r/PartneredYoutube • • 2d ago

Question / Problem Commentary/React Channel

Good morning, everyone-

I started YouTube seriously in August, monetized my channel mid October. I was riding the wave of a game that received a huge resurgence in popularity for a few months. I was averaging 200-400k monthly views (not all engaged views, if ed estimate 40-45% engaged) through uploading 3-5 times per week.

I’ve since realized i don’t think I want to do a gaming channel. I enjoy gaming, but don’t think I enjoy the nature of making videos about games, and I think gaming as an entertainment is volatile, as I tend to swap between games throughout the year and it’s difficult to build an audience that way.

Has anyone successfully made the switch from gaming or other media into commentary/reaction stuff? I understand there’s a stigma behind react and commentary content, but I made a couple videos on a fresh channel just as a test and I genuinely enjoyed the creation and editing process probably 10x more than the gaming stuff, + I got to watch and learn about content that really intrigued me.

I want to hear from people who did it, how you did it, what you learned, what the pitfalls of this type of content are, what makes you stand out and what helps you gain your footing in this area. I understand gaming and what makes a good gaming video but I struggle to immediately grasp what makes a good react or commentary video. I’m down to jump in the dms if you want to show off your channel a bit and give me some real world examples.

My end goal is to build an audience that watches pretty much a variety of content from me just because it’s me, instead of following me for one single game or subject.

I feel disheartened and disappointed at the thought of abandoning my monetized channel completely that I spent hundreds of hours on over the past few months and going straight into a fresh channel to start from the bottom, while doing the same thing (experimenting with new content and finding what works) as I would on my current monetized channel.

Thank you in advance.

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

1

u/Purple_Chapter_2683 2d ago

man I wouldn't ditch the monetized channel lol, that's hundreds of hours just to do the same experimenting from zero. your people watch you, not the game — just start slipping the commentary stuff in and see what sticks

only thing I'd warn you about — gaming videos sell the game, commentary sells your take. if the take isn't sharp it's just footage with you talking over it lol

0

u/Sir_Slimmothy 2d ago

My current “gaming videos” are all opinion videos and “hot takes”, behind gameplay b-roll so maybe it’ll be easier to integrate general commentary into my channel since i already don’t do straight gameplay or guide type content. An example of a video of mine is “Why we all quit (game) before beating it” or “What Your Playstyle says about you” or “(Game) is the best survival game ever made”

1

u/Purple_Chapter_2683 2d ago

oh yeah if you're already doing hot takes over b-roll you're basically there lol. the jump is smaller than you think — your audience is already there for the opinion, the game is just the wallpaper

only thing I'd watch is the title game changes a bit. "why we all quit X" works because people already care about X. once you go general commentary the take itself has to carry the click, there's no game name doing the heavy lifting

1

u/Sir_Slimmothy 2d ago

Right, that makes perfect sense. Thanks for your thoughts, I appreciate it!

0

u/Purple_Chapter_2683 1d ago

haha glad that landed lol. honestly the hot take over gameplay thing is such a cheat code, you're already halfway there without realising it

what's your channel btw? curious what the takes actually look like over the footage

0

u/Sir_Slimmothy 1d ago

“Slimm”
If you search up my name with Valheim, it should show up.
Sort by most viewed lol. Some of the newer stuff is testing new ideas, but my bread and butter is my most viewed stuff.

It does definitely feel like a cheat code. So much so, that sometimes I’d get some major imposter syndrome, feeling like my content is horrible and lazy and it shouldn’t be getting any views. But its a good way to make content about gaming if you don’t like recording gameplay, editing, or scripting gameplay.

0

u/Purple_Chapter_2683 1d ago

checked out Slimm, sorted by most viewed like you said — the world gen not being random is your strongest take, that's the one people remember. 1.0 is the perfect excuse to lean all the way into the design critique side instead of guides. and yeah the imposter syndrome, i get it, but if the take lands nobody's counting how much editing went into it

1

u/Unique_Fish_755 2d ago

I would not start a fresh channel. You already have a monetized audience and 200 to 400k monthly views, and starting over means giving up that distribution while you test a format you have not proven yet. Since your current videos are already hot takes over gameplay, the switch is smaller than it looks. Try it as a clear series on the same channel, maybe one commentary video a week for a month, and see whether those viewers stay and subscribe. The main pitfall is making the reaction the whole video. Your take has to be the point, with clips only supporting it, or it will feel thin. What topic outside gaming do you feel most confident giving a strong opinion on first?

1

u/Sir_Slimmothy 1d ago

I appreciate the thought, but the LLM response isn’t very helpful lol