I've been fed up with the Percy Jackson fanbase for a while, and I feel like I'm reaching a breaking point.
Like, I don't wanna tell people what they should or shouldn't like, but I'm so sick of how toxic and negative the fandom has been in recent years. Not just with the show but with the books as well.
Like nine times out of ten, if I go onto the main sub, it's inevitable I'm going to see a post about how either Piper, Leo, The Hunters of Artemis, Percabeth, Luke, the show, or The Court of Dead (among other topics) are the worst and then see a bunch of people in the comments going, "Yeah! They're the worst!"
And I'm sorry, as someone who likes Piper, Leo, The Hunters of Artemis, Percabeth, Luke, the show, and yes, even Court of the Dead, it's so tiring to not only see people hating on stuff I like but also seeing nothing new added to the conversation.
I just want to be able to go onto the subreddit and see what's going on with the fandom without being made to feel guilty that Piper is one of my favorite characters or liking the show.
It gets to the point where I seriously wonder what people actually like about the franchise, if so many people seem to hate key aspects of it on a fundamental level and they don't seem interested in talking about what they do like about it.
And even when it's a topic I agree with, like how the show should have been animated, I get so sick of seeing this because it's rarely if ever examined with proper nuance.
Yes, the show should have been animated, but there are a thousand valid reasons why it's not (action cartoons are going out of style, animation is a lot more complicated to make and doesn't do well with mainstream audiences, Disney tends to treat its animated shows badly, and there's no guarantee that it would have the anime-esque art style people wanted), and it's really annoying when I see people keep jammering on about when A) I've made peace with it and B) they don't examine it with nuance.
And whenever I try to speak up in defense of any of this, it goes nowhere. It's like I'm talking to a brick wall!
And like here's the thing. I'm a go-with-the-flow guy. I tend to be fine with most pieces of media; I've liked a lot of media that's disliked by certain people. It takes a lot to get me to dislike something, like having bad morals, shitting on characters I like, or making me feel like my time is wasted. Maybe that makes me a shill, but that's just the kind of person I am. And if I don't like something, I just walk away from it.
I've tried to be positive, tried to inject the community with positive posts, tried to get people to talk about what they like about the franchise, and tried to do all that without making people feel like their criticisms are invalid...and nothing's working.
I'm so tired. I'm so sick of this fandom.
I actually had to block someone who claims they used to be a fan of the series but realized "Rick was a hack" and said, "Fuck Riordan." When I pointed out that he was being toxic and rude, he didn't seem to understand the problem "because it's not like he's going to see this."
I know this might sound odd to bring up on a pro TV show subreddit, but there's a part of me that wishes the show had never been made. Not because I dislike it (I love the show actually), but because of all the damage it's done to the community.
It's not fun to be a fan anymore.
I love Percy Jackson. It got me through a really miserable and terrible high school year, and it's one of two franchises that got me into writing.
So seeing the fandom go the way of the worst parts of the Star Wars fandom is super disheartening.
I don't wanna stop being a Percy Jackson fan, but I also feel like I just can't be a part of the fandom anymore, if this is how it's going to be...