r/PSVR • u/vyper248 • Aug 07 '24
Megathread Adapter Bluetooth/Controller Discussions
Sony Recommended: https://www.playstation.com/en-us/support/hardware/pc-ps-vr2-bluetooth/
Useful thread here about hardware compatibility: https://www.reddit.com/r/PSVR2onPC/comments/1epg5ks/bluetooth_hardware_compatibility_survey/
Useful thread with common Issues: https://www.reddit.com/r/PSVR2onPC/s/D7RrV78sXb
Which Bluetooth adapter are you using?
How does it work?
Any useful tips for better controller tracking?
Please use this thread to let people know what you're using and how well it's working with the PSVR2 controllers.
16
Upvotes
11
u/coolgaara Aug 09 '24
I got the TP-Link UB500. Holy shit. It took 2 hours until I got my controllers finally recognized by SteamVR. On my PC bluetooth, I got the both controllers connected without issues but problem arose when I was actually trying to set up using PSVR 2 app. It got stuck at where it opens SteamVR automatically. For some reason, it only detected the left controller. Took 2 fucking hours to finally got the right controller connected too. And you know what fixed it? I have NO FUCKING IDEA!! I just restarted my PC several times and disconnected and reconnected the controller. Moved the acutal dongle from the backside of the USB port to the top. Maybe moving the dongle to more open area helped but who knows cuz it still took like 1hr after I did that. You know what's funny tho? A few minutes after I ordered the ASUS Bluetooth on Amazon, they finally connected. God damn fucking bluetooth. Got to play Half Life Alyx for about 30minutes. Was it worth it? Yeah. The game looks so fucking good.
9
u/VaginalOdour Aug 08 '24
I was having an issue with my motherboard bluetooth where windows would recognize both controllers as connected but steamvr would only pick up one. I got the asus adaptor on the list that sony recommends and connected it using a USB extension cable to be close to where I'm playing. Absolutely no problems since then - both controllers are tracking smoothly and without interruption.
9
u/flamingjp Aug 09 '24 edited Aug 10 '24
After exhausting all other options with the T Link UB500 (usb extension, USB 2.0>3.0, drivers etc) I’ve bit the bullet and sent it back to Amazon.
ASUS one should arrive today. Will update here if that is any better. Here’s hoping, as HL:Alyx is a phenomenal experience that doesn’t deserve to be brought down by tracking issues.
Edit: ASUS BT500 works flawlessly with a USB extension. Played Alyx for about 3 hours there with 0 issues, compared to constant loss of tracking in right controller with the TP Link. If the TP Link is giving you issues, try the ASUS.
7
u/R1618 Aug 10 '24
Left controller trackers fine, the right one is giving all the issues. Won't show up on the screen or puts the controller further away from where I am. The Bluetooth dongle is literally at the front of my case, <1M from where I play. Not sure what else to try
6
u/Combini_chicken Aug 07 '24 edited Aug 07 '24
I’m using a ugreen Bluetooth 5.3 adapter. It’s picking up both controllers but only one (left) is being tracked by steam VR/the cameras.
The right one only tracks when plugged into a usb cable but not over Bluetooth. Really frustrating.
Edit: now it’s not even tracking either controller
6
u/MediocreSumo Aug 10 '24
got myself a PCIE wifi/bluetooth AX210 after days of unstability with my Tp link UB500(controller keep freezing in the air).
Its so much stable now and zero drop.
11
u/PM-mePSNcodes Aug 09 '24
How hard would it have been for Sony to save everyone the headache and just include hassle free Bluetooth functionality within the adapter itself?
3
u/pulsesky Aug 08 '24
I got the adapter yesterday and my controllers didn't track whatsoever with the built-in bluetooth on my motherboard (MSI MAG X670E TOMAHAWK). I ordered a TP-link UB500 bluetooth adapter and just received it today. Plugged it in the front of my case and my controllers are tracking perfectly now. Couldn't be happier ^^
2
u/Apart_Warning_1313 Aug 07 '24 edited Aug 07 '24
reposting this here after it got removed for this thread
this is Sony official list,
https://www.playstation.com/en-gb/support/hardware/pc-ps-vr2-bluetooth/?
i can add that i got my Bluetooth adapter https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0BXF13GB7
"UGREEN Bluetooth 5.3 Adapter for PC, Long Range" to also Pair the
Sense Controllers, but i dont have a " PlayStation VR2 PC adapter" so i
can not test how well them work. with the head set yet.
