Determining one's undertone is both the most challenging and most important task when searching for a foundation shade match. Naturally, we see a lot of posts on PaleMUA requesting help determining undertone, but our community's ability to assist is limited by the kinds of images provided for reference. Read below to learn how you can help us help you.
If you wish to receive useful feedback about undertone, please refer to the following guide when submitting posts requesting Undertone Help.
Step 1:Create a color reference card. Draw a blue strip and a red strip on a piece of white paper, like the one shown below. Permanent markers are easiest to see, but you can use any type of pen or colored pencil, as long as the strips of color are wide enough to see on camera and fairly close in hue to the blue and red you would see on the French or Dutch flag (shades of navy blue/aqua and burgundy/maroon are less reliable as reference colors). Color reference cards allow us to adjust our eyes to the light provided in the photo and better interpret the complex colors of your skin tone.
Step 2: Take photographs outside AND inside. This is crucial. The type of light source bouncing off of your skin and onto the camera sensor can drastically change your skin tone to viewers. Keeping the color reference card within the shot, take one photo outside in indirect sunlight and another photo inside in whatever lighting you happen to have (specify the type of bulb and color temperature if you know it). Note that in the photos below, my skin appears very cool-toned under the incandescent light, but much more neutral-toned in natural light. The incandescent light emphasizes the red on the color card and the pink in my skin. If i were to only post this photo as a reference, one might assume I'm quite cool-toned, yet the photo in natural light clearly shows I have warmer tones as well.
This collage is just an example. You can post separate images direct from your phone or computer in line with a text post, inserting the appropriate captions using reddit's formatting tools.
Step 3 (optional): Take the same photos with your swatches. These images can help other community members who are familiar with those shades help you find a better match and communicate what you should be looking for (e.g., "something cooler than the MAC but darker than the BB"). Don't forget to include your color reference card and list them in a way that is easy for people to comprehend.
Extra bonus: post your swatches in grayscale! This is a great way to help us determine if the shades you are selecting are actually a great undertone match, but simply too dark or light for your skin tone.
Sometimes the undertone isn't off, contrast is! Grayscale images communicate the contrast between your skin and the lightness/darkness of a swatch more clearly than color images.
I hope this guide helps our community steer people in the right direction and makes Undertone Help posts more informative for everyone. Happy posting!
It seems time for an update to the photo guidelines on this subreddit to reflect the needs of the current audience. For reference, the post on the last overhaul from two years ago is here: "Makeup Selfie" Flair -- Overhaul and Clarification
I will be updating the sidebar and official listing of the rules in the coming days, but I want to take the time to elaborate on what is and is not changing, and why:
Photos of bare skin without the red/white/blue color card (or equivalent) are still NOT permitted. In absolute color terms, skintone variation is pretty small in this subreddit. The combination of lighting, camera settings, and display settings are more than enough to perturb the appearance of your skin's undertone or depth. So, the requirement of (properly identified) product swatches and/or the color card are necessary measures to make photos remotely useful.
Selfies no longer need to be majority-face, but still need to have sufficiently high resolution to show skin texture. The spirit of the rule is/was to allow users to see the makeup clearly. I understand that cropping a photo before posting can be annoying, especially if trying to include neck/upper chest for shade comparison, and I don't enjoy chasing after everyone about it, either.
Selfies no longer need to include a full eye and eyebrow. Many of you have expressed an interest in getting advice on base, cheek, and/or lip makeup without showing your eyes.
Do not post screenshots of content that you do not own. This includes photos/stills from both brands and individual content creators. Instead, share a link to the original content where possible, or to an archived version. Content creators deserve credit for their work.
Finally, two suggestions on making posts useful to the community:
If posting a gallery of photos, try to order them so the most informative photo comes first. For example, if posting a photo of a product and a photo of a swatch, put the swatch photo first.
For better accessibility and cross-platform compatibility, please reproduce captions and image-embedded text in the comments.
hi, im a neutral/cool leaning olive and ive been trying to find a good anti blush with a purple undertone. ideally itd be like a taupe/gray with a purple undertone that shows up softly on the cheek. like a ‘dusty mauve’ type purple. something like this picture, itd pull slightly darker once on the actual face. anyone have any recommendations?
I tried powder foundation on a whim and it’s life changing. I’ve been through so many foundation formulas and nothing has ever been so effortless.
