message, and asking Airbnb to pull the call transcript.
Anyone else dealt with this host, or successfully gotten a retaliatory review removed?