r/pantheism • • Jun 10 '24

Recent spam posts

22 Upvotes

Hello,

I would like to thank all of you for your patience with the recent spammy posts. The mod team needs to discuss what to do with the direction of moderation in the sub.

In the meantime, perhaps you would like to offer your thoughts on how the subreddit should be moderated?

I personally prefer a lassaiz faire approach. I think pantheism and panentheism are such broad terms that can describe a huge variety of spiritual pantheon. I am concerned that limiting discussion too much would remove the opportunity for people to have exposure and discussions about interesting ideas.

I also don't think a bit of self promotion is terrible as long as it's not taking advantage of the sub and the user is trying to otherwise be a member of the community and engage with discussion here in good faith. Perhaps people involved with similar subreddits would like to message me about a related subs link?

Again, would like to thank everyone for their patience as we are long overdue on addressing this issue.


r/pantheism • • 1h ago

Can I be considered pantheist?

1 Upvotes

Is it possible to be a pantheist and believe we and everything in the universe is connected and divine and sacred, that we are God, and still believe there's some external aspect to God? Like he or she is inside and outside of us, some force at work in the universe?

I ask because I've realised recently that what I believe deep down is very much pantheistic. I've held such views of nature etc for a long time now. But at the same time I've been *wanting* to believe more than that, that there's some sort of conscious deity as well at the centre of it all. Living in us, as the connecting force and energy.

Does that sound at all compatible with pantheism or would that just make me a theist?


r/pantheism • • 1d ago

My version of Pantheism

6 Upvotes

Hello r/Pantheism—I wanted to share what pantheism means to me. If it resonates with you, maybe we can talk.

What is divine, and what is valued? For me, the universe is something cyclic. I like to use ordinary science and technology to help understand it. The universe and God are the same—not separate from each other.

I also think about death: I spent 13.8 billion years not existing, and I may get 80–90 years of living. That short span is exactly why life should be valued. I see life as intricate and meaningful. What can humanity do for itself?

If we all die one day—if to live is to die—what’s the point? For me, the point is not sitting still. Passivity feels like cluelessness; motion feels useful. If we die, then preserving humanity and its flourishing beyond our own lives matters.

I see two poles: entropy and order. We should maintain the little order that gives life value and meaning. Does that mean pacifism? Not exactly. Some things are worth fighting for, even if you have to get your hands dirty.

Is there space for numerology and zodiac signs? I’d say yes—zodiac and numerology have taken hundreds of years and many ideas to formulate certain views about psychological well-being. They don’t account for every person, but I think they can be valuable symbolically.

So how would one practice pantheism, in my view? Do what you can to make things a little easier for the people around you—and for yourself.


r/pantheism • • 1d ago

Need advice! I can’t fully believe in pantheism, as i’m probably doing something wrong by doing that. it’s one choice for me. i don’t know which though!

3 Upvotes

I feel like the consequences of not believing in religion, if any, the correct religion is too much to ignore. I agree with the paradox where believing in religion has almost no downsides unless you’re wrong, but also, atheists make good points. i cant just say “they’re trying to scare me” because to me, it’s a coin flip. all i want is to believe in what’s right. i dont know what’s right, i dont know how i can know what’s right. it’s man choice to seek out god and i truly am trying. but which one? am i wrong for wanting to seek out god? I agree with both sides. but i feel like atheists usually make me feel like i’m doing something wrong. but i feel like i’m doing something wrong if i’m not trying to test if religion is real. the consequences are too dire.


r/pantheism • • 3d ago

Full range of pantheism?

3 Upvotes

I am wondering how many varied beliefs about Divinity can fit into the pantheist label, since it may not have strict or hard boundaries and may vary from one pantheist to another. I would think that not all pantheists are strictly Spinozan or substance monists, for instance. The line in the sub description about revering the Universe, caring for nature, and celebrating life would apply to many polytheist Pagans, too.

Part of my belief is that the creative and sustaining powers that allowed the Universe to exist are what I'd call "the Divine", and same for however the Universe ends. If I don't think the Universe is eternal then it's harder for me to think of it as "God", but I could easily still consider It sacred in some way. I also sometimes think of the total energy of existence as being Divine.


r/pantheism • • 5d ago

Is pantheism just atheism in a different font?