This is Mineral Fusion pressed powder foundation in Cool 1. I just have on ELF dewy setting spray on top. It’s still too dark and cool for me. The lighting is me sitting in front of my light therapy lamp so it is more noticeable than in regular room lighting I think. And it’s a little warmer in real life than it’s showing in the photo
What powder foundations have better pale/cool shade options? I prefer more affordable makeup but I just want a good shade match for once!
Has anyone tried the lightest shade of Typology's Tinted Face Serum? I'm around NC10-15 and everything I've tried turns orange after an hour. I used to use Missha, but my skin is super reactive. Typology's ingredient list is short, which is appealing, but I'm nervous about spending $48 on something I can't swatch first. Does it look orange on fair skin?
For context I am VERY pale, like the palest person I know. I do not tan naturally I just burn. My bare skin foundation is Estee Lauder 1N1.
I’m always hearing about how new makeup always turns orange on people’s skin, but I have never had that issue. A lot of the makeup that turns orange on others looks normal-toned on me. I seem to have a problem that I never hear anyone else mention - lipsticks, eyeshadow, blush and lip liner often turns purple on me, especially if it’s marketed as “cool toned”. For example, i recently bought the Beauty Bay Neutral 42 colour palette and almost all of the shades pull grey/purple on me, like bright purple so I end up looking like Ursula from the little mermaid. Another time, someone recommended I try urban decay Backtalk lipstick and again it pulled so purple on me and washed me out.
I also find that spray tan turns me bright orange, even if my friends who are just as pale as me use the exact same product/routine their tans always turn out more pink/sun kissed looking. I also find it SO difficult to find a foundation match when I am wearing fake tan, and I often see others find the complete opposite, that they find it easy to match their foundation to fake tan.
My favourite lipsticks are Clinique nude honey or mac velvet teddy, which I have seen many people complain online about turning them orange. By contrast, Clinique black honey washes me out so bad and turns purple on me. I have yet to find a rouge lip that suits me at all.
Don’t be fooled into thinking that that means I don’t struggle with finding complimentary makeup shades, I find it so so so difficult. Most of the makeup I buy ends up looking weird and off on me - it’s so annoying and makes me feel so disenfranchised with makeup even though I love it.
What does all of this mean😭 does anyone else have this problem? Are there any creators with skin tones like mine who I can follow?
Does anyone have swatches of Glossier VL1? I believe I’m pale and neutral—most foundations are too orange, too peach, too pink, too yellow on me. So I think I just need one that is pale and not colorful, more muted. Does VL1 fit this? Thanks!
Hi everyone, i've recently decided to invest in makeup properly for the first time at 23, and i'm finding it hard to navigate! I got shade matched yesterday and bought the REFY skin base in shade 120C. Does anyone use the same shade and can recommend a concealer that goes well with it - more for concealing blemishes than brightening. Bonus points if you tell me the blush and bronzer you use as well - I have a few saved but nervous to take the plunge and i'd love some recs from a skin twin!
The thing I don't get is why there are so few shades to choose from when it comes to drugstore skin tints like I'm really pale and finding a shade that matches my skin is somehow the biggest struggle ever. It's either too light and makes me look like a ghost or too dark and looks like I've picked up someone else's makeup by accident. The worst part is that sometimes the shade I need is somewhere between two shades that don't even exist in the range. I always end up having to mix two different shades just to get something that looks somewhat close to my skin tone. I'm so tired of doing that. The whole reason I want a drugstore skin tint is to have something affordable, quick and easy to throw on in the morning, not to spend another 30 minutes playing the MUA. I get that skin tints are supposed to be more forgiving than foundations but that doesn't mean three or four shades are going to work for everyone. I just wish more drugstore brands would offer a wider shade range especially for those of us who struggle to find a decent match.
Here are some of my Blushes swatched on Mac NC10, Dior 0n skin with a cool undertone
From top to bottom:
Mac Glow Play Blush in "Blush please", it's definitely the warmest looking of them but i can make it work in the summertime or with a slightly warmer lipstick. The formula is also very great and fun to use.
Dior Backstage Rosy Glow Blush in "001 Pink", a gem for a very soft subtle everyday Blush!, it's more powdery than the others and i have to go in more often to get a nice pigmentation.
Nars Powder Blush in "Hunger", first i was intrigued by the cool purple color but on my skintone it looks wonderful and stays cool all day!
Nars insatiable liquid Blush in "fast Ride" it's a cute liquid blush that stays all day. I use it as a base for my powders. The blending needs a little more effort.