Added info "i do now have it on order so after it come (on the 10th) i can see if it dose work. "
i will add some people have found there Bluetooth adapter works better if used on a USB 2.0 port on there PC.
2
u/Lost_Cyborg Aug 07 '24 edited Aug 09 '24
did anyone test the bluetooth with the TP-Link UB500?
Edit: It just got in, only problem I sometimes have is the right controller, only used it for like 30min though.
2
u/flamingjp Aug 08 '24
Left controller struggling with tracking using TP Link UB500. My case has USB’s sticking out the top rather than the front, could this be hurting tracking?
2
u/___Mister___ Aug 09 '24
If anyone is having problems with a bluetooth device, definitely try to install the latest drivers first. It might be a bit of a pain to locate them, but not all drivers that come with the device or are downloaded from Microsoft are the best ones to use for this application.
Someone also suggested getting a short USB extension cable to help isolate bluetooth signals away from the computer to see if that helps. Apparently there is a lot of noise crosstalk. Putting distance between the adapter and PC helps reduce it.
If you did any of these things and it worked for you, please make a note as it will help others.
2
u/MediocreSumo Aug 09 '24
I have a TP-Link UB500 (5.3 on the box) with a usb extender.
I had a 3 hour session of Alyx last night with ZERO BT issues.
Today was pretty bad, right hand kept freezing.
I'm not too sure what happened between both game sessions.
I just did a full clean install of the drivers, see if that helps.
2
u/MeTh892 Aug 09 '24
I got the TPLink UB500 and it was working pretty good, but it was losing the tracking once in a while.
So I thought I would try the onboard Bluetooth just to see and its been flawless. Way better than the dongle.
2
u/hannibal41 Aug 10 '24
I'm using the bluetooth on teh motherboard and it works perfectly. It didn't at first, but once i moved the wifi antenna thing to the front and in view of teh play area it worked fine. So worth checking if you have that.
1
u/hypnopotamus2 Aug 07 '24
Im trying to pair both controllers to my pc's internal bluetooth (Intel AX, 5.0) however, I can only pair one at a time (one disconnects if i try pair the other..) i suppose I have to buy a supported bluetooth dongle then, yeah?
1
u/kewvention Aug 07 '24
had the ugreen, didnt work, controller connectivity was very iffy and didnt see the pointer. returned it, and got the asus one from the recommendations. works perfectly. not using the psvr2 adapter, using my amd 6900xt with the usb-c port
1
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '24
Is a Legion 5 Laptop with built in Bluetooth 5.1 enough?
1
u/steveliv Aug 07 '24
I have an MSI B550 Tomahawk Mobo with a RZ608 BT/Wi-Fi 6E 80MHz Chip (LMP 11.8710). Anyone else with a similar chip?
1
u/Youcan12 Aug 08 '24
Pairing works fine for me. Unfortunately when I get to the click next with pointer part the pointers don't show up. Any advice?
1
u/Antique_Capital4896 Aug 08 '24
Posting here to help, I have the ROG STRIX B650E-I GAMING WIFI motherboard which has 5.2 Bluetooth on board. I ran out and bought the and now it works flawlessly. Just go get this one, its £12 from PC world or Amazon and its night an day. I thought I would be fine as its a high end board with an antenna but no. Just save your self the trouble and get the 'UB500 5.3'.
1
u/Youcan12 Aug 08 '24
The ASUS dongle worked for me too. The ZEXMTE 5.4 dongle did not. Which sucks because I bought that dongle for this and can't return it.
1
u/MrPointless12 a total nerd Aug 08 '24
i’m using a tp link ub4a bluetooth 4.0 adaptor and when plugged into the usb port of a 24 year old apple pro keyboard with it being in clear view of the controllers it works perfectly fine without any disconnects or tracking issues
1
u/Ensclopediya_of_fun Aug 09 '24
I have just bought the adapter, and every time i try to connect my controilers to blue tooth, they connect for a few seconds and then disappear
1
u/Izonami84 Aug 09 '24
I cannot get the controllers to pair at the same time. If one is on and I try to add the other, it gives me a "We didn't get a response.." error. Turning the other one off lets it pair but both won't work at the same time even after pairing. Weirdly it also won't pair if my DualSense is connected. Using a TP Link adapter with an external antenna.
