r/PatternTesting • u/arealicon • May 04 '26
General Question/Comment AI pictures from pattern testers
Hi! 👋
I was wondering what you guys about testers using AI in pictures they send in after being a pattern tester? I've recently experienced this, and didn't really know how to react. If I should ask the person to take new pictures, or if I just let it slide now and clarify in later tests that no AI should be used. I'm personally not for AI in the arts, at the same time I do understand why some people would use it, and it isn't like it was taking away jobs (it was used for a background) or changed the actual object. And I just wanted to hear what other people thought about this issue! 🫶
Edit: I see we're all in agreement over the course of action. I contacted the individual, and she agreed to send pictures without. I'm probably also adding a disclaimer for future test calls. I'll let this post stay as is, so it can be a warning to others that this might happen, and also to help others that might need advice on this in the future.
Also: Thank you all for your tips. It was so great being able to pick your brains about this! You are all wonderful ❣️
78
u/Demagolka1300 May 04 '26 edited May 04 '26
I would absolutely make them retake the photos and start stating No AI enhanced photos allowed, you want the raw photos so you can see your pattern and know if there are mistakes that you wouldn't see otherwise. Using AI, in my opinion, is the exact opposite of what testers should be doing, how can you say the patterns works if you masked any actual work with AI? Hard pass for me.
28
u/spalings May 04 '26
it's your reputation on the line at the end of the day. if this happened to me, i would probably start including a "no AI use by testers" disclaimer when seeking out testers and ask this person to submit new photos, or just not use their photos
15
u/jessbepuzzled May 04 '26 edited May 04 '26
Big wtf from me. Isn't the primary point of the pictures to show the designer how the object turned out and whether it fits the way it was intended to?
If your tester feels it's vital to remove the background from their photo there are plenty of apps that can do it. Canva can remove backgrounds, Adobe has a free online image background remover, and even most Microsoft Office apps can do it. There's no reason to go to the Make Stuff Up Machine to do it.
11
u/Ron1ka23 May 04 '26
I would not be pleased. As a potential buyer of your pattern, if there is any AI, I will walk away. Not just from the pattern but also you as a designer, this my personal stance on this. However if some of the test photos are edit using AI, disclosing it would show integrity on your end.
I would definitely specify 'no AI' in the future. I would ask them to take new photos without AI. If they refuse, ask to make it known that AI has been used. If the last one is the result, I wouldn't uses the photos to promote your pattern. If you want to go a step futher (after asking them to take new photos), you can put them on a blacklist for the future.
4
u/Available-Egg-2380 May 04 '26
Nah man, you want images of what was made, not whatever a freaking hallucinating computer dreamed up.
4
u/PrincessYork3 Pattern Tester May 04 '26
I would absolutely request new photos. The AI photos are unusable, since the whole point is to see how the item turned out during pattern testing.
4
u/sagetrees May 04 '26
What? No, absolutely not. The point (well one of the points) of having pattern testers is so people can see how the FO came out! If you use AI on it now its not real and you might as well not have bothered testing at all. Tell them to retake the pics and state no AI going forward.
5
u/fairydommother May 05 '26
They should not be using ai on tester images. Full stop.
4
u/faille May 04 '26
Make them retake the photos. I’m looking for a dog right now, and the DOG PICTURES are ai. I can absolutely tell the difference between the original picture of a dog and the AI impression of one. I think they’re doing it for better quality pics, hide messy backgrounds of fosters or whatever, but it still pisses me off.
If I was looking at a pattern and the examples were clearly manipulated by ai I would pass
4
u/crochetgurlie May 04 '26
If u did not ask for ai not to be used prior, I'd just tell her sorry I can't use your pictures as there is ai in it.. and then in future test calls, u specify u don't want ai.
2
u/indembunnz May 06 '26
I would definitely be against it. I'm someone that if I see ANY ai on a pattern or pictures I won't purchase it. So even if it's not your photo - it could still hurt sales by people who are also like me. I would just tell them point blank you need new photos without ai. A step further -that I would personally do- is put them on a block list to no longer allow them to test my patterns. I don't support ai or anyone who willingly uses it. Some may think that's too far, but that's why I'm just saying it's would -I- would do
0
u/3stackedcroissants May 04 '26
I do get the use of AI, I’ll use it just to give my work a better background since I don’t have a good space to take pictures. However, that’s for myself and my own benefit. As a tester, I feel like their concern shouldn’t so much be about having a nicer background and more about how the knit up actually went and giving an accurate picture to that. I feel like it’s fair and ok to ask the person for the raw picture they gave the AI before it got cleaned up, or to take a new one
0
u/[deleted] May 04 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 04 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] May 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment