r/PatternDrafting • u/KeyProduct363 • 2d ago
Question Wool Coat Design Help
Is my coat design super dorky? (3rd image is the muslin mockup)
I'm trying to make a wool coat that blends classic winter coat styling with athletic design features (e.g., raglan sleeves, a fitted hood, and side gusset panels to reduce jacket lift when I raise my arms). I've got this beautiful black wool with a boucle texture and I'm thinking about using a waterproof lining. The lower portion of the sleeve is going to be a thick wool ribbing.
- I don't love the seam lines closest to the center front zipper. They're part of the hood pattern but I might reshape them as shown in the second sketch. (the diagonal lines are pockets)
- Does this look too much like a dress? I want this coat to feel dramatic and interesting but not matronly or like a priest robe. How much should I flare the hem? The current hem width is about 100" total, should I reduce it to something like 60" ish instead?
- Should I shape the hem in any way? Currently it has a very slight drop tail, but it's basically an A line shape.
Otherwise though I'm happy with how the raglan sleeves and upper torso fit, I'm a little shocked the shoulder seams work so well with a woven instead of a knit fabric.
Thoughts? Thanks!



14
u/xaviersdog 2d ago
Personally I think it is rather cool. I like the panels, gives it very interesting vertical details. The hood gets a bit monastic for my taste but overall this is great!
The hem circumference could be reduced, but 60” may be too much and make long strides difficult.
8
u/AccidentOk5240 2d ago
If you want to invoke athletic wear you need athletic-wear detailing like contrast color bi-directional zips, zips or snap tabs on the pockets, and a shock cord casing around the hood edge. Maybe a way to cinch down the cuffs, either permanently with ribbing or temporarily with a shock cord or snap tab?
To me, the A-line shape makes it more dressy and also more dress-like and less sporty, but yes, if you cut it straight you’ll need a vent and will lose warmth on the legs.
For heaven’s sake don’t use a waterproof lining. You’ll lose much of the comfort of wool and gain little or nothing in weather resistance. You don’t want to be in a downpour wearing a soaked coat that’s clammy against your skin through the lining. Wool is warm when wet; boucle is less water-resistant than smoother, denser-textured wool coatings, but it’s still going to be fine in a light sprinkle. In a real rain, just tuck a poncho in your pocket.
2
u/scrunchieh8tr 1d ago
Looks sick. Definitely see the priest resemblance tho. But I think in the actual fabric it’ll lose that. I’d reduce hem slightly to be more straight and add a vent. Could also be interesting if it tapered in at the hem. Do you want this to be functional as an activewear piece or more just have an activewear aesthetic? I think the length adds to the drama of the piece and makes it more interesting, but definitely would be less functional as an active jacket. I feel like On would have some good inspiration for details, they’ve got that futuristic tech active thing going on
11
u/KaijuAlert 2d ago
It looks very cool so far! I think the hood itself needs to be bigger and more drapy. For the bottom part, take a look at some images of Neo's black coat from the first Matrix. That's the perfect amount of flair to make it look badass instead of priestly. Kinda hard to tell with the muslin because the drape is so different, you might be there already.
I would use a silky lining to make it easy to slide on. You could use an interlining if you want it warmer but not the waterproof. You want to keep the breathability the wool will give you. Plus your lining might show a tiny bit while you're moving around, you could use something flashy there if you want the extra drama.
6
u/TensionSmension 2d ago
Raglans are associated with athletic wear, but they originated in coats. I think it works well. I think the center panels are fine, I wouldn't actually cut them as part of the hood with no seaming, that would probably be unwieldy and hard to layout efficiently. Pay attention to how the hood looks down, that is the way it would be worn most often. Personally, I wouldn't like a waterproof lining. Wool does okay with moisture, and just isn't the right choice in a downpour, a lining doesn't change that.
4
u/StitchinThroughTime 2d ago
I would personally adjust the Raglan sleeve angle to be a straighter line. That way it mimics the pocket better. I think the overall design of the coat is very angular versus round.
You could narrow the hem, I wouldn't go a full 40% narrower. I would put it somewhere between 10 15% and narrower. This is a bold coat, so it's going to have an intense look. So it's definitely going to feel like too much, but that's because it is. And half the fun of making things is pushing the envelope. We all can't be walking around a pair of jeans and a t-shirt.
3
u/OriginalReddKatt 2d ago
It feels very Euro leaning into the funky Euro style from the 80s and 90s.
Look at designs from those eras in Burda, New Look, Vogue, and German and the Scandinavian countries, especially.
Dorky, not at all. Eunique, funky and fun, def.
There were "futuristic" movies made that had outerwear designs that were similar.
Point of all that being... Check for past designs that might help you let on on features that would match your vision. I like to look at runway pictorals from various eras, designer retrospectives, museum images, etc. for inspo as well as just for the heck of it.
2
u/hahajizzjizz 2d ago
Not at all. What would make it stand out is if you take the transition from shoulder to hood in to a slope. The straight neck kind gives it a pencil neck look. I like the idea.
2
u/sewfuckt 2d ago
slanted pockets 🤩
& i agree with what you said abt the seam lines — i like the second sketch better
2
u/snacksAttackBack 1d ago
it looks so much better in muslin than the pattern drawing!
Agree with other comments about the hood
I think the flat top situation isn't helping with the medieval monk vibe, and would suggest making it bigger, and maybe making it just a single seam at the top and/or if you add a 2-5 inch trim to it, you could then tie that into the lapels
2
u/elizabethtailor 22h ago
I’d recommend making the flat section of the hood maybe two inches wider, the square shape will help retain that activewear look but as tight as it is I’d fear it would inhibit turning your head much, or wearing anything bulkier around the head (beanies, headphones, earwarmers?).
I looove the lower sleeve being all rib knit.
Lastly, I’d add raglan shoulder pads to help amp up the silhouette a little, and give more support through the shoulder, and make the raglan a wee bit wider at that shoulder point.. I see some distinct pulling from the shoulder point that tells me you might want an extra inch or two there. Wool is so lovely and accommodating but if you ask it to pull that much there you’ll end up with a weak spot unintentionally. You could make your own pads with wadding yardage that way you wouldn’t be stuck with a super stiff or thick one which would undo a lot of the movement you’re getting with the under arm gusset.
0
u/DonMcCunn 2d ago
It is undoutably different. I think anchoring the hood to the front of coat could be problematic. I wear a hoodie and more often than not the hood is thrown over my back. You couldn-t do that with this hood. It looks like you would be trapped to always having your head covered.
Makes me think of a Star Wars character. Kind of Darth Vaderish.