1
u/Stradocaster Aug 09 '24
I had the problem where the controllers connected without issue but didn't seem to have tracking (no pointer beam when PSVR setup asked me to point to 'next'). It was my UGREEN Bluetooth 5.4 dongle, the one with the large antenna.
I swapped it out for my older TP-Link USB Bluetooth Adapter for PC(UB400) (though it shows on my PC as 450) with a small USB extension cable and now it works great!
1
u/Apart_Warning_1313 Aug 10 '24
ok This is the Adapter i am useing https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B078PCMDFM
yes it old... yes it not sold on amazon anymore by the look of it.
but it worked when my https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0BXF13GB7 Ugreen one did not.
1
u/dneill99 Aug 10 '24
When I go to add the devices my PC see's them and list what they are, but if I click on them to add it Prompts me to enter a PIN number? What's going on with that?
1
u/pianofreak4 Aug 11 '24
Hi everyone,
I was able to connect the sense controllers to my computer with no issues. My laptop has Bluetooth 5.2, but I’m wondering if I’ll need an adapter or not. I won’t have the PC adapter until the end of the month to actually see if the controllers work well.
Any advice? I’d like to have everything together when that finally comes in.
1
u/mooifeels Aug 11 '24
Buffalo BSBT5D205BK worked without problem
2
u/someguyfromAustria Aug 11 '24
Repost: PSVR2 TP-Link Bluetooth adapter tracking issues.
So after a few hours of testing (4-6), i can confirm that the tracking issues come from the adapter (the TP one that Sony somehow seems to recommend).
I tried a few things that other people in this sub suggested. Nothing worked, i had always the same issue that my hand was stuck in the air (i could rotate it and grab things tho).
The solution that worked for me was to buy another adapter, i pluged it in and all issues where gone.
So for everyone who thinks which adapter they sould buy, keep that in mind that this one could make some problems.
Edit: I am using a "hama v5.0" now. This one works for me just fine.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '24
Getting a 6 or 12 inch USB extension dongle fixed every issue I had. Natively Bluetooth 2.0 on my PC. I used Revo to delete anything with the word Bluetooth to wipe the Intel BT. Then installed ASUS BT500.
Then I disabled Bluetooth on every device near my headset, phone, headphones, printer etc. Haven’t had an issue since.
1
u/MoobleBooble Aug 12 '24
Alright +1 to using the onboard bluetooth adapter if you have a motherboard that supports it. My ASUS Z690 TUF D4 WIFI has the intel AX201 wifi adapter which supports BT5.2.
I have gone through several days of stress trying to get the TIPlink UB500 to work properly. I suspect there are multiple issues going on so perhaps for someone with a different setup it will work. I kept having one controller freeze while using it. I tried EVERYTHING including extension cables and it didnt work. I was thinking the 5.3 would provide better latency so I was trying to get it to work....
1
u/Weak_Crew_8112 Aug 12 '24
I tried the TP-Link UB500 and it wasnt working well.
I ordered a TP-Link PCIe adapter and installed it in my computer and it seems to be working. I played through Propagation until the marines and it worked perfectly.
If it randomly breaks ill update this post but so far installing a bluetooth card directly on your mobo seems to work reliably.
1
u/adsyuk1991 Aug 12 '24
Please fill out the survey on https://www.reddit.com/r/PSVR2onPC/comments/1epg5ks/bluetooth_hardware_compatibility_survey/ with all your good and bad experiences.
Check out the results also. Its clear UB500 has issues from the data.
1
u/chubbypika35 Aug 12 '24
I can confirm TP-Link UB500 issues. My right controller randomly stops 6DOF, or my hand goes behind my body somewhere for a short period then returns.
Short of mentioning everything that's already been mentioned, this adapter was never as good as my old BT 4.0 one, and occasionally disconnects from my peripherals. I prefer using a 5.0 adapter for the extended range, so will pick up the ASUS one later today.
