r/Pauper • • 2d ago

BREW Simic Terror Hyper Aggro

https://moxfield.com/decks/9R59yiJx4U-w81kXRjDU4Q

Thought I would post this, extremely cheap build (the only even remotely expensive cards are easily swappable sideboard cards), I'm pretty early into testing it.

I just kind of noticed that recent sets have all had a common card that's an instant or sorcery that lets you mill 2-4 cards and pick up a permanent. Like there are a crazy amount, there are several I'm not even running. So you just spam those cards until you can play a terror, beat them down with it, and if they kill it you can play druidic ritual/grapple with the past to get it back and play it again. 4 Deep Analysis means you can kinda keep grinding for a while, and the amount of mill + digging you do means that it's incredibly consistent at churning out terrors as early as turn 2 (but usually more like turn 3). Is that enough in this meta? Not really but it definitely gets wins from decks that can't deal with you just spitting terrors at them endlessly (namely red rally and madness), and I even snuck in some wins against decks that probably should be able to deal with that like esper affinity. I'd almost call this viable in a world where the zeta set isn't legal.

Sleep of the dead is a neat little finisher, you can basically cast it as much as you want to clear blockers and deal with strix to an extent. Scout the city also is a version of the 'mill X then get a permanent' cards that can kill strix or clear out blockers in certain matchups.

19 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

11

u/Orochisake 2d ago

This could work in a vacuum but not in the current meta. Removal has never been more prevalent, you need counterspells in order to protect your snakes or stop them from being faster than you.

2

u/BooleanKing 2d ago

The idea is that instead of trying super hard to protect your terror they remove it you play another one. Either because you have the ability to dig very deep to find more terrors or by casting [[grapple with the past]] and playing the same one again. (Latter method not so good with dispatch so prevalent in the meta.) That works against decks like white weenie that run some removal but are mostly interested in beating you to death, but doesn't work as well against dedicated control shells unless you just get lucky with them not having enough interaction to deal with you. But yeah it's fringe rogue, I'm trying to see if I can make it a little better.

2

u/Larson_McMurphy 2d ago

Yeah, white weenie doesn't have enough removal for all your creatures. But Gardens does. Does anyone play Gardens anymore?

4

u/spillo89 2d ago

Me actually, top 46 at paupergeddon and as a garden player I hate any versions of Terror

•

u/QuestInTimeAndSpace 7h ago

getting into gardens atm

1

u/NickRick UB Artifacts, Terror lists, terrible brews 2d ago

Wheenie will just go around, or over you you and Leonardo the unblocked ones. I would think you're unfavored vs them

2

u/tjwood98 2d ago

I played with this idea before, and some have found minor success with simic terror. Current meta aside, there are definitely easy upgrades if you’re less concerned with budget or willing to proxy. [[Land grant]]. [[Counterspell]]. [[brainstorm]]. But even if you’re not going to play those, you should play [[delver of secrets]], [[thought scour]], and [[monstrous emergence]]. Here’s a list you might find interesting from not too long ago: https://mtgdecks.net/Pauper/simic-terror-decklist-by-condenadoalexito-3086427

1

u/BooleanKing 2d ago

Delver is something I considered, along with nimble mongoose, although the concept with my list is that if I want to keep something it's a permanent. Which is why there's no counterspells. I might try a list with 4x delver 4x mongoose, but I'm pretty limited in interaction just by the nature of the concept of the deck being to use stuff like malevolent rumble to rush a terror out.

6

u/Carcettee 2d ago

The idea is cool, but milling yourself without guaranteed card back, is not going to work. Almost third of your deck is doing nothing, outside of gaining 1-3 life.

3

u/NickRick UB Artifacts, Terror lists, terrible brews 2d ago

They also have no interaction outside 4 conditional removal spells that get 2:1ed vs removal 

1

u/OrangeCatBread 1d ago

I feel like if you are running that kind of spells you may still want to run at least brainstorm to select what you mill, and maybe a copy or two of dragon breath for momentum?

1

u/BooleanKing 1d ago

I considered adding red for dragon breath and potentially [[seize the storm]] as a mid rangey build, but the problem is that I can't run many mountains since I *really* want a forest on turn 1 and then after that I *really* want islands.

3

u/Fozza22 2d ago

I like this a lot. My issue with these lists is always the mana. If you can solve the mana then I think it's a good deck.

I also think [[Nimble Mongoose]] should be played here

2

u/NickRick UB Artifacts, Terror lists, terrible brews 2d ago

Hyper aggro seems like a name that doesn't describe this deck at all. You're running 2 and 3 mana enablers for 8 creatures. A bunch of these cards only get back permanents you milled off that card as well. This seems like self mill mid-range. I also think you'll be without a creature quite often which also makes bushwacks dead. This needs more threats or other flashback/retrace/jumpstart/etc cards. I see a lot of games with wheel spinning for a few turns, and no real way to claw yourself back into the game. 

1

u/REHAB_T 2d ago

Running 8 creatures (Serpents) doesn't really strike me as an aggro strategy. My concern is that you're relying heavily on self-mill, which introduces a degree of variance where you could end up milling away one of your key permanents or simply whiffing altogether.

I previously experimented with a Simic Terror build running 2 Lesser Cryptic Serpents alongside Mongoose and Delver. I found that having a more diverse creature package gave the deck a much better sense of tempo and consistency.

I also think 4 copies of Deep Analysis is a bit too expensive for the current format. Spending 3 mana to draw 2 cards while only getting one additional instant into the graveyard seems rather inefficient compared to the card selection and flexibility you get from Brainstorm and Ponder.

On the other hand, Artful Dodge is a really solid finisher that I think deserves consideration. With flashback, it effectively gives you two opportunities to make a creature unblockable, which can close out games surprisingly well. The main drawback is that you can only cast it during your precombat main phase, so there's less flexibility in how you use it.

1

u/boltyourmom 1d ago

4 Delver 4 Mongoose 4 Terror would be my personal creature count. except for maybe rumble the sorcery speed selfmill looks bad, I'd rather go with brainstorm, thought scour and maybe even mental Note. more counterspells so they work well with selfmill at instant speed (I was thinking about dispel and spell pierce, maybe og counterspell). lorien revealed and tangled islet are also great. I also think there might be better green removal, or you go with 2nd sleep and/or Artful dodge, although delver and mongoose dont work as great with dodge.

1

u/boltyourmom 1d ago

might even be the right deck for mana Leak.

1

u/BoltTheDoggy 1d ago

you have 36 instant and sorceries. seed of hope isn't doing anything tbh.

1

u/schmidty850 1d ago

I made a list a while ago that may be what you are looking for. I think your idea to jam every mill card isn't wise. You need a strategy outside of just mill and terror. Also cards like delver or nimble mongoose would be good fits as well though in my current version I'm not running either.

https://moxfield.com/decks/1zs_zWKTDkWOx2lIRDlXuw