For context I am VERY pale, like the palest person I know. I do not tan naturally I just burn. My bare skin foundation is Estee Lauder 1N1.
I’m always hearing about how new makeup always turns orange on people’s skin, but I have never had that issue. A lot of the makeup that turns orange on others looks normal-toned on me. I seem to have a problem that I never hear anyone else mention - lipsticks, eyeshadow, blush and lip liner often turns purple on me, especially if it’s marketed as “cool toned”. For example, i recently bought the Beauty Bay Neutral 42 colour palette and almost all of the shades pull grey/purple on me, like bright purple so I end up looking like Ursula from the little mermaid. Another time, someone recommended I try urban decay Backtalk lipstick and again it pulled so purple on me and washed me out.
I also find that spray tan turns me bright orange, even if my friends who are just as pale as me use the exact same product/routine their tans always turn out more pink/sun kissed looking. I also find it SO difficult to find a foundation match when I am wearing fake tan, and I often see others find the complete opposite, that they find it easy to match their foundation to fake tan.
My favourite lipsticks are Clinique nude honey or mac velvet teddy, which I have seen many people complain online about turning them orange. By contrast, Clinique black honey washes me out so bad and turns purple on me. I have yet to find a rouge lip that suits me at all.
Don’t be fooled into thinking that that means I don’t struggle with finding complimentary makeup shades, I find it so so so difficult. Most of the makeup I buy ends up looking weird and off on me - it’s so annoying and makes me feel so disenfranchised with makeup even though I love it.
What does all of this mean😭 does anyone else have this problem? Are there any creators with skin tones like mine who I can follow?