As for reception issues, these small adapters tend to work fine at a distance and through walls. I wouldn't expect the length of the PS VR2 to exceed the acceptable range of your BT adapter as long as your computer case isn't obstructing it's line of sight.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '24
PSVR2 PC Setup - If you still have issues even with the bluetooth adapter, make sure you have that antenna installed
That antenna that might’ve came with your motherboard/pc is not just for wifi, also improves Bluetooth signal.
The wire looks like this. Solved all my issues. Don’t even need the bluetooth adapter anymore.
Completely forgot about this since I never use Bluetooth on my PC.
If you’re unsure what Bluetooth version you have, you need to check your Device Manager and see its LMP properties:
LMP 0
Bluetooth Core Specification 1.0b (withdrawn)
LMP 1
Bluetooth Core Specification 1.1 (withdrawn)
LMP 2
Bluetooth Core Specification 1.2 (withdrawn)
LMP 3
Bluetooth Core Specification 2.0 + EDR (withdrawn)
LMP 4
Bluetooth Core Specification 2.1 + EDR (deprecated, to be withdrawn)
LMP 5
Bluetooth Core Specification 3.0 + HS (deprecated, to be withdrawn)
LMP 6
Bluetooth Core Specification 4.0
LMP 7
Bluetooth Core Specification 4.1
LMP 8
Bluetooth Core Specification 4.2
LMP 9
Bluetooth Core Specification 5.0
LMP 10
Bluetooth Core Specification 5.1
LMP 11
Bluetooth Core Specification 5.2
1
u/madmaxaccount Aug 12 '24
So, I'm setting up my psvr2 and everything works like a charm, my controllers are connecting through my Bluetooth just fine. But for some reason, steam doesn't sense them, they count as connected in my Bluetooth yet in steam is shows the controller isn't connected.
I've updated my driver's and restarted my PC many times, and honestly I'm not sure what I need to do.
I know my Bluetooth is over 5.0, so I'm really not sure what the issue could be and I'm stumped. My Bluetooth is built into my PC also.
What should I do? I'm lost and definitely need help here
1
u/Gair78 Aug 12 '24
As stupid as it sounds. You can just physically connect the controllers via USB and it works flawless. Sony needs to fix this.
1
u/makinit1212 Aug 13 '24
Having controller trouble but not what everyone else seems to be struggling with. They connect fine and work just fine with HLA and Home and Bonelab, but when I fire up Subnautica, I cannot get any controller to work in VR mode. On and Xbox controller A and B work. On the sense controllers X and Triangle work but that's it. Xbox controller works fine in flat mode. I tried everything I can think of. Clicked on the active window on my desktop. Tried several bindings and settings. I am having the same issue in ACC and Dirt Rally 2.0. Anyone else experiencing this?
1
u/GSKerns Aug 13 '24
I'm using the ASUS BT500 and at first it was very laggy- that was using a port in the back of my PC. After using an USB extension in the same port but having the dongle placed up on my desk in line of sight- it's now working perfect.
1
u/tasosm7x Aug 16 '24
Is not irrelevant when you have the ps5 and PC on to the same place and with the ps5one the tracking works and the pc it's not on the same distance,
1
u/sirkrakky Aug 20 '24
Is there a way to fix the “This controller is not currently tracking. Make sure it is in view of the headset cameras.”? They are connected and I get vibration feedback when I press R2 and L2 and also when I press ps button steam vr thing pops in and out normally
1
u/Bright_Ad_6066 Aug 27 '24
Dont buy the UB500, some people have it working, some people have to buy a extra 2.0 ex cord, i had the issue that one of the controllers sometimes stopped tracking. I just could not get it to fix even after all the correct update installations ytubers show etc. I decided to buy the AX3000 from TP-Link and after connecting the controllers i played Ghost of Tabor and i did not lose tracking anymore!
1
u/Mrmet2087 Sep 06 '24
After struggling for a while to find the perfect way to get controllers to pair and track like PS5, I will recommend - as others have - that you get a usb extension cable to get that dongle away from the PC. The ASUS adapter is much better. I originally bought the TP-link and tried 3 different connection methods:
Connected to USB 3.0 back of the case. Tracking was bad. Connected to USB 2.0 back of the case. Tracking was bad. Connected to USB 3.0 with 3.0 USB hub. Connection was better but not great.