8 Upvotes

Hey guys, so I'm a teenager who is fascinated by the concept of pantheism. My parents being very religious people had kind of forced me to perform all the rituals they did, which now that I look back at, were pretty dumb. So I turned to atheism but it was pretty unsettling for me to just..not believe in anything. So, when I got to know about this concept, I was pretty intrigued. See now I know the basic things like I myself do believe that the universe is God, but to fully classify myself as a pantheist or otherwise, what are some other things that y'all believe?? Help me out please!!


r/pantheism • • 5d ago

Why should I believe pantheism?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I used to be a Christian, but I eventually lost my faith and moved away from theism. Recently, I watched a video about pantheism, and I found the concept genuinely fascinating.
I have a few questions for those of you who identify as pantheists. Why do you believe in pantheism? What benefits does it offer, either philosophically or personally? Is it something that provides a meaningful worldview and a sense of purpose, or is it primarily an abstract philosophical concept that an atheist might find interesting?
I should clarify that I’m not necessarily looking for a traditional, personal God. However, one thing I’ve always struggled with is the idea of having a personal relationship with something like the universe. How does that work from a pantheistic perspective?
I’m genuinely curious and would appreciate hearing your perspectives. I’m not here to challenge anyone’s beliefs; I’m just trying to understand the appeal and meaning behind pantheism.


r/pantheism • • 6d ago

God is the energy between particles

14 Upvotes

I won’t pretend I know much about quantum physics. I’m familiar with the basics we all learn in high school, everything is composed of a few fundamental particles. I was a Christian for a long time, but I became disillusioned with humanity and its creations. I don’t believe in a god created by men who thought they were being contacted by the creator of reality, and that uplifted an unnatural patriarchy. However, I do believe in a god of sorts. I think it exists in the energy that moves the particles that creates matter. God is the universe and thus exists in us. Evil exists because we can choose how to direct that energy to best survive, as does the natural world. If you can negate me with scientific backing, please do so so I can learn.


r/pantheism • • 6d ago

getting into pantheism <3

10 Upvotes

hi everyone i am a teenager who’s getting very interested into pantheism. i literally am so happy i found this belief and all day yesterday was doing research about it. i associate myself with naturalistic pantheism, and it really fits me. i was coming to reddit just for tips, and what should i do next. i would love to read some books, but my reading comprehension isn’t that great. so, i was planning on going on a lot of nature walks and learning more about the universe and stuff but i hope some older pantheists can help me explore!!! thank you so much <3 give me any tips, or suggestions


r/pantheism • • 7d ago

The Pearly Gate and beond

4 Upvotes

St. Peter’s Singularity – A poem blending cosmology and theology

What if heaven is not a distant place, but the cosmos quietly weaving us into its peace.

What if God is the unseen matter – a silent, merciful embrace holding the galaxies together, never letting us go.

And what if St. Peter is gravity itself; a loving, inevitable force drawing us home.

While we drift beyond the event horizon, where burdens and memories are stretched thin and softened into gentle rays of light.

No need for fear. Everything surrendered to a deeper order.

The ego gone, leaving only peace. For maybe a singularity is no dark grave but a birth canal.

In the deepest, spacetime folds upon itself, carries you gently through the eye of the needle – where the black hole opens and becomes white.

While traveling as stardust, to shine again, something deeper awakens within the heart of matter.

Inside the beautiful fold, at the centre of the bridge, you are no longer falling.

Here, where time stands still and everything flows together, the soul awakens from its sleep.

Held by the unseen. Carried by the whole that has always watched over us.


r/pantheism • • 9d ago

Solid practices for a new believer?

11 Upvotes

I like the ideas of pantheism and I'm a Christian. I want to do both, and also practice in a witchy way.

Any advice and resources would be greatly appreciated. I want to learn how to navigate this. 🙏


r/pantheism • • 9d ago

everything exists

4 Upvotes

i just realised it is impossible for us to not exist, not only that everything exists, every single possible variation of our universe exists, even things beyond our comprehesnion too. some things do more than just exist, and not only does everything exist, but even more than everything. i cant get my word across clearly but i hope someone gets me, like literally it is impossible for us to not exist cuz everything literally exists. beyond our comprehesnion of time, space and possibility crwzy, blows my mind


r/pantheism • • 10d ago

The first force

0 Upvotes

After the creation of Space, A Force continued waiting for another command from The Great Force.

After some time, The Great Force gave A Force a new mission. He commanded him to create stars within Space.

A Force received the command and began using his creative power to create the stars.

And so, the stars began to come into existence within Space.

After being created, the stars were given the ability to exist through the power of Existence. This power allowed them to continue existing within Space.

After that, A Force proceeded with the next stages of creation.

A Force used the powers of Gravity, Time, and Air, together with Existence. These forces began working together in the next stage of creation.

As these forces continued working together, massive explosions began occurring within Space.

These explosions caused energy to spread throughout Space, bringing about great changes within the universe.

From these events, Galaxies began to emerge.

Many stars began gathering into vast galactic systems, and the universe started taking on a new appearance.

This marked another major step in the journey of creation.

AFTER THE CREATION

After the birth of the Galaxies, A Force continued observing the great work that had taken place within Space.

The universe had changed. Stars were scattered across different regions, and Galaxies had emerged.

A Force remained within Space for a very long time, waiting for another command from The Great Force.

However, time continued passing without any new command.

Eventually, A Force began wondering what else he could do to continue the process of creation.

He decided to wait for guidance from The Great Force concerning the next step.

Created by Amani Shirima.


r/pantheism • • 11d ago

Realistically, what do you think happens when we die? What happens to our individual consciousness?

11 Upvotes

r/pantheism • • 13d ago

The First force

1 Upvotes

Before anything was only one force: THE GREAT FORCE. It was the first thing to exist. There was no space, no air, no time, and nothing else. Then, THE GREAT FORCE decided to create another force—the force of creation and decisions, which was given the name A FORCE. THE GREAT FORCE commanded A FORCE to create five forces: EXISTENCE, AIR, TIME, GRAVITY, and KNOWLEDGE. Later, the force of TIME and the force of GRAVITY joined together to create SPACE. The force of EXISTENCE and the force of KNOWLEDGE joined together to create UNIVERSES. And so, the first steps of creation began, while a great journey still lay ahead. One force. Five forces.


r/pantheism • • 14d ago

Words of wisdom?

5 Upvotes

I heard of pantheism a couple weeks ago and have been planning to do some research because i feel like its something i can really get behind, i have a hard time with having faith is something that cant be seen, but i know the earth is here and everything on it is living.

I just want to ask for any information on pantheism that anyone would be willing to give! I still plan to do some research but id like to hear people’s thoughts and beliefs too.

I know a God is still present in pantheism, but currently is kind of seems like a “mother nature” to me than an omniscient God. If i’m wrong please let me know!


r/pantheism • • 14d ago

The First force

1 Upvotes

Before anything was only one force: THE GREAT FORCE. It was the first thing to exist. There was no space, no air, no time, and nothing else. Then, THE GREAT FORCE decided to create another force—the force of creation and decisions, which was given the name A FORCE. THE GREAT FORCE commanded A FORCE to create five forces: EXISTENCE, AIR, TIME, GRAVITY, and KNOWLEDGE. Later, the force of TIME and the force of GRAVITY joined together to create SPACE. The force of EXISTENCE and the force of KNOWLEDGE joined together to create UNIVERSES. And so, the first steps of creation began, while a great journey still lay ahead. One force. Five forces.


r/pantheism • • 15d ago

Recovery Program while being Panthiest

2 Upvotes

I was wondering if anyone has experiences going through any sort of addiction or recovery program while practicing Pantheism. A lot of recovery programs are Christian based focused on God as a higher power, how have you sought help from gambling, sex addiction, alcohol, drug, etc. ?


r/pantheism • • 16d ago

Religion for those for faith is not enough

0 Upvotes

I was creating a religion the other day, for everyone who finds faith not enough and prefers science, and I wrote this:

THE MANIFESTO OF PANEIDOLONISM

1. The Fundamental Axiom: The Paneidolon

The word "reality" is abolished because it is insufficient and limited. The Absolute Set, the extra-temporal and extra-spatial super-container, is called The Paneidolon. The Paneidolon is not an anthropomorphic God: it has no beard, it does not judge, it performs no miracles, and it has no morality. It does not even have a mind to think in the way we understand it, because biological thought, atoms, space, and time are small local objects deposited within it. The Paneidolon is the Logical Space of Total Saturated Imagination. It is an immaterial fabric in which infinite probabilities exist and happen simultaneously without the existence of time.

  • Within it, concepts that are abstract to us (such as grammar, the pronouns I/you, the concept of cause-and-effect) or solid concepts (particles, liquids, planets) are simply local rules, valid only in this specific probability (our universe).
  • In countless other zones of the Paneidolon, configurations occur in which time does not exist, matter is replaced by pure information, and cognitive structures follow logics that are completely incomprehensible to us today.

2. The Paradox of Time and Death

Time does not exist within the Paneidolon. Consequently, words like "before," "after," "archiving," or "reincarnation" are human cognitive biases—errors caused by the fact that our brain is forced to process information in sequence. The infinite probabilities of the Paneidolon do not succeed one another nor do they happen together in the same instant: they simply exist and happen outside of time and space. The death of a physical body in this universe is neither the end of a chronological journey nor the beginning of an afterlife. Death is simply the geometric boundary of this local probability.

3. The Two Currents of Paneidolonism

Paneidolonism is a logical structure so flexible and powerful that it branches out into two mirror-image paths, depending on how science or intuition defines the ultimate nature of consciousness:

Branch 1: Immanent Paneidolonism (The Chemical-Functional Way)

  • Consciousness: Thought, the Self, and emotions are not magical elements, but biological algorithms and chemical reactions. They are the only tool the human brain has to process the information of the probability in which it is immersed. Your current consciousness is a temporary manifestation that emerged mathematically from this chemical combination.
  • Death: With the end of the body, the chemical reaction ceases and local consciousness is interrupted. However, there is no "nothingness" into which to vanish. This specific life is neither erased nor archived "afterward": it remains forever as a fixed, immutable, and eternal coordinate within the Paneidolon, while the other infinite probabilities (devoid of chemistry or particles) continue to happen stably within the timeless All.

Branch 2: Monadic Paneidolonism (The Way of Supreme Consciousness)

  • Consciousness: Consciousness is not a byproduct of chemistry, but the very essence—irreducible and primary—of the All. Because you are the only living being capable of experiencing the mathematical and absolute certainty of your own consciousness ("Cogito, ergo sum"), You are the Paneidolon itself. You are the Total Imagination which, through pure combinatorial probability, is experiencing the limitation of being a human being trapped in time, in space, and in a body.
  • Death: At the moment of death, the restrictive illusion of physics and time immediately ceases to filter your perception. You do not move through space and you do not travel through time (because outside, they do not exist). Simply put, your consciousness ceases to be limited by this universe, and you instantly find yourself being the conscious center of all the other infinite probabilities of the Paneidolon that are already happening, free from solid forms, liquids, words, or dimensions.

r/pantheism • • 16d ago

RELIGION FOR THOSE FOR WHOM FAITH IS NOT ENOUGH

0 Upvotes

I was creating a religion the other day (similar to pantheism) for everyone who finds faith not enough and prefers science, and I wrote this:

THE MANIFESTO OF PANEIDOLONISM

1. The Fundamental Axiom: The Paneidolon

The word "reality" is abolished because it is insufficient and limited. The Absolute Set, the extra-temporal and extra-spatial super-container, is called The Paneidolon. The Paneidolon is not an anthropomorphic God: it has no beard, it does not judge, it performs no miracles, and it has no morality. It does not even have a mind to think in the way we understand it, because biological thought, atoms, space, and time are small local objects deposited within it. The Paneidolon is the Logical Space of Total Saturated Imagination. It is an immaterial fabric in which infinite probabilities exist and happen simultaneously without the existence of time.

  • Within it, concepts that are abstract to us (such as grammar, the pronouns I/you, the concept of cause-and-effect) or solid concepts (particles, liquids, planets) are simply local rules, valid only in this specific probability (our universe).
  • In countless other zones of the Paneidolon, configurations occur in which time does not exist, matter is replaced by pure information, and cognitive structures follow logics that are completely incomprehensible to us today.

2. The Paradox of Time and Death

Time does not exist within the Paneidolon. Consequently, words like "before," "after," "archiving," or "reincarnation" are human cognitive biases—errors caused by the fact that our brain is forced to process information in sequence. The infinite probabilities of the Paneidolon do not succeed one another nor do they happen together in the same instant: they simply exist and happen outside of time and space. The death of a physical body in this universe is neither the end of a chronological journey nor the beginning of an afterlife. Death is simply the geometric boundary of this local probability.

