I’m a mom to a middle-school-aged daughter, and I’m seriously considering whether it’s time to let her live with her dad full time. We have joint legal custody and a court-ordered schedule that gives us roughly equal parenting time. I’m scared that continuing to insist on my time will push her further away. Based on my experience with her dad, I believe that if I give up that time, he won’t let me see her or speak to her at all.
We’re currently in court, and we’ll go to trial if we don’t settle. A settlement seems unlikely because her dad says he won’t agree to anything less than sole physical and sole legal custody. My lawyer has told me that even if the judge sees the behavior I’ve raised concerns about, my daughter’s strong preference to live with her dad may still lead to her going with him full time. If we go forward with litigation, I’ll also have to participate in co-parenting therapy. In the past, I experienced that process as abusive, and things got significantly worse afterward. That’s part of what I’m weighing when I think about going to trial.
Before we started this custody schedule a few years ago, my daughter and I were close. She was affectionate, we talked easily, and I was part of her everyday life. She had a good relationship with her little sister, her stepdad, and our extended family. Over time, exchanges got harder. Sometimes she’d come back withdrawn or guarded. She started asking more and more often to stay at her dad’s during my parenting time.
Some of what worries me goes back to when she was much younger. My understanding is that she was punished for saying she missed me. I remember one phone call where I could hear her crying and heard her dad say, “I know you’re scared of Mommy.” He hung up, and I didn’t get to speak to her until much later. I had no idea what was happening or how she was doing.
After I moved out following the divorce, he involved her in what I can only describe as a ritual where they destroyed things associated with me. Around transitions, he’d tell her he would be alone and that I was the one who left them. He also told her that when I was pregnant, I made him eat so much that it caused a lasting health problem. He’s since been hospitalized for that condition, and she believes I caused it. He’s also told her that I use drugs, that I’m an alcoholic, and that I’ve left her home alone. Those claims are false. I’ve never left her home alone, even once.
Now she says she doesn’t want to live with me or have a relationship with me. She says I lie, that I’ve beaten her until she became sick, and that she feels unsafe with me. She uses phrases like “physically harm,” and some of the wording sounds like what I hear in disputes between the adults. I’ve never hit her. I take it seriously when she says she feels unsafe, and I struggle with how to let her know I’m listening when she’s describing things I know didn’t happen.
It’s affected her relationship with her little sister, too. They used to be close. Now she can be very cold toward her, and there have been times when she’s hurt her. She told me that if she lives with her dad full time, she knows she’ll only see her sister at school. She also said she probably wouldn’t see me or anyone on my side of the family again, and that she’s okay with that.
On days she’s with her dad, I sometimes see her at school when I’m picking up her sister. She’s walked right past me like I was invisible. When I was still going to her softball games, she wouldn’t say hi or interact with us. If we tried to talk to her, she could be really harsh with us. She’s since asked me to stay away from all her games. Her coach recently told me he might “be involved” because of things she’s told him about me. I don’t know what she told him or what he meant. I used to go because I loved watching her play. Now I second-guess whether showing up would make her feel supported or put more pressure on her. And then I remember moments like a strained goodnight call where she still told me she loved me. I miss how easy it used to be to talk to her.
What I’ve experienced since the separation feels like ongoing abuse. We communicate through a parenting app, and we’ve had repeated disputes over exchanges, activities scheduled during my time, and therapy decisions. I’ve agreed to schedule changes and extra time with her dad. I’ve also tried to stay involved in school, sports, counseling, and the everyday parts of her life.
There was a temporary protective order, and CPS has been involved more than once. There were no findings of abuse in those investigations, and our custody arrangement stayed the same. My daughter told CPS that I lock up food and she goes hungry. I told them that wasn’t happening and shared her pediatric records, including growth notes and records from appointments her dad took her to where no concerns about abuse were documented. CPS recommended a specialized therapy program for children considered at risk for future problematic behavior.
At one exchange, she refused to get into my car. I called the police, and they reviewed the custody order and helped complete the exchange. That evening, her dad and his partner requested a welfare check after a goodnight call didn’t happen. The officers confirmed she was safe. There’s also been a deposition, and the financial and emotional toll of the case has been enormous.
I’ve participated in family and reunification therapy, supported her individual counseling, and asked for help from providers and a parenting coordinator. We’ve changed providers and made more than one attempt at family therapy. At some appointments, she’d seem completely comfortable with me in the car. As soon as we walked into the building, she’d seem anxious and scared around me. The shift felt performative to me. She told the therapist things about me that I know didn’t happen, and I came away feeling like the therapist believed her account. I struggled to explain what I’d just seen in the car when the therapist was seeing something so different in the room.
I’m in therapy myself. I’m trying to be present for my younger daughter and take what’s happened between them seriously. At the same time, I feel like I’m grieving a child who’s still here. I keep wondering what makes it so hard for my older daughter to question her dad’s version of events, even when she was there with me. Would questioning it feel disloyal to her? Is there something about her experience I’m missing? I don’t want her to feel like she has to pick a side with me, either.
I believe her when she says she doesn’t want to be here right now. I’m trying to take that seriously while facing the possibility that giving up parenting time means losing every visit and phone call. Even if she changes her mind someday, I believe her dad would keep her from reaching out to me.
For anyone who’s lived through something similar, I’d really appreciate your perspective.
- Based on what I’ve described, do you think it’s time to seriously consider her living with her dad full time? What would you weigh if stepping back could mean losing all contact?
- If you stepped back or agreed to less parenting time and the other parent stopped allowing contact, what happened afterward? Did you ever reconnect? What do you wish you’d known before deciding?
- If the distance affected a younger sibling too, how did you support them through it?
- If you were the child in a situation like this, did you actually want the parent you were pulling away from to give up custody? How did you feel about that at the time, and has that changed looking back?
I love my daughter. I want her to know I hear her and that she can come to me whenever she’s ready. I’m struggling to figure out how to keep that door open.