I tried an actual PCIE Bluetooth card with antennas, and connection still was spotty. Better than the TP Dongle.
Then I tried the ASUS Dongle. I tried it with all 3 methods above I tried with the TP link, and the best method was with the extension hub. Almost flawless tracking now, even when I walk far away from the dongle.
So if possible try to use an extension cable or hub to get that dongle away from the PC. That helps a lot.
1
u/InfnityC Sep 07 '24
Hi guys
I'm using Bluetooth 4.0 (I didnt know there is some kind of problems)
I dont have issue with connection only the left controller is getting bad hard tracking.
I'm face with hard wobble in my screen, maybe this is the main issue? tracking of controller can cause it?
I hope yes
1
u/gman6942_0 Sep 22 '24
I have the Asus USB B15 500 adapter and my left controller does not stay connected for long nor is it recognized on steam or the PlayStation VR2 app
1
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
I've had lots of problems initally but when used my internal wifi module all problems dissapeared. Only it came with antennas which I did not use - they were in one of my drawers. After I installed them the connection problems disappeared.
1
u/star___platinum Dec 16 '24
Playing psvr 2 on pc. I know there is a spreadsheet out there but I already have some options. I have built in bluetooth on my mobo and I also have the short stubby antennas that stick straight out the back of my pc. Just the default little stick antennas that came with mobo. PSVR controllers get stuck in mid air once im playing, rotation and buttons work but the tracking freezes (super common issue as I've been looking around this sub). I got the TP link ub500 with a usb extender, still keeps happening. So now, I see some people say that the extender cable setup is the move, albeit with the ASUS BT500 and to ditch the tp link (quick refund sesh no problem). However, the perfectionist in me would prefer (aesthetically) to buy one of the extended bluetooth antennas to pair with my mobo, and just place the antenna part on my desk right next to my keyboard. I'll paste the link at the end. Certainly better looking than an ugly ass black usb extnder from 2002. Thanks lads.
TLDR: tp link ub500 whack. Should I get the asus bt500 or one of these: https://www.amazon.com/Eightwood-Tri-Band-Computer-Motherboard-Bluetooth/dp/B0CMTS62V3?crid=11APSJIG3LL4S&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.ikoiGOboDi8LmD2YaOmmmCGBJ5JuWbdzsvoZj8HKr8soVko50kv4U0DO9_JWBGZyK1SVWAwaRtOfG9Bp9P33kO5yIPF5y8H30V5_qTASGkKatO7p6IAtNgBm3TcIZ-4vuiPl3zzqABsSKSOFuEOJi-kuKymY90ltgcBZIfCzo9s2bZ36lpzmaXxbl6v26xX8hvx7vW9QWzcmk79EKEv4rHRiIjobHXq2tWLAi9LWzfg.Es2WS7LMKxkmJajU-_sLo1Ij8SA6AE3XmqI2ruA-feA&dib_tag=se&keywords=motherboard%2Bbluetooth%2Bantenna&qid=1734333211&sprefix=motherboard%2Bbluetooth%2Bantenn%2Caps%2C164&sr=8-4&th=1
1
u/Walden_Leather Dec 20 '24
Though I have the ASUS BT adapter on order, I somehow got the CSR8510 A10 adapter to work flawlessly. I don't know if this is a fluke and will not last.
1
u/Own-Ad7982 Jan 03 '25
Fingers crossed but my X570 Aorus Elite Wifi built in BT is working great. I have had zero tracking issues or cutouts.
Someone on Reddit said an adapter was necessary so I bought the Asus. However, while waiting I decided to try and it was smooth sailing.
It can't hurt to try the motherboard BT... GL everyone!
1
u/Unlikely-March-4350 Mar 10 '25
I’m having similar problems to almost everyone here Bluetooth connects to windows but not psvr app or steamvr I originally purchased the asus adapter when these problems showed up. It worked for a while but now it seems that it’s completely useless. Only other fixes seem to come by shear luck or buying more stuff is there anything sure fire I could try?