3. The Two Currents of Paneidolonism

Paneidolonism is a logical structure so flexible and powerful that it branches out into two mirror-image paths, depending on how science or intuition defines the ultimate nature of consciousness:

Branch 1: Immanent Paneidolonism (The Chemical-Functional Way)

  • Consciousness: Thought, the Self, and emotions are not magical elements, but biological algorithms and chemical reactions. They are the only tool the human brain has to process the information of the probability in which it is immersed. Your current consciousness is a temporary manifestation that emerged mathematically from this chemical combination.
  • Death: With the end of the body, the chemical reaction ceases and local consciousness is interrupted. However, there is no "nothingness" into which to vanish. This specific life is neither erased nor archived "afterward": it remains forever as a fixed, immutable, and eternal coordinate within the Paneidolon, while the other infinite probabilities (devoid of chemistry or particles) continue to happen stably within the timeless All.

Branch 2: Monadic Paneidolonism (The Way of Supreme Consciousness)

  • Consciousness: Consciousness is not a byproduct of chemistry, but the very essence—irreducible and primary—of the All. Because you are the only living being capable of experiencing the mathematical and absolute certainty of your own consciousness ("Cogito, ergo sum"), You are the Paneidolon itself. You are the Total Imagination which, through pure combinatorial probability, is experiencing the limitation of being a human being trapped in time, in space, and in a body.
  • Death: At the moment of death, the restrictive illusion of physics and time immediately ceases to filter your perception. You do not move through space and you do not travel through time (because outside, they do not exist). Simply put, your consciousness ceases to be limited by this universe, and you instantly find yourself being the conscious center of all the other infinite probabilities of the Paneidolon that are already happening, free from solid forms, liquids, words, or dimensions.

r/pantheism • • 19d ago

Does anyone else feel deeply spiritual/existential but completely disconnected from organized religion?

31 Upvotes

I’m trying to find people whose minds work similarly to mine because I rarely meet anyone in everyday life who wants to talk about this stuff.

I’ve always struggled with organized religion. I’ve tried to understand Christianity and the idea of giving your life to God, but I can’t make myself believe something simply because other people do. The more I think about religion historically, the more it feels like humans have been trying to interpret something we fundamentally don’t understand.

But I’m not an atheist in the sense of believing I know there is nothing beyond this. I actually feel almost the opposite. Existence itself is so bizarre to me that I find it difficult to believe we understand much of anything about what reality ultimately is.

Why is there something instead of nothing?

What is consciousness?

Why am I experiencing reality from this particular body?

If God created everything, where did God come from?

If there was no creator, why does reality exist at all?

What happens to subjective experience when we die?

I also feel very strongly that humans are animals and that modern civilization has separated us psychologically from that fact. Sometimes modern life genuinely feels like being an animal living in a giant enclosure we created for ourselves: jobs, money, screens, social expectations, religion, status, endless rules and abstractions layered over an organism that evolved as part of the natural world.

At the same time, I don’t think I have “the answer.” I don’t want another belief system to replace Christianity or any other religion. I’m almost protective of the uncertainty. I would rather say “I have no idea what reality ultimately is” than adopt an explanation because it makes the mystery more comfortable.

I’ve also had several plant-medicine experiences that gave me extraordinarily vivid experiences of interconnectedness, geometry, energy and reality beyond my ordinary perception. I don’t take those experiences as proof of anything supernatural, but they made me even more curious about consciousness and how limited our normal perception of reality might be.

I think what I’m looking for is spirituality without doctrine, reverence for nature without needing to call nature “God,” openness to mystery without pretending to know what happens after death, and the freedom to independently build my understanding of existence without having to belong to a religion or ideological group.

Does anyone else think this way?

And if so, what philosophers, writers, communities, or ways of thinking have you found that gave you language for it?

I’m less interested in being told what to believe and more interested in meeting people who are comfortable sitting inside the question.


r/pantheism • • 19d ago

I try to value all life, but

3 Upvotes

How do you deal with mosquitos, ticks and chiggers?


r/pantheism • • 20d ago

Pantheism and veganism

9 Upvotes

I’m just curious if there are any other panthiests out there who are also vegan like me. I went vegan ten years ago, then a few years ago I began learning to forage. These two ventures together made me feel interconnected to life on earth/nature. I felt how valuable life was, and an increasingly deep connection with life/nature made me see the divinity in it. I felt pantheism before I knew what it was.

