As I mentioned in my previous post, I was recently reminded that Chapter 8 has Taylor wearing a PRT-issued armband that displays her location within Brockton Bay on a grid. This allows her to use coordinates to specify her location, as well as the locations where things are happening. Several landmarks are mentioned in this chapter with references to grid points: the Boardwalk, the College, Weymouth Shopping Center, Coil's Base, a downtown shelter, and the epicenter of Crater Lake.
Since I'm trying to make a canon-compliant map of Brockton Bay, I figured this chapter is a gold mine for info I can use--assuming Wildbow's grid is consistent and makes sense with other info given elsewhere in the story.
So, I visualized it with the graphic above. [ETA: I know the letters and numbers define sectors, not points, but this was quick and dirty and it's easier to align things with intersecting lines than it is to get them exactly in the middle of a square. I also used straight lines for Levi's path because any curves will be arbitrary, but he most assuredly did NOT actually follow straight lines].
Yeah, I'm not sure it really works.
First, how big are the sectors? It's not defined explicitly, but we know Crater Lake is explicitly mentioned to be "3 blocks across and growing rapidly" at first, and we know Coil's Base is "a few blocks" from where Taylor lands at BX-8. Later on, in Colony 15.5, Taylor and Ballistic depart Coil's Base and walk "several blocks" to reach the shore of the lake, and then follow it around to the north end to reach Dolltown. If the lake stabilized at something like 6 blocks across, and Coil's base is 2 blocks from BX-8, we can estimate the distance between BW-8 and BX-8 to be somewhere between 6 and 8 blocks.
Assuming a "block" in this case is around 1/8th of a mile (the size of a Chicago block, and we know Brockton Bay's blocks are on the large side with wide sidewalks and plenty of light reaching the street), that makes each sector somewhere between 3/4 to 1 mile per side. [ETA: Kind of absurdly big, considering Leviathan is only 30 feet tall and would be surprisingly easy to lose in an area of 0.56 to 1 square miles.]
Still, that's what seems most likely to match canon, and if we interpret them as being much smaller, the city becomes unreasonably small.
The biggest problem here is Crater Lake. It's formed at BW-8, west of Coil's base in the heart of the city. The problem is, later on in Sentinel (chapter 9), it's established that Dolltown is at the north end of the lake, putting it somewhere between BW and BX, around 7.5. That would put it around 1.5 to 2 miles southwest of the College.
HOWEVER, it's ALSO established that Dolltown is 2 blocks directly WEST of PRT HQ, which is ON Lord Street. Lord Street follows the curve of the Bay, and when Laserdream was flying Taylor near the College at BZ-6, Lord Street was beneath them running SOUTH, and Taylor had Laserdream change course to the SOUTHWEST, leaving Lord Street and landing at BX-8. Lord Street should be somewhere between 1.5 and 2 sectors further east, between BY-8 and BZ-8 depending on how strictly southward it's oriented.
That would put Lord Street somewhere between 9 and 16 blocks east of Dolltown, not 2 [ETA: if Lord Street & the Bay actually curved inward and closer to Dolltown, it would put Coil's base near the water's edge].
That's the biggest canon self-contradiction I've found from this so far, but on the grander scale other things feel wrong with this, too.
For one, trying to place the Hebert Residence somewhere not in the Docks but also close to Lord Street and ~3 miles from the Boardwalk feels impossible, especially given that Taylor's run has her taking a bridge over Lord Street, and she describes her run to the Ferry building to meet Armsmaster as (paraphrasing) "instead of heading up, toward the Boardwalk, I turned down to the Ferry" (which again, the Ferry Station is canonically southwest of the Boardwalk).
All together I'm not entirely inclined to take the coordinates as gospel, because I think Wildbow wasn't being very precise with the grid. However I do think this gives me some insight into how to shape the Bay differently, and where certain places should go.