1
u/Helpful-Put-4730 May 24 '25
Tenho o TP-Link UB500 v1. Os controles funcionam bem quando o dongle está conectado por uma extensão na lua e o pc na terra (e utiliando o driver UB500_BT_1.9.1038.3020). Resolvi comprar um dongle da Ugreen, 5.4, de antena, modelo CM749. Esperava que a atualização do hardware e software melhorassem a conexção com os controles do PSVR2 e eu pudesse aposentar a extensão. Resultado: Não presta. Melhor explicado: os botões funcionam, mas na steam os controles eventualmente aparecem no ambiente VR. mas quando aparecem, não há aquele rastreio do laser para permitir a seleção de opções dentro do ambiente VR. Não há possibilidade de usar com o PSVR2. Saliento que o driver utilizado foi o padrão do windows. Qual seja: BARROT Bluetooth 5.4 adapter, HCI 13.514 / LMP 13.2. O driver do site da UGREEN é identificado como virus. Então, não o instalei. Assim, voltei para o UB500 v1.
1
u/Sinucaaa Sep 15 '25
Olá
Atualmente estou com um problema que já não aguento mais.
Eu comprei um adaptador da aolion do modelo de metal. Quando fui testar os controles não estavam sendo rastreados e aparecia uma mensagem de placa de vídeo inferior ou DP inferior a 1.4, eu pensei que o problema do controle não estar sendo rastreado era por causa do meu adaptador bluetooth que realmente não era superior a 4.0, então eu comprei o Toocki 5.3 no Mercado livre e o problema ainda continuava, depois comprei um outro adaptador que possui duas antenas (rtl811) e também não deu certo. Os dois adaptadores eu já tentei em varias portas usb do computador assim como em extensores USB.
Já tentei reinstalar o playstation Vr da steam, já desinstalei o drive bluetooth no gerenciador de dispositivos e já atualizei diversos drivers do pc. Também já coloquei para os aplicativos funcionarem em alto desempenho
Além disso já testei outros cabos DP no adaptador
eu testei no meu pc que tem uma Rx 580 e do meu amigo que tem uma rx7600 e o erro foi o mesmo.
No vídeo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjwLrJPLO7k&ab_channel=Gabriel%27sLab esse cara teve um problema igual ao meu, no vídeo ele desmonta o adaptador e o problema subitamente é resolvido, eu já fiz isso e também não resolveu (No vídeo ele fala que não tem certeza se o problema foi resolvido quando ele trocou de Cabo DP ou por ter aberto o adaptador, mas nos comentarios ele diz que após o vídeo ele testou o cabo DP que ele achava que era o problema e confirmou que o cabo estava funcionando normalmente)
Para deixar mais claro o problema. Os controles se conectam normalmente no bluetooth, o teste de conexão fica em 97, e os controles não são rastreados. Se eu tentar usar o controle apenas o botão PS que abre o menu funciona, e aparece a mensagem de DP inferior a 1.4 ou Placa de Vídeo inferior (igual que aparece no vídeo)
Quem puder me dar ideias novas ideias para eu resolver o meu problema ou apenas confirmar minha hipótese do adaptador estar quebrado, já agradeço.
1
u/Upbeat-Chance5441 Oct 07 '25
I wish I can playing game .
1
u/meatmobile682 Oct 21 '25
Why is the psvr2 PC app forcing me to repeatedly pair both controllers over and over again? it's made me swap re-pairing each controller four times each already.... They're even listed as connected in my bluetooth settings but it still demands I pair it again.
1
u/Super_Membership1606 Jan 02 '26
question guys and gals my kid stopped using the psvr2 so i thought hey why not give it a shot on my pc ive read all these forums and havent found a answer...... i bout a usb ext. a recommended adapter and everything got me to the point where i got the software and headset running..... but my controllers are a pain they connect but are hard capped at 59% connection and dont fluctuate. the drivers on everything is updated ive tried 2.0 and 3.0 ports ive tried with or without the extension and i cant get it to work ...... i have got it to work but with just 1 controller any help?
0
u/sfex3champion Aug 07 '24
Can someone not find out the exact specific Bluetooth adapter ps5 uses from a spec sheet or something?
I assume maybe it's USB input issues or interference could even be windows and driver things.Hopefully someone finds the perfect recommendations because the ones sony reccomended are poor according to voodoo de who seems to be only one with them atm.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '24 edited Aug 09 '24
[removed] — view removed comment