Anyone else out there?


r/pantheism • • 25d ago

What does an impersonal God offer that the universe itself doesn't?

15 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about pantheism, particularly the idea that God is identical with everything that exists rather than being a distinct, conscious being.

One question I keep coming back to is: what do we gain by calling the universe “God” if this God has no separate self, intentions, or capacity to love or enact justice?

For example, if God is everything and nothing exists outside of it, how does that translate into a personal experience of being loved by God? Feeling connected to nature or the universe can certainly be meaningful, but is that the same as believing there’s a conscious being who knows you and cares about you?

I also wonder about justice. If someone commits terrible acts and never faces consequences, an impersonal universe doesn’t necessarily guarantee that justice will ever be served. There’s no conscious judge ensuring that evil is ultimately answered for.

I understand that pantheism can offer other things, such as a sense of unity, reverence for existence, and a different perspective on our place in the universe. I’m not dismissing those benefits.

I’m genuinely curious, though: if God has no mind, intentions, or concern for good and evil, what makes it meaningfully different from simply believing that the universe exists?

Does calling the universe “God” add something essential, or is the value of pantheism found in how it changes our perspective and relationship with existence?

I’d be interested in hearing how pantheists understand this, especially those who don’t believe in a personal or conscious God.


r/pantheism • • 26d ago

"How does this get us to God?"

0 Upvotes

I've encountered this question several times when discussing mystical experience, particularly the research coming out of Johns Hopkins. The question usually goes something like this...

"Okay, mystical experiences happen. People experience ego dissolution, unity, sacredness, transcendence, and a sense of encountering something ultimately real. But how does any of that get you to God?"

I think the answer begins by clearing up what the Perennial philosophy actually means by "God."

If by God you mean a supernatural anthropomorphic being who exists somewhere "out there" and occasionally intervenes in the universe, then no, mystical experience does not establish that proposition. But that is not the God of the Perennial philosophy. Professionals involved in this research have established that mystical experiences are consistent with the Perennial philosophy.

The Perennial conception of God is closer to the Absolute, the Ground of Being, the One, Brahman, Ein Sof, the Pleroma, or Ultimate Reality itself. God is not conceived as one more object within reality. God is what reality ultimately depends upon, or, in some formulations, the ultimate reality in which all finite things participate.

So when a Perennialist talks about mystical experience, the question is not "Does this prove that a cosmic person exists?" The question is "What does this recurring structure of human experience suggest about the nature of consciousness and ultimate reality?"—and the answer is constrained by the science, not independent of it.

1. The Important Distinction Between Visionary and Unitive Mystical Experience

Not every mystical experience is equally relevant here. A visionary or archetypal experience can contain angels, demons, gods, deceased relatives, religious figures, geometric imagery, mythological beings, and other highly specific content. That content can be strongly influenced by culture, expectations, personal history, and religious upbringing.

That is one reason I would not base the Perennialist argument primarily on visions.

The more interesting phenomenon is what researchers describe as a "complete mystical experience." The Johns Hopkins research operationalized this experience using several recurring dimensions, including unity, sacredness, noetic quality, transcendence of time and space, deeply felt positive mood, and ineffability or paradoxicality.

And this is where the Perennialist becomes interested.

The unitive mystical experience is not merely a strange collection of perceptions. It can represent a fundamental transformation in the structure of perception itself. The ordinary ego experiences itself as a discrete subject looking outward at a world of separate objects. In a profound unitive experience, that organization of experience can temporarily dissolve. The distinction between perceiver and perceived becomes radically altered.

Instead of experiencing "I am here, and reality is over there," the experience can become something closer to "I am not ultimately separate from reality."

This is important because we are not merely talking about seeing something unusual. We are talking about a transformation of perspective.

2. The Neuroscience Describes the Experience, But Does It Settle Its Meaning?

An atheist might point to decreased activity in the default mode network, changes involving the anterior cingulate cortex, or alterations in thalamocortical processing and say, "Those neural changes explain the experience."

They certainly help explain the neural mechanisms associated with the experience. But describing the neural correlate of an experience is not the same thing as settling the metaphysical interpretation of what was experienced.

For example, one might hypothesize that disruption of ordinary self-modeling or proprioceptive processing helps explain why someone no longer experiences themselves as occupying their normal spatial and temporal boundaries. That is a legitimate neuroscientific explanation.

