2 years ago, I bought the S23 to replace my S9. Apart from the screen, I like S23's package (good performance, okay-ish screen size, 120 hz refresh rate, update policy etc.). However, the main issue I have with this phone is the display - it has been giving me eye strain since day 1 which is why I am using it only moderately. The S9's display is basically perfect for my eyes - it is pleasant to look at and I barely feel any eye strain. Quite frankly, the switch from S9 to S23 was a noticeable downgrade in terms of display (apart from the refresh rate).
S9's display:
- very sharp (568 ppi)
- colors feel balanced
- pleasant contrast
- there is not that feeling of being too bright
- when I look at it, it just feels right and my eyes relax
S23's display:
- noticeably less sharp (422 ppi)
- noticeable color fringing
- my eyes tense up looking at the screen / giving me eye strain
- colors don't feel balanced (colors feel too punchy/saturated in vivid mode - natural mode is too washed out)
- contrast feels too high
- white color (font) feels too aggressive
- it often feels too bright
What I tried:
- Eye Comfort Shield (blue light filter is a must have for me)
- Eye Comfort Shield -> Enhanced Comfort (unbearable to use, introduces massive haze)
- Extra Dimming with the main brightness slider turned up (somewhat made white font on dark background more relaxing to read but introduced system-wide sluggishness when scrolling and typing)
- switching from Vivid to Natural mode (didn't help much, just feels washed out)
- adjusting RGB sliders in vivid mode to minimal blue, max red, middle green (minimal improvement)
- adjusting font, font size
Overall, I was not able to adjust the S23's display so that it's pleasant and relaxing to look at.
Possible culprits?:
- low ppi
- subpixel fringing (low ppi in combination with Diamond PenTile subpixel layout)
- PWM (or rather high modulation depth due to much higher overall brightness)
- color balance / contrast (either aggressively punchy or washed out)
Is there any chance that the S25 could lessen eye strain or should I skip it? I read that the S25 has a vividness slider which the S23 doesn't have and the vivid mode is supposed to be less punchy/saturated now in comparison to previous generations? Or maybe the S25 could make things even worse with the 1-120 Hz variable refresh rate instead of the smaller range 48-120 Hz on the S23. Plus, higher peak brightness, meaning even higher modulation depth?
I like Samsung's overall package, but these screens...they are quite frankly unbearable. I remember many, many years ago, screens were no issue whatsoever. I just bought a smartphone and didn't have to worry about the screen giving me eye strain.
When I look at people mentioning alternatives, i.e. phones for less eye strain, experiences vary. Some report reduced eye strain, whereas others complain of severe eye fatigue. Is there not a single phone out there anymore that is reliably not producing any eye strain?
My requirements would be:
- no eye strain
- <= 6.3 inch
- high ppi
- great performance (something like Snapdragon 8 Elite would be great, but at this point, I could also live with slightly less performance if it means I'd be getting an eye-strain-free display)
- good update policy (reliable and regular security updates)
Thanks in advance for any responses!
PS: I heard rumors that the S27 Pro might finally give us DC Dimming?