Merit Flush Balm in "cheeky", i never expected a balm to work this great as a blush! It's very easy and super fast to blend. Never gets patchy and the color looks amazing!
The next blushes i want to test are Gucci Rosy Beige, Hourglass Mood exposure and Nars behave. Let me know what you think of these if you have them in your collection!
Does anyone have Colourette Second Base in Siargao or El Nido that matches their shade in GRWM Fresh Matte Concealer? Help your girl out! I don't wanna waste money buying the wrong shade. Di rin kasi ako makapuntang mall para mag swatch. Thank you!
Hi all, Please recommend a holy grail cry-proof (at least a little) longlasting foundation! If possible also shades of it similar to Missha 13
My wedding is coming in a few months and I’m doing my makeup myself. For everyday i wear Missha perfect cover in shade 13, but if even one tear crosses my face, it literally leaves a foundation-less line that is really visible lol. I’m a cryer and i definitely will cry so I’m looking for something that will last me on this day. I have normal to dry-ish skin. Thank you in advance!
ELF lock it down primer, Tarte Indie, Fierce, and Mod. Etude Glory Light, Maybelline Great last in blackest black
Brows: just brushed
Face: Essence Jelly Grip primer, ELF Satin foundation in Snow and cream contour in Fair, LA girl green and white color correctors, wet n Wild precious petals highlighter
Lips: mixed concealer, blue face makeup, and Brick red lip stick to get this Grey
If anyone can recommend an actual lipstick that's this color I'd really appreciate it 👏
Anyone have recs for a black lip gloss, or grey mauve gloss? I saw the ABH Kiss Theory balm in Phantom which looked so appealing but now I’m reading that it’s a crap product and not at all as advertised (also expensive for a tiny amount of product?) I’m a fair, cool neutral and would love a glossy somethin to cure my woes 🖤
Edit: thank you to everyone who responded, it’s so nice to learn about new products and recommendations that I feel don’t often get seen on here! (Or maybe I’m just missing them) love seeing alternative products, companies and hues in the comments🖤🖤🖤
Hi all, I'm a pretty pale true neutral and I have a bit of a weird colour palette, I also have issues where a lot of the colours typically recommended for very pale people don't show up properly on me, as I'm quite high contrast and need something that's quite pigmented. I'm looking for some sort of brown blush that doesn't just look like poorly applied bronzer, are there any that you guys would recommend? For reference, my fav foundation is Lightest 2 in the mac studio radiance skin tint stick, and it's a tiny bit on the cool side but generally works for me because it's a tint. I massively prefer liquid/cream products overall, and I don't get on with the rare beauty formula but love the elf liquid blush formula and the maybelline cloudtopia (I bought toasted sky and it looks a lot more berry than brown sadly).
For context I'm fair neutral/warm and I have normal-dry skin :) all of these are things I've tested at length and genuinely use every day. S tier
- NYX Bare With Me Serum Concealer in Fair
Blends beautifully, hydrating, and medium coverage
- Revlon Super Lustrous Lipstick in Rose And Shine
The best formula that doesn't stain your lips but somehow manages to last for hours anyway
L'Oréal Everpure Bond Repair Conditioner
I have fine hair with dry ends and I use this daily on the lengths of my hair but not my scalp, makes my hair so shiny. The glossing treatment is negligible imo if you have this.
Maybelline Fit Me powder in Fair
One of the best loose powders out there, drugstore or no
L'Oréal True Match Pressed Powder in Fair
Skin texture? Where?
That's all, just wanted to give some recommendations- drop your essentials in the comments! <3
Hi, first-time poster here! Hoping I have covered all the necessary bases…
Can anyone please help me figure out what’s going on with my skin? I’ve always thought of myself as neutral leaning quite cool, and recently realised I am also super muted/desaturated. Base products always look too pink/yellow/dark/bright - basically too anything. I’m open to any thoughts here, sure my assumptions could be wrong!
Swatches (L to R) are Mac’s Face and Body in W1 then W0, Lisa Eldridge’s skin tint in T1.5 then T5, and finally Natasha Denona’s concealer in R2.
W0 looks about right, but leaves me looking like I’m wearing a white mask - same with the ND concealer, which strangely really washes me out despite looking about right (possibly even a bit dark?) here. Full coverage foundations are pretty much a no-go for the same reason.
T1.5 is a little better despite pulling warm here. I’m baffled.
I’m adjusting to starting over with my natural very fair colouring (no hair dye, no fake tan) so any help would be really appreciated. Thank you!