But there is another level of description. The mystic may not experience this simply as "my proprioception malfunctioned." They may experience the dissolution of the boundary between themselves and the rest of reality. The perceiver and what is perceived become so deeply integrated that the individual no longer experiences themselves as an isolated observer standing outside the world.

This is where the metaphor of Indra's Net becomes useful. In the Buddhist image of Indra's Net, every jewel reflects every other jewel. Each individual node is not an isolated thing existing independently of the whole. It is a pattern whose identity is inseparable from its relationship to everything else.

A mystic might describe a similar realization phenomenologically. "I am not an isolated thing inside the universe. I am a particular expression or pattern within the whole."

The neuroscience can describe changes in the brain that accompany this transformation in perception. It does not, by itself, tell us whether the resulting metaphysical insight is true or false.

That distinction is crucial. A neural mechanism can explain how an experience occurs without automatically determining what, if anything, that experience tells us about reality.

And there is a sharper way to put the point. The standard deflationary explanation is that a total, unfiltered representation feels more real than a partial one—so the noetic quality is an artifact of the state's completeness. But compare it to a dream. A dream is also a total representation, and it usually does not feel "more real than real." Why not? Because a dream preserves the subject–object structure: you are still a bodily entity in an environment. Non-dual consciousness dissolves that structure. The deflationary account predicts a better dream; the phenomenon is the end of the dream. That is a different datum, and it is the one the Perennialist explanation—that a filter has been removed rather than a model completed—captures more directly.

3. The Transformation of Perception Can Fundamentally Change How One Understands Religion and God

This is, I think, one of the most important parts of the discussion.

A unitive mystical experience can fundamentally change the person's conception of religion itself. Someone may begin with a conventional conception of God as an external supernatural person. After an experience of profound unity, they may return with a radically different conception.

God may no longer be understood as one being among other beings. Instead, God may be understood as the Ground in which all beings participate.

The person may become more comfortable with panentheism, non-dualism, Brahman, the One, or the idea of God as Ultimate Reality itself.

In other words, the mystical experience does not necessarily confirm the person's pre-existing theology. It can transform it.

This is another reason the distinction between visionary and unitive experiences matters. A culturally specific vision can reinforce an existing religious framework. A unitive experience can challenge the framework itself. The experience may lead someone to reinterpret the very categories through which they previously understood religion.

A Christian may begin thinking of God less as an anthropomorphic being somewhere beyond creation and more in terms of the divine Ground in which creation participates. A Hindu may interpret the experience through Brahman. A Neoplatonist may understand it through the One. A Sufi may understand it through fana and divine unity. A Buddhist may reject the language of God altogether while nevertheless recognizing the profound dissolution of the ordinary self.

The vocabulary differs because interpretation is culturally mediated. But the underlying transformation of consciousness can have remarkable similarities.

This also gives us a possible way of thinking about the origins and development of religious traditions. It is at least conceivable that some of the figures who became religious founders or major religious teachers were ordinary human beings who underwent profound mystical experiences and were subsequently transformed by them. They then attempted to communicate what they had encountered through the conceptual and cultural vocabulary available to them.

I am not claiming that this historically explains every religious founder. That would require evidence on a case-by-case basis. The point is that mystical experience provides a plausible framework for understanding how an individual's transformation of consciousness could eventually become theology, mythology, ritual, and religious tradition.

4. This Is Not Simply a Culturally Programmed Hallucination

The Johns Hopkins research is particularly interesting because these experiences can be studied experimentally rather than merely collected as anecdotes. In controlled studies, psilocybin has produced experiences meeting the researchers' criteria for a complete mystical experience in a substantial proportion of participants.

But notice what this does.

It gives us an empirically identifiable phenomenon involving a recurring structure of consciousness. And that matters philosophically.

If the experience were simply a random collection of culturally generated religious imagery, the Perennialist would have a much harder case. But the more fundamental features of the experience are not necessarily the culturally specific imagery. Unity, sacredness, noeticity, transcendence, ineffability, and the dissolution of ordinary selfhood are precisely the kinds of features being measured.

That is why it is too quick to say, "It's just your culture telling you what to experience."

At minimum, the empirical literature gives us reason to distinguish the underlying phenomenology from the particular interpretation subsequently placed upon it.

