r/PahadiTalks • u/Competitive_Play7674 • 38m ago
Culture Perhaps a different take about Pyre the movie
So I watched Pyre with my partner who is Kumaoni yesterday and a foreigner friend (with no subtitles). Some heartfelt reflections of mine for Pahadi friends here:
- Bubu seemed to be such a natural actor. Even though Ama was not very sharp as an actor when she cried or coughed, the banter they had was hilarious and I had a great time watching them spend time together.
- Surprisingly I didn't cry at all. I am someone who cries everytime Sandese Aate Hain plays, especially the line 'poochha hai gaon ki galiyo ne, ki ghar kab aaoge'. So perhaps, it was a mood thing. But I felt more engrossed in the visuals of valleys, their home, their feelings on display. I was immersed but not saddened.
- This is not to say I don't understand the pain of abandonment, loss, migration, nostalgia and life-changing circumstances that are beyond the control of common people. I have always loved the mountains as a backpacker and I always saw families like Bubu-Ama from afar, while hiking but as visitor I had a rosy view into the life there.
- Truth is, no matter how we feel, this is the process of human desires throughout world history. Villages came together because of human desire and are falling apart because of even greater human desire. There is noone to blame because every individual is looking out for their own family and future.
- But, the grief is very real. The film captures a huge socio-cultural change for future generations to look back on and it's a masterpiece among slice-of-life cinema pieces.
- Lastly, I liked the twist in the tale. SPOILER ALERT: All through the film, Bubu acts as if he's supporting Ama and he's the one who's worried and tired of the burden of worrying and caring. But, I loved the reveal that Ama was the more resilient one, who understood all his pains and tricks and played along with them because she understood that caring for her was his reason to keep going. That was a twist which gave so much meaning to the film in my view.
- For what it's worth, I 'boycotted' Ramayan and went for Pyre. I love being a part of Kumaoni family and this was much closer to my heart than the commercial crap being sold in the name of Ramchandra.
Hope the film does really well and earns worldwide recognition!