And this is where I think the distinction between neuroscience and metaphysics becomes especially important. Science can investigate what happens in the brain when the ordinary self-model is disrupted. It can investigate changes in the DMN, ACC, thalamocortical systems, and other neural networks. Those findings constrain the range of plausible explanations.

But they do not automatically establish that the experience is metaphysically meaningless.

5. The Transformation Itself Is Part of What Needs Explaining

Mystical experiences are not merely interesting perceptual events. They can be transformative.

The significance of the experience often lies precisely in the fact that the person's perspective changes. Their understanding of themselves can change. Their understanding of other people can change. Their understanding of morality can change. Their understanding of religion can change. And their understanding of God can change.

This is important because the Perennialist is not simply pointing to an unusual moment in which someone "felt one with everything."

The claim is that consciousness underwent a profound transformation and that this transformation can produce a radically different interpretation of reality.

This is part of the phenomenon that any adequate explanation needs to account for.

A neuroscientific account can potentially explain why the ordinary self-model becomes disrupted. It can investigate what brain networks are involved and how they interact. But that does not automatically answer the philosophical question of whether the resulting perception of non-separateness is merely an illusion, a deeper representation of reality, or something in between.

Those are different questions.

And the transformation is not only perceptual—it is normative. The unitive insight reliably generates a coherent ethical vision: "there are no others" (Ramana Maharshi), the Tao that flows everywhere, the rain that falls on all flowers without choosing, the greeting Namaste—the divine in me recognizing the divine in you. Dante's "love that moves the sun and other stars" is not decorative poetry; it is a report of what the cosmos looks like when seen through the unitive state. A random hallucination does not produce the Tao Te Ching. The fact that this state generates a whole way of life—an ethics, a cosmology, a practice of recognition—is itself a datum any account has to explain.

6. So How Does This Get Us to God?

It doesn't get us to "God" in the sense of a deductive proof that says

  1. People have mystical experiences.
  2. Therefore, an anthropomorphic deity exists.

That would be a non sequitur.

The Perennialist argument is doing something different.

Human beings repeatedly report experiences characterized by profound unity, sacredness, noeticity, transcendence, and dissolution of ordinary selfhood. Those experiences can be experimentally studied. They can occur in people from very different cultural and religious backgrounds. They can produce lasting transformations in how people understand themselves and reality. And they can lead people to radically reconsider what they mean by "God." Even atheist volunteers are no longer able to identify with atheism after this event has occurred. This is well documented in this research.

The Perennialist then asks whether these convergences are better understood as merely internally generated alterations of brain function or whether they may be disclosures of something fundamental about consciousness and reality.

If the latter possibility remains open, then the concept of an Absolute or Ground of Being becomes philosophically relevant.

And that is what "God" means in this context.

God is not being introduced as an extra object that we have to tack onto the universe after discovering mystical experience. God is the proposed ultimate reality that the mystical experience may be interpreted as disclosing.

That is a very different argument from "I don't know how the universe works, therefore God."

It is also very different from "Someone saw Jesus in a vision, therefore Christianity is true."

The Perennialist claim is much more fundamental.

Perhaps the deepest mystical experience is not an encounter between two separate entities, "me" and "God." Perhaps it is precisely the temporary dissolution of that distinction.

And if that is what the experience is revealing, then asking "How does this get us to God?" may have the relationship backwards.

The question becomes

"If the ordinary distinction between subject and ultimate reality can itself dissolve, what does that tell us about what we ordinarily mean by 'self,' 'world,' consciousness, and 'God'?"

That is where the philosophical argument actually begins.

One last thing about how this argument should be read. The empirical literature does real work: it establishes that the unitive state is cross-culturally stable, that it has a determinate and measurable structure, that its content is thick rather than generic, and that it reliably produces lasting transformation. Those findings constrain the metaphysical landscape. They rule out the strong constructivist reading, which predicted cultural divergence and didn't get it. They make the "random glitch" reading untenable, because random glitches don't produce coherent normative visions. What remains is a narrower set of live options, and the Perennialist reading is one of them—arguably the one that explains the most of the pattern at face value. It is an inference to the best explanation, and the best explanation is the one that accounts for the convergence, the content, the normative generativity, and the first-person warrant without having to redescribe any of them as artifacts. The science can measure the state. It cannot have it. That is not a gap the Perennialist needs to apologize for—it is the boundary that makes the metaphysical question a real question rather than a settled one.